ECIM - European Cloud Marketplace for Intelligent Mobility brings to cities a platform that integrates a variety of mobility-related services, such as parking, shared bicycles and public transport, and allows developers to create multi-modal apps with seamless login, payment, discovery and use of different means of transport in the city. ECIM goes even further. It provides a base for development of new business models, such as Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS).
ECIM (European Cloud Marketplace for Intelligent Mobility) is a flexible, cloudbased solution for public and private sector actors who seek or provide web services to address mobility related needs of their cities. The Marketplace is a unique environment where service providers, data providers and developers come together and engage in co-design and co-creation of Mobility applications for citizens. To providers the solution offers an effective distribution channel as well as opportunities to enter new markets and expand their user base. Developers, for their part, benefit from easy access to standardised APIs of different mobility services, some of which are available exclusively through the ECIM platform. The solution is indeed unique and as such has potential to revolutionise the way Mobility services are designed and delivered to citizens. The aims of this paper are to (1) provide an overview of the ECIM project (2) discuss the encountered barriers and challenges during the project deployment and resulting lessons learned and (3) to describe the identified avenues that can help ECIM remain sustainable in the long run while staying at the vanguard of the ongoing transport revolution.
ECIM (www.ecim-cities.eu) is an FP7 project, running between January 2014 and June 2016, with an overall budget of 4,384,000.00 EUR, with 50% of funding provided by the European Commission. The 14 partners from come from 6 countries, and different backgrounds: academic, industry, public authorities and SMEs: iMinds IS-Practice Intrasoft Relational Mobile-for BePark PayByPhone
Belgium Luxembourg Greece Belgium Belgium France
ISSY MEDIA 21C Consultancy CEN Group EJ Consultants CIRB ENoLL
UK Belgium Belgium
The work has been divided between 7 inter-related work packages (WP), with Living Lab as the overarching approach that engages all relevant stakeholders in each stage of the solution design, development, deployment, testing and evaluation. ECIM is currently in its final phase, and after successful piloting there is a proof-of-concept being run in Birmingham. Project partners are now focusing on dissemination of results and working on a plan to make ECIM sustainable after the end of EC funding. 2.1
ECIM has three main objectives: allow cities and businesses to easily migrate services to the cloud, open cloud-based services to innovators for use as a basis for new services and facilitate easy access and cross-border adoption of cloud-based services across Europe. ECIM completes the value-chain for cloud-based public services by deploying a Marketplace wherein public authorities and the private sector, especially SMEs, can migrate their services, create new ones and find a market to sell them. To validate ECIM we selected mobility/parking, consistently cited as high priorities for citizens and public service providers alike. Commercial off-street and public sector on-street parking solutions are easy to locate online. However, these offerings function in near total isolation from each other let alone with related areas such as public transport alternatives such as city bike stations. For example, merging real-time availability of on-street and off-street parking with transport options would enable cities to advance ‘softer’ urban mobility priorities e.g. encouraging environmentally friendly modes of transport. To address these issues, ECIM delivers a cloud-based platform with functionalities that facilitate migration of existing data and services (APIs) of various mobility service providers and public entities (e.g. parking, public transport) and innovative creation of new ones. Moreover, we want to show that by enabling open and innovative management of mobility within cities, ECIM has the potential to significantly improve citizens’ lives by reducing congestion, lowering pollution and saving time. It also has the capacity to help cities save time and money by using cloud computing to stimulate development, aggregation and use of interoperable services that can be reused across borders. 2.2
To design a solution according to real end-user needs, ECIM relies on the proven Living Lab approach ensuring end-user involvement in all stages of development. The approach taken in analysing possible business models and developing a sustainability plan also relied on Living Lab-supported validation exercise. To validate the solution, we ran pilots in Barcelona, Issy-les-Moulineaux and Brussels, and a proof of concept in Birmingham. The platform was built based on collected requirements from project partners, and various APIs were integrated. A mobile app was developed for the pilots, which were able to share services among themselves to demonstrate cross-border interoperability of the solution. Tests were conducted in several iterations, to feed developers with feedback and test the app with incremental improvements. As its basic idea, ECIM is a platform that plays the intermediary role in a two-sided market. In order to create a realistic sustainability plan, various tasks were performed, from market to business model analysis and validation. Following the market analysis, business model analysis was performed and validated with project partners. 3
ECIM had specific goals in what concerns development of the technical solutions. Based on extensive user requirements collection and iterative development, the platform Marketplace is considered as a core project outcome. Piloting the test app, as a Marketplace service consumer, helped us to validate the integrated multi-modal services concept, and finally, the solution was complemented with a sustainability plan. 3.1
The platform Marketplace, developed in WP3 [
While integrating various data and services from private and public providers, we
encountered the need for more homogeneous interfaces. The idea of harmonising API
formats, e.g. for a specific mobility domain (e.g. parking), stemmed from the efforts
required to integrate a variety of different service provider APIs, which enable
interaction with similar services. As a solution, we proposed common API
recommendations initially for parking services (on-street and off-street) [
Tests demonstrated that the ECIM app was perceived as potentially useful for
citizens and visitors [
ECIM complements existing OpenData initiatives by providing not only data (e.g. points-of-interest), but also (web)services, which allow a developer not only to read, but to also interact with mobility service providers. As such, it goes beyond the concept of OpenData and provides the ground for OpenServices, where an authenticated and authorised developer in able to consume and monetize public and private services, up to now available only to providers themselves. ECIM creates a set of API format recommendations to increase service interoperability, help developers easily integrate new services in an app, and enable both sides exploit ECIM cross-border capabilities. With its central role, taking care of interaction between different parties, the Marketplace brings as one of the first the concept of the ‘app store’ to the Mobility domain, paving way to development of Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) offerings. 3.5
The innovation potential of ECIM lies in its open common APIs, which enables service providers, such as park operators, to easily publish their API to the ECIM Marketplace, where it immediately becomes available to registered developers. Since the developers need to visit only one Marketplace and choose from a variety of services, his development path is much smoother and quicker. The platform takes the role of an intermediary and lowers the discovery and negotiation cost because it takes over all technical, financial and contractual negotiations. A developer or a service provider is also able to combine different APIs and create new ones, and finally publish them on the ECIM Marketplace. By providing this flexibility, ECIM gives developers and service providers the tools to innovate not only in technical terms, but also on finding new ways to monetize their products and innovate in the business model. 3.6
ECIM was built on the lessons learned in European Platform for Intelligent Cites (EPIC) project (2010-2013). ECIM also made use of lessons learned in other projects and initiatives: MOBI.Europe, SuperHub, POLITE, smartCEM, SATIE. As part of the requirements collection and technical design phase we explored several mobilityrelated initiatives, API services, Mobility apps, IoT and Mobile payments. During the project several commercial initiatives have emerged, and the ECIM team made sure the most important and relevant were studied and considered in the solution or concept design. Just to highlight one, MaaS, a concept emerged in 2015 in Finland, identified as a paradigm shift, changing the way citizens, employees or travellers use Mobility services. ECIM is seen as a technical enabler for MaaS offerings, putting MaaS brokers on the map of potential customers. 4 4.1
ECIM Marketplace enables SMEs to monetize their data and web services. With
strong value proposition for various groups of potential users, and a positive outcome
of the market analysis, the project partners engaged in studying a feasible business
model that would enable the project to become commercially viable and sustainable
also after the funding from the EC has been concluded. Sustainability planning started
with a market analysis [
• Enabling cooperation between service and data providers and developers • Technological means to do so (APIs) • Active interest and involvement of the public sector
Opportunities • Popularity of MaaS concept and paradigm shifts in transport market entailing diverse business opportunities • Involvement and investment from local, national and EU governments could secure leadership buy-in Threats • Limited Marketplace participants • As an EU project disincentives established mobility actors to invest • Other actors (e.g. UbiGo) expanding
into ECIM pilot cities • Several competitors with similar offers
We continued exploring which business model could help ECIM enter this market
and provide added value to its customers and become sustainable. ECIM business
model relies on the platform theory, which is characterized by interdependencies of
the participating groups of providers and consumers, and is conceptualized as a
multisided market where the utility that user A derives from participating in the market is
correlated to the number of users B (and conversely): externalities between
stakeholders internalized by the market [
Platform businesses have proven to be most viable in today’s Internet economy.
Nonetheless, to establish such a business, various roadblocks have to be overcome in
the go-to-market strategy. The conclusion of the workshops suggested the need of city
authority’s involvement in ECIM deployment in order to create impact. Establishing
ECIM as a general service relying on revenue sharing would require a substantial
business setup investment and more beneficial financial conditions to be attractive to
service providers with existing payment processing contracts. Nevertheless, the main
challenge is to start such two-sided market because the interdependencies on which
such markets are founded pose substantial difficulties. Participating is only interesting
for an actor if its counterparts also participate, and to launch such market is similar to
the “chicken and egg” problem. This coordination problem (“hold up”) refers to the
lack of incentives to invest for independent firms planning to offer complementary
goods/services. Such problems (‘indirect network effects’) are argued to be
“endemic” to the ICT industry [
The market analysis proved that there is room and demand for a solution such as ECIM, positive feedback on the concept was collected during the piloting, where testers (citizens) acknowledged the significant value of having several Mobility services integrated the one pilot app, which was developed using ECIM APIs. Furthermore, the business model workshop showed that the identified value proposition is realistic, and the overall business model is feasible. Revenue sharing gets increasingly complex with an increasing number of actors involved. As a technological and contractual intermediary ECIM establishes rules for these relationships and simplifies the revenue sharing. This is the case also because certain kinds of service re-users will also be able to provide their own services on ECIM Marketplace at some point, thus changing role to provider; or even being both at the same time. Nevertheless, based on the amount of the estimated initial investment, and the identified barriers in becoming an attractive platform for service providers to share their revenue, we identified that the most feasible initial model is to provide the platform as a public infrastructure that is not per se profitable, but instead relies on low running cost enabled by its cloud nature, while maintaining the opportunity to switch to a paid, revenue sharing model once it gains popularity. Project partners are already discussing the possibility to provide the platform to Brussels region as regional infrastructure service, provided by CIRB and commissioned by the Brussels parking agency, which aims to harmonise and streamline parking services in the region.