<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.0 20120330//EN" "JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
  <front>
    <journal-meta>
      <journal-title-group>
        <journal-title>April</journal-title>
      </journal-title-group>
    </journal-meta>
    <article-meta>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>DBpedia Viewer - An Integrative Interface for DBpedia Leveraging the DBpedia Service Eco System</article-title>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <string-name>Denis Lukovnikov Claus Stadler</string-name>
          <email>cstadler@informatik.uni-</email>
          <email>lukovnikov@informatik.uni-</email>
          <email>lukovnikov@informatik.uni- cstadler@informatik.unileipzig.de leipzig.de</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff1">1</xref>
        </contrib>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <string-name>Dimitris Kontokostas</string-name>
          <email>kontokostas@informatik.uni-</email>
          <email>kontokostas@informatik.unileipzig.de</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff0">0</xref>
        </contrib>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <string-name>Sebastian Hellmann Jens Lehmann</string-name>
          <email>hellmann@informatik.uni-</email>
          <email>hellmann@informatik.uni- lehmann@informatik.unileipzig.de leipzig.de</email>
          <email>lehmann@informatik.uni-</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff1">1</xref>
        </contrib>
        <aff id="aff0">
          <label>0</label>
          <institution>University of Leipzig</institution>
        </aff>
        <aff id="aff1">
          <label>1</label>
          <institution>University of Leipzig University of Leipzig</institution>
        </aff>
      </contrib-group>
      <pub-date>
        <year>2014</year>
      </pub-date>
      <volume>8</volume>
      <issue>2014</issue>
      <abstract>
        <p>With the growing interest in publishing data according to the Linked Data principles, it becomes more important to provide intuitive tools for users to view and interact with resources. The characteristics of Linked Data pose several challenges for user-friendly presentation of the information. In this work, we present the DBpedia Viewer as one method to address this problem. The DBpedia Viewer is the new DBpedia Linked Data user interface, which makes DBpedia data more accessible to non-experts while integrating the DBpedia service eco system as well as external Linked Data services.</p>
      </abstract>
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body>
    <sec id="sec-1">
      <title>-</title>
      <p>
        This work describes DBpedia Viewer, the new DBpedia [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref7">7</xref>
        ]
interface, which aims to present information from
DBpedia in an engaging way while adhering to the Linked Data
principles. DBpedia Viewer integrates existing DBpedia
services as well as external Linked Data visualization tools to
improve user-friendliness. The DBpedia interface was
originally envisioned to serve data from DBpedia datasets, but
could lead to a customizable framework that can easily be
con gured for other datasets. With the new DBpedia
interface, we aim to show that even a generic representation of
RDF data can be user-friendly and o er relevant services. A
distinguishing feature of DBpedia Viewer is the Triple
Action Framework, a framework which allows to dynamically
associate action types with triples.
DBpedia provides di erent kinds of information about
entities. Entities typically have types, labels, links, Linked Data
links and textual descriptions associated with them.
DBpedia contains links to equivalent entities in other datasets
(such as YAGO) and links to the same entities in DBpedia
datasets for other languages (such as nl.dbpedia.org). In
addition to the general information about entities, e.g. types
and categories, DBpedia contains properties and classes
speci c for particular domains. For example, the entity (of type
Person) dbpedia:Barack_Obama has a property dbo:spouse
which refers to the entity dbpedia:Michelle_Obama.
Since the start of the DBpedia project, several tools and
services were developed around DBpedia. DBpedia
Spotlight [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref9">9</xref>
        ] performs Entity Linking (or Named Entity
Resolution and Disambiguation, NERD) in text by linking
entity mentions to DBpedia entities. DBpedia Lookup3 is an
1Linking Open Data cloud diagram, by Richard Cyganiak
and Anja Jentzsch. http://lod-cloud.net/
2http://blog.dbpedia.org/2013/09/17/
dbpedia-39-released-including-wider-infobox-coverage\
-additional-type-statements-and-new-yago-and-wikidata\
-links/
      </p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-2">
      <title>3http://wiki.dbpedia.org/lookup/</title>
      <p>
        additional service which allows to search for DBpedia
entities using either strings or pre xes (for auto-completion).
The DBpedia mappings wiki 4 is an e ort to crowdsource the
mappings between the Wikipedia infoboxes and the
DBpedia ontology. Apart from DBpedia speci c tools, external
vizualization tools have been developed that use DBpedia,
such as RelFinder [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref4">4</xref>
        ] and LodLive [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref2">2</xref>
        ]. RelFinder explores
the knowledge graph to nd paths between two entities.
LodLive provides a visually appealing way to explore
information associated with an entity.
      </p>
      <p>Such tools and services exist independently, but together
form an eco system, which provides added value for the
DBpedia datasets. Our new interface integrates several tools
in a generic manner { partly to increase user-friendliness
and partly to showcase the achievements in the Linked Data
space obtained so far.</p>
      <sec id="sec-2-1">
        <title>3. DBPEDIA VIEWER USER INTERFACE</title>
        <p>The new DBpedia Linked Data interface (DBpedia Viewer)
co-exists with the previous interface which serves Linked
Data content to machines and browsers without JavaScript
support. While we can default to the new interface when it
is supported by the visiting agent, users can easily switch
between the two interfaces.</p>
        <p>DBpedia Viewer brings several improvements on the
presentation of information. In addition to many cosmetic changes,
DBpedia Viewer provides improved layout choices and new
functionalities that aim to make the UI more useful.
The layout has been adapted to provide additional
functionality as naturally as possible. As illustrated in Figure 1,
several new features are added, each discussed in Section 4.2.
DBpedia Viewer is provided as open source on Github5.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-2-2">
        <title>4. SYSTEM OVERVIEW</title>
        <p>The architecture can be divided in three levels. The base
level is the triple store, which is accessible using the SPARQL
query language. The web server and server-side code are
built on top of the database. The third level is the
clientside code.</p>
        <p>The old interface was implemented with server-side code
that generated a very simple HTML/RDFa page. DBpedia
Viewer provides two modes: A simple HTML/RDFa view
for machines and clients without JavaScript support and a
rich web interface for humans based on JavaScript. A switch
between the two interfaces is also available. The rich web
interface is based solely on client-side code to construct the
web page. All SPARQL queries are executed directly from
JavaScript which minimizes the page generation time and
reduces the load on the web server.</p>
        <p>Following, we provide an overview of DBpedia Viewer
technology stack (Section 4.1). We elaborate on the interface
features (Section 4.2) with an emphasis on the Triple Action
Framework (Section 4.3). Finally, we discuss the
extensibility of the tool(Section 4.4).</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-3">
      <title>4http://mappings.dbpedia.org</title>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-4">
      <title>5https://github.com/dbpedia/dbpedia-vad-i18n</title>
      <sec id="sec-4-1">
        <title>4.1 Technology Stack</title>
        <p>We use the Open Source edition of the Virtuoso server6
as our triple store. Virtuoso has a modular architecture
and supports plugins. These plugins use the VSP
(Virtuoso Server Pages) language to communicate with the triple
store, serve web requests and provide Linked Data. The
previous DBpedia interface was built as a Virtuoso plugin and
the DBpedia Viewer is built on top of the existing code.
Most of the new interface is client-side logic written in
JavaScript. As explained above, the client-side code constructs
the page by issuing SPARQL queries to the con gured
endpoints. Therefore, it is easy to use the new interface for
non-Virtuoso deployments by only serving the client-side
code. However, in this case, the old server-generated
HTML/RDFa interface is not preserved.</p>
        <p>For the client-side logic, we used AngularJS 7, an
opensource JavaScript framework that implements the Model
View Controller (MVC) paradigm for web applications. For
styling and layout, we used the CSS from Twitter
Bootstrap8.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-4-2">
        <title>4.2 Features</title>
        <p>Following we provide an elaborate discussion of the new
DBpedia Viewer features.</p>
        <sec id="sec-4-2-1">
          <title>4.2.1 Pretty Box</title>
          <p>The pretty box (part one of Figure 1) displays important
properties of the viewed entity. There is a prede ned set of
facts we provide, namely: (1) a picture, (2) the title, (3) the
types, (4) a short description and (5) links to other resources.
These data are generated from the set of triples describing
the viewed resources using prede ned mappings. The
DBpedia datasets provide most of this general information for
all entities. In some cases, however, the picture or links
to other resources are not available. The DBpedia Viewer
does not perform automatic selection of relevant properties
to display. This is out of the scope of this project. Our
goal was to develop a UI that is customizable to con gure
relevant properties used to adapt the view.</p>
          <p>In the top right corner of the pretty box (Figure 1), three
icons trigger the entity actions. The currently available
actions are links to alternate data representations (XML/RDF,
n3, JSON-LD, ...) as well as links to consult the resource
using alternative Linked Data browsers.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="sec-4-2-2">
          <title>4.2.2 Search Bar</title>
          <p>DBpedia Viewer provides search functionality with
autocomplete capabilities by re-using the DBpedia Lookup
service. DBpedia Lookup enables searching for DBpedia
entities using strings or provides pre x-based suggestions.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="sec-4-2-3">
          <title>4.2.3 Language Filtering</title>
          <p>The language ltering system allows the user to choose a
preferred display language. This lters all literal values based
on the user preferences and displays only the relevant
values. This feature is helpful on dbpedia.org where labels and</p>
        </sec>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-5">
      <title>6http://virtuoso.openlinksw.com/</title>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-6">
      <title>7http://angularjs.org/</title>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-7">
      <title>8http://getbootstrap.com/</title>
      <p>abstracts exist in 12 di erent languages. In the case a literal
does not exist in the preferred language, a fallback language
(usually English) is chosen by default.</p>
      <p>For entities having location information (latitude and
longitude), a map is shown with its coordinates. OpenStreetMap
is used for the map display.</p>
      <sec id="sec-7-1">
        <title>4.2.4 Triple Filtering</title>
        <p>Part four of Figure 1 highlights the triple ltering feature.
Triples can be ltered using both properties and values. This
is useful for the users who quickly want to nd speci c
properties and values. The ltering is based on string matching
and supports all literal values as well as URIs.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-7-2">
        <title>4.2.5 Shortcut box</title>
        <p>The shortcut box (part 5 in Figure 1) provides anchor links
to some important properties of entities. However, the list
of properties is currently hardcoded and contains links to
categories, types, external links, etc...</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-7-3">
        <title>4.2.6 Live Previews</title>
        <p>When the user hovers over a DBpedia link (URI, ontology
property or class) a concise, language- ltered preview is
displayed. For entities, this preview contains a picture (if
available), the title and a short description. Part 6 of Figure 1
shows a preview of the French Gothic architecture entity.
4.2.7</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-7-4">
        <title>Maps</title>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-7-5">
        <title>4.2.8 Triple Actions</title>
        <p>As displayed in part 8 of (Figure 1), next to each triple,
different icons exist, each representing a di erent triple action.
Triple actions are enabled using conditions on the triple.
Thus, the set of available actions for di erent triples may
be di erent. When the conditions are met, the action icon
is displayed next to the triple. When the user clicks on
the triple action icon, the action is executed. Below is an
overview of the currently implemented user actions:
Annotation { uses DBpedia Spotlight to annotate text.
Only applicable to texts of certain length.</p>
        <p>RelFinder { links to RelFinder, where the connections
(including indirect ones) between the viewed entity
and the value entity can be explored. Only
applicable to DBpedia resources.</p>
        <p>LodLive { opens the value entity with the LodLive
browser. Only applicable to DBpedia resources.
OpenLink Faceted Browser { view the value entity
using OpenLink Faceted Browser. Only applicable to
DBpedia resources.</p>
        <p>Wikipedia { opens the Wikipedia page associated with
the value entity. Only applicable to DBpedia resources.
DBpedia template mapping { links to the DBpedia
mapping associated with the DBpedia template. Only
applicable to DBpedia resources under the Wikipedia
template namespace.</p>
        <sec id="sec-7-5-1">
          <title>4.3 Triple Action Framework</title>
          <p>The Triple Action Framework (TAF) aims to improve the
integration of tools from the DBpedia eco system on the
DBpedia website. The interface maintainer can easily add new
actions or adapt existing ones for a particular deployment.
TAF allows to de ne a triple action with the following core
semantics, (1) bind and (2) execute.</p>
          <p>Upon page load, for each triple, the bind method of each
action is called to determine whether this action is
applicable for this triple. The bind method may use any
information available from the triple to decide whether the action
is applicable or not. For example, the DBpedia Spotlight
annotation action should only be made available for
annotation of textual resources, so the bind method of this action
checks whether the object of the triple is a string literal and
whether it exceeds a con gurable minimum length.
The execute method of an action is called when the user
clicks on an action icon next to the triple. For the DBpedia
Spotlight annotation action, this method uses the text in
the object of the triple, sends it to the DBpedia Spotlight
API for annotation and waits for a response. When the API
responds, the Spotlight action changes the display value of
the object of the triple to show the annotations.</p>
          <p>In the actual implementation, TAF provides additional hooks,
providing more functionality to de ne new actions with ease.
Moreover, the Triple Action Framework allows to de ne
locally/globally stateful actions and hidden (system-level)
actions that execute upon binding and are not available to the
users. Actions of the hidden type are used to detect
coordinates for the map and to populate the shortcut box as well
as some parts of the pretty box.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="sec-7-5-2">
          <title>4.4 Extensibility</title>
          <p>The triple action framework (TAF) promotes the
extensibility of the new interface. The website maintainer can quickly
de ne new actions and add them to the interface. TAF
lightens adding new functionality by providing a useful
abstraction where easy access to the triple is provided and
displaying is already taken care of. To create a new action,
one simply needs to implement the hooks with the desired
action logic. We are looking for ways to make TAF action
creation easier.</p>
          <p>
            DBpedia is distributed in many language chapters [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref5">5</xref>
            ].
DBpedia Viewer can be deployed on all DBpedia language
editions by changing the con guration on the Virtuoso server.
When deploying to other DBpedia chapters, the
functionality supported in the DBpedia Viewer depends on whether
this functionality is available for that dataset.
First, we discuss di erent tools that are integrated in the
new interface. This is followed by an overview of some
Linked Data browsers.
          </p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="sec-7-5-3">
          <title>Integrated tools</title>
          <p>
            RelFinder [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref4">4</xref>
            ] allows users to explore connections between
multiple entities in a intuitive and interactive way. Given
two entities, RelFinder shows paths in the underlying RDF
graph connecting the two entities. The relationship
discovery algorithm used in [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref4">4</xref>
            ] is based on the original DBpedia
Relationship Finder algorithm [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref8">8</xref>
            ]. The search algorithm is
essentially a breadth- rst search algorithm with several
optimizations for the problem.
          </p>
          <p>
            DBpedia Spotlight [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref9">9</xref>
            ] is an Entity Linking (EL) system.
Given a text, the purpose of EL is to nd which parts of
text refer to which entities. DBpedia Spotlight performs
EL with DBpedia entities. The linking approach of
DBpedia Spotlight consists of three steps: (1) the spotting stage
where the phrases in the text are recognized that might refer
to entities, (2) the candidate selection stage where possible
"meanings" of spotted phrases are generated and (3) the
disambiguation stage where the best candidate entity is chosen
as the meaning of the phrase.
          </p>
          <p>
            Another tool integrated as a triple action is LodLive [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref2">2</xref>
            ].
LodLive is an exploratory tool that allows users to browse
Linked Data in an interactive way, using a dynamic visual
graph. Moreover, it integrates information available across
di erent SPARQL endpoints. This way, it aims to showcase
the principles behind Linked Data.
          </p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="sec-7-5-4">
          <title>Linked Data browsers and integrators</title>
          <p>
            Dadzie and Rowe [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref3">3</xref>
            ] performed a survey of tools for Linked
Data consumption. In their review, the authors make a
distinction between visualization (e.g. RelFinder[
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref4">4</xref>
            ]) and
presentation (e.g. Marbles). A wide range of tools is
discussed and a comparative study of their features is
performed. They also make a distinction between three kinds of
users: (1) tech-users, (2) domain experts and (3) lay users.
One of the conclusions of their survey is that the reviewed
Linked Data consumption tools are mostly oriented at tech
users. Some of the tools discussed by Dadzie and Rowe [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref3">3</xref>
            ]
are discussed in this section.
          </p>
          <p>
            The Marbles Linked Data browser 9 is a server-side
application that generates HTML from Semantic Web content
using Fresnel [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref10">10</xref>
            ] vocabularies. Marbles is used in DBpedia
Mobile [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref1">1</xref>
            ], a location-based Linked Data browser. DBpedia
Mobile shows locations available from DBpedia on a map
with information about the location.
          </p>
          <p>
            Pubby 10 is a server-side Java application that can be
congured to use a SPARQL endpoint and publish the data
behind it as Linked Data. It also provides a simple (static)
HTML user interface. The Graphity project 11 provides a
framework for publishing RDF data or building applications
around it. LDIF [
            <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref11">11</xref>
            ] is a framework aiming to integrate
in
          </p>
        </sec>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-8">
      <title>9http://mes.github.io/marbles 10http://wifo5-03.informatik.uni-mannheim.de/pubby/ 11https://github.com/Graphity/graphity-browser</title>
      <p>formation about entities from di erent datasets but does not
focus on displaying data.</p>
      <sec id="sec-8-1">
        <title>6. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK</title>
        <p>The DBpedia Viewer is a step towards a customizable
framework for interactive, user-friendly presentation of Linked
Data. The original goal was a DBpedia-speci c user
interface that integrates some tools working with DBpedia.
However, the Triple Action Framework also proved to be
useful for de ning system actions, which allow for greater
and easier customization of the interface.</p>
        <p>The interface does not try to conceal the technical
philosophy behind Linked Data. Instead, it embraces the
philosophy and presents the data as it is in a visually appealing
fashion, highlighting the underlying ideas and
demonstrating the possibilities of the integrated tools.</p>
        <p>The Triple Action Framework (TAF) introduced with
DBpedia Viewer demonstrates a method for adding interactive
functionality to Linked Data, going beyond merely serving
RDF facts. Such ideas may not only inspire improvements
in other Linked Data interfaces but might also evolve to
a standardized framework for human interaction with data
across the Semantic Web in the future.</p>
        <p>
          Future versions of DBpedia Viewer will enforce a stronger
modularization between triples, actions and display, thus
following the MVC design pattern. This will generalize the
interface into a framework that can be customized for
different datasets. We also plan to add triple actions for the
incorporation of triple validation by the end users [
          <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref12 ref6">6, 12</xref>
          ].
Another triple action we are investigating is the option to
automatically import DBpedia triples into WikiData.
A potential area of future research is the analysis of user
behavior on the interface to produce novel Entity
Summarization and Entity Ranking data and methods. Entity
Summarization scores can be useful for Question Answering and
Semantic Relatedness. The scores can also be used to
extend the pretty box with the most important entity-speci c
information (e.g.: birth place for persons) and to compute a
better list of properties for the shortcut box.
        </p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-8-2">
        <title>Acknowledgements</title>
        <p>We would like to thank Google for sponsoring this work
through the Google Summer of Code 2013 project.12 This
work was also supported by grants from the European Union's
7th Framework Programme provided for the projects LOD2
(GA no. 257943) and GeoKnow (GA no. 318159).</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back>
    <ref-list>
      <ref id="ref1">
        <mixed-citation>
          [1]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Christian</given-names>
            <surname>Becker</surname>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Christian</given-names>
            <surname>Bizer. DBpedia Mobile</surname>
          </string-name>
          :
          <article-title>A Location-Enabled Linked Data Browser</article-title>
          . LDOW,
          <volume>369</volume>
          ,
          <year>2008</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref2">
        <mixed-citation>
          [2]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Diego</given-names>
            <surname>Valerio</surname>
          </string-name>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Camarda</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Silvia Mazzini, and Alessandro Antonuccio.
          <article-title>LodLive, exploring the Web of Data</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Semantic Systems</source>
          , pages
          <fpage>197</fpage>
          {
          <fpage>200</fpage>
          . ACM,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref3">
        <mixed-citation>
          [3]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Aba-Sah Dadzie</surname>
            and
            <given-names>Matthew</given-names>
          </string-name>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Rowe</surname>
          </string-name>
          .
          <article-title>Approaches to visualising linked data: A survey</article-title>
          .
          <source>Semantic Web</source>
          ,
          <volume>2</volume>
          (
          <issue>2</issue>
          ):
          <volume>89</volume>
          {
          <fpage>124</fpage>
          ,
          <year>2011</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref4">
        <mixed-citation>
          [4]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Philipp</given-names>
            <surname>Heim</surname>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <article-title>Ste en Lohmann, and Timo Stegemann. Interactive Relationship Discovery via the Semantic Web</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 7th Extended Semantic Web Conference (ESWC</source>
          <year>2010</year>
          ), volume
          <volume>6088</volume>
          <source>of LNCS</source>
          , pages
          <volume>303</volume>
          {
          <fpage>317</fpage>
          , Berlin/Heidelberg,
          <year>2010</year>
          . Springer.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref5">
        <mixed-citation>
          [5]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Dimitris</given-names>
            <surname>Kontokostas</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Charalampos Bratsas, Soren Auer, Sebastian Hellmann, Ioannis Antoniou, and
          <string-name>
            <given-names>George</given-names>
            <surname>Metakides</surname>
          </string-name>
          .
          <article-title>Internationalization of Linked Data: The case of the Greek DBpedia edition</article-title>
          .
          <source>Web Semantics: Science, Services and Agents on the World Wide Web</source>
          ,
          <volume>15</volume>
          (
          <issue>0</issue>
          ):
          <volume>51</volume>
          {
          <fpage>61</fpage>
          ,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref6">
        <mixed-citation>
          [6]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Dimitris</given-names>
            <surname>Kontokostas</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Amrapali Zaveri, Soren Auer, and Jens Lehmann.
          <article-title>TripleCheckMate: A Tool for Crowdsourcing the Quality Assessment of Linked Data</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 4th Conference on Knowledge Engineering and Semantic Web</source>
          ,
          <year>2013</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref7">
        <mixed-citation>
          [7]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Jens</given-names>
            <surname>Lehmann</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Robert Isele, Max Jakob, Anja Jentzsch, Dimitris Kontokostas,
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Pablo N.</given-names>
            <surname>Mendes</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Sebastian Hellmann, Mohamed Morsey, Patrick van Kleef,
          <article-title>Soren Auer, and Christian Bizer. DBpedia - A Large-scale, Multilingual Knowledge Base Extracted from Wikipedia</article-title>
          .
          <source>Semantic Web Journal</source>
          ,
          <year>2014</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref8">
        <mixed-citation>
          [8]
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Jens</given-names>
            <surname>Lehmann</surname>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <article-title>Jorg Schuppel, and Soren Auer. Discovering Unknown Connections - the DBpedia Relationship Finder</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 1st Conference on Social Semantic Web (CSSW</source>
          <year>2007</year>
          ), volume
          <volume>113</volume>
          <source>of LNI</source>
          , pages
          <volume>99</volume>
          {
          <fpage>110</fpage>
          .
          <string-name>
            <surname>GI</surname>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2007</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref9">
        <mixed-citation>
          [9]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Pablo</surname>
            <given-names>N Mendes</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <article-title>Max Jakob, Andres Garc a-Silva, and Christian Bizer. DBpedia Spotlight: shedding light on the Web of Documents</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Semantic Systems</source>
          , pages
          <fpage>1</fpage>
          <article-title>{8</article-title>
          . ACM,
          <year>2011</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref10">
        <mixed-citation>
          [10]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Emmanuel</surname>
            <given-names>Pietriga</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <given-names>Christian</given-names>
            <surname>Bizer</surname>
          </string-name>
          , David Karger,
          <string-name>
            <given-names>and Ryan</given-names>
            <surname>Lee</surname>
          </string-name>
          .
          <article-title>Fresnel: A browser-independent presentation vocabulary for rdf</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Isabel Cruz</source>
          , Stefan Decker,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Dean Allemang</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Chris Preist, Daniel Schwabe, Peter Mika, Mike Uschold, and LoraM. Aroyo, editors,
          <source>The Semantic Web - ISWC</source>
          <year>2006</year>
          , volume
          <volume>4273</volume>
          of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, pages
          <volume>158</volume>
          {
          <fpage>171</fpage>
          . Springer Berlin Heidelberg,
          <year>2006</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref11">
        <mixed-citation>
          [11]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Andreas</surname>
            <given-names>Schultz</given-names>
          </string-name>
          , Andrea Matteini, Robert Isele,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Pablo N Mendes</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>Christian</given-names>
          </string-name>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bizer</surname>
            , and
            <given-names>Christian</given-names>
          </string-name>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Becker</surname>
          </string-name>
          .
          <article-title>LDIF - A Framework for Large-Scale Linked Data Integration</article-title>
          .
          <source>In 21st International World Wide Web Conference (WWW</source>
          <year>2012</year>
          ), Developers Track, Lyon, France,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref12">
        <mixed-citation>
          [12]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Amrapali</surname>
            <given-names>Zaveri</given-names>
          </string-name>
          , Dimitris Kontokostas, Mohamed A.
          <string-name>
            <surname>Sherif</surname>
            , Lorenz Buhmann, Mohamed Morsey, Soren Auer, and
            <given-names>Jens</given-names>
          </string-name>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Lehmann</surname>
          </string-name>
          .
          <article-title>User-driven Quality Evaluation of DBpedia</article-title>
          . In To appear
          <source>in Proceedings of 9th International Conference on Semantic Systems, I-SEMANTICS '13</source>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Graz</surname>
          </string-name>
          , Austria, September 4-
          <issue>6</issue>
          ,
          <year>2013</year>
          . ACM,
          <year>2013</year>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
    </ref-list>
  </back>
</article>