=Paper= {{Paper |id=Vol-2823/Paper14 |storemode=property |title=Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based Biosensors for detection of Biomolecules: A Review |pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2823/Paper14.pdf |volume=Vol-2823 |authors=Rishika Sen, Cherry Bhargava }} ==Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based Biosensors for detection of Biomolecules: A Review== https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2823/Paper14.pdf
Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based Biosensors for detection of
Biomolecules: A Review
Rishika Sen, Cherry Bhargava
Lovely Professional University, Phagwara, Punjab, India

                Abstract
                This manuscript presents brief review on Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based Biosensor from
                initial phase to currently used Tunnel field Effect Transistors for biosensing application. TFET
                based Biosensors have gained attention due to phenomenal properties such as high sensitivity,
                low cost, and ability to detect label-free biomolecules. Conventional Field Effect Transistors
                have lots of advantages as biosensors in comparison to other biosensors but there exist various
                limitations on subthreshold swing where (SS>60 mv/decade), various short channel effects
                reduced the device sensitivity leading to restriction in using it as biosensors. For improving
                various research is going on so that scientists can find a way out to make a device overcoming
                all the disadvantages faced by previously developed biosensor made by different transistor
                devices. This manuscript aims to clearly distinguish between different TFET Biosensors based
                on their working and sensitivity parameters to provide better insights to the researchers to
                further carry on the research for making more reliable and advance Biosensors.

                Keywords 1
                Biosensor, TFET, sensitivity



1. Introduction
                                                                        Biological analytes are hard to detect based
   In this emerging world, where science has                        on their intrinsic properties, they need
made so much progress scientists try hard to                        labels such as enzymes, radioactive molecules
find solutions to every problem. The recent                         attach with the analyte for detection and it was
problem such as COVID pandemic has                                  a drawback as label-based detection are
disrupted people lives and such problem was                         expensive and also time-consuming. On the
also seen a couple of years ago when smallpox                       other hand, label-free detection does not require
was introduced therefore these issues are never-                    labels to facilitate measurements because they
ending, Biosensors are the advancement of                           use intrinsic physical properties such as charge,
technology for such issues giving precise way                       size, dielectric permittivity, etc to detect the
to deal with the discovery of biomolecules [1].                     presence of biomolecules in a cheaper sample
Usually, a biosensor consists of two                                and time- saving. These ideal qualities of label-
components: a recognition element (molecular)                       free biosensors spread their applications in
known as a receptor and target analytes like                        numerous zones like the clinical field for
DNA, antibodies, cells, and a transducer to                         beginning phase location of biomolecules,
convert the information into a measurable                           conveyance of medications, food handling,
quantity.                                                           natural observing, security, and observation. A
                                                                    Biosensor is a device that produces an electrical
                                                                    signal from the biophysical response. The

ACI’21: Workshop on Advances in Computational Intelligence at
ISIC 2021, February 25–27, 2021, Delhi, India
EMAIL: rishikasen666@gmail.com (Rishika Sen)
Cherry.Bhargava@lpu.co.in (Cherry Bhargava)

             ©️ 2021 Copyright for this paper by its authors. Use
             permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution
             4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).
             CEUR Workshop Proceedings (CEUR-WS.org)
principal chemical-based biosensor was                   1.1 Literature Review
founded by Clark et al. in 1962 [1]and from that
point forward this arising field has picked up
                                                       Low cost, low power, rapid, small, ultra-
loads of consideration among overall analysts
                                                     sensitive, robust biosensors are highly
for creating precise and more solid biosensors.
                                                     recommended for Point of Care Applications.
The biosensor comprises of two different stages
                                                     Biosensor build on Complementary metal oxide
– 1) Biomolecule location and 2) Trans-
                                                     semiconductor compatible silicon nanowire
conduction. The first stage comprising of
                                                     tunneling field effect transistor (SiNW- TFET)
biomolecule location is one of the important
                                                     has been proposed by Anran Gao (2016) [3]. It
tasks as locating a biomolecule in a device
                                                     has been observed that SiNW- TFET provided
where it could be recognized by the biosensors
                                                     good amount of parasitic capacity by using
helps is detecting the biomolecules in a more
                                                     inherent ambipolar nature through biomarker of
precise manner. The second stage transduction
                                                     human lung cancer CYFRA21-1 and pH
defines the process that is used to define
                                                     sensing as unfunctionalized Silicon nanowire
biosensors by converting the recognized
                                                     TFET devices can be characterized as hydrogen
biomolecules into an electrical form or readable
                                                     ion sensors. Changes in surface charges at the
form for precise detection. All these biosensors
                                                     Silicon nanowire surface gates the Tunnel Field
are utilized to improve human existence. There
                                                     Effect device that modulates the nanowire
are various biosensors based on the
                                                     current. The ambipolar nature and conductivity
transduction                              process.
                                                     was shown for both positive and negative
The working principle of electrochemical
                                                     voltages at gate. This ambipolar response
biosensor [2] is to experience the adjustment in
                                                     discriminates the electrical noise to carry with
the electrical properties of the sensor by
                                                     object analysis.
response focused on biomolecules. The noticed
                                                     Analytical model of p-n-p-n TFET for working
changes are utilized as estimating boundaries
                                                     as biosensor for label-free detection of
for the sensor and depending on boundary
                                                     biomolecules has been developed by Rakhi
noticed they are additionally characterized into
                                                     Narang (2012) [4]. It has been observed that the
amperometric,          potentiometric,         and
                                                     proposed model gives two important properties
conductometric. The exceptionally ground-
                                                     that is possessed by biomolecules 1) dielectric
breaking substitute of ordinary insightful sort
                                                     constant 2) charge. Comparison with
biosensor is optical biosensors as it needs
                                                     conventional FET based biosensors was also
extremely restricted groundwork for the
                                                     made in the terms of sensitivity of TFET based
location of the focused biomolecule. Optical
                                                     biosensors consisting of various parameters like
fields with analyte are utilized in an optical
                                                     shift in threshold, variation in ON-current (Ion)
biosensor to identify tumor cells, poisons, and
                                                     level and ON-OFF ratio of current (Ion/Ioff).
so on Calorimetric and Acoustic biosensors
                                                     Also, it was concluded that TFET based sensors
discover great applications for the discovery of
                                                     show wide deviation in current level and
DNA. All these biosensors are utilized to
                                                     therefore change in ON current (Ion) can be
improve human existence. Thermal and mass-
                                                     considered as appropriate parameter for
based biosensors are unpredictable and have
                                                     sensing.
low reaction time. Optical and electrochemical
                                                     Detection of biomolecules using electrical
biosensors have taken more consideration for
                                                     characteristics      is     attractive   because
dependable and precise reactions because of
                                                     inexpensive, label-free, provide stability and
their low location limit and extremely high
                                                     ease of on-chip fabrication of sensors [5]. TFET
particularity. There is a lot of progress going on
                                                     having nanostructures or particularly nanowires
TFET based biosensors but researchers face
                                                     has gained importance because of enough
lots of problem in finding all the information
                                                     surface to volume ratio and high electrostatic
related to Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based
                                                     control. For biomolecule detection specific
biosensors at one time. This manuscript has
                                                     receptor is allowed to get in contact with oxide
been bifurcated into three sections. Section I
                                                     or dielectric layer of semiconductor device and
elaborates the brief literature review, Section II
                                                     because of their charge, it produces gating
describes the structure and performance
                                                     effect on the device thereby changing the
comparison of various biosensors, and finally in
                                                     electrical properties like current, subthreshold
Section III conclusion is drawn.
                                                     voltages,     conductance        etc.  Therefore,
sensitivity is in accordance with gating effect,      element model on three dimensional biological
higher the response of TFET with gate effect          field-effect transistor (BioFET) via Monte
higher will be the sensitivity of the device .        Carlo simulations on the DNA molecules
It has been concluded by Deblina Sarkar and K         position. It was also observed that SNR can be
Banerjee (2012) [5] that highest response to          low enough to disturb the device functionality.
gating effects of the biosensors is obtained in       Further study done by him was the effects of
subthreshold region but CFETs (Conventional           region of pinch-off and concentration of
Field Effect Transistors) cannot achieve              electrolyte on Signal to Noise ratio. It was
minimal        subthreshold       swing        that   concluded that sharing between ions across
simultaneously limits the sensitivity and             probes of DNA specifically at low-electrolyte
response.                                             concentration significantly increases the
Conventional DM-FET based biosensors                  amount of change of charge inversion in FET
showed less sensitivity in comparison to DM-          thereby increasing the sensitivity. Therefore,
TFET based biosensors but showed low                  there is a great need of properly controlled
subthreshold current.                                 environment for achieving reliability of
In 2016, Sayan kanungo [6] investigated the           biosensors and mostly in miniaturization of
effect of (SiGe) source and n+ pocket doped           devices.
channel using extensive device level                  In 2010, Jae- Hyuk Ahn et al [9] proposed the
simulation. It has been observed that silicon-        double gate nanowire field effect transistor for
germanium source DMTFET showed high                   increasing the sensitivity of conventional FET
superiority in comparison to n+ pocket                devices. Gate region was separated as G1
Dielectric Modulated TFET to obtain higher            (primary) and G2 (secondary) allowing
subthreshold current level while maintaining          independent voltage control for modulating
the sensitivity of device .                           potential of channel and sensitivity was
In 2019, experimental study has been done by          enhanced.
Cao W [7] that provided good insights into            Due to the disadvantages of MOSFETs under
Subthreshold Swing (SS) characteristics of            miniaturization research on electronic devices
TFET by examining effects of four critical            has been moved to TFETs. Although TFET
parameters like level of source and doping,           devices are suitable but still have few things
band gap, length, and tunnel effective mass in        that need to be controlled like it has low on
the perspectives of Fermi-Dirac Distribution          currents that results in low switching speed and
and Tunneling probability variation. It was           shows ambipolar behaviour. It was observed by
observed that shortening of Fermi Dirac               Anne S. Verhulst (2007) [10] that reduction of
Distribution, OFF-current and uncovered               gate length leads to several advantages like
intrinsic Subthreshold Swing compete among            increase in switching speed and decrease in
themselves to provide minimum achievable              processing complexity.
Subthreshold Swing. This work also concluded          Furthermore, short gate TFETs investigation
that for homo junction TFET design: small             has been carried to know the capability of
channel length, suitably high doping level of         tunnel field effect transistor by simulating low
source and small tunnel effective mass is             power digital applications using supply
suitable and for hetero junction Tunnel Field         voltages less than 0.5 V. The study done
Effect Transistor design in these parameters,         showed that tunneling current has very less or
small band gap present at tunnel junction is          negligible contribution on charging and
preferable.                                           discharging gate capacitance of TFETs. It was
There are various types of biosensors as been         also observed that although short gate TFET
discussed above and in that row M Waleed              has high resistance region but the charging and
Shinwari (2011) [8] presented the effect of           discharging speed still meets requirements for
distribution of DNA probe on reliability of           application in low voltages. The performance
label-free biosensors. As we have observed that       analysis was done on SG-TFETs using different
since the miniaturization for increasing the          materials like Silicon, Germanium and
sensitivity parameter, there was lack of research     heterostructure studying various parameters
in knowing the variation of received signals          such as voltage overshoot, static power, delay
with respect to the position of probes over           energy consumption etc. It was concluded that
sensitive surface therefore a computational           heterostructure Short Gate TFETs can be said
study has been done by them using finite              as promising candidate for extending supply
voltages to lower the voltages below 0.5                1.2 Comparison of Different
because of short gate structures, small bandgap
material for source and sufficient driving                 TFET Based Biosensors
current in Tunnel Field Effect Transistors.
In 2018, Deepak Soni et al [11] carried out             In this section Tunnel Field Effect
research for improving the speed of sensing and         Transistor device structure and their
sensitivity of TFET based biosensor using the           performance in terms of sensitivity for the
concept of formation of plasma. The research            application as biosensor is described.
was carried out by adding an electrode on the
source region of conventional biosensors using      1. Silicon Nanowire Tunnel Field Effect
negative supply for extending cavity above the         Transistor
source region. The introduction of additional
Source Electrode with negative supply voltage           The silicon nanowire TFET based
forms the cavity over source region overcomes       biosensors was designed using novel CMOS
the issues such as abrupt junction formation at     compatible anisotropic wet etching approach
source junction and channel junction. It was        and conventional lithography alongwith
also observed that issues related to solubility     tetramethylammonium hydroxide. In Figure 1
limit of silicon material was also solved           (a), one can observe that SiNWs forms a cluster
because of formation of plasma layer of holes       (10 wires each) that is used as one unit for
near Silicon and HFO2 interface. It has been        sensing specific molecule. The structure clearly
concluded that excess biomolecules in the           shows that the surface of Silicon nanowires are
region of source and cavity increased the           smooth and of high quality [3]. The ID-VG
concentration of plasma layer of holes near         characteristics    of      SiNW-TFET        and
Silicon-HFO2 because of better coupling that in     conventional TFET based biosensors in log
return improved the capability of sensing and       scale was compared. It can be observed in
the sensing speed of Biosensors.                    Figure 1 (b) that subthreshold swing of TFET
    A transition metal dichalcogenide material      was decreased in comparison to conventional
based TFET was proposed by Prabhat Kumar            FET device (MOSFET).
and Brajesh Kumar (2019) [12] as transition
metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) are said to be
promising candidates for sensing applications.
It has been observed that TMDs have
atomically thin-layered structure, dangling
bond free structure and novel physical
properties. The presented device showed
Subthreshold swing of 50mv/ decade and
measured sensitivity of 2.11 for 5mV change in         Figure 1 (a): Silicon nanowire-based
voltage across gate.
                                                    Biosensor diagram [3]
    Label free biosensors is preferable due to
their simple operation. L- shaped TFET [13]
based biosensors are used because of their low
voltage       Subthreshold    Swing,      power
consumption and off state current. In 2020,
Chong C proposed a dielectric modulated L-
shaped TFET where a cavity was formed inside
the electrode of gate in vertical direction. The
cavity is filled with biomolecules for working it
as a biosensor. The simulation was carried out
and was observed that current sensitivity can be
increased as high as 2321, the sensitivity of          Figure 1 (b): ID-VG characteristics of Silicon
threshold voltage could reach 0.4 and               nanowire-TFET and conventional TFET based
sensitivity of SS could reach 0.7. The results      biosensors in log scale [3]
assured that Dielectric Modulated L-shaped
TFET sensor is good to go for increased
sensitivity and less power consumption.
   Figure 1 (c): ID-VG curve of Silicon nanowire
TFET device for VD = 1 V [3]

    In Figure 1 (c), ID-VG curve of Silicon
                                                    Figure 2 (b): ID-VG characteristics of DM-TFET
Nanowire TFET device for VD = 1 V is shown
that justify that this proposed structure has SS    [4]
of 37 mv/dec for n-channel that simultaneously
increased the sensitivity. The current and              We can observe ID-VG characteristics in
subthreshold swing (SS) of n-channel relation       Figure 2 (b) that shows good response for
shows that subthreshold swing of TFET is not        different dielectric constant values and
static like conventional FET and therefore, it is   therefore the sensitivity of biosensor is
strongly dependent on gate voltage.                 improved. The thing that was not taken care
                                                    was ambipolar conductivity which effect the
                                                    sensitivity of the device and limits the
                                                    performance of this device. They performed the
2. Dielectrically Modulated Tunnel FET
                                                    sensitivity analysis by considering dielectric
   based Biosensor.                                 constant and charge separately but if we
   The Dielectric modulated TFET based              observe practically then the charge is present
biosensor is basically a Dual gate geometry p-      only when biomolecules are present therefore
n-p-n architecture. The change of quality in        this is the concerning factor for in proposed
physio-chemical reaction in analyte is              device.
complicated that fails to detect electrically
neutral biomolecule. The challenges faced by        3. Short Gate and Full Gate TFET Based
label-based biosensor is suppressed using label        Biosensor
free detection technique. The p-n-p-n (Tunnel
source MOSFET) was considered shown in              Sayan Kanungo in 2015 carried out
Figure 2 (a) because p-i-n structure have less on   performance analysis of both SG-TFET and
current.                                            FG-DMTFET. In the device, the two gates
                                                    operate simultaneously and the dual gate
                                                    structure enhances biomolecule impact on
                                                    dielectric constant and leads to high sensitivity
                                                    of the sensors [6]. To enhance the value of
                                                    tunneling current, Si-Ge was used as source
                                                    with germanium concentration of 0.5 in both
                                                    SG-TFET and FG-TFET. The gate length of
                                                    short gate TFET was kept 20 nm and Full gate
                                                    was kept 42 nm as we can see in Figure 3(a) and
                                                    (b). The SG-DMTFET limited the impact of
                                                    ambipolar conductivity and showed improved
                                                    sensitivity.
   Figure 2 (a): Schematic diagram of
Dielectrically modulated Tunnel FET based
Biosensor [4]
                                                  SG-TFET (Short Gate Tunnel Field Effect
                                                  Transistor) that can produce sensitivity of drain
                                                  current almost seven times that of FG-TFET
                                                  (Full Gate Tunnel Field Effect Transistor). The
                                                  ID-VG curve of both short gate and full gate
                                                  TFET based Biosensor is shown in Figure 3 (c).
                                                  Further, it is being said that structural
                                                  enhancement in FG-TFET and material
                                                  specifications can increase the sensitivity
                                                  performance.

                                                  4. Junctionless based electrically doped
   Figure 3 (a): Structure of Short gate Tunnel
                                                      TFET based Biosensor
Field Effect Transistor based Biosensor [6]
                                                      The device structure is made of n+ heavily
                                                  doped Si layer and isolated gates to form
                                                  intrinsic region and p+ source region under the
                                                  polarity gate (PG) and control gate (CG). The
                                                  polarity bias of Si body is similar to that of
                                                  conventional tunnel field effect transistor [14].
                                                  As the device is junction less, the device is free
                                                  from doping control, thermal dissipation and
                                                  fabrication complexity as shown in Figure 4 (a).




    Figure 3 (b): Structure of Double gate
Tunnel Field Effect Transistor based Biosensor
[6]




                                                     Figure 4 (a): Schematic of Junctionless
                                                  based dielectric modulated TFET based
                                                  Biosensor [14]
Figure 3 (c): Comparison of ID-VG
characteristics of both SG and FG TFET based
biosensor [6]

   The full gated DMTFET consists of full
gated intrinsic channel as which decreases the
width of barrier and hence sensitivity is
achieved. Further due to one-dimensional
tunneling the on current of Dual metal gate is
limited. The short gate TFET should be
operated in specific biasing range and this       Figure 4 (b): ID-VG characteristics at different
precise biasing can enhance the sensitivity of    dielectric constant [14]
                                                       Figure 5 (b): SS comparison curve of
                                                    conventional and proposed TFET device [11]
Figure 4 (c): drain current sensitivity at
different dielectric constant [14]

   The performance of device is increased due
to the absence of junction and improved the
issue of random dopant fluctuation. The drain
current sensitivity curve is shown in Figure 4
(c) and ID-VG curve at different dielectric
constant is shown in Figure 4 (b). Although it is
free from short channel effects, fabrication
issues etc but still the issue of ambipolar
conductivity persist therefore structural           Figure 5 (c): Sensitivity comparison curve of
modulation of the device is still needed.           both conventional and proposed TFET device
                                                    [11]
5. Dual-gate source electrode dielectric
   modulated based Biosensor                           This research was carried out for improving
                                                    the response time and sensitivity of Tunnel
Deepak Soni et al proposed a structure that uses    Field Effect based biosensor using the concept
charge plasma -based concept for detection of       of formation of Plasma. The sensitivity was
biomolecule for efficiently thereby increasing      improved by adding an electrode on the source
the sensitivity.                                    region of conventional biosensors using
                                                    negative supply for extending cavity above the
                                                    region of source [11]. The introduction of
                                                    additional Silicon Electrode with negative
                                                    supply voltage for forming the cavity over the
                                                    source region overcomes the issues related to
                                                    abrupt junction formation at junction of source
                                                    and channel as shown in Figure 5 (a). It was
                                                    also observed that issues related to solubility
                                                    limit of silicon material due to layer of Plasma
                                                    formation of holes near Si-HFO2 interface was
                                                    also solved. It has been concluded that excess
                                                    biomolecules in the region of source and cavity
                                                    increased the concentration of plasma layer of
                                                    holes near Si- HFO2 because of better coupling
   Figure 5 (a): Schematic of Dual gate source      that in return improved the subthreshold swing,
electrode dielectric TFET Biosensor [11]            capability of sensing and the sensing speed of
                                                    Biosensors as shown in Figure 5 (b) and (c).
Figure 8. Comparison Chart of TFET based Biosensors
S no.             Device name                                  Performance                                    Limitations
                                            Low Subthreshold swing of 30mv/decade in n-
        Silicon Nanowire Tunnel Field       channel and 79mv/decade in p-channel that results
  1                                                                                           Ambipolar conductivity
        Effect Transistor                   in improved sensitivity as compared to
                                            conventional FET devices
                                                                                                 The sensitivity analysis was
                                                                                                 performed using charge and
        Dielectrically modulated Tunnel                                                          dieletric individually but practically
  2                                         Improved sensitivity for varying Dielectric Constant
        FET based Biosensor                                                                      charge is present only when
                                                                                                 biomolecules are present and that
                                                                                                 is one of the concern
                                            Proper Biasing results in sensitivity improvement
        Short Gate and Full Gate TFET                                                            On Current (Ion) is limited due to
  3                                         almost seven times that of Full gate TFET based
        based Biosensor                                                                          one directional tunneling
                                            Biosensor
        Junctionless dielectric modulated   Performance of device is increased due to absence Device is free from short channel
  4     electrically doped TFET based       of Junction and imporved issue of random dopant effects but still faces issue of
        Biosensor                           fluctuation                                          ambipolar conductivity
                                            Charge Plasma concept overcomes issues such as
        Dual gate source electrode                                                               Random Dopant Fluctuation was
                                            abrupt junction, solves issue of solubility imit of
  5     dielectric modulated based                                                               still a serious issue in proposed
                                            silicon material and increased sensing speed of
        Biosensor                                                                                device
                                            biomolecules resulting in quick response time
                                                                                               Results in reduction of mechanical
        Transistion metal Dichalcogenides Showed excellent sensitivity and sharp threshold of
  6                                                                                            flexibility due to brittle nature of
        material based Biosensor           50 mv/dec
                                                                                               the material
                                                                                               Sensitivity of proposed device
        Dielectric modulated L-Shaped
                                           Proposed device is suitable for ultra sensitive and highly depends on amount of
  7     Gate Field Effect Transistor based
                                           low consumption biosensors.                         positive charge present in the
        Biosensor
                                                                                               biomolecules



6. Transition metal Dichalcogenides
   material based Biosensor


                                                                  Transition Metal Dichalcogenides material
                                                                  based TFET is proposed in 2019 for label-free
                                                                  detection of Biomolecules. In recent years
                                                                  stretchable and flexible electrons have gained
                                                                  more attention in different fields like robotic
                                                                  and medical fields because of their
                                                                  advancement in performance. The TFET
                                                                  biosensor made by using silicon are offering
                                                                  excellent performance but their mechanical
                                                                  flexibility is not good due to its brittle nature.
   Figure 6 Sensitivity comparison of Silicon                     This device showed sharp threshold of 50
                                                                  mv/dec as shown in Figure 6 and excellent
based TFET and TMD material based TFET
                                                                  sensitivity.
[12]
7. Dielectric Modulated L-shaped Gate Field
   Effect Transistor based Biosensor.                    The simulation was carried out and was
                                                      observed that current sensitivity can be
                                                      increased as high as 2321, the sensitivity of
    The research carried out by Chen Chong,           threshold voltage could reach 0.4 and
Hongxia Liu shows the range of current                sensitivity of SS could reach 0.7 as shown in
sensitivity, subthreshold swing sensitivity and       Figure 7(b) and 7(c). The proposed device is
sensitivity of threshold voltage of the proposed      appropriate      for   ultra-sensitive,    low-
structure. The material used for making source,       consumption biosensors. It can be said from the
drain, channel and substrate was silicon. The         simulated result that greater the relative
gate dielectric used was HfO2 [13]. The study         permittivity of biomolecules, smaller the cavity
was carried out by using six small biomolecules       will be and the higher the amount of positive
with different dielectric constant filled in          charge, higher will be the sensitivity of the
different nanocavity thickness operated at            proposed biosensor.
different gate voltages as shown in Figure 7 (a)
                                                      1.3 Conclusion

                                                      In the above discussion a brief literature review
                                                      and performance comparison in terms of device
                                                      structure and sensitivity is done along with
                                                      summary of comparison based on performance
                                                      and limitations as shown in Figure 8. It can be
                                                      concluded that sensitivity is related to various
                                                      parameters but majorly 5 parameters are
                                                      directly related to improvement in sensitivity 1)
   Figure 7 (a): Schematic view of Dielectric         Device size and structure 2) material used to
Modulated L-shaped Gate Field Effect                  make device 3) Oxide thickness and gate length
Transistor based Biosensor [13]                       4) position of cavity and fill factor 5)
                                                      subthreshold characteristic and drain current.
                                                      Although TFET based devices are free from
                                                      short channel effects but there are another
                                                      factors that are of high concern like ambipolar
                                                      conductivity, steric hindrance, fabrication
                                                      complexity and precise biasing condition. This
                                                      review analyzed various biosensors and
                                                      therefore different structures has been proposed
                                                      to make device more sensitive having quick
                                                      response time but still various parameters could
   Figure 7 (b): ID-VG characteristics at different   be studied for further improvement in
dielectric constant [13]                              Biosensing application to be able to work in real
                                                      time as biosensor. This study further concluded
                                                      that Dielectric modulated L-shaped TFET [11]
                                                      based biosensors achieved good range of
                                                      sensitivity as compared to all the previously
                                                      designed biosensors.

                                                      2. References


                                                      [1]     P, Mehrotra " biosensors and their
                                                            applications," Science direct, pp. 1-7,
Figure 7 (c) Subthreshold slope of device at                2016.
different dielectric constant [13]
[2] Lyons, LeLand C, Clark Jr. Champ               [14]   Hongxia Liu, Shulong Wang, Shupeng
     "ELECTRODE            SYSTEMS         FOR         Chen, Haiwu Xie and Chen Chong,
     CONTINUOUS MONITORING IN                          "Sensitivity Analysis of Biosensors
     CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY," The                      Based on a Dielectric-Modulated L-
     New York Academy of Sciences, vol. 102,           Shaped Gate Field-Effect Transistor,"
     no. 1, pp. 29-45, 1962.                           Micromachine MDPI, vol. 12, no. 1,
[3] Juan Eduardo Sosa-Hernandez and                    2020.
     Gustavo Hernandez-Vargas,                     [15] Kaushal Nigam, Dheeraj Sharma and
     "Electrochemical Biosensors: A Solution           Bandi Venkata Chandan, "Junctionless
     to Pollution Detection with Reference to          based dielectric modulated electrically
     Environmental Contaminants,"                      doped tunnel FET based biosensor for
     Biosensors MDPI, vol. 8, no. 2, 2018.             label‐free detection," Micro and Nano
[4] Anran Gao, Na Lu, Yuelin Wang_Tie Li               Letters, vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 452-456, 2018.
     “Robust ultrasensitive tunneling-FET
     biosensor for point-of-care diagnostics,”
     Nature, 2016.
,[5]    Narang R , IEEE Trans Electron
     Devices, vol. 59, no. 10, p. 2809–2817,
     2012.
[6]     Banerjee K. Sarkar D, "Fundamental
     limitations      of       conventional-FET
     biosensors:          Quantum-mechanical-
     tunneling tothe rescue," in Device Res
     Conf, 2012.
[7]     Chattopadhy S, Gupta PS ,Kanugo S,
     IEEE Trans Electron Devices, vol. 63, no.
     6, p. 2589–2596, 2016.
[8]     Cao W, vol. 067141, pp. 0-9, 2014.
[9]     Shinwari MF and Shinwari MW,
     Sensors Actuators B Chemical, vol. 160,
     no. 1, pp. 441-447, 2011.
[10] Choi S-J, Han J-W, Park TJ, Lee SY,
     Choi Y-K, Ahn J-H, Nanodevices Letter,
     vol. 10, no. 8, pp. 2934-2938, 2010.
[11] Vandenberghe WG, Verhulst AS,
     "Tunnel field-effect transistor without
     gate-drain overlap," Applied Physics
     Letters , vol. 91, no. 5, 2007.
[12] Dheeraj Sharma, Mohd. Aslam
     Shivendra Yadav, Deepak Soni,
     "Approach for the improvement of
     sensitivity and sensing speed of TFET‐
     based biosensor by using plasma
     formation concept," Micro and Nano
     Letters , vol. 13, no. 12, pp. 1728-1733,
     2018.
[13] Brajesh Kumar Kaushik, Prabhat
     Kumar Dubey, "Transition metal
     dichalcogenide material based tunneling
     field-effect transistor for label free bio-
     sensing application," SPIE digital
     Library, vol. 11087, 2019.