KWH FDHV SURY LQ GHVJU QDL VXSRUW RU QWDL HYOX $ VS QW YXD GIF SRVLEO HQW DOQJH WLRXY LQYHVJD WR Q\V OLWHUDX
R o s t o c k , b e r t n s t e i n . 2 2 1 8 0 5 7 o s t o c k e r m a n y SUGRHYL QOVJX V3DWIUP N (FOLSH WROV IU DQJXH GVL KUW K YDW HQ J LP XS UO RI DV WKH P &ODULW\ FRSDUEPLOW\ QG WKD SURYLGHV IJX KHZ R13 DU SOLG I FOD ILR]UPWQ ZKH DSOFE QG WK 0HWD(GL Q $R; ODZLJ IU WKH GVLJQ RI PHOWD I FUDLRQ WKH KLJHUTX\DOQRW V SULQFOHV SRLE 31 K UGV F6 HYDOXWLRQ SULQFOHV Z E WRGX ULI\ Q KH ROZJ DV W\ WRDSHQLOVXUI Y IXU HQV G\0 RL K I FHSW DQG V\ERO P XV LI Y2UDG6\EO P FRQHSW 3R(0¶)UX P (0$,/MDQHN]LKX#URVPWF D \XUYHV 0RG\ HILQV 3ULQFSOH RI 6HPLWF &OD \U LIWKUXEHDJVSR&\ F8VHSUPLWGXQ&E$YRD,/ &R(U8N5VK:S3FHGLQJ 6 ,)*3RU:NLQJ&IHF %/DQWRZ 7KLV SUQFOH GPDV IRU D RQHW UFVSG GH-=LKDQ PEUJO W RQWKH3UDF LI(SV0 <QUHW%&ORLD 6F JD Q XS O IRU LWHV HO\ IFWLY VX D QR 7KH QHG WR E UD LI O\ WZK HJG D KU6\LI([PQEFRHOSWV RG HEOLQ1JYUP±D/W D U 'RPDLQ 6SHFI /JXV DQG 3\ K RDWG OQHSFLV K \E PI'WFH9 VXULQJRDO R GLIHUQF 9DULEOHVQ GZKYFRIXP W \ SRVLEOH&QTXWU\ KDPI[J +\ EURLOGV6ZKQHFPW[D JS M >@ 'LIHUQWDR 7K SHUIRPDQF UHFR PQGDWL V ±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
VHWLQJ 7SDUEOLHPDO\ FVL I WK Q\ ]G SU Z HJD R WKL QF IRFXVH ZH 3 TX SUO K EWZ QGHFLV UKRXSOV\PF DQG LIW YH Q HYDOXWLRQ I Q XOG 7 DUVS FWLYKH O XSLUD P K I RH QWV ZDUG VHFK LWZK GX GH DOVR WRZKLF GD KHLU QL ODWY\ RZ D D D D DQO\ WLF SK\ VLF WXFD O\
$SURDFK (YDOXWHLRQ6J U HQ SDOLG \E > @2WK U XRV > WKH 7KXV WDLFO VJ I DQO\ WLF /RNLQJDWKHS OIVF EGXU RI 7KLV W\XG D RZQ QDO$\ WLF SLU(FDO P V L 8QIUX\ SREOHPDWF L UV WK $O I SUYG EH KDV LRQ &RJQLWYH KHOS WR OLQDPVUH WK UV YDHOXWLRQ LQWHJUDR 0RG\¶V HVLJQ SO PWG RQ KHW $GR; J WKHEQUXPRI FL D V G E VFLH ZUG QRWD I S VLF 7KH ' 0RG\ [SV R WUDFN \ H L8J - VQ 6RI 3 %HUD (YDOXWLQJ & /DFYH 0 . /HFWXU 1RV LQ SXWHU&RP 6FLQ OXGJ VEHUL /FWX \6VWHP PHWKRGOJLV ) Q ESP VRIWZDUHQJL ,(7 F 6 .LWFKHQDP '|UQGRIH *LUDOGR )' (VSx 6 *LUDOGR :- 3VW 2 .URJLH %X G6\,IP (J X [UL D QGHYORSPW 7K * 3 % 5RHOQV &RQWH[ YDOX TLW\ RI GHOLQJP XVU RG POLHQJ ± 1RWHV LQ UW$IFDO ,QHLJ ± IR YLVXDO $UWLIFDO ± ODQJXH \$SOLQJ SK\ VLF (YDOXWLQJ HYDOXWLRQ *HR&QIUF ,QWHUDLRO (YDOXWLRQ 3URFHGLQJV &RQIHUF , 7 IHFWLY V D YLXO QRW " H IFWLYQV R D U UHSQW YLVXDO RI WLYHQV PDWHU S,R YLQJ K F ± ± ± RGHOLQJP ( , YDHOXWLRQ D VHFXUL W\ EHUP ± (QWHUSLV 0 %LDRWQFIVUP %LDRWQFIVUP