=Paper=
{{Paper
|id=Vol-3426/paper36
|storemode=property
|title=Influencing Factors Analysis on European and World Regional Economies Development Caused by War in Ukraine Based on Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Theory
|pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3426/paper36.pdf
|volume=Vol-3426
|authors=Victoria Vysotska,Myroslava Bublyk,Yurii Matseliukh,Maryna Shevchenko,Valentyna Panasyuk,Dmytro Karpyn
|dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/momlet/VysotskaBMSPK23
}}
==Influencing Factors Analysis on European and World Regional Economies Development Caused by War in Ukraine Based on Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Theory==
https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3426/paper36.pdf
Influencing Factors Analysis on European and World Regional
Economies Development Caused by War in Ukraine Based on
Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Theory
Victoria Vysotska 1,2, Myroslava Bublyk 1, Yurii Matseliukh 1, Maryna Shevchenko2,3,
Valentyna Panasyuk4 and Dmytro Karpyn5
1
Lviv Polytechnic National University, S. Bandera Street, 12, Lviv, 79013, Ukraine
2
Osnabrück University, Friedrich-Janssen-Str. 1, Osnabrück, 49076, Germany
3
National Technical University “Kharkiv Polytechnic Institute”, Kyrpychova str., 2, Kharkiv, 61000, Ukraine
4
West Ukrainian National University, Lvivska Street, 11, Ternopil, 46004, Ukraine
5
Ivan Franko Drohobych State Pedagogical University, I. Franko Street, 24, Drohobych, 82100, Ukraine
Abstract
The paper examines the level of unfavorable factors influencing the indicators of the
development of the economies of Europe and the world, which were caused by the war in
Ukraine. Taking into account the consequences of the war in Ukraine were considered from
various points of view: economic, social, political, environmental, etc. The catastrophic
consequences of the war in Ukraine negatively affected and continue to affect the development
of European economies. The paper found that the rate of economic growth is rapidly
decreasing, especially in Eastern European countries. The studied forecasts indicate a high
probability of signs of recession in the countries of Eastern Europe. Under the influence of the
war in Ukraine, the article identifies the signs of a migration crisis and a rapid increase in prices
for necessities. Among the adverse impact criteria, which are recommended to be taken into
account by the governments of the countries in the process of making management decisions,
the volatility of prices for wheat, gold and gas, as well as fluctuations in the exchange rates of
the dollar and the yen to the euro, are highlighted. It is recommended to consider the amount
of 400 billion US dollars given in the report of the World Bank as a tenfold underestimated
value when assessing the scale of damage caused to the economy of Ukraine. It is substantiated
that the computational methods (cluster analysis, correlation analysis, etc.) used in the work
are sufficient for determining the level of adverse effects of the factors of the war in Ukraine
on the indicators of the development of the economies of the countries of Europe and the world.
Keywords 1
Multi-criteria decision-making, MCDM, economic crisis, economic indicators, economic risks,
cluster analysis, correlation analysis, GDP, migration, dollar, euro, the hryvnia, gold, Japanese
yen, wheat
1. Introduction
Any large-scale event in the economic and political space, especially war, clearly has a significant
negative impact on the development of the regional economy. The war collapsed not only the economy
of Ukraine but also created challenges for the economies of other countries, especially on the territory
of Europe. At the same time, Eastern European countries feel the burden of war more than other
countries. Russia's war against Ukraine caused large-scale damage to the Ukrainian economy. In a new
MoMLeT+DS 2023: 5th International Workshop on Modern Machine Learning Technologies and Data Science, June 3, 2023, Lviv, Ukraine
EMAIL: victoria.a.vysotska@lpnu.ua (V. Vysotska); my.bublyk@gmail.com (M. Bublyk); indeed.post@gmail.com (Y. Matseliukh);
mshevchenko@uni-osnabrueck.de (M. Shevchenko); v.panasiuk@tneu.edu.ua (V. Panasyuk); dmytro.karpyn@gmai.com (D. Karpyn)
ORCID: 0000-0001-6417-3689 (V. Vysotska); 0000-0003-2403-0784 (M. Bublyk); 0000-0002-1721-7703 (Y. Matseliukh); 0000-0003-2165-
9907 (M. Shevchenko); 0000-0002-5133-6431 (V. Panasyuk); 0000-0002-0476-3406(D. Karpyn)
©️ 2023 Copyright for this paper by its authors.
Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).
CEUR Workshop Proceedings (CEUR-WS.org)
World Bank report, their total amount is estimated at 400 billion US dollars. Also, the Russian invasion
of Ukraine slows down the pace of economic recovery after the pandemic in the transition economies
of Europe and Central Asia. The pace of economic growth is rapidly falling, and according to forecasts,
a recession is possible in some countries of Eastern Europe. European countries, especially Eastern
European countries, suffer the most [1]. But what exactly are the factors, trends and indicators that
significantly change and affect other indicators - this is the goal of our research. Of course, there are
basic indicators, such as the migration of the people (refugees from Ukraine after the start of the full-
scale invasion of Russia [2]), inflation for goods and services, a jump in the exchange rate, etc. The
pace of economic growth is rapidly falling, and according to forecasts, a recession is possible in some
countries of Eastern Europe [1-6]. The war in Ukraine has had a significant negative impact on the
world economy. The world economy is increasingly weakened by the war due to significant
interruptions in trade and a jump in food and fuel prices [3]. Activity in the Eurozone, the largest
economic partner of transition and developing countries in the Europe and Central Asia region, suffered
a significant decline in the second half of 2022, due to disrupted supply chains, increased stress in
financial markets and declining levels of consumer and business confidence [7-14]. However, the most
devastating consequences of the invasion are rapidly increasing energy prices due to a significant
reduction in Russian energy supplies. The reduction in growth forecasts for 2023 extends to all countries
in the Europe and Central Asia region, as uncertainty significantly affects forecasts. Continuation of the
war or its escalation could lead to much greater economic and environmental damage [15, 16], and a
greater likelihood of fragmentation of international trade and investment. The risk of financial stress
also remains high, given high levels of debt and inflation.
The purpose of the work is to conduct a study of the level of unfavorable factors influencing the
development indicators of the economies of Europe and the world, which were caused by the war in
Ukraine, as well as to determine the priority of the selection of criteria for the adoption of managerial
decisions by the governments of countries based on the theory of multi-criteria decision-making
(MCDM). Tasks:
1. Classify the consequences of the war in Ukraine by groups of factors of influence: economic,
social, political, environmental, etc.
2. To establish the factors that negatively influenced and continue to influence the development
of the economies of European countries, with the aim of their further use in decision-making in the
MCDM theory.
3. To study the signs of recession in the countries of Eastern Europe and to determine their level:
to recommend a range of key destructive factors caused by the war in Ukraine, which should
be taken into account by the governments of countries in the process of making management
decisions.
justify the need for a deeper assessment by the World Bank of the scale of damage caused to
the economy of Ukraine due to Russia's aggression.
to conduct a cluster analysis and correlational analysis of indicators of the development of the
economies of European and world countries and their changes under the influence of the war.
2. Related works
Most believe that on February 24, 2023, one year will pass since the beginning of the full-scale war
that Russia unleashed against Ukraine. But in fact, the war began in 2014. Since then, Ukraine has been
successfully developing its economy independently and defending itself. Although since 2014, as a
result of the Russian invasion, Ukrainian cities and villages in the east of the country have been
destroyed, and thousands of our military and civilian compatriots have died. Of course, since 2022,
Russia's special operation has acquired a larger and more brutal character with tens of thousands of our
military and civilian compatriots killed, mass migration both within the country and beyond its borders.
And it has become even more difficult for the country to independently support and develop its
economy. Hundreds of infrastructure facilities and enterprises, thousands of medium and small
businesses were destroyed, and millions of Ukrainians were forced to seek refuge either in safer regions
of the country or abroad. As of September 2022, the UN recorded 7 million Ukrainians in Europe [2].
Of them, 4 million applied for temporary shelter. Currently, according to forecasts, Ukraine's economy
will shrink by 35% this year, as economic activity has suffered significant damage due to the pollution
of agricultural land, the destruction of production facilities, and the reduction of the workforce, as more
than 14 million people have become displaced persons [3].
But this war hit not only Ukraine, its negativity is felt in all corners of the world. The global economy
has not yet had time to recover from the devastating impact of Covid-19, as Russian aggression once
again drags the world economy into the grip of an economic crisis. Global economic growth after
accelerating in 2021 (6%) began to slow down rapidly (3.2%) [1]. This is the lowest rate in the previous
20 years, excluding the crises of 2008 and 2020. In 2023, a minimum growth rate of 0.3% is expected,
as the jump in energy prices will continue to affect the future, and the volume of production will
decrease by 0.2% [3]. The hybrid energy war of Russia against Europe has pushed energy prices high,
and the destruction of the food industry and agricultural sector in Ukraine and the blockade of Ukrainian
exports are one of the main criteria for the increase in food prices in the world.
According to the results of a recent assessment of the World Bank, the needs for recovery and
reconstruction (social, productive sectors and infrastructure) require about 400 billion US dollars [4].
This figure is 1.5 times higher than the size of the pre-war economy of Ukraine.
Russia's war in Ukraine slowed down world economic development and almost doubled the growth
of world prices. In 2022, global inflation reached 9% compared to 5% in 2021 [1]. And some poor
countries, which are dependent on food prices and grain imports, found themselves on the brink of
starvation. GDP is forecast to grow by 1.9% in 2023 against 2.7% in 2022, as the world is struggling
with many economic and political problems [5]. Weaker growth could lead to a modest slowdown in
inflation to 4.7% in 2023 after averaging 7.6% in 2022. The countries of Central and Eastern Europe
suffered a significant shock from the full-scale war in Ukraine. Due to their economic interconnections
and geographical proximity to Ukraine, the countries of Central and Eastern Europe are particularly at
risk when it comes to separating the Russian economy from the West. It is expected that the negative
consequences of the war in Ukraine, as well as the sanctions imposed on the Russian Federation and
Belarus, against the background of the unfolding energy challenges, will drag on well into 2023 and
threaten the economic indicators and growth of the region. Therefore, we should expect at least a
technical recession in some countries of Central and Eastern Europe [5-6]. A sharp rise in the prices of
key commodities such as energy and metals could seriously undermine the region's economy. This will
particularly affect energy importers such as Georgia, Ukraine, Turkey, Slovakia, Hungary and Serbia.
In addition, 90% of wheat imports to Turkey and Georgia are accounted for by Russia and Ukraine.
However, prices are expected to remain volatile and continue to rise, fueling inflation and putting
further pressure on public finances and the budget balance.
The theory of multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) is very often used to solve complex socio-
economic issues [17-29]. In the conditions of war, it is difficult to determine the number of criteria, and
the order of preference when evaluating and choosing the best option among many alternatives of
management decisions, which the leaders of the countries aim to implement to obtain the desired result
- sustainable development of the economy, balanced social development of communities, etc. [29-36].
When conducting a multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA), one should analyze those factors that in
this situation have the greatest (critical) influence on the choice of the optimal value [37-41]. In
everyday life, which is studied by the social sciences, there are still few successful practices of applying
the MCDM theory [42-44]. There is even less experience in using this decision-making tool in wartime
[45-48]. Therefore, the theory of multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) needs to be studied and
researched in the real conditions of the war in Ukraine [49-55].
The authors of the works [32-33] believe that the analysis of influence criteria should be completed
with a conclusion about whether the criterion is favorable or unfavorable when choosing the MCDM
theory. When analyzing influencing factors, it is advisable [32] to compare a group of homogeneous
influencing factors to choose the criterion that, in combination with the already selected criteria, will
provide the opportunity to obtain the maximum result with the least losses. Researchers [33] worked on
the study of different ways of choosing a management decision from all other possible decision-making
options and proposed a method of choosing an option with minimal compromise and maximum
benefits. This greatly simplified the decision-making process for the decision-making manager. Many
scientists [32, 33] believe that the criteria used in the analysis of these criteria can be both qualitative
and quantitative. There are two groups of MCDM methods for determining the weight of each
alternative [31, 32]. One of them is called the compensatory decision-making method. This method
allows evaluating the criteria from both weak and strong sides, taking into account the advantages of
the strengths of the criteria to compensate for their weaknesses. This method is sometimes called a
compensatory decision-making tool. It includes the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) technology,
which is especially valuable when studying environments that are extremely difficult to study [32]. This
tool is used to compare qualitative criteria or criteria that are difficult to describe with quantitative
values [49-57]. Another method is called anticipatory decision-making [32]. This method is used when
comparing pairs of criteria. Here, in each pair of criteria, it is established which criterion is more
important than the other [58-69]. The anticipatory decision-making method includes [32] tools of
elimination and selection. Because of this, it is called ELECTRE, indicating that it expresses reality.
This method is also used to select, rank and sort alternatives to solve a problem when making managerial
decisions [70-99].
3. Materials and methods
Among the methods used in the work, it is possible to single out the methods of descriptive statistics
(for the distribution of temporarily displaced persons), the trend method of forecasting (for researching
the dynamics of food prices), data visualization in the Cartesian and polar coordinate systems,
correlation and regression analysis were also used, carried out cluster analysis. In the work, the results
of the analysis of factors influencing the development of economies are visualized using histograms,
correlograms and dendrograms. So, to study the negative economic impact of the war in Ukraine, we
analyzed several indicators, including the following:
1. Refugee distribution from Ukraine after the beginning of the full-scale invasion of russia (Fig. 1) [7].
Figure 1: Descriptive statistics
2. Dynamics of growth/decrease in prices for food products in the world (in particular, for wheat)
caused by the Russian-Ukrainian war in 2022 (Fig. 2) [8].
Figure 2: Plotting in the Cartesian coordinate system (dynamics of changing price of wheat, where X
is the day from 2000 to 2022 and Y is the price of wheat in EUR)
3. Dynamics of the inflation rate in Europe (Fig. 3) [32].
Figure 3: Graph of inflation in Europe Figure 4: Changes indicator in prices for eggs
4. Dynamics of the indicator of changes in egg prices in Ukraine (Fig. 4) [32]
5. Dynamics of the euro exchange rate and its changes during conversion to the following currencies:
Euro to USD and Euro to Japanese yen (Fig. 5) [9].
Figure 5: Dynamics of the indicator in the Cartesian coordinate system (Euro to USD and to Japanese
yen), where X is the date and Y is a high price
6. Correlation of the price of gold during the period from January 1, 2000, to September 1, 2022.
(Fig. 6) [10]
7. Correlation of the price of the hryvnia against the dollar (Fig. 7-10) [11-12]
Figure 6: Gold price correlation chart Figure 7: Price correlation against dollar (x – day, y – price)
Figure 8: Graphs of price dynamics dollars for hryvnias (from 2017 to 2023 and the last year)
Figure 9: Graphs of price dynamics euros for hryvnias (from 2017 to 2023 and the last year)
Figure 10: Graphs of price dynamics Japanese yen for hryvnias (from 2017 to 2023 and the last year)
8. Dynamics of changes in the real GDP of Ukraine in % compared to the corresponding quarter of
the previous year (Fig. 11a) [11-12]. If you analyze it in terms of GDP (Fig. 11b) [13], then our economy
looked like this: after the 2008 crisis, GDP decreased significantly, and as soon as everything stabilized,
the next crisis occurred, which is very difficult for a young country to survive, after which the index
again is falling In general, these events were not special and, like any crisis, occurred in four stages.
a) b)
Figure 11: Dynamics of changes in the real GDP of Ukraine in % compared to the corresponding quarter
of the previous year and b) chart of stages of the crisis that affected Ukraine [32]
9. Value of GDP of countries in the polar coordinate system for 2022 (Fig. 14) [14]
Figure 12: Graphic presentation of data on the GDP of countries in the polar coordinate system [14]
What conclusion can be reached after analyzing all these data? The economic situation in the world
directly affects the economy of Ukraine. The war significantly changed not only the economic
indicators of Ukraine but Europe in the first place and the whole world in general. The economy is best
characterized by the GDP indicator, which changed significantly specifically for Ukraine in 2022 and
negatively affected all of Europe, especially Eastern. The devaluation of the Ukrainian hryvnia was
caused by crises that occur in 4 stages: crisis-depression-revival and boom, we can see all these stages
on the graphs and they all affected our pre-war economy. The economy of our country is not stable and
stable, but it can withstand quite destructive crises, but while it is at this level, our currency will
depreciate against the dollar, which explains the reason for the correlation of the price per 100 dollar in
hryvnias.
4. Experiments, results and discussion
4.1. Analysis of statistical data on the distribution of refugees from Ukraine
after the beginning of the full-scale invasion of Russia
Fewest people left in the second part of June. To our surprise, the largest number of people left in
September, because it seemed that at the beginning, many more people left the country.
Results of descriptive statistics:
1) Sample size – 126; 2) Arithmetic average – 4391815.412698412;
3) Mode – 16685; 4) Median – 4398175.0;
5) Scope – 10831846; 6) Standard deviation – 2523521.006447698;
7) Coefficient of variation – 57.45963273299777; 8) Dispersion – 6368158269982.803;
9) Excess – -0.284366254699147; 10) Asymmetry – 0.34268464108388286;
11) Minimum – 16654; 12) Maximum – 10848500;
13) Amount – 553368741; 14) Standard error – 224813.11939176763.
Since the capacity of the checkpoints is limited, in the beginning, due to the great panic and the large
influx of refugees, fewer people could cross the border. There were long delays and you could stand in
line for several days at the border. Therefore, in fact, in the first days of a full-scale invasion, most
people waited at the borders but did not cross them. There were days when the borders were closed
altogether, to speed up the delivery of humanitarian aid and weapons. On the graph, this can be seen
from the points that are at the very bottom; the upper points grow steadily, but from time to time a
"trough" is formed. These are the days when the borders were closed. Later, when everything stabilized,
the flow of people slept and the panic subsided, more and more people crossed the border in one day.
This is confirmed by the schedule, which is growing (not including the days when the borders were
closed). The histogram displays the frequency of the number of people from the sample falling into a
certain interval, that is, we can see which interval the most people fall into. In our case, it can be seen
that most people fell into the third interval. So, from the beginning of the full-scale invasion, most often
in one day from 3111466 to 4658872 people crossed the border.
Figure 13: Histogram
Having constructed a correlation field, we see that the number of people who left increases sharply
at first (up to approximately the 22nd day of the war), then a little more smoothly (up to the 195th day
of the war).
It can also be seen on the correlation field that at first the points are clustered, and the further they
are, the more scattered they are. In our opinion, this is because, in the first few months of the full-scale
invasion, the borders were closed less frequently to allow those who were standing at the border to
leave, and not to create an even larger crowd. Later, when the number of people decreased, it became
possible to close them for the transportation of humanitarian goods, weapons, and inspections.
On the days when some negative events took place and the following few days, the number of people
who left increased sharply. For example, on March 26 (the 30th day of the war), Russian troops
launched a rocket attack on an oil depot in the Veliki Kryvytsi area (Lviv region), a total of 3 explosions
were recorded, and 5 people were injured. After that, you can see on the correlation field a jump in the
number of people who left. That is, there is a certain dependence between events and the mood of the
population because even if you take only one region of Ukraine, there are fluctuations on the graph.
If we look at the 6 points below on the correlation field, we see that this is the month of June. Then
there was almost no shelling and, accordingly, the number of people who left was very small.
Figure 14: Correlation field of the number of refugees (y) before the day of the war (x)
The correlation coefficient ranges from -1 to 1. In our case, it is close to 1, so our dependence is
close to a straight line. The correlation coefficient is 0.675287478.
Figure 15: Correlogram
The procedure that constitutes the essence of hierarchical classification consists of the fact that the
first cluster is formed in the proximity matrix of two objects, the values of which are listed following
the selected strategy. The second object with a larger number of columns and tape is thrown out, and
instead of the first object (with a smaller number of columns and tape) a cluster formed from these
objects with the listed values is inserted. As a result, the dimension of the matrix is reduced by one.
When the proximity matrix has a dimension of 2×2, the clustering procedure is stopped. Based on the
information obtained at each step about the association of clusters and the minimum distance values
found, a dendrogram is constructed and its interpretation is provided.
With the help of cluster analysis, objects were divided not by one parameter, but by a whole set of
characteristics, namely by the number of people who left for each country and the distance to it.
Moreover, the influence of each of the parameters is rather strengthened or weakened by entering the
corresponding coefficients into the mathematical formulas.
Figure 16: The association of clusters with the minimum distance values and the cluster merging
procedure (column 1 - number, 2 - union, 3 - node, 4 - metrics)
Figure 17: Dendrogram
Since cluster analysis, unlike most mathematical and statistical methods, does not impose any
restrictions on the type of objects under consideration, we were able to examine a set of raw data of an
almost arbitrary nature. Also, with its help, we considered a rather large amount of information and
shortened, compressed a larger mass of information, and made it compact and clear. Thanks to the
features of clustering, we were able to determine with the help of our algorithm the number of clusters
into which the data should be divided, as well as to highlight the characteristics of these clusters.
After analyzing the node-metric union, we can see that two graphical and one manual solution
coincide. The main result of hierarchical clustering is a dendrogram, which shows the hierarchical
dependence between clusters. After constructing it, you can conclude the distance between clusters, the
higher the column, the greater the distance between clusters (clustering is performed in the form of
nested groups). As a result of clustering and dendrogram construction, we concluded that the closer the
clusters are to each other, the closer they are geographically to Ukraine. Accordingly, these clusters
bear a greater socio-economic burden in terms of receiving refugees from Ukraine.
4.2. Analysis of the dynamics of the increase/decrease in the prices of food
products in the world (in particular, for wheat), caused by the Russian-
Ukrainian war
The main questions of the work are: "To what extent do important political events (wars, crises)
have a strong influence on the world market?" and "How exactly do prices for certain materials
change?". First of all, we can put forward the following hypothesis: any major event in a country that
affects the total output of products for export causes an increase in the price of the product that this
country supplies. Revolutions and wars, economic crises and a change in the political vector - all this
has a direct impact on the general picture of the global economic trade space.
Consider a specific example: the war in Ukraine and the trade crisis in Europe. Ukraine ranks first
in the export of sunflower oil abroad and is one of the key exporters of wheat and grain crops in general.
She consumes only a quarter of the grain crops she grows. The rest is exported. Europe is directly
dependent on these imported products. Russia's blockade of Ukrainian Black Sea ports led to a global
food crisis and provoked global food inflation (as of August – 6% (inflation index)). So, these are our
guesses. The next step will be proof and direct analysis of the question. These graphs illustrate the
correspondence between wheat price jumps and similar changes in inflation rates around the world. So,
it can be concluded that there is a relationship between the inflation rate and the cost of a certain type
of product that is produced for export. This is confirmed not only by the year 2022 and the Russian-
Ukrainian war. Almost all of the most famous crises or economic events can be traced on an inflation
graph. Fig. 18 demonstrates the year 2008 (an extraordinary jump in inflation), which corresponds to
the crisis in America (loan crisis), which caused the economic crisis of the whole of Europe and beyond.
A similar jump can be observed in Fig. 18 corresponds to the period of the European debt crisis. We
can observe the relevant economic consequences of this event on 2 unknown graphs. This supports our
thesis that the restriction of wheat available for purchase could indeed have caused the crisis in Europe.
Data for graphical representation: the ratio of wheat and gas prices.
a b
Figure 18: Graph in the polar coordinate system: a) wheat and gas and b) wheat and gold
Above, 2 variants of dependence of two quantities were given. It can be seen that the relationship
"wheat - gas" is represented by an almost straight line, while "wheat - gold" has a non-linear
representation. There is a logical and simple explanation for this. Since the prices of commodities, such
as wheat and gas, directly depend on crises (to be more precise, the stronger the crisis, the higher the
price of the resource), the relationship between them is almost linear. If we consider the wheat-gold
situation, it should be noted that during the crisis, gold prices do not rise, but on the contrary, valuable
materials become one of the most stable assets of the economy. So, since wheat and gold have different
distributions of value concerning time, they will not have relationships (straight, linear) on the graph
given above.
Figure 19: Descriptive data statistics
The following conclusions can be drawn from the above table (Fig. 20): the most expensive metals
are nickel, zinc, aluminium and gold. The largest is the range of such products as wheat (233-1435) and
nickel (4350-54750), as well as aluminium and oil. Gas and nickel have the steepest increases in the
distribution curve (kurtosis).
Figure 20: a) The result of constructing a histogram of the price of wheat during the war (x is grouping
intervals and y is the frequency of values; b) The correlogram of the autocorrelation function
As you can see, according to the histogram, wheat prices rose sharply after a certain period after the
start of the war (not immediately). The price increased about 5 times, then decreased by two-thirds and
then increased again. Such "jumps" can be caused by different situations on the front line. The price
rose after the territories responsible for a large part of the supply was seized, the blockade of the Black
Sea ports in the spring. All this caused a sharp rise in the price of wheat in Europe. After the
establishment of the grain corridor, the situation improved, but it remains unstable.
Looking at the time series graph, we can conclude that the data has a downward trend. Therefore, it
is possible to assume the non-stationarity of the original time series.
To more accurately determine the stationarity of the series, the correlogram of the autocorrelation
function is analyzed. In the case of a stationary time series, a rapid decline with increasing t will be
depicted already after the first few values. The constructed correlogram demonstrates that the studied
series is not stationary, but contains a trend component. For cluster analysis: the set G, which includes
𝑚 objects, each of which is characterized 𝑛 by features.
Figure 21: Table " operator - indicator " - objects indicators values according to descriptive statistics
Figure 22: The result of the software construction of the table "union - node - metric
Interpretation of the result of cluster analysis
At level 0.1, 6 clusters are formed: 1 cluster – object NICKEL; 2nd cluster – objects WHEAT,
HRW.WHEAT; 3rd cluster – object SOYBEAN.OIL; 4th cluster – objects SUGAR, GASOLINE;
5th cluster – NATURAL.GAS, COTTON objects; 6th cluster - objects SOYBEANS, CORN.
At level 0.2, 4 clusters are formed: 1 cluster – NICKEL object; 2nd cluster – objects WHEAT,
HRW.WHEAT, SOYBEAN.OIL, SUGAR, GASOLINE; 3rd cluster – NATURAL.GAS, COTTON
objects; 4 cluster - objects SOYBEANS, CORN.
At level 0.3, 3 clusters are formed: 1 cluster – object NICKEL; 2nd cluster – objects WHEAT,
HRW.WHEAT, SOYBEAN.OIL, SUGAR, GASOLINE; Cluster 3 – objects NATURAL.GAS,
COTTON, SOYBEANS, CORN.
a) b)
Figure 23: Cluster dendrogram for Prices of a) formed clusters and b) display of clusters at level 0.1
a) b)
Figure 24: Dendrogram of presentation of clusters at the level of a) 0.2 and b) 0.3
a) b)
Figure 25: a) Dendrogram of clusters at three levels simultaneously (0.1, 0.2, 0.3) and b) the result of
the software implementation of the interpretation of the cluster analysis result
As a result of the cluster analysis, we obtained a division of the types of products of the world
economy according to their average value. Conclusions: the most expensive product is nickel; the
cheapest product is wheat; the price for sugar, petrol, gas and cotton is at the same level.
4.3. Analysis of changes in the euro currency, namely currency conversion:
Euro to USD and Euro to Japanese yen
The Dataset about European Currency includes changes in the euro currency, namely the conversion
of currencies: Euro to USD and Euro to Japanese yen. Why such a topic? The dollar and the euro are
the two largest reserve currencies in the world, which compete with each other. The Europeans cannot
raise the interest rate and restore the confidence of investors, because this will slow down the economy
and it will lose its main incentive - cheap loans. The relevance of the topic: Russia's attack on Ukraine
only increased the inflationary trend in the world, creating a shortage of energy and food, which pushed
prices even higher.
a) b)
Figure 26: Graphic representation of the dynamics of a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
Results of descriptive statistics for Euro to USD:
1) Sample size – 250; 2) Arithmetic average – 1.10138;
3) Mode – 1.137; 4) Median – 1.1131;
5) Scope – 0.1833; 6) Standard deviation – 0.05031769;
7) Coefficient of variation – 4.56860389; 8) Dispersion – 0.00253187;
9) Excess – -1.093598375; 10) Asymmetry – -0.37715017;
11) Minimum – 1; 12) Maximum – 1.1833;
13) Amount – 275.345; 14) Standard error – 0.00318237;
15) Interval – 0.1833; 16) Reliability level (95%) – 0.006267795.
Results of descriptive statistics for Euro to Japanese yen:
1) Sample size – 250; 2) Arithmetic average – 132.92628;
3) Mode – 128.54; 4) Median – 131.75;
5) Scope – 18.47; 6) Standard deviation – 4.337306014;
7) Coefficient of variation – 3.262940943; 8) Dispersion – 18.81222346;
9) Excess – -0.926684877; 10) Asymmetry – 0.397360339;
11) Minimum – 124.38; 12) Maximum – 142.85;
13) Amount – 33231.57; 14) Standard error – 0.274315318;
15) Interval – 18.47; 16) Reliability level (95%) – 0.540274133.
So, the graph in the Cartesian system reflects the relationship between two values (the highest price
of the session and the date). The graph shows the dynamics of the rise or fall of the euro against the US
dollar over a certain period, namely over the last year. Since May, the US dollar has strengthened against
other currencies at a record pace. If a stronger dollar has two-fold implications for the United States
economy, it is almost certainly bad news for the rest of the world. The Europeans cannot raise the
interest rate and restore the confidence of investors, because this will slow down the economy and it
will lose its main incentive - cheap loans. The European financial system does not have the margin of
safety for such manoeuvres and cannot afford a sharp increase in rates due to the energy crisis. Another
reason for switching from the euro to the dollar is uncertainty in the EU economy. The US is a self-
sufficient economy with a strong labour market and a determined central bank. The country can provide
itself with food, energy and stable debt payments, even if it is hit by a recession. The European Union
cannot boast of this. The bloc's economic prospects are unclear due to the gas crisis and the war in
Ukraine. In August, for the first time in 20 years, the euro became cheaper than the dollar. Now the rate
fluctuates at the level of 1 to 1. Looking at the graph of the relationship between two values (the highest
price of the session and the date) in the polar system, you can draw similar conclusions as for the
Cartesian system. In June, the euro fell sharply in value, and in mid-July it equalled the dollar. The euro
fell 0.7 per cent to $0.9884, its lowest level since December 2002.
The graph also shows the dynamics of growth or decline of the euro against the Japanese yen over
a certain period, namely over the last year. The expected widening of the gap between key rates between
Japan and the US further reduced the value of the currency. It fell 0.5% to a low of 138.10 per dollar in
morning trading, a level not seen since September 1998. The yen hit multiple lows in recent weeks as
traders abandoned it in pursuit of higher interest rates in the United States, where the Federal Reserve
is expected to act more aggressively this year to combat soaring inflation. The Bank of Japan followed
a soft monetary policy and warned only against "excessive fluctuations" in the price of the yen. Inflation
in Japan reached 2.5% in June, above the bank's range. In particular, the Japanese government did not
rely on the "invisible hand of the market", but actively developed and directed all economic processes
at the macro level. He not only determined what the Japanese economy should do, but also contributed
to the accumulation of production resources - financial, labor, and material - in the relevant areas.
However, at the same time, the enterprises retained a private form of ownership, and the government
did not interfere in their operational activities, which left enough space for the operation of market
mechanisms. Looking at the graph of the relationship between the two values of the polar system, you
can draw similar conclusions as for the Cartesian system. Japan, like Ukraine, due to the shortage of
natural resources cannot independently provide itself with everything it needs. This situation forces
Japan to have a large export sector. Because only at the expense of selling products and services for
export, the country can buy abroad what it lacks. For Japanese exports to be strong and competitive, in
this country considerable attention is paid to structural policy, that is, to the formation of such a structure
of the economy under which the use of available resources (labor, natural, material) would give the
country the greatest effect. In other words, the Japanese government strictly monitors that enterprises
(at least at the level of large business) produce, not what anyone wants, but what can find a constant
and solvent demand in the foreign market. The next step is to create a bar chart that displays the
frequency data. A histogram helps to illustrate the relationship of individual elements to each other and
their change over time. Quantitative ratios of the highest price indicator of the session are presented in
the form of rectangles that reflect the distribution of numerical data at certain time intervals. Intervals
are plotted on the abscissa axis, and frequencies are plotted on the ordinate axis. It can be concluded
that the interval from 1.122 to 1.143 had the most values.
a) b)
Figure 27: Histogram of a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
Comparing the constructed graphs of the cumulate based on the data from the histogram and the
cumulate based on the integral indicator, you can see that they are quite similar, which in turn is an
indicator of the correctness of the histogram construction. The difference between these two cumulates
is that the cumulate constructed according to the histogram data has k approximation nodes and is a
broken curve, and the cumulate constructed according to the integral percentage has n −1 approximation
nodes and is smoother.
a) b)
Figure 28: Cumulative are built according to the histogram data of a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to
Japanese yen
a) b)
Figure 29: Cumulative are built according to the integral interest of a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to
Japanese yen
In the correlation analysis, we used another sample of 250 items. The following statistics were
selected: high price (the highest price of the session), low price (lowest price of the session) for Euro to
USD and the open price of the session (the initial price of the session), end price of the session (final
price of the session) for Euro to Japan yen.
a) b)
Figure 30: A sample of 250 items for data correlation
In Fig. 31 you can see the result of constructing the correlation field. Points are located from the
bottom to the right. This means that the relationship between the values is direct. The points of the
correlation field are also located very close to each other, so it can be concluded that the connection
between the features is strong.
a) b)
Figure 31: Correlation field a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
A sample correlation coefficient is used to quantify the closeness of the relationship. The sample
correlation coefficient r does not exceed unity in absolute value. It ranges from -1 to 1. In our case, the
correlation coefficient (Euro to USD) is equal to 0.99781499. And the correlation coefficient (Euro to
Japanese yen) is equal to 0.98216595. If the correlation coefficient is 0.66-0.99, then we can conclude
that the relationship is strong. Let's calculate the correlation ratio. First, let's calculate the number of
intervals according to the Sturges formula: k=1+logn=8.85174904 9.
a)
b)
Figure 32: Table of intervals, partial math. expectations and number of sample elements for a) Euro
to USD and b) Euro to Japan yen, where lines 1 – interval, 2 – number of sample elements, 3 –
mathematical expectation, 4 – the product of the previous two lines
For Euro to USD: the mathematical expectation of partial groupings is 232.6924702; group variance
is 11331538.32; variance obtained from the ungrouped response is 11332392.96; correlation relation is
0.999962291. For Euro to Japan yen: the mathematical expectation of partial groupings is 258.4200913;
group variance is 30238.13405; variance obtained from the ungrouped response is 30202.96483;
correlation relation is 1.000582045.
a)
b)
Figure 33: Autocorrelation calculations a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
a) b)
Figure 34: Autocorrelation graph for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
a) b)
Figure 35: Histogram of the autocorrelation function for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
Splitting one of the sequences into three equal parts. The correlation matrix is a square table in which
the correlation coefficient between the corresponding parameters is located at the intersection of the
corresponding row and column.
a) b)
Figure 36: Dividing the sequence into three equal intervals with the corresponding number of sample
elements for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
a) b)
Figure 37: Correlation matrix for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
After analyzing the graphic presentation of the relationship between the two studied sequences, it
can be concluded that they have a strong linear relationship. The placement of points on the graph
indicates the presence and direction of communication.
So, the correlation analysis (Euro to USD) allowed us to find out the interdependencies between
various random variables and to understand that the presented signs (high price (the highest price of the
session) and low price (the lowest price of the session)) have a strong dependence. A change in one or
more of these values leads to a systematic change in another. As the highest price of the session
increases, the lowest price of the session increases, so there is a positive relationship, in other words,
there is a positive relationship between the highest price of the session and the lowest price of the
session. So, in our case, the correlation is positive and positive. This can be seen from the calculated
correlation coefficient, the value of which is almost 1. Thus, if the correlation coefficient is 0.66-0.99,
then we can conclude that the relationship is strong.
Correlation analysis (Euro to Japan yen) allowed us to find out the interdependencies between
various random variables and understand that the presented signs (open price (opening price of the
session) and low price (ending price of the session)) have a strong dependence. A change in one or more
of these values leads to a systematic change in another. As the initial price of the session increases, the
final price of the session increases, so there is a positive relationship, in other words, there is a positive
relationship between the initial price of the session and the final price of the session. So, in our case,
the correlation is positive and positive. This can be seen from the calculated correlation coefficient, the
value of which is almost 1. Thus, if the correlation coefficient is 0.66-0.99, then we can conclude that
the relationship is strong. The correlation coefficient varies from 0 to 1 and is always in absolute value
no less than the Pearson coefficient for the same variables, which is correct in our case. A value of 0
for the correlation coefficient indicates no connection, and a value of 1 indicates a functional
connection. After analyzing our correlation coefficient, we can conclude that we have a functional
relationship between two signs (high price (the highest price of the session) and low price (the lowest
price of the session)). The greater the value of this coefficient, the closer the connection. It also follows
from the difference between the correlation coefficient and the corresponding Pearson correlation
coefficient. The greater the difference, the more non-linear the relationship. In our case, the difference
is insignificant, which indicates the linearity of the relationship. (Pearson coefficient = 0.9978 and
correlation ratio = 0.9999). As a result of the primary processing of data using descriptive statistics
within the parameters defined for this, a table was built, which is called the "object-property" table. So,
for cluster analysis, a set G is submitted, which includes m objects, each of which is characterized by n
features. The data are presented below in Fig. 38(a-b). As shown in Fig. 38(c-d) indicators in size and
dimension are very heterogeneous, which means the impossibility of a reasonable interpretation of the
obtained result of the cluster analysis. Therefore, there is a need to standardize this table. The formation
of the closely located "original table" and "copy table" from them. Standardization is a transition to
some uniform description for all features and the introduction of a new conventional unit of
measurement that allows formal comparison of objects or their features.
a) b) c) d)
Figure 38: The "object-property" table by month (from August to October) for a) Euro to USD and b)
Euro to Japanese yen and Normalized table "object-property" for c) Euro to USD and d) Euro to
Japanese yen, where column 1 - volume, 2 - the lowest price, 3 - the beginning of the session (red line
1 - minimum value, 2 - maximum)
A proximity table was constructed using hierarchical cluster analysis. (Fig. 39). For convenience,
the names of the months have been replaced by serial numbers. Thus, with the help of the nearest
neighbour strategy, we obtained the union of all objects into 1 cluster (Fig. 40).
a)
b)
Figure 39: Proximity table for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen
a) b)
Figure 40: Join-node-metric table for a) Euro to USD and b) Euro to Japanese yen (column 1 - number,
2 - union, 3 - node, 4 metric)
We can conclude that the result of hierarchical cluster analysis is the construction of a dendrogram.
It, in turn, describes the proximity of individual points and clusters to each other and graphically
represents the sequence of merging clusters. In other words, with the help of a dendrogram, you can
depict a nested grouping of objects that changes at different levels of the hierarchy.
Figure 41: The result of constructing a dendrogram (Euro to USD)
Drawing horizontal lines in the plane of the dendrogram (Euro to USD) at a given height, in this
case, allows you to highlight individual clusters. Namely:
At level 1, we have four clusters: 1st cluster – objects 7,9; 2nd cluster – objects 4,5; 3rd cluster
– objects 8,11; 4 cluster - objects 6,7,9.
At level 1.5, we have three clusters that include the following objects: 1st cluster - objects 10,
6, 7, 9; cluster 2 – objects 1, 4, 5; Cluster 3 - objects 2, 3.
At level 2 we have two clusters: 1st cluster - objects 1-5; 2nd cluster - objects 8, 11, 10, 6, 7, 9.
At level 5.5 we have one cluster: 1 cluster - objects 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11.
Drawing horizontal lines in the plane of the dendrogram (Euro to Japan yen) at a given height, in
this case, allows you to highlight individual clusters. Namely:
At level 1, we have four clusters: 1st cluster – objects 6,7; 2nd cluster – objects 4,5; 3rd cluster
– objects 10, 6, 7; 4 cluster - objects 8,11.
At level 1.5, we have three clusters that include the following objects: 1st cluster - objects 10,
6, 7, 9; cluster 2 – objects 1, 4, 5; Cluster 3 - objects 2, 3.
At level 2 we have two clusters: 1st cluster - objects v; 2nd cluster - objects 8, 11, 10, 6, 7, 9.
At level 7 we have one cluster: 1 cluster - objects 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11.
Figure 42: The result of constructing a dendrogram (Euro to Japan yen)
So, with the help of cluster analysis, we were able to reduce the dimensionality of the data by
grouping similar objects into clusters using the nearest-neighbour strategy. Namely, we will form
clusters grouped by months, which at the initial stage were recorded by days. Also, as a result of
constructing the dendrogram, we were able to reveal the hierarchical structure of the input data, that is,
we received data in a more visual structure, which in turn allows us to graphically see which objects
are the most distant from each other, and which are the closest to each other.
4.4. Gold price correlation
According to the data on the correlation of the price of gold during the period from January 1, 2000,
to September 1, 2022. to investigate exactly how changes in the value of gold occurred, to explain why
the value of gold is a very important criterion, as it shows how world events affect the economy in the
world (Fig. 43).
Figure 43: Pie chart and histogram for gold price correlation
Thanks to this visualization, the correlations of gold prices in certain periods are quite clearly visible.
Figure 44: Histograms for gold price correlation
Figure 45: Cumulative and descriptive statistics Figure 46: Gold price correlation chart
Results of descriptive statistics for correlations of gold prices:
1) Sample size – 712; 2) Arithmetic average – 1039.51938202247;
3) Median – 1190.95625; 4) Standard deviation – 518.597396331107;
5) Dispersion – 268943.259481404; 6) Excess – 1.75036169809394;
7) Amount – 740137.8; 8) Asymmetry – -0.0847406208547518;
9) Minimum – 259.175; 10) Maximum – 2020.5125;
11) Standard error – 19.4352591190456.
The main events that took place in the world in the period from 01.01.2000 were analyzed. to
September 1, 2022, when there were significant changes in the schedule. In this way, the following
analysis was obtained (Fig. 46). We see that every significant increase in the price of gold on the
histogram is the result of certain market mechanisms. For example, in 2006 we can see an increase in
the price of gold by more than 250 dollars per ounce of gold (31.1 g) compared to the beginning of
2005. This is caused by such a market mechanism as the devaluation of the national currency.
Currency devaluation is an official decrease in the gold content of a monetary unit or a decrease in
the rate of the national currency to gold, silver, or a certain foreign currency. In modern conditions, the
term is used for situations of a significant decrease in the rate of the national currency relative to "hard"
currencies (usually relative to the US dollar).
After the Great Depression in the USA, President Roosevelt's government introduced the Federal
Reserve System (FED), which enabled central planning and stabilization of state economies.
From 2006 to 2008, inflationary phenomena manifested themselves with relatively greater force.
This wave of increasing inflationary processes is related not so much to the current state of the economy
but to the manifestation of symptoms of the global economic crisis in general.
In 2008, the US Federal Reserve began mass issuance of the national currency, causing the dollar to
devalue. Nevertheless, until 2008, there was a tendency towards a revaluation of the dollar against
foreign currencies (for example, the hryvnia). Revaluation takes place by exchanging foreign currency
for national currency with the help of currency speculation. Revaluation is an increase in the value of
the national currency relative to foreign or international currencies.
Figure 47: Execution of autocorrelation of our data and cumulative autocorrelation of our data
Figure 48: Visualization of cluster analysis using a dendrogram
At level 1.6, 2 clusters are formed: cluster–association 2008-2009 (d8); cluster - association 2010-
2011 (d9). At level 2.8, 1 cluster is formed: the cluster is the union of 2012 and d9 (2008-2009 (d8)).
4.5. Correlation of the hryvnia price against the dollar
Fig. 49-50 shows the correlation of the hryvnia price against the dollar.
Figure 49: Histogram and cumulate in the language using the tools of the plot.r library
Results of descriptive statistics for correlation of the hryvnia price against the dollar:
1) Sample size – 2227; 2) Arithmetic average – 1719.68729506062;
3) Median – 1615.7817; 4) Standard deviation – 856.315950045983;
5) Dispersion – 733277.006303154; 6) Excess – 1.13853180346934;
7) Amount – 3829743.6061; 8) Asymmetry – 0.00222181320354175;
9) Minimum – 788.61; 10) Maximum – 3001.0175;
11) Standard error – 18.1457082906201.
Figure 50: Descriptive statistics using the library Psych.r
4.6. GDP of European countries for 2022
Consider 42 European countries and territories, in particular:
Figure 51: Cumulative, where Euro Area -1, Germany -2, United Kingdom -3, France – 4, Italy -5, Russia
-6, Spain -7, Netherlands -8, Turkey -9, Switzerland -10, Poland - 11, Sweden -12, Belgium -13, Ireland
-14, Norway -15, Austria -16, Denmark -17, Finland -18, Romania -19, Czech Republic -20, Portugal -
21, Greece -22, Ukraine -23, Hungary -24, Slovakia -25, Luxembourg -26, Bulgaria -27, Croatia -28,
Belarus -29, Lithuania -30, Serbia -31, Slovenia -32, Latvia -33, Estonia -34, Cyprus -35, Iceland -36,
Bosnia and Herzegovina -37, Albania -38, Malta -39, Moldova -40, Macedonia -41, Kosovo -42
Figure 52: Smoothing schedule with forecasting
Let's construct a correlation of the inflation rating to the unemployment rating
Figure 53: Correlation field and Correlation coefficients
A sample correlation coefficient is used to quantify the closeness of the relationship. The sample
correlation coefficient r does not exceed unity in absolute value. For independent random variables, the
correlation coefficient is zero, but it can be zero for some dependent variables, which are called
uncorrelated. To determine the correlation coefficient, we will use three different methods: the Kendel,
Pearson, and Spearman methods. When the paired statistical dependence deviates from the linear one,
the correlation coefficient loses its meaning as a characteristic of the degree of closeness of the
relationship. In this case, such a measure of communication as a correlation relation is used (Fig. 55a).
Let's divide the sequence into three equal parts to build a correlation matrix for them (Fig. 55b).
Figure 54: a) Code to the task of correlation relation search – 0.8541093457326192 and b) dividing
the sequence into three equal parts
The result of splitting the sequence:
In the case of a large number of observations, when correlation coefficients must be calculated
sequentially for several samples, for convenience, the obtained coefficients are summarized in tables,
which are called correlation matrices.
Figure 55: Derivation of the correlation matrix
A heatmap was created to better represent the correlation.
Figure 56: Heatmap and Autocorrelation Graph
The phenomenon of autocorrelation takes place in those cases when the correlation analysis is
carried out on data for certain periods, the phenomenon of autocorrelation may appear, that is, the
connection between data for previous and subsequent periods. In the presence of a trend and cyclical
fluctuations, the values of each subsequent level of the series depend on the previous values. The
correlation dependence between successive levels of a time series is called autocorrelation of the levels
of the series. Cluster analysis for the GDP of Ukraine is one of the methods of multivariate statistical
analysis, that is, data analysis when each observation is represented not by a single indicator, but by a
set of values of different indicators (Country, GDP, GDP Year-over-Year, GDP Quarter-over-Quarter,
Interest Rate, Inflation Rate, Jobless Rate, Gov. Budget, Debt/GDP, Current Account, Population). It
includes some algorithms, with the help of which the formation of the clusters themselves and the
distribution of objects by clusters is carried out. Cluster analysis, first of all, solves the problem of
adding structure to the data, that is, their group homogeneity, and also ensures the selection of compact,
distant groups of objects, that is, it looks for a "natural" division of the population into areas of
accumulation of objects. Cluster analysis allows us to consider fairly significant volumes of data,
sharply shorten and compress them, and make them compact and visual. To begin with, it is necessary
to normalize the statistical data table built at the beginning of the work to obtain "object-property" table.
Figure 57: Table "object-property" for GDP of Ukraine, where line 1 - GDP of Ukraine, 2 - GDP per year,
3 - GDP per quarter, 4 - interest rate, 5 - inflation, 6 - unemployment, 7 - budget, 8 - debt, 9 – account
(column 1– Arithmetic average, 2 – Standard error, 3 – Mode, 4 – Median, 5 – Standard deviation, 6 –
Dispersion, 7 – Coefficient of variation, 8 – Excess, 9 – Asymmetry, 10 – Minimum, 11 – Maximum, 12
– Amount, 13 – Reliability level).
Next, we build a proximity matrix.
Figure 58: Proximity table for GDP of Ukraine, where line/column 1 - GDP of Ukraine, 2 - GDP per year,
3 - GDP per quarter, 4 - interest rate, 5 - inflation, 6 - unemployment, 7 - budget, 8 - debt, 9 – account
The cluster analysis procedure is based on recalculating the values of the proximity matrix and, as a
result, at each such calculation step, objects, an object with a group, or two groups are combined. After
each such union, the dimension of the matrix decreases by one, and the number of clusters or the number
of objects in a particular cluster increases by one. The nearest neighbour strategy was chosen for the
study of this dataset. The distance between two groups is defined as the distance between the two nearest
elements from these groups. This strategy is monotonous and strongly compresses the feature space.
Figure 59: Cluster dendrogram for GDP of Ukraine
Figure 60: Dendrogram for two clusters for GDP of Ukraine
Figure 61: Dendrogram for four and five clusters for the GDP of Ukraine
During the study, a dataset with 250 elements was analyzed, which contains data on the change of
the European currency against the dollar during the last year. The dataset contains the following data:
date, session end price, session start price, session high price, session low price, session volume and
price change percentage. Summing up the results of the analysis, we can say that the main hypothesis
about the influence of political events on the economic situation in the world has been confirmed. With
graphical representations of wheat prices and world inflation lines, as well as historical background on
world crises, patterns such as war, political change, revolutions => inflation => and rising prices could
be seen. To make the situation in Ukraine more specific, the war caused inflation, but it did not have
such an impact on the world economy as the blockade of seaports, one of the main ways of supplying
grain and other goods for export. This was the cause of inflation in Europe, rising prices for both wheat
and other imported goods and the first steps of the food crisis. The situation stabilized after the "grain
corridor" was established. Downward trends can be traced on the smoothing graphs, i.e. predictions that
over time the situation will return to the pre-war norm or remain at a stable level (provided there are no
new factors). Also, as a conclusion of the analysis, it can be stated that the price growth trends for gold
and gas (or wheat) are different and, if in peacetime mainly money, gas or goods are in circulation, then
during a crisis it is gold and precious metals (by value which political events have a much smaller, if
not the opposite, impact). Market volatility and investor concerns may lead to a deterioration in the
financial conditions of world countries. Currency depreciation and rising borrowing costs have opened
up vulnerabilities and increased the risk of related consequences. In 2023, for the global economy,
KPMG predicts GDP growth of 1.9% and inflation at the level of 4.7%.
5. Conclusions
The paper examines the level of unfavorable factors influencing the indicators of the development
of the economies of Europe and the world, which were caused by the war in Ukraine. Taking into
account the consequences of the war in Ukraine were considered from various points of view: economic,
social, political, environmental, etc. The catastrophic consequences of the war in Ukraine negatively
affected and continue to affect the development of European economies. The paper found that the rate
of economic growth is rapidly decreasing, especially in Eastern European countries. The studied
forecasts indicate a high probability of signs of recession in the countries of Eastern Europe. Under the
influence of the war in Ukraine, the article identifies the signs of a migration crisis and a rapid increase
in prices for necessities. Among the adverse impact criteria, which are recommended to be taken into
account by the governments of the countries in the process of making management decisions, the
volatility of prices for wheat, gold and gas, as well as fluctuations in the exchange rates of the dollar
and the yen to the euro, are highlighted. It is recommended to consider the amount of 400 billion US
dollars given in the report of the World Bank as a tenfold underestimated value when assessing the
scale of damage caused to the economy of Ukraine. It is substantiated that the computational methods
(cluster analysis, correlation analysis, etc.) used in the work are sufficient for determining the level of
adverse effects of the factors of the war in Ukraine on the indicators of the development of the
economies of the countries of Europe and the world
6. References
[1] Consequences of the war for the world economy and certain European countries: Czechia. URL:
https://voxukraine.org/naslidky-vijny-dlya-svitovoyi-ekonomiky-ta-okremyh-krayin-yevropy-
chehiya/
[2] Migration of the population for half a year of the war: summing up the results. URL:
https://mixdigital.com.ua/blog/migracziya-naselennya-za-piv-roku-vijni-pidbivayemo-pidsumki/
[3] The russian invasion of Ukraine impedes post pandemic economic recovery in emerging europe
and central asia. URL: https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2022/10/04/russian-
invasion-of-ukraine-impedes-post-pandemic-economic-recovery-in-emerging-europe-and-
central-asia
[4] How the war affected the economy of Ukraine. URL: https://www.dw.com/uk/ak-vijna-vplinula-
na-ekonomiku-ukraini/a-63093916
[5] Geopolitical uncertainty and high inflation negatively. URL:
https://kpmg.com/ua/uk/home/media/press-releases/2022/10/heopolitychna-nevyznachenist-i-
vysoka-inflyatsiya-nehatyvno-vplyvayut-na-svitovu-ekonomiku.html
[6] The Impact of the Ukrainian-Russian War on World Trade and Economic Development: An
Empirical Study. URL: https://aab-economics.kmf.uz.ua/aabe/article/view/8
[7] Ukraine Invasion Refugee data 2022. Information about Refugee exodus from Ukraine during the
invasion by Russia. URL: https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/anuragbantu/ukraine-invasion-
refugee-data-2022
[8] Commodity Prices Dataset (2000 - 2022). A daily time-series of commodity futures for over 20
different commodities. \URL: https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/debashish311601/commodity-
prices
[9] European Currencies and Commodities Index | Kaggle. URL:
https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/longbriannguyen/european-currency-and-commodities-
index?select=EUR_CAD+Historical+Data.csv
[10] Daily Gold Price Historical Data. Gold Historical Data. URL:
https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/psycon/daily-gold-price-historical-data
[11] Economic factors of the Ukrainian hryvnia. Dataset was made for NBU IT Challenge. URL:
https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/imgremlin/nbu-challange
[12] Exchange Rates. URL: https://kursyvalyut.victana.lviv.ua/
[13] Gross domestic product (GDP) in Ukraine 2023. URL:
https://index.minfin.com.ua/ua/economy/gdp/
[14] Economy of Europe_2022. Economic records from 42 European countries. URL:
https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/hanzlanawaz/economy-of-europe-2022
[15] M. Bublyk, V. Vysotska, Y. Matseliukh, V. Mayik, M. Nashkerska, Assessing losses of human
capital due to man-made pollution caused by emergencies, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-
2805 (2020) 74-86.
[16] Y. Matseliukh, V. Vysotska, M. Bublyk, T. Kopach, O. Korolenko, Network modelling of resource
consumption intensities in human capital management in digital business enterprises by the critical
path method, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2851 (2021) 366–380.
[17] B. Sarkar, Fuzzy decision making and its applications in cotton fibre grading. Soft Computing in
Textile Engineering (2011) 353-383. https://doi.org/10.1533/9780857090812.5.353
[18] J. Ren, X. Ren, Y. Liu, Y. Man, S. Toniolo, Sustainability assessment framework for the
prioritization of urban sewage treatment technologies. Waste-to-Energy (2020) 153-176.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-816394-8.00006-9
[19] A. Jahan, K. L. Edwards, M. Bahraminasab, Multi-criteria decision-making for materials selection.
Multi-criteria Decision Analysis for Supporting the Selection of Engineering Materials in Product
Design (2016) 63-80. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100536-1.00004-7
[20] D. Uzun Ozsahin, A. Denker, A. G. Kibarer, S. Kaba, Evaluation of stage IV brain cancer treatment
techniques. Applications of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Theories in Healthcare and
Biomedical Engineering (2021) 59-69. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-824086-1.00004-9
[21] A. Jahan, K. L. Edwards, M. Bahraminasab, Future developments. Multi-criteria Decision
Analysis for Supporting the Selection of Engineering Materials in Product Design (2016) 227-232.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100536-1.00008-4
[22] I. Ozsahin, D. Uzun Ozsahin, B., Uzun, M. T. Mustapha, Introduction. Applications of Multi-
Criteria Decision-Making Theories in Healthcare and Biomedical Engineering (2021) 1-2.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-824086-1.00001-3
[23] H. Karunathilake, E. Bakhtavar, G. Chhipi-Shrestha, H. R. Mian, K. Hewage, R. Sadiq, Decision
making for risk management: A multi-criteria perspective. Methods in Chemical Process Safety 4
(2020) 239-287. https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.mcps.2020.02.004
[24] D. Deb, K. Bhargava, Optimization of on-site PID detection methods. Degradation, Mitigation,
and Forecasting Approaches in Thin Film Photovoltaics (2022) 133-149.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-823483-9.00019-X
[25] M. Bublyk, A. Kowalska-Styczen, V. Lytvyn, V. Vysotska, The Ukrainian Economy
Transformation into the Circular Based on Fuzzy-Logic Cluster Analysis, Energies 14 (2021)
5951. https://doi.org/10.3390/en14185951
[26] A. Jahan, K. L. Edwards, M. Bahraminasab, Multi-attribute decision-making for ranking of
candidate materials. Multi-criteria Decision Analysis for Supporting the Selection of Engineering
Materials in Product Design (2016) 81-126. doi:10.1016/B978-0-08-100536-1.00005-9
[27] D. Uzun Ozsahin, K. Meck, S. T. Halimani, B. Uzun, I. Ozsahin, Fuzzy PROMETHEE-based
evaluation of brain cancer treatment techniques. Applications of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making
Theories in Healthcare and Biomedical Engineering (2021) 41-58. doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-
824086-1.00003-7
[28] M. Bublyk, Y. Matseliukh, Small-batteries utilization analysis based on mathematical statistics
methods in challenges of circular economy, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2870 (2021) 1594-
1603.
[29] L. Cui, S. Yue, X. Nghiem, M. Duan, Exploring the risk and economic vulnerability of global
energy supply chain interruption in the context of Russo-Ukrainian war. Resources Policy 81
(2023) 103373. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2023.103373
[30] V. Kumari, G. Kumar, D. K. Pandey, Are the European Union stock markets vulnerable to the
Russia–Ukraine war? Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance 37 (2023) 100793.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbef.2023.100793
[31] A. Sokhanvar, S. Çiftçioğlu, C. Lee, The effect of energy price shocks on commodity currencies
during the war in Ukraine. Resources Policy 82 (2023) 103571. doi:
10.1016/j.resourpol.2023.103571
[32] Y. Chen, J. Jiang, L. Wang, R. Wang, Impact assessment of energy sanctions in geo-conflict:
Russian–Ukrainian war. Energy Reports, 9 (2023) 3082-3095. doi: 10.1016/j.egyr.2023.01.124
[33] G. S. Sedrakyan, Ukraine war-induced sanctions against Russia: Consequences on transition
economies. Journal of Policy Modeling 44(5) (2022) 863-885. doi:10.1016/j.jpolmod.2022.08.003
[34] V. Vysotska, A. Berko, M. Bublyk, L. Chyrun, A. Vysotsky, K. Doroshkevych, Methods and tools
for web resources processing in e-commercial content systems, in: Proceedings of 15th
International Scientific and Technical Conference on Computer Sciences and Information
Technologies, CSIT, 1, 2020, pp. 114-118.
[35] M. Umar, Y. Riaz, I. Yousaf, Impact of Russian-Ukraine war on clean energy, conventional
energy, and metal markets: Evidence from event study approach. Resources Policy 79 (2022)
102966. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2022.102966
[36] O. B. Adekoya, J. A. Oliyide, O. S.,Yaya, M. A. S. Al-Faryan, Does oil connect differently with
prominent assets during war? Analysis of intra-day data during the Russia-Ukraine saga. Resources
Policy 77 (2022) 102728. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2022.102728
[37] X. Zhou, G. Lu, Z. Xu, X. Yan, S. Khu, J. Yang, J. Zhao, Influence of Russia-Ukraine War on the
Global Energy and Food Security. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 188 (2023) 106657.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2022.106657
[38] R. Karkowska, S. Urjasz, How does the Russian-Ukrainian war change connectedness and hedging
opportunities? Comparison between dirty and clean energy markets versus global stock indices.
Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 85 (2023) 101768.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intfin.2023.101768
[39] G. Lo, I. Marcelin, T. Bassène, B. Sène, The Russo-Ukrainian war and financial markets: The role
of dependence on Russian commodities. Finance Research Letters 50 (2022) 103194.
[40] V. Lytvyn, A. Hryhorovych, V. Hryhorovych, V. Vysotska, M. Bublyk, L. Chyrun, Medical
content processing in intelligent system of district therapist, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-
2753 (2020) 415–429.
[41] A. Sokhanvar, E. Bouri, Commodity price shocks related to the war in Ukraine and exchange rates
of commodity exporters and importers. Borsa Istanbul Review 23(1) (2023) 44-54.
[42] B. Steffen, A. Patt, A historical turning point? Early evidence on how the Russia-Ukraine war
changes public support for clean energy policies. Energy Research & Social Science 91 (2022)
102758. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2022.102758
[43] P. Żuk, P. Żuk, National energy security or acceleration of transition? Energy policy after the war
in Ukraine. Joule 6(4) (2022) 709-712. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2022.03.009
[44] M. A. R. Estrada, E. Koutronas, The impact of the Russian Aggression against Ukraine on the
Russia-EU Trade. Journal of Policy Modeling 44(3) (2022) 599-616.
[45] L. A. Lambert, J. Tayah, C. Lee-Schmid, M. Abdalla, I. Abdallah, A. H. Ali, S. Esmail, W. Ahmed,
The EU's natural gas Cold War and diversification challenges. Energy Strategy Reviews 43 (2022)
100934. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2022.100934
[46] J. deLisle, China’s Russia/Ukraine Problem, and Why It’s Bad for Almost Everyone Else Too.
Orbis 66(3) (2022) 402-423. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orbis.2022.05.009
[47] D. Koshtura, M. Bublyk, Y. Matseliukh, D. Dosyn, L. Chyrun, O. Lozynska, I. Karpov, I.
Peleshchak, M. Maslak, O. Sachenko, Analysis of the demand for bicycle use in a smart city based
on machine learning, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2631 (2020) 172-183.
[48] M. F. B. Alam, S. R. Tushar, S. M. Zaman, E. D. S. Gonzalez, A. M. Bari, C. L. Karmaker,
Analysis of the drivers of Agriculture 4.0 implementation in the emerging economies: Implications
towards sustainability and food security. Green Technologies and Sustainability 1(2) (2023)
100021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.grets.2023.100021
[49] M. Osiichuk, O. Shepotylo, Conflict and well-being of civilians: The case of the Russian-Ukrainian
hybrid war. Economic Systems 44(1) (2020) 100736. doi: 10.1016/j.ecosys.2019.100736
[50] C. W. Su, M. Qin, H., Chang, A. Țăran, Which risks drive European natural gas bubbles? Novel
evidence from geopolitics and climate. Resources Policy 81 (2023) 103381.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2023.103381
[51] M. C. Sanders, C. E. Sanders, A world's dilemma ‘upon which the sun never sets’: The nuclear
waste management strategy (part IV): Spain, Switzerland, Taiwan, Ukraine, and United Arab
Emirates. Progress in Nuclear Energy, 144 (2022) 104090. doi: 10.1016/j.pnucene.2021.104090
[52] A. Brantly, N. Brantly, Biopolitics: Power, Pandemics, and War. Orbis 67(1) (2023) 64-84.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orbis.2022.12.008
[53] L. Podlesna, M. Bublyk, I. Grybyk, Y. Matseliukh, Y. Burov, P. Kravets, O. Lozynska, I. Karpov,
I. Peleshchak, R. Peleshchak, Optimization model of the buses number on the route based on
queueing theory in a Smart City, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2631 (2020) 502 - 515.
[54] M. Yagi, S. Managi, The spillover effects of rising energy prices following 2022 Russian invasion
of Ukraine. Economic Analysis and Policy 77 (2023) 680-695. doi: 10.1016/j.eap.2022.12.025
[55] T. H. Le, Quantile time-frequency connectedness between cryptocurrency volatility and renewable
energy volatility during the COVID-19 pandemic and Ukraine-Russia conflicts. Renewable
Energy 202 (2023) 613-625. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2022.11.062
[56] A. Umland, Germany’s Russia Policy in Light of the Ukraine Conflict: Interdependence Theory
and Ostpolitik. Orbis 66(1) (2022) 78-94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orbis.2021.11.007
[57] A. Bricout, R. Slade, I. Staffell, K. Halttunen, From the geopolitics of oil and gas to the geopolitics
of the energy transition: Is there a role for European supermajors? Energy Research & Social
Science 88 (2022) 102634. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2022.102634
[58] H. Lipyanina, A. Sachenko, T. Lendyuk, S. Nadvynychny, S. Grodskyi. Decision Tree Based
Targeting Model of Customer Interaction with Business Page, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-
2608 (2020) 1001-1012.
[59] A. Krysovatyy, H. Lipyanina-Goncharenko, S. Sachenko, O. Desyatnyuk, Economic Crime
Detection Using Support Vector Machine Classification, CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2917
(2021) 830–840.
[60] A. Talibov, B. Guliyev, A method for assessing the military-economic indicators with the purpose
of locating a logistics center for redeploying troops. Advanced Information Systems 5(2) (2021)
152–158. https://doi.org/10.20998/2522-9052.2021.2.23
[61] М. Shevchenko, V. Mishchenko, I. Sitak, K. Oryekhova, S. Yavorsky, Theoretical bases of
providing the economic sustainability of the enterprise. Financial activity: problems of theory and
practice 3(30) (2019) 112-120.
[62] O. Kuzmin, M. Bublyk, Economic evaluation and government regulation of technogenic (man-
made) damage in the national economy, in: Computer sciences and information technologies
(CSIT), 2016, pp. 37–39.
[63] R.P. Strubytskyi, N.B. Shakhovska, Analysis of approaches to modeling of cloud data warehouses.
In: Actual Problems of Economics 149(11) (2013) 263-269.
[64] M.O. Medykovskyi, I.G. Tsmots, O.V. Skorokhoda, Spectrum neural network filtration
technology for improving the forecast accuracy of dynamic processes in economics, Actual
Problems of Economics 162(12) (2014) 410-416.
[65] P. Bidyuk, A. Gozhyj, Y. Matsuki, N. Kuznetsova, I. Kalinina, Modeling and forecasting economic
and financial processes using combined adaptive models, Advances in Intelligent Systems and
Computing 1246 (2021) 395-408.
[66] I. Lurie, et al., Inductive technology of the target clusterization of enterprise's economic indicators
of Ukraine. In: CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2353 (2019) 848-859.
[67] V. Lytvynenko, D. Nikytenko, M. Voronenko, N. Savina, O. Naumov, Assessing the Possibility
of a Country's Economic Growth Using Dynamic Bayesian Network Models, in: Proceedings of
IEEE 15th International Scientific and Technical Conference on Computer Sciences and
Information Technologies, CSIT, 2020, pp. 36-39.
[68] V. Lytvynenko, et al., Comparative studies of self-organizing algorithms for forecasting economic
parameters, International Journal of Modern Education and Computer Science 12(6) (2020) 1-15.
[69] M. Voronenko, D. Nikytenko, J. Krejci, N. Savina, V. Lytvynenko, Assessing the possibility of a
country's economic growth using static Bayesian network models, CEUR Workshop Proceedings
2608 (2020) 462-473.
[70] V. Tyschenko, N. Vnukova, V. Ostapenko, S. Kanyhin, Neural Networks for Financial Stability
of Economic System, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-3387 (2023) 274-288.
[71] R. Yurynets, Z. Yurynets, M. Grzebyk, M. Kokhan, N. Kunanets, M. Shevchenko, Neural Network
Modeling of the Social and Economic, Investment and Innovation Policy of the State, CEUR
Workshop Proceedings Vol-3312 (2022) 252-262.
[72] N.r Shpak, O. Pyroh, M. Tomych, M. Voronovska, H. Kovtok, Applied Intelligent Systems of
Support for Public-Private Partnership in Foreign Economic Activity, CEUR Workshop
Proceedings Vol-3171 (2022) 1499-1508.
[73] R. Yurynets, Z. Yurynets, O. Budіakova, L. Gnylianska, M. Kokhan, Innovation and Investment
Factors in the State Strategic Management of Social and Economic Development of the Country:
Modeling and Forecasting, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2917 (2021) 357-372.
[74] N. Shpak, K. Doroshkevych, Y. Shpak, I. Salata, M. Sharko, Strategy and Tactics of International
Digitalization and Intellectualization of Economic Relations, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-
2870 (2021) 1477-1487.
[75] V. Kuchkovskiy, V. Andrunyk, M. Krylyshyn, L. Chyrun, A. Vysotskyi, S. Chyrun, N. Sokulska,
I. Brodovska, Application of Online Marketing Methods and SEO Technologies for Web
Resources Analysis within the Region, CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2870 (2021) 1652-1693.
[76] Y. Romanenkov, V. Pasichnyk, N. Veretennikova, M. Nazaruk, A. Leheza, Information and
Technological Support for the Processes of Prognostic Modeling of Regional Labor Markets,
CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2386 (2019) 24-34.
[77] M. Medykovskyy, I. Tsmots, Y.,Tsymbal, A. Doroshenko, Development of a regional energy
efficiency control system on the basis of intelligent components, in Computer Sciences and
Information Technologies, CSIT, 2016, pp.18-20.
[78] M.O. Medykovskyi, I.G. Tsmots, Y.V. Tsymbal, Intelligent data processing tools in the systems
of energy efficiency management for regional economy, Actual Problems of Economics 150(12)
(2013) 271-277.
[79] V. Kravchyshyn, M. Medykovskyj, Analysis of modeling methods of wind energy potential of a
region. In: Computer Sciences and Information Technologies, CSIT, 2016, pp. 175-178.
[80] A.Y. Berko, Methods and models of data integration in E-business systems, Actual Problems of
Economics (10) (2008) 17-24.
[81] A. Berko, Consolidated data models for electronic business systems. In: The Experience of
Designing and Application of CAD Systems in Microelectronics, CADSM, 2007, pp. 341-342.
[82] S., Gavrylenko, I., Sheverdin, M. Kazarinov, The ensemble method development of classification
of the computer system state based on decisions trees. Advanced Information Systems 4(3) (2020)
5–10. https://doi.org/10.20998/2522-9052.2020.3.01
[83] I. Butko The use of geospatial information by public authorities to support the decision making of
management. Advanced Information Systems 5(1) (2021) 39-44.
[84] A. Povoroznyuk, O. Povoroznyuk, K. Shekhna, Application of fractal processing of digital
mammograms in designing decision support systems in medicine, Advanced Information Systems,
4(4) (2020) 109–113. https://doi.org/10.20998/2522-9052.2020.4.15
[85] L. Chyrun, P. Kravets, O. Garasym, A. Gozhyj, I. Kalinina, Cryptographic information protection
algorithm selection optimization for electronic governance IT project management by the analytic
hierarchy process based on nonlinear conclusion criteria, CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2565
(2020) 205-220.
[86] O. Veres, Y. Matseliukh, T. Batiuk, S. Teslia, A. Shakhno, T. Kopach, Y. Romanova, I.
Pihulechko, Cluster Analysis of Exclamations and Comments on E-Commerce Products, CEUR
Workshop Proceedings Vol-3171 (2022) 1403-1431.
[87] A. Karpyak, O. Rybytska, Cluster Analysis of Motivational Management of Personnel Support of
IT Companies, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-3171 (2022) 1684-1693.
[88] I. Rishnyak, Y. Matseliukh, T. Batiuk, L. Chyrun, O. Strembitska, O. Mlynko, V. Liashenko, A.
Lema, Statistical Analysis of the Popularity of Programming Language Libraries Based on
StackOverflow Queries, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-3171 (2022). 1351-1379.
[89] A. Vasyliuk, Y. Matseliukh, T. Batiuk, M. Luchkevych, I. Shakleina, H. Harbuzynska, S.
Kondratiuk, K. Zelenska, Intelligent Analysis of Best-Selling Books Statistics on Amazon, CEUR
Workshop Proceedings Vol-3171 (2022) 1432-1462.
[90] I. Sokolovskyy, N. Shakhovska, Statistical modeling of diffusion processes with a fractal structure,
CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2488 (2019) 145-154.
[91] O. Duda, N. Kunanets, O. Matsiuk, V. Pasichnyk, N. Veretennikova, A. Fedonuyk, V. Yunchyk,
Selection of Effective Methods of Big Data Analytical Processing in Information Systems of Smart
Cities, CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol-2631 (2020) 68-78.
[92] M.O. Medykovskyi, I.G. Tsmots, Y.V. Tsymbal, Information analytical system for energy
efficiency management at enterprises in the city of Lviv (Ukraine), Actual Problems of Economics
175(1) (2016) 379-384.
[93] Y. Kolokolov, A. Monovskaya, Observations-Based Computational Analytics On Local Climate
Dynamics: Change-Points, International Journal of Computing 16(2) (2017) 89-96.
[94] Y. Kolokolov, A. Monovskaya, Observations-Based Computational Analytics On Local Climate
Dynamics. Part 2: Seasonality, International Journal of Computing 16(3) (2017) 152-159.
[95] Y. Kolokolov, A. Monovskaya, Observations-Based Computational Analytics On Local Climate
Dynamics. Part 3: Forecasting, International Journal of Computing 16(4) (2017).210-218.
[96] V. Osypenko, et al., About innovation-investment designing of complex systems by inductive
technology of system information-analytical research, in: Proceedings of International Conference
on Intelligent Data Acquisition and Advanced Computing Systems: Technology and Applications,
IDAACS 2019, pp. 424-430.
[97] N. Melnykova, Net al., Data-driven analytics for personalized medical decision making,
Mathematics 8(8) (2020) 1211.
[98] O. Veres, P. Ilchuk, O. Kots, L. Bondarenko, Big Data Analysis for Structuring FX Market
Volatility due to Financial Crises and Exchange Rate Overshooting, CEUR Workshop Proceedings
Vol-2870 (2021) 1488-1499.
[99] A. Demchuk, et al., Commercial content distribution system based on neural network and machine
learning, CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2516 (2019) 40–57.