=Paper= {{Paper |id=Vol-3386/paper2 |storemode=property |title=Enhancing BPMN 2.0 with IoT Modeling Aspects: How Much Language is Enough? (short paper) |pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3386/paper2.pdf |volume=Vol-3386 |authors=Yusuf Kirikkayis,Florian Gallik,Manfred Reichert |dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/zeus/KirikkayisGR23 }} ==Enhancing BPMN 2.0 with IoT Modeling Aspects: How Much Language is Enough? (short paper)== https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3386/paper2.pdf
&OIBODJOH #1./  XJUI *P5 .PEFMJOH "TQFDUT
)PX .VDI -BOHVBHF JT &OPVHI
:VTVG ,JSJLLBZJT 'MPSJBO (BMMJL BOE .BOGSFE 3FJDIFSU

    *OTUJUVUF PG %BUBCBTFT BOE *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT 6MN 6OJWFSTJUZ  (FSNBOZ


                                         "CTUSBDU
                                         &YUFOEJOH #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU #1. XJUI *OUFSOFU PG 5IJOHT *P5 DBQBCJMJUJFT FOBCMFT SFBM
                                         XPSME BXBSF QSPDFTT BVUPNBUJPO CVTJOFTT SVMF FYFDVUJPO BOE QSPDFTT NPOJUPSJOH "T B QSFSFRVJTJUF
                                         GPS FYQMPJUJOH UIF CFOF6UT PG UIJT SFBMXPSME BXBSFOFTT *P5 CFIBWJPS OFFET UP CF DBQUVSFE JO CVTJOFTT
                                         QSPDFTT NPEFMT 5IF EF GBDUP TUBOEBSE GPS CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH #1./  TFFNT UP CF BQQSPQSJBUF
                                         GPS DPWFSJOH *P5 BTQFDUT BT XFMM )PXFWFS NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT NJHIU CF IJOEFSFE CZ UIF
                                         BNCJHVPVT VTF PG UIF #1./  NPEFMJOH FMFNFOUT 4UJMM JU IBT UP CF FWBMVBUFE IPX QSPDFTT NPEFM
                                         SFBEFST BDUVBMMZ QFSDFJWF *P5 BTQFDUT DBQUVSFE JO #1./  QSPDFTT NPEFMT 5IJT QBQFS EJTDVTTFT UIF
                                         DIBMMFOHFT PG NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT XJUI #1./ BOE EFSJWFT SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT UP CF
                                         JOWFTUJHBUFE JO GVUVSF XPSL

                                         ,FZXPSET
                                         *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT #1. *P5 #1./ 




 *OUSPEVDUJPO
5IF *P5 SFQSFTFOUT B OFUXPSL PG JOUFSDPOOFDUFE QIZTJDBM EFWJDFT JF TFOTPST BOE BDUVBUPST
UIBU BMMPX DBQUVSJOH FYDIBOHJOH BOE DPMMFDUJOH EBUB UP SFTQPOE UP QIZTJDBM FWFOUT 5IVT UIF
EZOBNJD DPOUFYU PG UIF QIZTJDBM XPSME DBO CF DBQUVSFE BOE USBOTGPSNFE UP B EJHJUBM TIBEPX 5IF
*P5 UIFSFGPSF JT B GVOEBNFOUBM UFDIOPMPHZ JO BSFBT MJLFT TNBSU NBOVGBDUVSJOH TNBSU MPHJTUJDT
PS TNBSU IFBMUIDBSF *O UIFTF BSFBT *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT TVQQPSU DBO DSFBUF B DPNQFUJUJWF
FEHF CZ FYQMPJUJOH UIF EBUB QSPEVDFE CZ *P5 EFWJDFT <> 8F SFGFS UP QSPDFTTFT UIBU VUJMJ[F *P5
EFWJDFT BOE NBQ *P5 CFIBWJPS UP QSPDFTT BDUJWJUJFT BOE FWFOUT BT *P5BXBSF
   5IF JODPSQPSBUJPO PG *P5 DBQBCJMJUJFT JOUP *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT P5FST QSPNJTJOH
QFSTQFDUJWFT GPS CSJEHJOH UIF HBQ CFUXFFO EJHJUBM QSPDFTTFT BOE UIF QIZTJDBM XPSME <> 8IJMF
*P5 FOBCMFT DPMMFDUJOH BOE FYDIBOHJOH EBUB BCPVU UIF QIZTJDBM XPSME #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHF
NFOU #1. FOBCMFT NPEFMJOH JNQMFNFOUJOH FYFDVUJOH NPOJUPSJOH BOE BOBMZ[JOH CVTJOFTT
QSPDFTTFT <> *O UIF DPOUFYU PG #1. NPSFPWFS *P5 EFWJDFT DBO CF VTFE UP BVUPNBUF EJ5FS
FOU UZQFT PG UBTLT UP FOIBODF QSPDFTT BOE UBTL NPOJUPSJOH BOE UP TVQQPSU SFBMXPSME BXBSF
EFDJTJPONBLJOH <> "O FTTFOUJBM DIBMMFOHF PG NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT JT UP
QSPQFSMZ DBQUVSF *P5SFMBUFE BTQFDUT JO UIF QSPDFTT NPEFMT < > "NPOHTU PUIFST NPEFMJOH


;&64 $FOUSBM &VSPQFBO 8PSLTIPQ PO 4FSWJDFT BOE UIFJS $PNQPTJUJPO 'FCSVBSZ   JO )BOOPWFS (FSNBOZ
£ ZVTVGLJSJLLBZJT!VOJVMNEF : ,JSJLLBZJT  GMPSJBOHBMMJL!VOJVMNEF ' (BMMJL 
NBOGSFESFJDIFSU!VOJVMNEF . 3FJDIFSU
ñ  : ,JSJLLBZJT  9 ' (BMMJL   . 3FJDIFSU
                                       i  $PQZSJHIU GPS UIJT QBQFS CZ JUT BVUIPST 6TF QFSNJUUFE VOEFS $SFBUJWF $PNNPOT -JDFOTF "UUSJCVUJPO  *OUFSOBUJPOBM $$ #:  
    CEUR
    Workshop
    Proceedings
                  http://ceur-ws.org
                  ISSN 1613-0073
                                       $&63 8PSLTIPQ 1SPDFFEJOHT $&6384PSH




aX "º?K M/ .X GC#F2 U1/bXV, R8i? w1la qQ`Fb?QT- w1la kykj- >MMQp2`- :2`KMv-
ReRd 62#`m`v kykj- Tm#HBb?2/ i ?iiT,ff+2m`@rbXQ`;
EB`BFFvBb 2i HX, 1M?M+BM; "SJL kXy rBi? AQh JQ/2HBM; bT2+ib, >Qr Jm+?
GM;m;2 Bb 1MQm;?\

BEEJUJPOBM SFTFBSDI JT SFRVJSFE UP JOWFTUJHBUF IPX *P5 BTQFDUT TIBMM CF WJTVBMMZ DPWFSFE JO
#1./  NPEFMT XIJMF GPTUFSJOH NPEFM DPNQSFIFOTJCJMJUZ JF XIFUIFS UP PQU GPS WBSJBOU
  PS  <> *O EFUBJM UIF GPMMPXJOH SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT 32T OFFE UP CF DPOTJEFSFE UP
VOEFSTUBOE XIFUIFS B #1./  FYUFOTJPO GPS *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT CFDPNFT OFDFTTBSZ /PUF
UIBU UIFTF SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT XFSF EFSJWFE GSPN TZTUFNBUJD MJUFSBUVSF SFWJFXT < > BT XFMM BT
B DPNQBSJTPO PG UIF UXP NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT JF NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT XJUI TUBOEBSE
#1./  WT NPEFMJOH UIFN CBTFE PO BO FYUFOTJPO PG #1./ XJUI *P5TQFDJ6D FMFNFOUT  

 32      *T #1./  TVJUBCMF GPS NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT
 32      *T UIFSF BOZ *P5TQFDJGJD CFIBWJPS UIBU DBOOPU CF NPEFMFE JO UFSNT PG #1./ 
 32      $BO *P5SFMBUFE NPEFMJOH FMFNFOUT CF JEFOUJGJFE JO #1./  GSPN B VTFS QFSTQFDUJWF
 32      "SF UIFSF QBUUFSOT JO NPEFMJOH *P5ESJWFO CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT
 32      %PFT UIF VTF PG EJkFSFOU #1./ NPEFMJOH FMFNFOUT JOGMVFODF UIF DPHOJUJWF MPBE
          EVSJOH UIF DPNQSFIFOTJPO PG *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT

   32 BJNT UP JEFOUJGZ XIFUIFS #1./  JT TVJUBCMF GPS NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT 32
JOUFOET UP JOWFTUJHBUF XIFUIFS UIFSF FYJTUT BOZ *P5TQFDJ6D CFIBWJPS XIJDI JT SFMFWBOU GPS
QSPDFTT FYFDVUJPO CVU DBOOPU CF QSPQFSMZ SFQSFTFOUFE JO UFSNT PG #1./  5P BOTXFS 32 
*P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT GSPN EJ5FSFOU EPNBJOT OFFE UP CF BOBMZ[FE BOE NPEFMFE XJUI TUBOEBSE
#1./  *O QBSUJDVMBS UIJT NJHIU VOSBWFM *P5 CFIBWJPS UIBU DBOOPU CF EJSFDUMZ NPEFMFE
JO #1./  *O DPOUSBTU 32  BJN UP JEFOUJGZ XIFUIFS *P5 BTQFDUT DBQUVSFE JO #1./ 
QSPDFTT NPEFMT DBO CF WJTVBMMZ PS UFYUVBMMZ SFDPHOJ[FE GSPN B VTFS QFSTQFDUJWF XIFO VTJOH
TUBOEBSE NPEFMJOH FMFNFOUT FH QPPMT MBOFT BDUJWJUZ UZQFT BOE FWFOU UZQFT  32  BJN UP
EFUFSNJOF XIFUIFS UIFSF BSF QBUUFSOT PG *P5ESJWFO CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT XIFO NPEFMJOH UIFN
JO UFSNT PG #1./  *O UVSO 32 JOWFTUJHBUFT UIF DPHOJUJWF MPBE PG VTFST XIFO SFBEJOH BOE
DPNQSFIFOEJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT JO #1./  'PS UIJT QVSQPTF GPS FYBNQMF B /"4"5-9
RVFTUJPOOBJSF NBZ CF VTFE "OTXFSJOH 32T    TIBMM BMMPX VT UP VOEFSTUBOE IPX *P5BXBSF
CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT NPEFMFE JO UFSNT PG TUBOEBSE #1./  B5FDU IVNBO DPHOJUJPO BOE IPX
GBS UIF SFTQFDUJWF QSPDFTT NPEFMT BSF QFSDFJWFE BT *P5BXBSF GSPN B VTFS QFSTQFDUJWF "MM 6WF
SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT OFFE UP CF BOTXFSFE JO PSEFS UP BTTFTT XIFUIFS BO *P5TQFDJ6D #1./ 
FYUFOTJPO JT CFOF6DJBM UP GPTUFS SFBMXPSME *P5ESJWFO CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT


 $PODMVTJPOT
5IJT QBQFS JOUSPEVDFE 6WF SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT UIBU OFFE UP CF BEESFTTFE XIFO NPEFMJOH *P5
BXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT XJUI #1./  *O MJUFSBUVSF UXP BQQSPBDIFT BSF QSPQPTFE GPS
NPEFMJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT  VTJOH TUBOEBSE #1./  BT  FYUFOEJOH UIF #1./ 
TUBOEBSE XJUI *P5TQFDJ6D NPEFMJOH FMFNFOUT )PXFWFS FYJTUJOH XPSLT IBWF OFHMFDUFE UIF
VTFS QFSTQFDUJWF XIFO EFDJEJOH XIJDI PG UIFTF UXP WBSJBOUT TIBMM CF VTFE $POTFRVFOUMZ UIF
QSPT BOE DPOT PO IPX UP NPEFM *P5 BTQFDUT JO #1./CBTFE QSPDFTTFT IBWF QSJNBSJMZ CFFO
DPOTJEFSFE GPSN B UFDIOJDBM QFSTQFDUJWF UBLFO CZ *P5 FYQFSUT 6TFS TUVEJFT BSF OFFEFE UIBU
BEESFTT UIF QSFTFOUFE SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT *O DPSSFTQPOEJOH TUVEJFT EJ5FSFOU BTQFDUT TVDI
BT UIF SFDPHOJUJPO PG *P5 BTQFDUT JO #1./CBTFE QSPDFTT NPEFMT UIF DPHOJUJWF MPBE PG VTFST
XIFO SFBEJOH *P5BXBSF QSPDFTTFT JO #1./  BOE EJ5FSFOU NPEFMJOH QBUUFSOT GPS *P5BXBSF




                                                                                                RR
EB`BFFvBb 2i HX, 1M?M+BM; "SJL kXy rBi? AQh JQ/2HBM; bT2+ib, >Qr Jm+?
GM;m;2 Bb 1MQm;?\

QSPDFTTFT JO #1./ GSPN VTFS QFSTQFDUJWF DBO CF JEFOUJ6FE 7BSJPVT UFDIOJRVFT NBZ CF VTFE GPS
UIJT QVSQPTF TVDI BT UIF TVSWFZ PG TUVEZ QBSUJDJQBOUT BOE DPOEVDUJOH B XJUIJOTVCKFDU TUVEZ


3FGFSFODFT
 <> ' .BSUJOT % %PNJOHPT .PEFMMJOH JPU CFIBWJPVS XJUIJO CQNO CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT 1SPDF
     EJB $PNQVUFS 4DJFODF  Ù *OU $POG PO &/5&3QSJTF *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT
 <> +BOJFTDI FU BM 5IF JOUFSOFU PG UIJOHT NFFUT CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NBOBHFNFOU B NBOJGFTUP
     4ZTUFNT .BO BOE $ZCFSOFUJDT .BHB[JOF  Ù
 <> 3 4FJHFS - .BMCVSH # 8FCFS 3 #FSHNBOO *OUFHSBUJOH QSPDFTT NBOBHFNFOU BOE
     FWFOU QSPDFTTJOH JO TNBSU GBDUPSJFT " TZTUFNT BSDIJUFDUVSF BOE VTF DBTFT +PVSOBM PG
     .BOVGBDUVSJOH 4ZTUFNT  Ù
 <> : ,JSJLLBZJT ' (BMMJL . 3FJDIFSU .PEFMJOH FYFDVUJOH BOE NPOJUPSJOH JPUESJWFO
     CVTJOFTT SVMFT XJUI CQNO BOE ENO $VSSFOU TVQQPSU BOE DIBMMFOHFT JO &OUFSQSJTF %FTJHO
     0QFSBUJPOT BOE $PNQVUJOH 4QSJOHFS *OU 1VCMJTIJOH  QQ Ù
 <> : ,JSJLLBZJT ' (BMMJL . 3FJDIFSU 5PXBSET B DPNQSFIFOTJWF CQNO FYUFOTJPO GPS
     NPEFMJOH JPUBXBSF QSPDFTTFT JO CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NPEFMT JO 3FTFBSDI $IBMMFOHFT JO
     *OGPSNBUJPO 4DJFODF 4QSJOHFS *OU 1VCMJTIJOH  QQ Ù
 <> ' )BTJÇ & 4 "TFOTJP &YFDVUJOH JPU QSPDFTTFT JO CQNO  $VSSFOU TVQQPSU BOE SFNBJOJOH
     DIBMMFOHFT JO 3FTFBSDI $IBMMFOHFT JO *OGPSNBUJPO 4DJFODF  QQ Ù
 <> " $BSBDBT 'SPN CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NPEFMT UP QFSWBTJWF BQQMJDBUJPOT 4ZODISPOJ[BUJPO BOE
     PQUJNJ[BUJPO JO 1FSWBTJWF $PNQVUJOH BOE $PNNVOJDBUJPOT 84  QQ Ù
 <> " $BSBDB " #FSOBVFS $PNQJMJOH CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NPEFMT GPS TFOTPS OFUXPSLT JO 
     *OU $POG PO %JTUSJCVUFE $PNQVUJOH JO 4FOTPS 4ZTUFNT BOE 8PSLTIPQT  QQ Ù
 <> " $BSBDB 5 ,SBNQ 0O UIF FYQSFTTJWFOFTT PG CQNO GPS NPEFMJOH XJSFMFTT TFOTPS
     OFUXPSLT BQQMJDBUJPOT JO #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .PEFM BOE /PUBUJPO 4QSJOHFS  QQ Ù
<> " :PVT6 $ #BVFS 3 4BJEJ " , %FZ VCQNO " CQNO FYUFOTJPO GPS NPEFMJOH VCJRVJUPVT
     CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT *OGPSNBUJPO BOE 4PNXBSF 5FDIOPMPHZ  Ù
<> $ 5 4VOHVS 1 4QJFTT / 0FSUFM 0 ,PQQ &YUFOEJOH CQNO GPS XJSFMFTT TFOTPS OFUXPSLT
     JO $POG PO #VTJOFTT *OGPSNBUJDT  QQ Ù
<> 4 .FZFS " 3VQQFO - )JMUZ 5IF UIJOHT PG UIF JOUFSOFU PG UIJOHT JO CQNO JO "EWBODFE
     *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH 8PSLTIPQT 4QSJOHFS *OU 1VCMJTIJOH  QQ Ù
<> 1 7BMEFSBT 7 5PSSFT & 4FSSBM .PEFMMJOH BOE FYFDVUJOH JPUFOIBODFE CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT
     UISPVHI CQNO BOE NJDSPTFSWJDFT +PVSOBM PG 4ZTUFNT BOE 4PNXBSF   
<> . 8JOUFS ) /FVNBOO 3 1SZTT 5 1SPCTU . 3FJDIFSU %F6OJOH HB[F QBUUFSOT GPS QSPDFTT
     NPEFM MJUFSBDZ  FYQMPSJOH WJTVBM SPVUJOFT JO QSPDFTT NPEFMT XJUI EJWFSTF NBQQJOHT &YQFSU
     4ZTU "QQM  
<> $ *WBO $ 'MBWJP ' 'BCSJ[JP 1 "OESFB 3 #BSCBSB 5 'SBODFTDP " TZTUFNBUJD MJUFSBUVSF
     SFWJFX PO JPUBXBSF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH WJFXT SFRVJSFNFOUT BOE OPUBUJPOT +PVSOBM
     PG 4PNXBSF BOE 4ZTUFNT .PEFMJOH  
<> 7 5PSSFT & 4FSSBM 1 7BMEFSBT 7 1FMFDIBOP 1 (SFGFO .PEFMJOH PG JPU EFWJDFT JO CVTJOFTT
     QSPDFTTFT " TZTUFNBUJD NBQQJOH TUVEZ JO $POG PO #VTJOFTT *OGPSNBUJDT 




                                                                                            Rk