=Paper= {{Paper |id=Vol-3386/paper7 |storemode=property |title=Toward Model-driven Planning Support for Construction Processes (short paper) |pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3386/paper7.pdf |volume=Vol-3386 |authors=Anjo Seidel |dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/zeus/Seidel23 }} ==Toward Model-driven Planning Support for Construction Processes (short paper)== https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3386/paper7.pdf
5PXBSE .PEFMESJWFO 1MBOOJOH 4VQQPSU GPS
$POTUSVDUJPO 1SPDFTTFT
"OKP 4FJEFM

    )BTTP 1MBUUOFS *OTUJUVUF 6OJWFSTJUZ PG 1PUTEBN 1SPG%S)FMNFSU 4US ¶ 1PUTEBN  (FSNBOZ


                                         "CTUSBDU
                                         $POTUSVDUJPO TJUFT BSF TIBQFE CZ LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF NVMUJJOTUBODF BOE JUFNEFQFOEFOU QSPDFTTFT
                                         5IF LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST JO TVDI EPNBJOT OFFE UP NPEFM UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT BOE DPOTUSVDUJPO
                                         FMFNFOUT BOE QMBO UIF GVUVSF QSPDFTT FYFDVUJPO DPMMBCPSBUJWFMZ XJUI BMM JOWPMWFE QBSUJFT )PXFWFS JU
                                         JT DIBMMFOHJOH UP NPEFM UIFTF QSPDFTTFT DPNQSFIFOTJWFMZ BOE BDDFTTJCMZ GPS EPNBJO FYQFSUT XIJMF UIF
                                         QMBOOJOH PG UIF GVUVSF FYFDVUJPO DBO OPU CF GVMMZ TVQQPSUFE ZFU 5IJT QPTJUJPO QBQFS QSPQPTFT UIF NFBOT
                                         UPXBSE EFWFMPQJOH TVJUBCMF QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT QSPWJEJOH UIF PQQPSUVOJUZ UP NPEFM QSPDFTT
                                         HPBMT BOE DPNCJOJOH CPUI UP EFSJWF VTFGVM FYFDVUJPO QMBOT GSPN BOBMZ[JOH UIF QSPDFTT NPEFMßT TUBUF
                                         TQBDF JO SFHBSE UP UIF HPBM NPEFM

                                         ,FZXPSET
                                         ,OPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF 1SPDFTTFT $POTUSVDUJPO 1SPDFTTFT 1SPDFTT .PEFMJOH (PBM .PEFMJOH 1MBOOJOH
                                         4VQQPSU




 *OUSPEVDUJPO
*O SFDFOU ZFBST DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT BSF CFDPNJOH NPSF BOE NPSF EJHJUJ[FE GSPN NPCJMF EFWJDFT
UP %.PEFMT PG DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT BOE ESPOFT GPS TVQFSWJTJOH UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPHSFTT <>
   5IF CVTJOFTT QSPDFTT NBOBHFNFOU DPNNVOJUZ BMTP TUBSUFE UP JOWFTUJHBUF UIF VTF DBTF PG
DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT < > *O HFOFSBM QSPDFTTFT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE LOPXMFEHF
JOUFOTJWF <> BT UIFZ IBWF UIF GPMMPXJOH DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT<> XIJDI BSF JNQPTFE CZ UIF WPMBUJMF
FYFDVUJPO DPOUFYU PG UIF QSPDFTTFT ,OPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT BSF FYFDVUFE CZ LOPXMFEHF
XPSLFST TVDI BT DPOTUSVDUJPO XPSLFST BOE DPOTUSVDUJPO NBOBHFST 'VSUIFSNPSF LOPXMFEHF
JOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT BSF VOQSFEJDUBCMF BOE VOSFQFBUBCMF 5IFZ FNFSHF BT LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST
NBLF EFDJTJPOT CBTFE PO UIFJS EPNBJO LOPXMFEHF 1MBOOJOH JT BO JNQPSUBOU QBSU PG LOPXMFEHF
XPSL *U NFBOT BMJHOJOH UIF GVUVSF FYFDVUJPO PG UBTLT UPXBSE B QSPDFTT HPBM "T XFBUIFS
DPOEJUJPOT DIBOHF GBVMUT PDDVS BOE EFMBZT QPTUQPOF GVUVSF QSPHSFTT QMBOT IBWF UP CF BEBQUFE
BOE UIF LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST OFFE UP SFQMBO
   .PSF DIBMMFOHJOH QSPDFTTFT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE NVMUJJOTUBODF QSPDFTTFT
BOE JUFNEFQFOEFOU <> " IPVTF IBT NVMUJQMF QSPDFTT JOTUBODFT SVOOJOH GPS FBDI PG JUT :BUT
XIJDI JO UVSO JO:VFODF FBDI PUIFSßT QSPDFTT FYFDVUJPO "MTP BMM JOTUBODFT BSF JUFNEFQFOEFOU
BT UIF QFSGPSNFE BDUJWJUJFT MJLF QBJOUJOH KPCT EFQFOE PO FYJTUFOU NBUFSJBM TVDI BT UIF QBJOU BOE

UI $FOUSBM &VSPQFBO 8PSLTIPQ PO 4FSWJDFT BOE UIFJS $PNQPTJUJPO
£ BOKPTFJEFM!TUVEFOUIQJEF " 4FJEFM
  " 4FJEFM
                                       i  $PQZSJHIU GPS UIJT QBQFS CZ JUT BVUIPST 6TF QFSNJUUFE VOEFS $SFBUJWF $PNNPOT -JDFOTF "UUSJCVUJPO  *OUFSOBUJPOBM $$ #:  
    CEUR
    Workshop
    Proceedings
                  http://ceur-ws.org
                  ISSN 1613-0073
                                       $&63 8PSLTIPQ 1SPDFFEJOHT $&6384PSH




aX "º?K M/ .X GC#F2 U1/bXV, R8i? w1la qQ`Fb?QT- w1la kykj- >MMQp2`- :2`KMv-
ReRd 62#`m`v kykj- Tm#HBb?2/ i ?iiT,ff+2m`@rbXQ`;
MDQ a2B/2H, hQr`/ JQ/2H@/`Bp2M SHMMBM; amTTQ`i 7Q` *QMbi`m+iBQM S`Q+2bb2b


B QMBTUFSFE XBMM
   5SBEJUJPOBM NPEFMJOH UFDIOJRVFT MJLF #1./ BSF OPU XFMM TVJUFE UP EFQJDU UIF DPNQMFYJUZ PG
TVDI EPNBJOT &WFO UIF FYJTUJOH NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT GPS DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT <  > EP
OPU GVM9MM DFSUBJO SFRVJSFNFOUT PG LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT GVMMZ 'PS JOTUBODF MBUF HPBM
NPEFMJOH BOE QMBOOJOH BSF BO JNQPSUBOU QBSU PG LOPXMFEHF XPSL <> 1MBOOJOH JT UIF BMJHONFOU
PG BDUJPOT BDDPSEJOH UP B HPBM 8JUI DIBOHJOH HPBMT BOE FYFDVUJPO DPOUFYUT FYFDVUJPO QMBOT PO
DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT OFFE UP CF SFQMBOOFE GSFRVFOUMZ *G DPOTUSVDUJPO XPSLFST CFDPNF TJDL UIF
EFMJWFSZ PG UIF QBJOU QPTUQPOFT PS TJNQMZ UIF XFBUIFS QFSNJUT QBJOUJOH UIF IPVTFßT GBDBEF UIF
QBJOUJOH BDUJWJUJFT IBWF UP CF SFTDIFEVMFE 5IJT NJHIU JO:VFODF UIF PWFSBMM QSPHSFTT BOE UIF
TDIFEVMF PG UIF XIPMF DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUF OFFET UP CF SFQMBOOFE
   5P UBDLMF UIF QSPCMFN PG QSPWJEJOH QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU GPS DPNQMFY EPNBJOT TVDI BT DPOTUSVDUJPO
TJUFT XF QSPWJEF B SFTFBSDI BHFOEB UIBU DPNCJOFT UIF BOBMZTJT PG UIF VTF DBTF BOE UIF BQQMJDBCJMJUZ
PG EJ8FSFOU QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT UP JU 8F BMTP OFFE UP BMMPX UIF NPEFMJOH BOE SF
NPEFMJOH PG HPBMT EVSJOH EFTJHO BOE SVOUJNF 8JUI UIF QSPDFTT NPEFM BOE UIF HPBM NPEFMT BU
IBOE UIF CFIBWJPS PG UIF QSPDFTT NPEFM DBO CF BOBMZ[FE JO SFHBSE UP UIF HPBMT 5IF SFTVMUT DBO
CF VTFE UP HFOFSBUF FYFDVUJPO QMBOT GPS UIF GVUVSF FYFDVUJPO PG UIF DVSSFOU DBTF
   *O UIF GPMMPXJOH 4FDUJPO  XF PVUMJOF UIF FYJTUJOH XPSL SFMBUFE UP PVS SFTFBSDI FOEFBWPS
4FDUJPO  EJTDVTTFT PVS BQQSPBDI BOE UIF QMBOOFE DPOUSJCVUJPO CFGPSF 4FDUJPO  DPODMVEFT UIF
QBQFS


 3FMBUFE 8PSL
8PSL SFMBUFE UP PVS SFTFBSDI BHFOEB JODMVEFT LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT NPEFMJOH BQ
QSPBDIFT UPXBSE DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT UIF NPEFMJOH PG LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT BOE
QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU
   ,OPXMFEHF XPSLFST GBDF UBTLT PG JEFOUJGZJOH BOE TPMWJOH QSPCMFNT XJUI B MPX MFWFM PG
TUBOEBSEJ[BUJPO JO LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT <> 5IFJS FYFDVUJPO DPOUFYU JT WBTU BOE GBTU
DIBOHJOH <> %J $JDDJP FU BM QSPWJEF BO PWFSWJFX PG UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF
QSPDFTTFT BOE UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT UP TVQQPSU UIFN <> )PXFWFS JU JT DIBMMFOHJOH UP NPEFM UIFN
DPNQSFIFOTJWFMZ BOE UIFZ BSF PQFO VOEFSTQFDJ9FE <> "EEJUJPOBMMZ UP CFJOH LOPXMFEHF
JOUFOTJWF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT DBO CF DPOTJEFSFE NVMUJJOTUBODF BOE JUFNEFQFOEFOU <>
NBLJOH NPEFMJOH FWFO NPSF DIBMMFOHJOH
   %J8FSFOU BQQSPBDIFT BJN UP NPEFM DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT 'JSTU WBO EFS "BMTU FU BM JOUSP
EVDFE DBTF IBOEMJOH BT B NFBOT UP TVQQPSU UIF QSPDFTTFT PG B EVUDI DPOTUSVDUJPO DPNQBOZ <>
#Z OPX OFX DBTF NBOBHFNFOU BQQSPBDIFT IBWF FNFSHFE BOE NJHIU BMTP CF BQQMJDBCMF .BSFOHP
FU BM QSPQPTFE UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH MBOHVBHF $P1.PE- <> *U DPNCJOFT UIF
EFDMBSBUJWF NPEFMJOH PG BDUJWJUJFT BOE JUFNT PO XIJDI UIFTF BDUJWJUJFT DBO CF FYFDVUFE
   *O UIF DPOUFYU PG -FBO $POTUSVDUJPO .BOBHFNFOU EJ8FSFOU 5PPMT IBWF CFFO EFWFMPQFE UP
NPEFM BOE NPOJUPS UIF QSPDFTTFT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT <>
   %J8FSFOU NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT BJN UP EFQJDU LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT BOE NJHIU
UIFSFGPSF CF TVJUBCMF UP NPEFM DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT )ZCSJE NPEFMJOH UFDIOJRVFT DPNCJO
JOH UIF DPODFQUT PG EFDMBSBUJWF BOE EBUBDFOUSJD QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT BSF QSPNJTJOH
GPS UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO EPNBJO $POUFNQPSBSZ BQQSPBDIFT BSF 0$#$ <> 3&4&%" <> BOE




                                                                                               9y
MDQ a2B/2H, hQr`/ JQ/2H@/`Bp2M SHMMBM; amTTQ`i 7Q` *QMbi`m+iBQM S`Q+2bb2b


3F(SB%B <> 0UIFS BQQSPBDIFT BJN UP JNQMFNFOU DBTF NBOBHFNFOU <> UP TVQQPSU LOPXMFEHF
JOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT $BTF .BOBHFNFOU BOE .PEFM BOE /PUBUJPO <> BOE GSBHNFOUCBTFE $BTF
.BOBHFNFOU < > XFSF QSPQPTFE
   5IPVHI MBUF HPBM NPEFMJOH JT DSVDJBM GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT JU JT POMZ MJNJUFEMZ
TVQQPSUFE JO NPTU QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDIFT <> *O QSFWJPVT XPSL UIF NFBOT UPXBSE UIF
NPEFMJOH PG HPBMT GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT XFSF QSPWJEFE < >
   "OPUIFS JNQPSUBOU BTQFDU PG LOPXMFEHF XPSL JT QMBOOJOH *U JT UIF BMJHONFOU PG BDUJPOT UP
SFBDI B HPBM %J8FSFOU BQQSPBDIFT BJN BU QSPWJEJOH QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU 4NBSU1. <> DBO CF
VTFE GPS FYDFQUJPO IBOEMJOH 4QSPWJFSJ BOE 7PHMFS <> DPNQPTF QSPDFTT NPEFMT GSPN QBSUMZ
TUSVDUVSFE NPEFMT 0UIFS BQQSPBDIFT CZ 8ZOO FU BM <> BOE 3P[JOBU FU BM <> BMMPX UP
TJNVMBUF QSPDFTT NPEFMT UP QSPWJEF EFDJTJPO TVQQPSU %J8FSFOU QSFEJDUJWF QSPDFTT NPOJUPSJOH
BQQSPBDIFT QSFEJDU UIF OFYU BDUJPOT JO SVOOJOH JOTUBODFT CBTFE PO NBDIJOF MFBSOJOH < >
4UJMM UIF DPOUFNQPSBSZ BQQSPBDIFT EP OPU GVMMZ NBQ UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT BOE SFRVJSFNFOUT
GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT 5IF 9STU TUFQT UPXBSE NPEFMESJWFO QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU CZ
QSPWJEJOH SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT GPS UIF OFYU CFTU BDUJPOT BDDPSEJOH UP B HPBM XFSF NBEF JO QSFWJPVT
DPOUSJCVUJPOT < >


 1MBOOFE $POUSJCVUJPO
8F FOEFBWPS UP QSPWJEF TVJUBCMF QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF NVMUJJOTUBODF BOE
JUFNEFQFOEFOU QSPDFTTFT MJLF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT 5P QVSTVF UIJT HPBM UIF HFOFSBM JEFB JT
UP DPNCJOF UIF QSPDFTT NPEFM XJUI B HPBM NPEFM GPS UIF DVSSFOU QSPDFTT FYFDVUJPO 5IF NPEFMßT
TUBUF TQBDF DBO UIFO CF BOBMZ[FE UP 9OE QPTTJCMF FYFDVUJPO TFRVFODFT UIBU TBUJTGZ UIF HPBMT PG
UIF LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST <> "OBMZ[JOH HPBMTBUJTGZJOH QBUIT NBZ SFTVMU JO LOPXMFEHF BCPVU
XIBU OFYU BDUJPOT BSF TVJUBCMF UP SFBDI UIF HPBM 5IJT LOPXMFEHF DBO CF VTFE UP QSPWJEF EFDJTJPO
TVQQPSU <> *O UIF GVUVSF DPNQSFIFOTJWF FYFDVUJPO QMBOT DPVME CF HFOFSBUFE BT XFMM
   'JSTU B TVJUBCMF CFIBWJPSBM NPEFMJOH UFDIOJRVF UP EF9OF UIF QSPDFTTFT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT
JT OFFEFE 4FDPOE HPBMT OFFE UP CF NPEFMFE JO UIBU DPOUFYU 5IF TUBUF TQBDF BOBMZTJT XJUI CPUI
NPEFMT OFFET UP QSPWJEF NFBOJOHGVM QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU JO GPSN PG FYFDVUJPO QMBOT 5IJT SFTVMUT
JO PVS GPMMPXJOH SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT

32 8IBU JT B TVJUBCMF NPEFMJOH MBOHVBHF UP EFQJDU DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT DPNQSFIFOTJWFMZ
32 )PX DBO HPBMT CF NPEFMFE JO UIF DPOUFYU PG DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT
32 )PX DBO FYFDVUJPO QMBOT GPS DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT CF BVUPNBUJDBMMZ HFOFSBUFE GSPN QSPDFTT
    NPEFMT BOE HPBM NPEFMT

  5P BOTXFS 32 XF QMBO UP BOBMZ[F UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT GPS NPEFMJOH LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF
NVMUJWBSJBOU BOE JUFNEFQFOEFOU QSPDFTTFT 8F XJMM JOWFTUJHBUF BOE DPNQBSF DPOUFNQPSBSZ
BQQSPBDIFT GPS NPEFMJOH DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT BOE LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT "T B
SFTVMU FYJTUJOH BQQSPBDIFT DBO UIFO CF FYUFOEFE PS OFX BQQSPBDIFT DBO CF EFWFMPQFE UP NBQ
UIFTF SFRVJSFNFOUT *O PVS 9STU JOGPSNBM BOBMZTJT DBTF NBOBHFNFOU <> FTQFDJBMMZ GSBHNFOU
CBTFE DBTF NBOBHFNFOU <> TFFNFE QSPNJTJOH 5IF DPODFQUT BMMPX B OPUJPO PG NVMUJJOTUBODF
QSPDFTTFT XIJMF CFJOH BCMF UP EFQJDU UIF EFQFOEJOH JUFNT :FU EJ8FSFOU BEBQUBUJPOT IBWF UP CF
NBEF UP VUJMJ[F UIFTF BQQSPBDIFT GVMMZ



                                                                                             9R
MDQ a2B/2H, hQr`/ JQ/2H@/`Bp2M SHMMBM; amTTQ`i 7Q` *QMbi`m+iBQM S`Q+2bb2b


   "MTP QBSU PG UIF QSJPS BOBMZTJT JT JEFOUJGZJOH UIF NFBOT UP NPEFM HPBMT BOTXFSJOH 32
5FDIOJRVFT UP NPEFM HPBMT DBO UIFO CF DPNCJOFE XJUI UIF SFTVMU PG 32 " HFOFSBM BQQSPBDI
UPXBSE UIF NPEFMJOH PG HPBMT GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT XBT BMSFBEZ QSPWJEFE < >
" DPOTUSBJOUT UIF TUBUF PG UIF JOWPMWFE EBUB BOE BWBJMBCMF BDUJPOT JO GVUVSF FYFDVUJPO TUBUFT
)PXFWFS UIF JOWPMWFE LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST QSP9U GSPN NPSF EPNBJO TQFDJ9D NFBOT UP NPEFM
HPBMT 4VDI BQQSPBDIFT DPVME JODMVEF UIF VUJMJ[BUJPO PG CVJEJOH JOGPSNBUJPO NPEFMT #*.
XIJDI QSPWJEF %NPEFMT PG CVJMEJOHT UP CF CVJMU 5IFZ BSF BMSFBEZ XFMM FTUBCMJTIFE JO UIF
EPNBJO BOE DBO EFQJDU UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO JUFNT JO EJ8FSFOU FYFDVUJPO TUBUFT
   5P BEESFTT 32 UIF TUBUF TQBDF PG UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMT DBO CF BOBMZ[FE 4FWFSBM
DIBMMFOHFT IBWF UP CF PWFSDPNF 4UBUF TQBDFT PG QSPDFTT NPEFMT HSPX FYQPOFOUJBMMZ BOE DBO
CFDPNF JO9OJUFMZ MBSHF )PXFWFS UIF MBSHF TUBUF TQBDFT BMTP ZJFMET UIF QPTTJCJMJUZ UP 9OE NBOZ
TVJUBCMF QSPDFTT FYFDVUJPOT UIBU DBO CF VUJMJ[FE UP EFSJWF FYFDVUJPO QMBOT )PXFWFS JU TIPVME CF
SFEVDFE BT NVDI BT QPTTJCMF BOE TVJUBCMF BMHPSJUINT OFFE UP CF EFWFMPQFE UIBU DPQF XJUI UIFJS
TJ[F BOE SFUVSO TVJUBCMF QMBOT 5IF SFUSJFWFE TVJUBCMF FYFDVUJPO QMBOT DBO UIFO CF FWBMVBUFE IPX
SFTJMJFOU UIFZ BSF UP DIBOHJOH FYFDVUJPO DPOUFYU *O UIBU DPOUFYU NBDIJOF MFBSOJOH UFDIOJRVFT
DBO CF VUJMJ[FE UP JODPSQPSBUF EPNBJO LOPXMFEHF JOUP UIF QMBOT 5IFTF QMBOT UIFO OFFE UP CF
EJTQMBZFE DPNQSFIFOTJCMZ " VTVBM XBZ UP EJTQMBZ QMBOT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT BSF TDIFEVMFT
XJUI (BOUUDIBSUT 5IF SFTVMUJOH QMBOOJOH SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT TIPVME CBMBODF UIF DPNQMFYJUZ PG
BMM QPTTJCMF FYFDVUJPO TFRVFODFT BOE DPNQSFIFOTJCJMJUZ
   "MM UISFF SFTFBSDI RVFTUJPOT MPOH GPS UPPMJOH TVQQPSU 8F BJN UP EFWFMPQ QSPUPUZQJDBM JNQMF
NFOUBUJPOT GPS DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH DPOTUSVDUJPO HPBM NPEFMJOH BOE UIF DPNQVUBUJPO
PG QMBOOJOH SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT PVU PG UIF QSFWJPVT UXP 5IF TVJUBCJMJUZ PG UIF QSFTFOUFE BQQSPBDI
TIPVME CF FWBMVBUFE JO UIF 9FME CZ DPOEVDUJOH DBTF TUVEJFT


 $PODMVTJPO
$POTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTTFT BSF LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF NVMUJJOTUBODF BOE JUFNEFQFOEFOU 1MBOOJOH
JT BO JNQPSUBOU UBTL PG UIF JOWPMWFE LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST CVU POMZ MJNJUFEMZ TVQQPSUFE 5IJT
QPTJUJPO QBQFS QSPQPTFT BO BQQSPBDI UP QSPWJEF QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU GPS QSPDFTTFT PO DPOTUSVDUJPO
TJUFT BOE TJNJMBS EPNBJOT 5IF BQQSPBDI TUBSUT CZ BOBMZ[JOH UIF SFRVJSFNFOUT GPS DPNQSFIFOTJWF
DPOTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMT 4VDI B NPEFMJOH BQQSPBDI DBO UIFO CF EFWFMPQFE BOE DPNCJOFE
XJUI TVJUBCMF HPBM NPEFMJOH GPS DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT #PUI QSPDFTT NPEFM BOE HPBM NPEFM DBO UIFO
CF VUJMJ[FE UP BOBMZ[F UIF NPEFMßT QPTTJCMF CFIBWJPS JO PSEFS UP 9OE FYFDVUJPO QMBOT UIBU TBUJTGZ
UIF HPBM 5IF SFTVMU PG UIJT FOEFBWPS JT NPEFMESJWFO QMBOOJOH TVQQPSU GPS DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT
BOE TJNJMBS EPNBJOT


3FGFSFODFT
 <> ' &MHIBJTI 4 .BUBSOFI 4 5BMFCJ . ,BHJPHMPV . 3 )PTTFJOJ 4 "CSJTIBNJ 5PXBSE
     EJHJUBMJ[BUJPO JO UIF DPOTUSVDUJPO JOEVTUSZ XJUI JNNFSTJWF BOE ESPOFT UFDIOPMPHJFT B
     DSJUJDBM MJUFSBUVSF SFWJFX 4NBSU BOE 4VTUBJOBCMF #VJMU &OWJSPONFOU  
 <> 8 . WBO EFS "BMTU . 4UP8FMF + 8BNFMJOL $BTF IBOEMJOH JO DPOTUSVDUJPO "VUPNBUJPO
     JO $POTUSVDUJPO   Ù



                                                                                              9k
MDQ a2B/2H, hQr`/ JQ/2H@/`Bp2M SHMMBM; amTTQ`i 7Q` *QMbi`m+iBQM S`Q+2bb2b


 <> & .BSFOHP 8 /VUU . 1FSLUPME $PQNPEM $POTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH MBOHVBHF
     BOE TBUJT9BCJMJUZ DIFDLJOH *OG 4ZTU    EPJKJT
 <> $ % $JDDJP " .BSSFMMB " 3VTTP ,OPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT $IBSBDUFSJTUJDT
     SFRVJSFNFOUT BOE BOBMZTJT PG DPOUFNQPSBSZ BQQSPBDIFT + %BUB 4FNBOU   Ù
     EPJT
 <> & .BSFOHP 8 /VUU . 1FSLUPME $POTUSVDUJPO QSPDFTT NPEFMJOH 3FQSFTFOUJOH BDUJWJUJFT
     JUFNT BOE UIFJS JOUFSQMBZ JO . 8FTLF . .POUBMJ * 8FCFS + WPN #SPDLF &ET #VTJOFTT
     1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU  UI *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF #1. ä WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF
     /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS 4DJFODF 4QSJOHFS  QQ Ù EPJ=
     @
 <> 1 1Z¶SJ¤ 5IF DPODFQU PG LOPXMFEHF XPSL SFWJTJUFE + ,OPXM .BOBH   Ù
     EPJ
 <> , % 4XFOTPO 1PTJUJPO #1./ JT JODPNQBUJCMF XJUI "$. JO . - 3PTB 1 4P8FS &ET
     #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU 8PSLTIPQT  #1.  *OUFSOBUJPOBM 8PSLTIPQT WPMVNF
      PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO #VTJOFTT *OGPSNBUJPO 1SPDFTTJOH 4QSJOHFS #FSMJO )FJEFMCFSH 
     QQ Ù EPJ=@
 <> 4 4JOHI , ,VNBS 3FWJFX PG MJUFSBUVSF PG MFBO DPOTUSVDUJPO BOE MFBO UPPMT VTJOH TZTUFNBUJD
     MJUFSBUVSF SFWJFX UFDIOJRVF Ù "JO 4IBNT &OHJOFFSJOH +PVSOBM   Ù
 <> 8 . 1 WBO EFS "BMTU " "SUBMF . .POUBMJ 4 5SJUJOJ 0CKFDUDFOUSJD CFIBWJPSBM DPO
     TUSBJOUT *OUFHSBUJOH EBUB BOE EFDMBSBUJWF QSPDFTT NPEFMMJOH JO " "SUBMF # (MJNN
     3 ,POUDIBLPW &ET 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF UI *OUFSOBUJPOBM 8PSLTIPQ PO %FTDSJQ
     UJPO -PHJDT WPMVNF  PG $&63 8PSLTIPQ 1SPDFFEJOHT $&6384PSH  63-
     IUUQDFVSXTPSH7PMQBQFSQEG
<> + $ 4FDP 4 %FCPJT 5 5 )JMEFCSBOEU 5 4MBBUT 3&4&%" EFDMBSJOH MJWF FWFOUESJWFO
     DPNQVUBUJPOT BT SFBDUJWF TFNJTUSVDUVSFE EBUB JO OE *&&& *OUFSOBUJPOBM &OUFSQSJTF
     %JTUSJCVUFE 0CKFDU $PNQVUJOH $POGFSFODF &%0$  *&&& $PNQVUFS 4PDJFUZ 
     EPJ&%0$
<> - (BMSJOIP + $ 4FDP 4 %FCPJT 5 5 )JMEFCSBOEU ) /PSNBO 5 4MBBUT 3FHSBEB 3FBDUJWF
     HSBQI EBUB JO ' %BNJBOJ 0 %BSEIB &ET $PPSEJOBUJPO .PEFMT BOE -BOHVBHFT  SE
     *'*1 8(  *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS 4DJFODF
     4QSJOHFS  QQ Ù EPJ=@
<> . ,VS[ 8 4DINJEU " 'MFJTDINBOO . -FEFSFS -FWFSBHJOH $../ GPS "$. FYBNJOJOH
     UIF BQQMJDBCJMJUZ PG B OFX 0.( TUBOEBSE GPS BEBQUJWF DBTF NBOBHFNFOU JO + &IMFST
     # 5IBMIFJN &ET 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF UI *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF PO 4VCKFDU0SJFOUFE
     #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU 4#1. 0/&  "$.  QQ Ù EPJ
     
<> . )FXFMU . 8FTLF " IZCSJE BQQSPBDI GPS :FYJCMF DBTF NPEFMJOH BOE FYFDVUJPO JO
     . - 3PTB 1 -PPT 0 1BTUPS &ET #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU 'PSVN  #1. 'PSVN
      WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO #VTJOFTT *OGPSNBUJPO 1SPDFTTJOH 4QSJOHFS $IBN 
     EPJ=@
<> 4 )BBSNBOO . .POUBMJ . 8FTLF 3F9OJOH DBTF NPEFMT VTJOH DBSEJOBMJUZ DPOTUSBJOUT
     JO . - 3PTB 4 8 4BEJR & 5FOJFOUF &ET "EWBODFE *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT &OHJOFFSJOH
      SE *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF $"J4&  WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS
     4DJFODF 4QSJOHFS $IBN  QQ Ù EPJ=@



                                                                                             9j
MDQ a2B/2H, hQr`/ JQ/2H@/`Bp2M SHMMBM; amTTQ`i 7Q` *QMbi`m+iBQM S`Q+2bb2b


<> 4 )BBSNBOO " 4FJEFM . 8FTLF .PEFMJOH PCKFDUJWFT PG LOPXMFEHF XPSLFST JO " .BS
     SFMMB # 8FCFS &ET #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU 8PSLTIPQT  #1.  *OUFSOBUJPOBM
     8PSLTIPQT 3FWJTFE 4FMFDUFE 1BQFST WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO #VTJOFTT *OGPSNBUJPO
     1SPDFTTJOH 4QSJOHFS  QQ Ù 63- IUUQTEPJPSH@
     EPJ=@
<> " 4FJEFM 4 )BBSNBOO . 8FTLF .PEFMCBTFE EFDJTJPO TVQQPSU GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF
     QSPDFTTFT +PVSOBM PG *OUFMMJHFOU *OGPSNBUJPO 4ZTUFNT  Ù
<> " .BSSFMMB . .FDFMMB 4 4BSEJ±B 1 5VDDFSJ 4NBSU1. "VUPNBUFE BEBQUBUJPO PG
     EZOBNJD QSPDFTTFT JO ' 5PVNBOJ # 1FSOJDJ % (SJHPSJ % #FOTMJNBOF + .FOEMJOH
     / # )BEK"MPVBOF . # #MBLF 0 1FSSJO * 4BMFI 4 #IJSJ &ET 4FSWJDF0SJFOUFE
     $PNQVUJOH  *$40$  8PSLTIPQT  8&40" 4F.B14 3.40$ ,"4" *4$ '03
     .07&4 $$4" BOE 4BUFMMJUF &WFOUT 1BSJT 'SBODF /PWFNCFS   3FWJTFE 4FMFDUFE
     1BQFST WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS 4DJFODF 4QSJOHFS $IBN  QQ
     Ù EPJ=@
<> % 4QSPWJFSJ 4 7PHMFS 3VOUJNF DPNQPTJUJPO PG QBSUMZ TUSVDUVSFE CVTJOFTT QSPDFTTFT VTJOH
     IFVSJTUJD QMBOOJOH JO *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF PO &OUFSQSJTF 4ZTUFNT &4  #BTFM
     4XJU[FSMBOE 0DUPCFS   *&&& /FX :PSL  QQ Ù EPJ&4
     
<> . 5 8ZOO . %VNBT $ + 'JEHF " ) . UFS )PGTUFEF 8 . 1 WBO EFS "BMTU #VTJOFTT
     QSPDFTT TJNVMBUJPO GPS PQFSBUJPOBM EFDJTJPO TVQQPSU JO " ) . UFS )PGTUFEF # #FOB
     UBMMBI ) 1BJL &ET #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU 8PSLTIPQT #1.  *OUFSOBUJPOBM
     8PSLTIPQT #1* #1% $#1 1SP)FBMUI 3FG.PE TFNBOUJDTXT #SJTCBOF "VTUSBMJB 4FQUFN
     CFS   3FWJTFE 4FMFDUFE 1BQFST WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS 4DJFODF
     4QSJOHFS #FSMJO )FJEFMCFSH  QQ Ù EPJ=@
<> " 3P[JOBU . 5 8ZOO 8 . 1 WBO EFS "BMTU " ) . UFS )PGTUFEF $ + 'JEHF 8PSL:PX
     TJNVMBUJPO GPS PQFSBUJPOBM EFDJTJPO TVQQPSU %BUB ,OPXM &OH   Ù EPJ
     KEBUBL
<> * 5FJOFNBB . %VNBT . - 3PTB ' . .BHHJ 0VUDPNFPSJFOUFE QSFEJDUJWF QSPDFTT
     NPOJUPSJOH 3FWJFX BOE CFODINBSL "$. 5SBOT ,OPXM %JTDPW %BUB   Ù
     EPJ
<> $ % 'SBODFTDPNBSJOP $ (IJEJOJ ' . .BHHJ ' .JMBOJ 1SFEJDUJWF QSPDFTT NPOJUPSJOH
     NFUIPET 8IJDI POF TVJUT NF CFTU JO . 8FTLF . .POUBMJ * 8FCFS + WPN #SPDLF &ET
     #VTJOFTT 1SPDFTT .BOBHFNFOU  UI *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POGFSFODF #1.  4ZEOFZ /48
     "VTUSBMJB 4FQUFNCFS   1SPDFFEJOHT WPMVNF  PG -FDUVSF /PUFT JO $PNQVUFS
     4DJFODF 4QSJOHFS $IBN  QQ Ù EPJ=@
<> " 4FJEFM 4 )BBSNBOO %FDJTJPO TVQQPSU GPS LOPXMFEHFJOUFOTJWF QSPDFTTFT JO + .BOOFS
     % -¼CLF 4 )BBSNBOO 4 ,PMC / )FS[CFSH 0 ,PQQ &ET 1SPDFFEJOHT PG UIF UI
     $FOUSBM &VSPQFBO 8PSLTIPQ PO 4FSWJDFT BOE UIFJS $PNQPTJUJPO ;&64  #BNCFSH
     (FSNBOZ 'FCSVBSZ   WPMVNF  PG $&63 8PSLTIPQ 1SPDFFEJOHT $&6384PSH
      QQ Ù 63- IUUQDFVSXTPSH7PMQBQFSQEG
<> 4 )BBSNBOO 8*$,3 " +PJOU 4FNBOUJDT GPS 'MFYJCMF 1SPDFTTFT BOE %BUB 1I% UIFTJT
     6OJWFSTJU¤U 1PUTEBN 




                                                                                          99