=Paper= {{Paper |id=Vol-2544/paper5 |storemode=property |title=Remote Heartbeat Monitoring System for Cardiovascular Patients |pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2544/paper5.pdf |volume=Vol-2544 |authors=Toyeeb A. Musliudeen,Lukman A. Olawoyin,Abdulkarim A. Oloyede,Timothy K. Oyun,Nasir Faruk,Ibraheem Katibi |dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/irehi/MusliudeenOOOFK18 }} ==Remote Heartbeat Monitoring System for Cardiovascular Patients== https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2544/paper5.pdf
              Remote Heartbeat Monitoring System for
                     Cardiovascular Patients
       Toyeeb A. M usliudeen                           Abdulkarim A. Oloyede                                Nasir Faruk
           Departmnet of                         Departmnet of Electronics, Univeristy                    Departmnet of
TelecommunicationScience University                         of York, UK                         TelecommunicationScience University
              of Ilorin                                 aao500@york.ac.uk                                    of Ilorin
    musliudeentoyeeb@gmail.com                                                                        Faruk.n@unilorin.edu.ng
                                                         Timothy K. Oyun
                                                          Departmnet of                                     Ibraheem Katibi
         Lukman A. Olawoyin
            Departmnet of                        TelecommunicationScience University                Cardiology Unit, Department of
TelecommunicationScience University                           of Ilorin                                        M edicine
               of Ilorin                                                                                  University of Ilorin
                                                                                                       iakatibi@unilorin.edu.ng
      lolawoyin@unilorin.edu.ng


    Abstract— The rise in Cardiovascular disease (CVD) cases          the HR at rest is the number of occurrence of the beat of the
is alarming, as it’s become the world’s major disease                 heart in the sitting condition, when lying down or when the
contributing to almost 50% of noncommunicable disease. The            nerve is calm. This is set within the range of 60 to 100 beats
need to have real time access of the patient’s heart condition        per minute (b m) [3]. However, the HR of an athlete and an
(heartbeat) is necessary in proper management and treatment           active adult is slower than that of a resting or stationary
of CVDs. However, the lack of manpower and adequate                   person [4]. The normal HR for a baby (less than one year of
funding hinder the deployment of heart beat monitors in
                                                                      age) is higher and this is expected to be around 120 to 160
considerable number of hospitals in developing countries. In
                                                                      bpm and that of an healthy child is expected to be around 75
this paper, we present design and implementation of energy
                                                                      to 110 bpm [5].
efficient and cost-effective remote heartbeat monitoring
system. The implementation consists of pulse sensor, Arduino              Over the years, there have been different methods of
UNO, HC-05 Bluetooth module and 9v battery. The                       measuring heartbeat. However as technology advances, the
ATMega328 microprocessor of the Arduino is programmed in              methods involved is also advancing. The conventional
C language with the use of the library function "Pulse Sensor         manual method of taking the heart pulse has advanced into
Playground" of the Arduino, while the end terminal                    electronic methods [6]. Two of the most common types of
application is programmed with java via processing. A front           the electronic methods are the electrical method
end application was developed and used to display the pulse
                                                                      (electrocardiography) and the optical method (photo
data. The de vice constructed operates smoothly, based on the
sampled BPM data collected from 5 adults. The design is quite         plethysmography). The electrical method uses the voltage
efficient as it successfully connects the pulse sensor remotely to    extracted fro m placing a strap of electrode pads on the body,
the frontend application. It also relays the BPM value to the         while that of the optical method uses light as its source of
terminal device in real time.                                         data [7]. The optical method of the pulse sensor involves the
                                                                      process of placing the fingertip between the infrared
    Keywords—heartbeat monitor, Cardiovascular, energy                transmitter and a photodiode sensor. As blood flows through
efficiency Arduino, Bluetooth                                         the vein, it absorbs the infrared light which is in turn
                                                                      captured by the photodiode sensor. Afterwards, the intensity
                                                                      of the reflected light captured by the photodiode sensor
                      I. INT RODUCTION                                (LDR) y ields the blood pulse value [8]. The pulse value is
Card iovascular disease (CVD) is a condition involving the            then further displayed via a display terminal for access by a
blood vessels, either narrowing or co mplete blockage of the          cardiologist or medical practitioner.
blood vessels, resulting to heart attack. So me examp les of               The need to have real time access of the patient’s heart
this disease include the heart failure, heart attack, coronary        condition (heart beat) is necessary in proper management and
artery diseases, stroke and many others [1].                          treatment of CVD. Heart beat monitoring systems is
                                                                      commonly used to measure the heartbeat of patients.
The global rise in CVDs cases has become the topic issue              However, lack of manpower and adequate funding hinder the
and burden as its currently the world’s major disease                 deployment of the devices in considerable number of
contributing to almost 50% of non-commun icable disease               hospitals in developing countries. Moreover, power supply
[2]. This has surpasses the communicable d iseases. The               is another big issue to sustain the running of these devices
global death as the result of CVDs currently stood at 17.3            within the time span needed to monitor patients with CVDs.
million deaths per year, th is number however, is expected to         Furthermore, the economic pressure and realities has pushed
grow even higher by the year 2030 [2].                                most of the healthcare industries to seek for new and cost
                                                                      effective paradigms that could provide health care service to
    Hence, detecting this disease is essential and one of early       people. Therefore in this paper, a user friendly, portable, cost
step is to examine for irregular heartbeat pattern in a patient.      and energy efficient heart beat monitoring system that could
The rate at which the heart beats could be used as a basis for        be used to remotely (via wireless medium), access the beat
detecting the condition of the heart of a patient. The heartrate      rates or HR of patients with CVD is developed. The device
(HR) varies in accordance to the age, activity and the                allows for remote monitoring of a patient which is often
condition of a person. The HR for a healthy adult, defined as         required as the doctor to patent ratio in Africa can be as low


Copyright © 2019 for this paper by its authors. Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
IREHI 2018 : 2nd IEEE International Rural and Elderly Health Informatics Conference
as 1:50000 [9].The device also provide a short range wireless       allow free mobility of the patient while his / her health
technology for sending the captured HR to a remote terminal.        parameters being monitored. A wireless sensor is to be used
The remote terminal would be able to display the HR of              in monitoring the health parameters such as the HR, and
different patients from time to time.                               connectivity is made to mobile application via bluetooth.
                                                                        In [19], the authors proposed a system for people in rural
                    II. RELAT ED WORKS                              areas due to their inaccessibility to doctors and other medical
    There are two major types of devices used in monitoring         practitioners that would monitor their health parameters
the heartrate. These include the electrical methods which           (such as the heart rate). It was as well proposed in [19], a bi-
requires placing a large strap of device on the body while the      analysis hierarchical method. The first layer been an
optical method doesn’t require anything of such and can be          integration with android phone that stores data at SQLite,
effectively used as compared to the electrical method [10].         analyzes the data and then send a text based emergency short
The development of low cost heart rate measuring device can         message to the health practitioners. After receiving the
be achieved through the use of optical technology where             message, the medical practitioner then analyzes the data
LDR and LED are used in sensing the pulses [11]. The                received.
amplifier circuit amplifies the pulse signal, and then filters it
through a band pass filter. The microcontroller receives the                   III. DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
amplified and filtered pulse signal, and then process es the
                                                                       The components used in carrying out the full
analog signal. Afterwards, it then counts the HR and displays
it on the LCD display [12], [13].                                   implementation of this work are presented. The components
                                                                    can be sub-divided into two: Hard ware co mponents (Pulse
    In [14], optical technology was employed to design a            sensor, Arduino UNO and Bluetooth module) and Software
microcontroller-based HR monitor via fingertip sensor was           components (Arduino IDE (Integrated development
presented. Optical technology was employed by the device in         Environ ment) and Processing).
detecting blood that flows through the fingers, and in the
process offers great advantage of handiness, usability and          A. Pulse Sensor
portability over the tape-based recording system. The                   This is an Arduino based plug-and-play sensor for taking
Discrete Fourier Transform was applied in analyzing the
                                                                    the rate at which the heart beats. It is majorly used by
electrocardiography (ECG) signals in order to derive the HR         developers, athletes, students, for easy incorporation of real
measurement. In the research work, the performance of the
                                                                    time data of the amplifier and noise cancellation circuits
HR monitoring device was taken in co mparison with the              which aid its ability to produce a reliable pulse reading easily
ECG signal represented on an oscilloscope and the manual            and quickly [20] [21]. A picture of the front and back view of
pulse measurement of the heartbeat.                                 this device is shown in figure 1.
    In [15], a co mpliance tracking mechanism (called CHF
Tel-Assurance) was imp lemented [15]. Patients were
monitored with the aid of technology and were reviewed on a
weekly basis by a mu ltidisciplinary team. So me of the team
members fro m the cardiac rehabilitation telemetry, and home
care research units. The goals of the team were to make
provision for an improved patient result, hospitalization, and
readmission rates. The core approach was to allow patients to
be the co-handler of how their heart system behaves via user
education on usable technology.
    The core approach In [16] was to allow patients to be
the co-handler of how their heart system behaves via user                  Fig 1. Front view and back view diagram of a pulse sensor [27]
education on usable technology. In this article, seventy-four
(74) heart failure patients were enrolled in the ECG
                                                                    B. Arduino UNO
monitoring and telephone follow-up program. In response,
patients are capable of sending their respective ECG data               The Arduino UNO is an ATmega328P integrated circuit
fro m their mobile telephone to a remote receiving terminal         open source microcontroller board. It has seven power pin,
where the data could be accessed by a heart care                    and Eighteen (18) input / output digital pins of which Twelve
professional. The patients were evaluated and responded to,         (12) are dedicated to digital PMW and Six (6) analogue
based on the ECG data that the patient must have sent to the        input. It also has a reset button, USB connector, and a power
remote consultant.                                                  jack as shown in Fig 2. The components that make up the
                                                                    controller are designed in such a way to perform the
    Bodmas et al [17] tried to establish the feasibility and        functions of a microcontroller., All that is needed is to
potency of remote monitoring and management of the                  connect it to a power source (such as a 3V or 5V battery or to
chronic heart failure. Patients were assessed by tele-              computer via USB cable) to start the device. The Arduino
monitoring for HR, blood pressure, weight and arterial              UNO has been embedded with an inbuilt boot loader to
saturation of oxygen. Patient's satisfaction, safety and quality    upload a new program to the board of the Arduino. However,
of life based on the implementation of these approaches were        the boot loader can be bypassed thereby controlling the
evaluated for humanistic outcome.                                   microcontroller with the use of the In-Circuit Signal
    Also, According to S.A Moraru, Szakacs, and L. perniu           Programming (ICSP) header [22, 23]
in [18], the proposition of the authors was based on having a
device that is wearable on the patient’s body which will
      Fig 2 Arduino UNO with ATmega328p Microprocessor [28]



C. Bluetooth Module (HC-05)
Bluetooth module was used to interface with an Arduino                                     Fig 4. Arduino IDE
board in order to transmit the data fro m the Arduino board to
a Bluetooth-enabled terminal such as a PC [24]. The
Bluetooth module used in this work is Bluetooth module
HC-05 which can either be set to master or slave. The            E. Processing
module has Seven (7) p ins, namely; KEY, VCC, GND,                   Processing is an open source developing agent tool for
TXD, RXD and STATE as shown in figure 3. These are               writing an application program which in turn can be used in
ONLY Six pins and not Seven. Among all the just mentioned        the same or other computer [26]. Its usefulness in this project
pins, the needed ones for this project are; the VCC which the    is when the computer is needed to communicate with the
voltage source from the Arduino is connected to, the GND         Arduino. In this project, the processing software is used to
that is connected to the Arduino ground pin, the RXD that        program java based computer application, named remote
receives data fro m the Arduino transmitting serial, and the     heart rate monitor, to display the reading and pulse wave of
TXD which transmits the received serial data from the            the sensor on the computer. What it does is that it creates an
Arduino to the end terminal [25].                                environment that accepts data fro m the Arduino via the
                                                                 Bluetooth module and displays it on the application created
                                                                 fro m this processing environment.

                                                                            IV. IMPLEMENTATION AND RESULT S
                                                                 This work is implemented using cost effective and energy
                                                                 efficient method. The schematic design used for the
                                                                 implementation of the wo rk is shown in fig. 5 while the
                                                                 flow chart is shown in figure 6. The simplicity of the
                                                                 method can be seen from the flo w and block d iagram.

                                                                 Patients        Sensing           Arduino         Remote Pulse
                                                                                   and               Uno             Monitor
                                                                                 Readin           +Bluetooth         Te rminal
                                                                                    g              module
     Fig 3. Fromt and Back view of HC-05 Bluetooth module [29]

D. Arduino IDE                                                                    Fig 5: Block Diagram of Design
   The Arduino integrated development environment is an
   environment in which an Arduino board can be                  The project was first imp lemented using a breadboard to be
   programmed. A written program or code is called               able to determine any problem with any of the co mponents
   SKETCH [23]. In this work, the Arduino IDE is used as         and while putting the components together.
   an environment in which the Arduino UNO program is            As shown in figure 8, a set of LEDs are connected on the
   written, compiled and uploaded on the Arduino board as        circuit board. A resistor of 200Ω is used in regulating the
   depicted in figure 4.                                         input voltage of the LED to prevent it fro m burning because
                                                                 of high input voltage to the LED.

                                                                 Furthermore, the schematic b lock d iagram is also shown in
                                                                 figure 7. It can be seen from this diagram that the patient’s
                                                                 pulse rate is measured, analyzed and then wirelessly relayed
                                                                 to a distance-dependent remote terminal.
                                                                      The value of the resister was determined using the
                                                                   equation below

                                                                                                                                  1.0

                                                                      Where;
                                                                      R is the value of the unknown resistor
                                                                       Vs is the supply voltage power used in powering the
                                                                   circuit in our case the value is    as this is the output
                                                                   voltage from the Arduino
                                                                     Vf is the forward voltage required to power the LED in
                                                                   our case the value is
                                                                      If is the forward current required for the LED to operate
                                                                   and in our case, this is
                                                                       The work was imp lemented by connecting the anode
                                                                   (+ve part) of the LED to the Arduino PIN while the cathode
                                                                   (-ve part) is grounded on the circuit board. The female pin
                                                                   connector is also attached to the circuit board wh ich contains
                                                                   the ground port, voltage port, analog port and Bluetooth
                                                                   module port. The prototype produced is as shown in Fig 9
                                                                   below with a s mall electrical junction box wh ich contains all
                                                                   the components (Arduino UNO, circu it board and a 9V DC
                                                                   battery). To test the device, there is need to ensure that the
             Fig 6: Flow chat for Implementation                   Bluetooth module HC-05 is paired with the end terminal.
                                                                   The module must then be attached to a specific computer
                                                                   port on the end terminal device as shown in Figure 10 below;
                                                                       After attaching a port to the HC-05 Bluetooth module,
                                                                   the HRM application can then be launched as shown in Fig
                                                                   11.




Fig 7: Block diagram of the remote heart rate monitoring system.




                                                                               Fig 9: Prototype remote Heartrate Monitor System

                                                                       It can be seen at Fig 10 that once the application is
                                                                   launched, all available ports on the terminal device are
                                                                   shown. Once the appropriate computer port is selected, the
                                                                   pulse data will be received on the selected port. On the
                                                                   terminal device where this project is implemented, the HC-
 Fig 8 Project implementation on Printed Circuit Board (PCB).
                                                                   05 Bluetooth module was attached to computer port 21 for
the recipient of the pulse data in real time as shown in Fig 12
and 13.




                                                                              Fig13: Pulse sensor taken for one person
                                                                     The terminal application displays the pulse rate in bit per
                                                                  minute (BPM ) and the pattern of individual heartbeat.
            Fig 10: Port allocation to HC-05 Bluetooth module




                                                                                        Fig 14. Average BPM
                                                                    TABLE 1: HEART RATE VARIABILITY OF 5 PATIENT; BEFORE,
                                                                  DURING AND AFTER EXERCISE
               Fig 11: Port selection on the terminal device
                                                                  Patient     before Excersie    During Excersie    After Excersie
                                                                  ID              (BPM )             (BPM )            (BPM )
                                                                              1      2 Avg        1      2 Avg      1      2 Avg
                                                                  Patient 1   72   74      73    94   108    101   67    64        66
                                                                  Patient 2   69   64      67    80    98     89   62    58        60
                                                                  Patient 3   74   77      76   100   105    103   58    54        56
                                                                  Patient 4   65   66      66    95   105    100   60    55        58
                                                                  Patient 5   80   89      85    98   108    103   63    66        65


                                                                      The HR monitor device successfully connects remotely
                                                                  to the front-end computer-based application via a short-range
                                                                  Bluetooth connection. The front-end application displays the
                                                                  BPM value of the individual that has the pulse sensor placed
                                                                  on his or her body, majorly on the index finger. It was
                                                                  observed that the front-end application displays high BPM
                                                                  value, usually above 150, on startup. Accurate BPM is
                                                                  recorded when the monitored individual is fully settled and
            Fig 12: Pu lse sensor taken for two people            calm for some minutes. Furthermore, when the accurate
                                                                  BPM value is displayed, just as that in the Figure Fig what,
                                                                  the value mostly varies with difference of five. That is, when
                                                                  the displayed BPM value is 83, it might keep showing values
 fro m 83 to 88. It must also be noted that the configured band                  [13] K. Y. Sham, and P. L.-K. Wong, "Fitness monitoring device having an
 rate (rate of data transmission) is 9,600 at both heart rate                          electronic pedometer and a wireless heart rate monitor," Google
                                                                                       Patents, 1999.
 monitor and the front-end application, based on the HC-05                       [14] A. Bhat, S. Dhoble, and K. Rewatkar, “Microcontroller Based Heart
 Bluetooth recommendation.                                                             Rate Monitor using Fingertip Sensors.”
                                                                                 [15] D. Knox, and L. Mischke, “Implementing a congestive heart failure
     Furthermore, for validation, the HR of five different                             disease management program to decrease length of stay and cost,”
 adults were sampled, before, during and after a set of                                Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 55-74, 1999.
 exercise. The results obtained are shown in Table 1 . In Table                  [16] S. Scalvini, E. Zanelli, M. Volterrani, G. Martinelli, D. Baratti, O.
 1, the heat rate obtained are all within the normal range                             Buscaya, P. Baiardi, F. Glisenti, and A. Giordano, “A pilot study of
 expected for healthy people, even though, the device needs                            nurse-led, home-based telecardiology for patients with chronic heart
                                                                                       failure,” Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 113-
 calibrations and comparison with the standard calibrated                              117, 2004.
 heart beat monitors.                                                            [17] M. Bondmass, N. Bolger, G. Castro, and B. Avitall, “The effect of
                                                                                       physiologic home monitoring and telemanagement on chronic heart
                                                                                       failure outcomes,” Internet Journal of Advanced Nursing Practice, vol.
               V. LIMIT ATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS                                         3, no. 2, 2000.
 This paper presents the design and implementation procedure                     [18] P. Szakacs-Simon, S. Moraru, and L. Perniu, "Android application
 for a cost-efficient and low power consumption remote heart                           developed to extend health monitoring device range and real-time
                                                                                       patient tracking." pp. 171-175.
 rate monitor. This device could help to improve and                             [19] M. V. Ramesh, S. Anand, and P. Rekha, "A mobile software for health
 revolutionise healthcare delivery in developing countries and                         professionals to monitor remote patients." pp. 1-4.
 help in realization of green virtual clinic imp lementation                     [20] E. M. Nidhi Mutha, Ruchira Rokade, Ganesh Deshmukh, “Patient
 proposed in [30-33]. The device is capable of monitoring HR                           Health Monitoring Using Android Application,” International Journal
 of patients with various disease conditions which could help                          of Innovative Research in Computer and Communication Engineering,
 in detecting heart problems. Its operates smoothly and the                            vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 13, 2016.
                                                                                 [21] F. O. T urjo, M. A. Islam, S. U. Bhuiyan, T. Islam, and B. B. Pathik,
 design is quite efficient as it successfully connects the pulse                       "Design, simulation and implementation of a novel online patients'
 sensor remotely to the front-end application. It also relays the                      health checking method for physicians." pp. 1-5.
 BPM value to the terminal device in real t ime. Ho wever, the                   [22] Y. A. Badamasi, "The working principle of an Arduino." pp. 1-4.
 device is yet to be calibrated. Also, it was observed that some                 [23] H. P. da Silva, C. Carreiras, A. Lourenço, A. Fred, R. C. das Neves,
 random high BPM pulse values were displayed when the                                  and R. Ferreira, “Off-the-person electrocardiography: performance
                                                                                       assessment and clinical correlation,” Health and Technology, vol. 4,
 pulse sensor is idle and gets stabilized when the sensor is in                        no. 4, pp. 309-318, 2015.
 contact with the patient thumb. These limitations will be                       [24] Y. Jawahar, “Design of an Infrared based Blood Oxygen Saturation and
 examined as part of future work.                                                      Heart Rate Monitoring Device,” McMaster University Hamilton,
                                                                                       Ontario, Canada., Canada, 2009.
                            REFER ENCES                                          [25] E. Jovanov, A. Milenkovic, C. Otto, and P. C. De Groen, “A wireless
                                                                                       body area network of int elligent motion sensors for computer assisted
  [1] GBD 2013 Mortality and Causes of Death, Collaborators (17 December               physical rehabilitation,” Journal of NeuroEngineering and
       2014). "Global, regional, and national age-sex specific all-cause and           rehabilitation, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 6, 2005.
       cause-specific mortality for 240 causes of death, 1990-2013: a            [26] R. Faludi, Building wireless sensor networks: with ZigBee, XBee,
       systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013".               arduino, and processing: " O'Reilly Media, Inc.", 2010.
       Lancet. 385 (9963): 117–71. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(14)61682-2.            [27] R. Shams, A. Sayed, M.M.A. Hasheem and A. Kaber, "Use of fingertip
       PMC 4340604 Freely accessible. PMID 25530442.                                   in the design and development of a device that measures the heart rate",
  [2] Lawrence J. Laslett, Peter Alagona Jr, Bernard A. Clark III, Joseph P.           ICCCE 2010, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, May 11 – 12, 2010.
       Drozda Jr, Frances Saldivar, Sean R. Wilson, Chris Poe and Menolly        [28] H.P da Silva et al, "Clinical correlation and activity assessment of off-
                                                                                       the-person electrocardiography", Health technology version 4, 2015,
       Hart (2012). The Worldwide Environment of Cardiovascular Disease:
       Prevalence, Diagnosis, Therapy, and Policy Issues. Journal of the               page 309 – 318.
       American College of Cardiology, Volume 60, Issue 25 Supplement,           [29] E. Jovanov et al, "Wireless Body Area Network of intelligent motion
       December 2012DOI: 10.1016/j.jacc.2012.11.002                                    sensors for computer assisted physical Rehabilitation", J.
   [3] I. Harary, and B. Farley, “In vitro studies of single isolated beating          Neuroengineering Rehabilitation, vol. 2, 2005.
       heart cells,” Science, vol. 131, no. 3414, pp. 1674-1675, 1960.           [30] N. Faruk, N.T Surajudeen-Bakinde, A. A Oloyede, O. O Bello, S.I
  [4] A. E. Aubert, B. Seps, and F. Beckers, “Heart rate variability in                Popoola, A Abdulkarim, Lukman A Olawoyin, “On green virtual
       athletes,” Sports medicine, vol. 33, no. 12, pp. 889-919, 2003.                 clinics: A framework for extending health care services to rural
  [5] G. E. Billman, “Heart rate variability–a historical perspective,”                communities in Sub-Saharan Africa”, in proc.. International Rural and
       Frontiers in physiology, vol. 2, pp. 86, 2011.                                  Elderly Health Informatics Conference (IREHI), 2017 , pp 1-7.
  [6] B. M. Dugan, and V. G. Dugan, "Systems and methods for heart rate          [31] N. Faruk, A. A. Oloyode, O. W. Bello, S. I. Popoola, L.A. Olawoyin,
       monitoring, data transmission, and use," Google Patents, 2014.                  “Framework for Universal T elecommunication Access: Prospects for
  [7] B. Mallick, and A. K. Patro, “Heart rate monitoring system using finger          mHealth in Developing Economies”, IEEE Conference on ICT for
       tip through arduino and processing software,” International Journal of          Communicable diseases, ISBN: 978-1-5090-6223-2, pp 46-51, 2016.
       Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), vol. 5, no. 1,     [32]. Bello, O.W., Opadiji, J. F. Faruk, N. & Adediran, Y.A. (2016).
                                                                                       Opportunities for Universal Telecommunication Access in Rural
       pp. 84-89, 2016.
  [8] N. Daimiwal, M. Sundhararajan, and R. Shriram, "Comparative                      Communities: A Case Study of 15 Rural Villages in Nigeria’s Kwara
       analysis of LDR and OPT 101 detectors in reflectance type PPG                   State. The African Journal of Information and Communication (AJIC),
       sensor." pp. 1078-1081.                                                         (Issue 17); pp 1-26. Thematic Issue: Economic Regulation, Regulatory
  [9] http://www.who.int/gho/health_workforce/physicians_density/en/                   Performance and Universal Access in the Electronic Communications
   visited 13/10/2018                                                                  Sector. Published by University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg,
 [10] T. F. Robinson, S. M. Factor, and E. H. Sonnenblick, “The heart as a             South Africa. Available online https://www. wit s.ac.za/linkcentre/ajic/
       suction pump,” Scientific American, vol. 254, no. 6, pp. 84-91, 1986.     [33] Faruk, N., Bello, O. W. Opadiji, J. F. & Adediran, Y. A. (2017). Socio -
[11] M. Hashem, R. Shams, M. A. Kader, and M. A. Sayed, "Design and                    economic Challenges of Rural Telecommunication Access Schemes in
       development of a heart rate measuring device using fingertip." pp. 1-5.         Nigeria. International Journal of Information and Communication
[12] S. F. Babiker, L. E. Abdel-Khair, and S. M. Elbasheer,                            Technology (ICT), 14 (1); pp 194-217. Published by the Department of
       “Microcontroller based heart rate monitor using fingertip sensors,”             Library and Information Technology Federal University of Technology
       University of Khartoum Engineering Journal, vol. 1, no. 2, 2011.                Minna                 Nigeria.              Available              online
                                                                                       https://www.ajol.info/index.php/ict/index