<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.0 20120330//EN" "JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
  <front>
    <journal-meta />
    <article-meta>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>Secure Electronic Medical Records Transmission using NTRU Cryptosystem and LSB in Audio Steganography</article-title>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group>
        <aff id="aff0">
          <label>0</label>
          <institution>Adamu Abdulkadir, Shafi'i Muhammad Abdulhamid, Oluwafem Osho, Ismaila Idris and John K Alhassan Department of Cyber Security Science, Federal University of Technology</institution>
          ,
          <addr-line>Minna</addr-line>
          ,
          <country country="NG">Nigeria</country>
        </aff>
      </contrib-group>
      <abstract>
        <p>- Electronic medical records (EMR) are vital information, extremely sensitive private data in healthcare, and need to be frequently shared via the internet among peers. One of the major benefits derived from the internet is the ease of sending information from one system to another, irrespective of the location or distance between the nodes. This, and many other related important functionality, over the years, has attracted attackers who dedicate themselves to breaching the integrity, availability and confidentiality of EMR information. Existing literature have proposed cryptographic techniques that are not quantum-safe. In this paper, an audiobased system for hiding EMR information using a quantumsafe cryptographic technique, Nth degree Truncated Polynomial Ring Units (NTRU) cryptosystem, and the Least Significant Bit (LSB) steganographic technique is proposed. The system was evaluated based on embedding capacity (EC), peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR), mean square error (MSE), and histogram plots. Results showed our proposed system is able to securely hide the medical records without causing significant distortions in the original audio.</p>
      </abstract>
      <kwd-group>
        <kwd>- Electronic medical records (EMR)</kwd>
        <kwd>Information hiding</kwd>
        <kwd>Security</kwd>
        <kwd>Cryptography</kwd>
        <kwd>Steganography</kwd>
        <kwd>LSB</kwd>
        <kwd>NTRU</kwd>
      </kwd-group>
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body>
    <sec id="sec-1">
      <title>I. INTRODUCTION</title>
      <p>Electronic medical records (EMR) are very delicate private
records for diagnosis and treatment in healthcare, which
need to be regularly shared among medical personnel in
both rural and urban settings such as healthcare providers,
insurance companies, pharmacies, researchers, patient’s
families, among others. This poses a major challenge on
keeping a patient’s medical history up-to-date and most at
times private. Transmissions of EMR information are
mostly done using the cyber space or wide area networks
which are prone to attacks.</p>
      <p>Since the advent of the internet, its capacity and
sophistication have continued to advance. From a platform
used primarily for displaying static web pages, it has
become a tool for dynamic exchange of EMR data and
information. Today, the internet not only serves as a
repository of EMR information, but also, among other
purposes, provides functionality for exchange of
information among different medical personnel.</p>
      <p>
        Unfortunately, the current architecture of the internet does
not support security [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref1">1</xref>
        ]. Attackers exploit this inherent
weakness to perpetrate different attacks which target EMR
data. Hence, the need for security of EMR data online
cannot be over-emphasized. One method of protecting EMR
data online is data hiding.
      </p>
      <p>
        EMR data hiding simply involves embedding EMR data in
different media. EMR data, such as text, images, videos, or
audio can be concealed in a media, for security purpose.
Techniques used for hiding EMR data are watermarking,
steganography, and cryptography [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref2">2</xref>
        ]. Watermarking is
essentially used to indicate ownership of an object [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref3 ref4">3, 4</xref>
        ].
Steganography is used to secure EMR data transmission. A
message is usually hidden in another message to make it
imperceptible to unauthorized entities [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref5 ref6">5, 6</xref>
        ].
      </p>
      <p>
        One shortcoming, however, with strictly relying on
steganograsphy is its vulnerability to steganalysis [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref7">7</xref>
        ]. With
steganalysis hidden messages can be detected [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref8 ref9">8, 9</xref>
        ]. One
solution is to encrypt the message before embedding it in a
media. Cryptography scrambles messages to render them
unintelligible to unauthorized entities. This ensures that
even if the attacker discovers the hidden message the actual
content of the message is not decoded.
      </p>
      <p>In this study, we propose a security enhancing EMR data
hiding system that leverages cryptography and
steganography, specifically, the Nth degree TRUncated
Polynomial Ring Units (NTRU) and Least Significant Bit
(LSB) respectively.</p>
      <p>The rest of the paper is organized as follows: in section II,
we review some related studies. The methodology used in
the study is discussed in the next section. Section IV
presents the implementation of the system and results of the
evaluation. The study is concluded in section V.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-2">
      <title>II. RELATED WORKS</title>
      <p>
        Different cryptographic and steganographic techniques have
been proposed by authors. In the choice of steganographic
techniques, few authors considered the use of transform
domain techniques. These include Discrete Wavelet
Transform (DWT) [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref10">10</xref>
        ], and Discrete Cosine Transform
(DCT) [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref11">11</xref>
        ]. However, most studies employed spatial
domain techniques, with LSB as the most common. In the
study by [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref12">12</xref>
        ], a Hash Least Siginificant Bit (H-LSB) was
proposed. This entails the use of hash function to determine
the position of insertion in the LSB. [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref13">13</xref>
        ], in their own work,
combined the use of Pixel value differencing (PVD) and
LSB to embed messages in truecolor RGB images. PVD
helps to determine the size of the secret message
embeddable in a pixel, using the difference between two
consecutive pixels [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref14">14</xref>
        ]. With this method, the stego-image
can hide much larger information, whilst still maintaining
good visual quality [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref15 ref16">15, 16</xref>
        ].
      </p>
      <p>
        To encrypt the messages before they are embedded into the
various media, most studies seem to favor the use of
symmetric techniques. Some of the techniques proposed are
AES [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref17 ref18 ref19 ref20 ref21 ref22">17-22</xref>
        ], DES [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref23">23</xref>
        ], Blowfish [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref24">24</xref>
        ], and Affine Cipher
[
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref25">25</xref>
        ]. Saraireh [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref26">26</xref>
        ] proposed the use of the filter bank cipher
over Galois field (GF (28)), to improve the resistivity of the
cipher against cryptanalysis attacks, specifically, differential
and linear attacks. Usha, Kumar and Boopathybagan [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref27">27</xref>
        ]
proposed an information hiding systems that implements
double layer of EMR data encryption. The message is first
encrypted using the Playfair cipher. The ciphertext is then
encrypted using AES. Hayfaa, Ahmad and Noor [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref28">28</xref>
        ], in
their study, designed a simple substitution cipher which
represents each character by five bit. It is essentially based
on substituting characters in the English language with a
code number.
      </p>
      <p>
        One of the few studies that involved the use of asymmetric
cryptographic scheme is [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref29">29</xref>
        ]. The study explored the effects
of two encryption schemes, RSA and DHA, on time
complexity. Their results showed that while the use of RSA
increased the time complexity in steganalysis, the Diffie
Hellman Algorithm did not. Table 1 presents a summary of
some related studies.
      </p>
      <p>
        The objective of combining steganography with
cryptography is to enhance the security of the hidden
message, to the effect that even if the hidden message is
discovered its true contents remain unreadable to the
attacker. The level of security will therefore be dependent
on the strength of the cryptographic scheme employed. Most
existing studies proposed modern cryptographic techniques.
However, these techniques are vulnerable to many attacks
including brute-force, known plaintext, chosen ciphertext
attacks [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref30">30</xref>
        ].
      </p>
      <p>
        One other issue borders the fact that most asymmetric
cryptographic schemes are based essentially on either
integer factorization or discrete logarithms. These classes of
problems, unfortunately, can be solved quickly by quantum
computers that employ quantum algorithms. The
implication is that, the capacity of the techniques to secure
encrypted information cannot be guaranteed [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref31">31</xref>
        ]. There is
therefore need for cryptographic techniques that are
      </p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-3">
      <title>III. METHODOLOGY</title>
      <p>EMR data hiding system that leverages on cryptography and
steganography to secure message is presented. The message
is first encrypted using NTRU. The encrypted message is
then embedded into a digital audio media using LSB
technique before it is transmitted by the sender. The
encryption/decryption process by NTRU and embedding
algorithm of the LSB technique are presented in the
succeeding sections respectively. Figure 1 presents the
embedding process. For extraction of the hidden message by
the receiver, the process is essentially reversed.
quantum-safe. This is the major contribution of this
research.</p>
      <sec id="sec-3-1">
        <title>Authors (Year)</title>
        <p>Bob to compute:

sends to Bob.</p>
        <p>, and then uses the public key of

≡  ⨂ ℎ + ( )
(4)
is the encrypted version of the message Alice finally
Decryption: For Bob to decrypt the encrypted message 
from Alice, he computes:
 ≡  ⨂ 
( )
(5)
The coefficients of  are chosen from the interval −  ⁄2 to
 ⁄2 . He recovers the message via:</p>
        <p>⨂  ( )
This method is used to hide sequence of binary message in
the least significant bit of a digital audio file. This technique
capitalizes on the nature of the Human Auditory System
(HAS) which does not have the ability to detect slight
differences in the audio frequencies, especially when it is
more concentrated at the audible spectrum. LSB has the
advantage that it allows large amount of information to be
hidden</p>
        <p>without reducing the quality of the audio file.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-4">
      <title>Consequently, it is easy to carry out.</title>
      <p>
        An illustration of how the message ‘FUT’ is embedded into
an audio file using the concept of LSB is presented in
bit stream. To convert ‘FUT’ to binary, we convert the
ASCII value equivalent of the different characters in the
message to binary. This is presented in Table 2. The least
significant (right-most) bit of the audio stream is then
replaced with the bit stream of the message.
NTRU is a ring-based public key cryptosystem proposed by
Hoffstein, Pipher and Silverman [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref32">32</xref>
        ]. It is an efficient and
computationally inexpensive cryptosystem, known for its
low
      </p>
      <p>
        memory requirement, high speed, moderately, and
easily created keys [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref33">33</xref>
        ]. The technique is secure against
brute-force, meet-in-the-middle, multiple transmission, and
lattice-based attacks. And it is a quantum-safe cryptosystem.
 &gt; 
ℤ[] / (
      </p>
      <p>– 1)
For an NTRU cryptosystem, we define three integer
parameter: (, , )</p>
      <p>, and four sets of polynomials of degree
 − 1 : ℒ , ℒ , ℒ , ℒ . We assume that (, ) = 1
, and
. The notation for the ring is given as:  =
.
(2)
(3)</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-5">
      <title>We write an element</title>
      <p>as:
 =
∑</p>
      <p>We write a star multiplication, denoted by ⨂ , which is
explicitly a cyclic convolution product.</p>
      <p>Key Creation: Bob randomly select polynomials ,   ℒ</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-6">
      <title>We denote two inverses,  and  , of polynomial  by:</title>
      <p>⨂  ≡ 1( )
and  ⨂  ≡ 1( )
(1)</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-7">
      <title>Bob then computes:</title>
      <p>ℎ ≡</p>
      <p>⨂ ( )
Therefore, the public key of Bob is the polynomial ℎ, while
his private key is  .</p>
      <p>Encryption: To send a message to Bob, Alice simply
selects a message  from the set of plaintexts ℒ , randomly
F
U
T
70
85
84</p>
      <sec id="sec-7-1">
        <title>Binary</title>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sec-7-2">
        <title>Representation</title>
        <p>1000110
1010101
1010100</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-8">
      <title>C. Performance evaluation metrics The performance of our proposed system is evaluated by the embedding capacity (EC), mean squared error (MSE), peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR), and histogram plots.</title>
      <p>Embedding Capacity (EC): This is the maximum quantity
of EMR data that can be embedded into a cover audio
without significantly altering the value of the original audio
file. It is the fraction of the secret message by the cover
audio object.</p>
      <p>=
(6)
Mean Squared Error (MSE): Denotes the cumulative
square error between the cover audio signal and the
stegoaudio. When the value of the MSE is low it is better, and
therefore the little the error rate between the illustrations
which shows little alteration was added. MSE is computed
using the formula:
 =
∑ , [ ( , ) ( , )]
∗
(7)
M and N stand for the rows and columns of the audio
samples. I1 is the stego audio while I2 is the cover audio</p>
      <sec id="sec-8-1">
        <title>Peak Signal to Noise Ratio (PSNR): It is used to estimate</title>
        <p>the amount of resemblance that exists between the original
audio and the stego-audio. This parameter depends on MSE.
It is also referred to as the quality measurement between
two or files involved. It is measured in decibels. When the
comparison of PSNR is high it means the system is good
and this shows that the distortion is low.
(8)
Where R is the slightest variation of the stego-audio, which
is usually 255 in integer EMR data type.</p>
        <p>Histogram Plot: This provides a graphical representation of
the different amplitude values of the audio signal.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-9">
      <title>IV. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS</title>
      <p>The proposed NTRU + LSB technique was developed using
a PC with the following properties: Pentium (R) CPU
T4500 @ 2.30GHz, 4GB RAM, Windows 8.1 pro operating
system, and Java programming language (using NetBeans
8.1 platform). Appendices A to D depict some screenshots
of system testing.</p>
      <p>To evaluate the performance of the proposed technique, five
.wav digital audio samples were used. Five messages of
different sizes were generated, with each embedded into one
audio sample. The corresponding stego-audio files were
analyzed on MATLAB 2013a. Details including the audio
name, size, and message size, and results of the EC, MSE,
and PNSR are presented in Table 3.
hotstuff
Results showed that the different messages were
successfully embedded in the .wav audio covers. The low
MSE in each case shows that little alteration was added.
Equally, the high PNSR values, which are consequences of
the low MSE, confirm high resemblance between the
original audio samples and the corresponding stego-audio
files. This implies that our proposed system is good, causing
no significant distortions in the audios. To further explore
the effect of embedding messages in the selected audio files.
Figures 3 to 7 present the histogram plots. The results show
little or no differences in the audios after steganography.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="sec-10">
      <title>V. CONCLUSION</title>
      <p>
        In this study, we proposed and implemented an enhanced
EMR information hiding system to protect medical records
from unauthorized access in healthcare environment. The
system combined NTRU cryptographic algorithm and LSB
audio steganography to offer a more robust method for
hiding the EMR secrete data from unauthorized access. The
performance of the crypto-steganographic system was
evaluated using Matlab environment. Evaluation of the
performance showed little or no distortion to the sample
audios after message embedment. Our system could
promote secure communication in healthcare systems,
ensuring confidentiality, integrity, and availability.
Our major contribution lies in proposing a secure
cryptosteganographic technique. Future studies could consider
other quantum-safe cryptographic schemes. This includes
techniques based on lattice theory, coding theory, and
multivariate quadratic polynomials. Our proposed system
implemented the commonly used spatial domain technique,
LSB. Frequency domain techniques have been reported to
be stronger than those in the spatial domain [
        <xref ref-type="bibr" rid="ref34">34</xref>
        ].
Combining highly secure cryptographic and steganographic
techniques would no doubt increase the level of security an
EMR information hiding system can provide.
      </p>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back>
    <ref-list>
      <ref id="ref1">
        <mixed-citation>
          [1]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abdullah</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Aziz</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>R.H.H.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>New Approaches to Encrypt and Decrypt Data in Image using Cryptography and Steganography Algorithm</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Computer Applications</source>
          ,
          <volume>143</volume>
          (
          <issue>4</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>11</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>17</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref2">
        <mixed-citation>
          [2]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abikoye</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>O.C.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Adewole</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>K.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Oladipupo</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.J.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
          <article-title>Efficient Data Hiding System using Cryptography and Steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Applied Information Systems</source>
          ,
          <volume>4</volume>
          (
          <issue>11</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>6</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>11</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref3">
        <mixed-citation>
          [3]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Campagna</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          et al.,
          <year>2015</year>
          .
          <article-title>Quantum Safe Cryptography and Security: An Introduction, Benefits, Enablers</article-title>
          and Challenges, Available at: http://www.etsi.org/images/files/ETSIWhitePapers/QuantumSafeW hitepaper.pdf.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref4">
        <mixed-citation>
          [4]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Das</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2014</year>
          .
          <article-title>A Study on Modern Cryptography and their Security Issues</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering</source>
          ,
          <volume>4</volume>
          (
          <issue>10</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>320</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>324</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref5">
        <mixed-citation>
          [5]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Deshpande</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>N.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          et al.,
          <year>2015</year>
          .
          <article-title>Implementation of Audio Steganography Using RSA Algorithm</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Technology Enhancements and Emerging Engineering Research</source>
          ,
          <volume>3</volume>
          (
          <issue>4</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>81</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>84</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref6">
        <mixed-citation>
          [6]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Djebbar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>F.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          et al.,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
          <article-title>Comparative study of digital audio steganography techniques</article-title>
          .
          <source>EURASIP Journal on Audio, Speech, and Music Processing</source>
          ,
          <volume>25</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>1</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>16</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref7">
        <mixed-citation>
          [7]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Garg</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>N.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kaur</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>K.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>Hybrid information security model for cloud storage systems using hybrid data security scheme</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology</source>
          ,
          <volume>3</volume>
          (
          <issue>4</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>2194</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>2196</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref8">
        <mixed-citation>
          [8]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Gupta</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Ankur</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>G.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bhushan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>B.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
          <article-title>Information Hiding Using Least Significant Bit Steganography and Cryptography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Modern Education and Computer Science</source>
          ,
          <volume>6</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>27</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>34</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref9">
        <mixed-citation>
          [9]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Hayfaa</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Ahmad</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>R.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Noor</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>N.M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2014</year>
          .
          <article-title>Combining Cryptography and Steganography for Data Hiding in Images</article-title>
          .
          <source>conference of Applied Computer and Applied Computational Science (ACACOS)</source>
          , pp.
          <fpage>128</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>134</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref10">
        <mixed-citation>
          [10]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Latiff</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.S.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Chiroma</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>H.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Osho</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>O.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abdul-Salaam</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>G.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abubakar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.I.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <surname>Herawan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>T.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2017</year>
          .
          <article-title>A review on mobile SMS spam filtering techniques</article-title>
          .
          <source>IEEE Access</source>
          ,
          <volume>5</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>15650</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>15666</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref11">
        <mixed-citation>
          [11]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Hussain</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          et al.,
          <year>2015</year>
          .
          <article-title>Pixel value differencing steganography techniques: Analysis and open challenge</article-title>
          .
          <source>In 2015 IEEE International Conference on Consumer Electronics - Taiwan</source>
          , ICCE-TW
          <year>2015</year>
          . pp.
          <fpage>21</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>22</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref12">
        <mixed-citation>
          [12]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Jefferson</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>D.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          et al.,
          <year>2004</year>
          .
          <article-title>A security analysis of the Secure Electronic Registration and Voting Experiment (SERVE</article-title>
          ), Available at: http://requiem.googlecode.com/files/paper.pdf.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref13">
        <mixed-citation>
          [13]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Jefferson</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>D.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Rubin</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Simons</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>B.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <article-title>A comment on the May 2007 DoD report on Voting Technologies for UOCAVA Citizens</article-title>
          , Available at: https://www.verifiedvoting.org/wpcontent/uploads/2014/10/serve_d od_comment_
          <year>2007</year>
          .pdf.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref14">
        <mixed-citation>
          [14]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kaur</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Singh</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>N.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2015</year>
          .
          <article-title>SMS Encryption using NTRU Algorithm</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Science &amp; Technology, 3(2)</source>
          , pp.
          <fpage>96</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>100</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref15">
        <mixed-citation>
          [15]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kaur</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kaur</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>G.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2014</year>
          .
          <article-title>Review of Various Steganalysis Techniques</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies</source>
          ,
          <volume>5</volume>
          (
          <issue>2</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>1744</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>1747</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref16">
        <mixed-citation>
          [16]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Phad</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>V.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bhosale</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>R.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Panhalkar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.R.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
          <string-name>
            <given-names>A</given-names>
            <surname>Novel Security</surname>
          </string-name>
          <article-title>Scheme for Secret Data using Cryptography and Steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Computer Network and Information Security</source>
          ,
          <volume>2</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>36</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>42</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref17">
        <mixed-citation>
          [17]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Qian</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>T.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Manoharan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>A comparative review of steganalysis techniques</article-title>
          .
          <source>In 2015 IEEE 2nd International Conference on Information Science and Security</source>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>ICISS</surname>
          </string-name>
          <year>2015</year>
          . pp.
          <fpage>1</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>4</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref18">
        <mixed-citation>
          [18]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Rasmi</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Mohanapriya</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>An Extensive Survey of Data Hiding Techniques</article-title>
          .
          <source>Indian Journal of Science and Technology</source>
          ,
          <volume>9</volume>
          (
          <issue>28</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>1</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>7</lpage>
          . Available at: http://www.indjst.org/index.php/indjst/article/view/90457.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref19">
        <mixed-citation>
          [19]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Reddy</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.I.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kumar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.P.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>Secured Data Transmission Using Wavelet Based Steganography and Cryptography by Using AES Algorithm</article-title>
          .
          <source>Procedia Computer Science</source>
          ,
          <volume>85</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>62</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>69</lpage>
          . Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <volume>05</volume>
          .177.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref20">
        <mixed-citation>
          [20]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Wu</surname>
          </string-name>
          , H.-C. et al.,
          <year>2005</year>
          .
          <article-title>Image steganographic scheme based on pixelvalue differencing and LSB replacement methods</article-title>
          .
          <source>IEE Proc.-Vis. Image Signal Processing</source>
          ,
          <volume>152</volume>
          (
          <issue>5</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>611</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>615</lpage>
          . Available at: http://kar.kent.ac.uk/12311/.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref21">
        <mixed-citation>
          [21]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Sarmah</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>D.K.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bajpai</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>N.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2010</year>
          .
          <article-title>Proposed System for data hiding using Cryptography and Steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Computer Applications</source>
          ,
          <volume>8</volume>
          (
          <issue>9</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>1</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>8</lpage>
          . Available at: http://arxiv.org/abs/1009.2826.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref22">
        <mixed-citation>
          [22]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Sethi</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>P.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kapoor</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>V.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>A Proposed Novel Architecture for Information Hiding in Image Steganography by Using Genetic Algorithm and Cryptography</article-title>
          .
          <source>Procedia Computer Science</source>
          ,
          <volume>87</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>61</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>66</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref23">
        <mixed-citation>
          [23]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Singh</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Malik</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2013</year>
          .
          <article-title>Securing Data by Using Cryptography with Steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer Science and Software Engineering</source>
          ,
          <volume>3</volume>
          (
          <issue>5</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>404</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>409</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref24">
        <mixed-citation>
          [24]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Tsai</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>Y.Y.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Chen</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.T.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Chan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>C.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2014</year>
          .
          <article-title>Exploring LSB substitution and pixel-value differencing for block-based adaptive data hiding</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Network Security</source>
          ,
          <volume>16</volume>
          (
          <issue>5</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>363</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>368</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref25">
        <mixed-citation>
          [25]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Alhassan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.K.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abubakar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>B.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Olalere</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abdulhamid</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.I.M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <surname>Ahmad</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <source>Forensic Acquisition of Data from a Crypt 12 Encrypted Database of Whatsapp.</source>
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref26">
        <mixed-citation>
          [26]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Saraireh</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2013</year>
          .
          <article-title>A Secure Data Communication System Using Cryptography and Steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>International Journal of Computer Networks &amp; Communications</source>
          ,
          <volume>5</volume>
          (
          <issue>3</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>125</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>137</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref27">
        <mixed-citation>
          [27]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Zachariah</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>B.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Yabuwat</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>P.N.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bernard</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>E.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2016</year>
          .
          <article-title>Application of Steganography and Cryptography for Secured Data Communication -</article-title>
          A Review.
          <source>International Journal of Engineering Research &amp; Technology, 5(4)</source>
          , pp.
          <fpage>186</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>190</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref28">
        <mixed-citation>
          [28]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Usha</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Kumar</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>G.A.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Boopathybagan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>K.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2011</year>
          .
          <article-title>A secure triple level encryption method using cryptography and steganography</article-title>
          .
          <source>Proceedings of 2011 International Conference on Computer Science and Network Technology, ICCSNT</source>
          <year>2011</year>
          ,
          <volume>2</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>1017</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>1020</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref29">
        <mixed-citation>
          [29]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Waziri</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>V.O.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Isah</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Ochoche</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <surname>Abulhamid</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.I.M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2012</year>
          .
          <article-title>Steganography and its applications in information dessimilation on the web using images as securityembeddment: a wavelet approach</article-title>
          .
          <source>Int J Comput Inf Technol</source>
          ,
          <volume>1</volume>
          (
          <issue>02</issue>
          ), pp.
          <fpage>194</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>202</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref30">
        <mixed-citation>
          [30]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Latiff</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.S.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2017</year>
          .
          <article-title>A checkpointed league championship algorithmbased cloud scheduling scheme with secure fault tolerance responsiveness</article-title>
          .
          <source>Applied Soft Computing</source>
          ,
          <volume>61</volume>
          , pp.
          <fpage>670</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>680</lpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref31">
        <mixed-citation>
          [31]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Hoffstein</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Pipher</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          &amp;
          <string-name>
            <surname>Silverman</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>J.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>1998</year>
          . NTRU:
          <article-title>A ring-based public key cryptosystem</article-title>
          .
          <source>Algorithmic number theory; Lecture Notes in Computer Science (LNCS)</source>
          , pp.
          <fpage>267</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>288</lpage>
          . Available at: http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/BFb0054868.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref32">
        <mixed-citation>
          [32]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Singla</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          <article-title>and</article-title>
          <string-name>
            <surname>Bala</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2018</year>
          , April. A Review:
          <article-title>Cryptography and Steganography Algorithm for Cloud Computing</article-title>
          .
          <source>In 2018 Second International Conference on Inventive Communication and Computational Technologies (ICICCT)</source>
          (pp.
          <fpage>953</fpage>
          -
          <lpage>957</lpage>
          ). IEEE.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref33">
        <mixed-citation>
          [33]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Mustafa</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>G.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Ashraf</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>R.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Mirza</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <surname>Jamil</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2018</year>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>June.</surname>
          </string-name>
          <article-title>A review of data security and cryptographic techniques in IoT based devices</article-title>
          .
          <source>In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Future Networks and Distributed Systems</source>
          (p.
          <fpage>47</fpage>
          ). ACM.
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="ref34">
        <mixed-citation>
          [34]
          <string-name>
            <surname>Mohsin</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.H.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Zaidan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Zaidan</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>B.B.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>bin Ariffin</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>S.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Albahri</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>O.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Albahri</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>A.S.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Alsalem</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.A.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <string-name>
            <surname>Mohammed</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>K.I.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          and
          <string-name>
            <surname>Hashim</surname>
            ,
            <given-names>M.</given-names>
          </string-name>
          ,
          <year>2018</year>
          .
          <article-title>Real-Time Medical Systems Based on Human Biometric Steganography: a Systematic Review</article-title>
          .
          <source>Journal of medical systems</source>
          ,
          <volume>42</volume>
          (
          <issue>12</issue>
          ), p.
          <fpage>245</fpage>
          .
        </mixed-citation>
      </ref>
    </ref-list>
  </back>
</article>