Protection of information with limited access, especially state secrets, is an important task in the sphere of national and information security of the state. To minimize the possible damage to the national security of Ukraine from violations in the sphere of protection of state secrets) and to reduce the negative international rating and other serious consequences at the state level, the task of creating specialized databases, and developing and improving existing methods and models that implement relevant assessments is urgent. That is why, the theoretical-multiple presentation of the parameters of the generalized report and the report on the state of state secret protection in tuple models allow solving the actual scientific and practical task of formalizing the process of assessing the negative consequences of leaking a state secret, its disclosure or loss of material carriers of secret information, violation of the secrecy regime, etc. Previously, a tuple model of primary parameters was developed, and currently, as its continuation, a model of internal parameters and its hierarchical structure has already been proposed, due to the integrated theoretical-multiple representation of sets characterizing the information about the availability of the employees of the reporting subject of admission and access to of state secrets and the number of material carriers of secret information, allows, under the requirements of current legislation, to determine a set of input and output parameters for the formation of special databases and the formalization of the process of assessing the damage caused to national security from the leakage of state secrets. In the future, to implement the above-mentioned process, it is necessary to develop an appropriate model of formalization and processing of the database of secondary parameters of the subject of regime-secret activity.
According to requirements [
The number of violations related to treason
and/or sabotage, in terms of loss, disclosure, or
transfer to a foreign country of information
constituting SS, is significantly increasing both
in the world [
To minimize the possible damage to national
security from violations in the field of PSS and
reduce the negative rating at the state level, it
is necessary to create databases, methods, and
models that implement appropriate
assessments. That is why, the
theoreticalmultiple presentation of the parameters of the
“Generalized report on the state of security of
SS” [
One will use the set of all possible identifiers of IS (Information about the Subject) tuples, which can be used to display information about SRSA and be used in the process of detecting and assessing the consequences in case of loss of SS [19, 20]:
z IS = { IS } = {IS1,IS2,...,ISz} , =1 (1) where IS IS ( = 1, z) is the identifier of the tuple of parameters characterizing the φth SRSA.
For example, at z=4 (1) will have the form [19]:
4 = {⋃ } = { 1, 2, 3, 4}= =1
= { NAU, ZhVI, NA SBU, SI "SSI" } where 1 = NAU, 2 = ℎ , 3 = NA SBU, 4 = SI "SSI" respectively, the identifiers of the convoys of the SRSA “National Aviation University” (NAU), “Zhytomyr Military Institute named after S. P. Korolev” (ZhVI), “National Academy of the Security Service of Ukraine” (NA SBU), State institution “Sumy investigative detention center” (SI “SSI”).
For the φ-th SRSA, the tuple of parameters characterizing it has the following form:
IS = IS 1, IS 2 ,..., IS i ,..., IS k (2) where: IS i IS (i = 1, k ) is a component of the tuple, which is a subtuple and displays the ith parameter identifier of the φ-th SRSA, and k is the maximum number of such parameters.
Note that all members are characterized by the property of order.
For example, according to the Generalized
Report and the Report [
The first group of (primary) parameters is discussed in detail in the scientific work [18], and therefore we will describe the following second group of (internal) parameters IS 3 and IS 4 .
IS 4 IS 5 IS 6 IS 7 IS 8 IS 9
Information about the subject of reporting, his subordination, and departmental affiliation Information about RSD, financing of activities with PSS Information on whether employees of the reporting entity have permission and access to state secrets Section 4 Information on the number of material carriers of classified information Section 5 Information on the performance (scientific and/or scientific and technical support) of secret research, development, design, and other scientific works, the manufacture of secret products Section 5(А) Information regarding the order (scientific and/or scientific and technical support) of secret scientific research, research and development, design and other scientific works, production of secret products Section 6 Information about regime premises, objects of information activity Section 7 Information on the facts of MCCI losses or the disclosure of information constituting a state secret, as well as information with limited access to foreign countries or international organizations
Section 8 Information on international cooperation
IS 3 = Section 3 (“Information on whether the employees of the reporting entity have permission and access to state secrets”) is filled in by the SRSA as of the end of the reporting period by filling in the corresponding columns (parameters): where IS 3.i IS 3 (i = 1, q) —component of the subtuple, which displays the i-th parameter identifier of the φth SRSA of the organization, and q is their number.
For example, according to [
N , nE , nP , FA , nPN , nA , nSA , nRA ,nWR , nGA , nWA . where IS 3.1 = IS 1.1 = N (Name) is the set “Actual and conditional (if available) name of the reporting entity”; IS 3.2 = nE (number of Employees) is the set “Total number of employees according to the staff list”; IS 3.3 = nP (number of Positions) is the set “Total number of positions included in the nomenclature of positions”; IS 3.4 = FA (Forms of Aссess) is the set “Forms of access”; IS 3.5 = nPN (number of Positions included in the Nomenclature) is the set “Number of positions included in the nomenclature of positions”; IS 3.6 = nA (number of Employees with Aссess) is the set “The number of employees who have access to SS”; IS 3.7 = nSA (number of Employees with Suspended Aссess) is the set “The number of employees whose access to SS has been terminated”; IS 3.8 = nRA (number
h1 IS 3.1 = IS 11 = N = { N i } = {N 1, N 2 ,..., N h1 }, i=1 of еmployees with Revoked Aссess)—the set “The number of employees whose access to SS has been cancelled”; IS 3.9 = nWR (number of persons with Access Without Registration)—the set “The number of persons who were granted access to the DT in the procedure defined by the law without obtaining admission to the DT”; IS 3.10 = nGA (number of employees who Got Acquainted with classified information)—the set “The number of employees who got acquainted with secret information in other enterprises, institutions, organizations”; IS 3.11 = nWA (number of secret carriers who Went Abroad on private business)—the set “The number of secret carriers who went abroad on private business”.
For example, to assign specific values to the
following eleven parameters of the third
component IS 3 IS one will use SRSA 1 =
NAU [
Aviation University (NAU)”}) [18].
q2 IS 3.2 = nE = { nE i } = {nE 1,nE 2 ,...,nE q2 },
i=1 where nE i nE (i = 1, q2 ) is ith identifier of the total number of employees according to the staff list, and q2 is their number (for example, for 1 = NAU, taking into account [20], with = 1 , q2 = 1 (i = 1) , then (5) is defined as:
q3 IS 3.3 = nP = { nP i} = {nP1,nP 2,...,nP q3 }, i=1
1 1 1 = {⋃ nENAUi}= {⋃ nENAU1}= i−1 i−1
= {“4517,8”}, that is, the total number of NAU employees, according to the 2021 staff list, is 4517.8).
(5) (6) where nP i nP (i = 1, q3) is ith identifier of the total number of positions included in the nomenclature of positions, and q3 is their number (let the number of positions included in the nomenclature of cases be 10% of the total number of positions according to the staff list of NAU in 2021 [20], i.e. at = 1 , q3 = 1 (i = 1) , then (6) will be as:
1 1 1 = {⋃ nPNAUi}= {⋃ nPNAU1}= {"452"}
i=1 i=1 that is, the total number of positions included in the nomenclature of positions is 452.
q4 IS 3.4 = FA = { FA i} = {FA1, FA 2 ,..., FA q4 } ,
i=1
where FA i FA (i = 1, q4 ) is ith set of
tolerance forms, and q4 is their number (for
example, respectively [
3 FA = { FA i } = {FA 1, FA 2 , FA 3} = i=1 where FA1 = “1”, FA 2 = “2”, FA 3 = “3”.
Assume that for = 1 , q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , then (7) takes the following form:
2
FA1 = {⋃ }= { 1, =1 2}={“1”, “2”}, i.e. in NAU there are forms of admission as the first (or 1) and the second (or 2). {“1”, “2”, “3”}, q4 q5 IS 3.5 = nPN = {{ nPN i. j}} = {{nPN1.1,...},...,{...,nPN i. j ,...},...,{...,nPN q4.q5 }}, i=1 j=1 (7) (8) where nPN i. j nPN (i = 1, q4, j = 1, q5) is іth identifier of the number of positions included in the nomenclature of positions, and q5 is their number for q4 , hat is, for a specific form of admission (for example, with = 1 , for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q5 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (8) will take the form: 2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}= = {{“300”}, {“150”}}, that is, the number of positions in NAU included in the nomenclature of positions according to the first (or 1) form of admission is 300, and according to the second (or 2) form of admission—150).
q4 q6 IS 3.6 = nA = {{ nA i. j}} = {{nA1.1},...,{nA i. j},...,{nA q4.q6 }}, i=1 j=1 (9) where
nA i. j nA (i = 1, q4, j = 1, q6 ) is іth identifier of the number of employees who have admission to SS, and q6 is their number for q4 , that is, for a specific form of admission (for example, with = 1 , for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q6 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (9) will take the form of: 2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ =1 =1
= {{“250”}, {“100”}}, that is, the number of NAU employees who have admission to SS under the first (or 1) form of admission is 250, and 100 under the second (or 2) form of admission).
. } = {{ 1.1}, { where nSA i. j nSA (i = 1, q4 , j = 1, q7 ) is іth identifier of the number of employees whose access to SS has been terminated, and q7 is their number for q4 , hat is, for a specific form of admission (for example, = 1 for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q7 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (10) will take the form of: 2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}=
= {{“25”}, {“7”}}, i.e. the number of NAU employees whose access to SS has been terminated for the first (or 1) form of admission is 25, and for the second (or 2) form of admission—7). where nRA i. j nRA (i = 1, q4 , j = 1, q8 ) is іth identifier of the number of employees whose admission to SS has been canceled, and q8 is their number according to q4 , that is, according to a specific form of admission (for example, if = 1 for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q8 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (11) will be as: where nWR i. j nWR (i = 1, q4, j = 1, q9 ) is іth identifier of the number of persons who were granted access to the SS in the manner specified by the legislation without obtaining admission to the SS, and q9 is their number according to q4 , that is, according to a specific form of admission (for example, with = 1 , for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q9 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (12) will be as: 2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}=
= {{“25”}, {“7”}}, i.e. the number of NAU employees whose access to SS has been canceled for the first (or 1) form of admission is 25, and for the second (or 2) form of admission—7, or in this case IS 3.8 = IS 3.7 ).
2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}=
= {{“4”}, {“2”}}, i.e. the number of persons who were granted access to SS at NAU following the procedure specified by law without registration of admission to SS according to the first (or 1) form of admission is 4, and according to the second (or 2) form of admission—2).
q4 q9 IS 3.9 = nWR = {{nWR i. j}} = {{nWR1.1,...},...,{...,nWR i. j ,...},...,{...,nWR q4.q9 }}, i=1 j=1 (12) where nGA i. j nGA (i = 1, q4, j = 1, q10 ) is іth identifier of the number of employees who got acquainted with secret information in other enterprises, institutions, organizations, and q10 is their number for q4 , that is, for a specific form of admission (for example, with = 1 , for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2), q10 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (13) will take the form of: 2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}={{“5”}, {“3”}}, that is, the number of NAU employees who got acquainted with classified information in other enterprises, institutions, and organizations according to the first (or 1) form of admission is 5, and according to the second (or 2) form of admission—3).
q4 q11 IS 3.11 = nWA = {{ nWA i. j}} = {{nWA1.1,...},...,{...,nWA i. j ,...},...,{...,nWA q4.q11}}(1,4) i=1 j=1 where nWA i. j nWA (i = 1, q4, j = 1, q11) is jth identifier of the number of secret carriers who went abroad on private business, and q9 is their number for q4 , that is, for a specific ith form of admission (for example, with = 1 , for q4 = 2 (i = 1,2) , q11 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (14) will be as:
2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { 2.1}}= = {{“4”}, {“2”}}, that is, the number of secret carriers in NAU who went abroad on private business under the first (or 1) form of admission is 4, and under the second (or 2) form of admission—2).
IS 4 = Section 4 (“Information on the
number of material carriers of secret
information”) is formed by filling in the SRSA of
the graphs (parameters) of the corresponding
section of the Report [
IS 4 = IS 4.1,IS 4.2,...,IS 4.i ,...,IS 4.k , (15) where IS 4.i IS 4 (i = 1, k ) is component of the subtuple displaying the ith identifier of the RSO parameters of the φ-th SRSA, and k is their number.
For example, according to the requirements of
[
N ,SS ,aM ,nsM ,nrM ,nMr ,nMt ,nMf ,sU ,nMu , where: IS 4.1 = IS1.1 = N (Name)—set “Actual and conditional (if available) name of the reporting entity (SRSA)”; IS 4.2 = SS (Stamp of Secrecy)—set “Stamp of Secrecy”; IS 4.3 = aM (all Material Carriers of Classified Information)—set “Total MCCI (sum of columns 5-13)”; IS 4.4 = nsM (Number of registered and Stored MCCI at the end of the reporting period)—set “The number of MCCIs that are registered and maintained as of the end of the reporting period”; IS 4.5 = nrM (Number of Registered MCCI in the reporting period)—set “Number of registered MCCI in the reporting period”; IS 4.6 = nMr (number of MCCI, the secrecy stamps of which have been revised)—set “The number of MCCI, the secrecy vultures of which have been revised”; IS 4.7 = nMt (number of MССI transferred to foreign states and international organizations in the reporting period)—set “The number of MCCI that were transferred to foreign states
k2 IS 4.2 = SS = { SS i} = {SS1, SS 2 ,..., SS k2 }, i=1 and international organizations in the reporting period”; IS 4.8 = nMf (number of MССI with stamps restricting access of foreign states and international organizations)—set “The number of MCCI with the access restriction vultures of foreign states and international organizations (provided in columns taking into account the comparison with the vultures of secrecy of Ukraine following international treaties)”; IS 4.9 = sU (stamps restricting access of USSR)—set “Access restriction vultures of the former USSR”; IS 4.10 = nMu (number of MCCI with stamps restricting access of USSR)— set “Number of MCCI with access restriction vultures of the former USSR”.
For example, to assign specific values to
the specified seven parameters of the fourth
component IS 4 IS one will use SRSA
1 = [
IS 4.1 = IS1.1 = N , k1 = h1 (see (4) [18]).
(16) where SS i SS (i = 1, k2 ) is ith is the identifier of the number of secrecy vultures of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, and a is their number.
According to the Law of Ukraine “On State
Secrets” [
k2 k3 IS 4.3 = aM = {{ aM i. j}} = {{aM 1.1,...}, ...,{..., aM i. j ,...},...,{..., aM k2.k3 }}, i=1 j=1 classification of secrecy into: “secret” (or S), “top secret” (or TS) and “of special importance” (or SI), therefore k2 = 3 formula (16) looks like:
3 SS = { SS i} = {SS1, SS 2, SS 3} = i=1 (17) where aM i. j aM (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k3 ) is jth identifier of all MCCI (as the number of the sum of graphs 5–13), and k3 is their number for each k2 , i.e. according to the specific ith secret code (let’s imagine that = 1 for k2 = 2 (i = 1,2) ,
= {{ k3 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (17) will be as:
2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃ =1 =1
1.1}, { that is, in the NAU of all MCCIs, according to the secrecy vultures “secret” (or S)—215, and “top secret” (or TS)—75.
k2 k4.i
IS 4.4 = nsM = {{nsM i. j }} = {{nsM 1.1,...},...,{...,nsM i. j ,...},...,{...,nsM k2.k4.k(21}8}),
i=1 j=1
where nsM i. j nsM (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k4.i ) is jth
identifier of the number of MCCIs, which are
registered and stored as of the end of the
reporting period, and k4.i is their number for
each k2 , that is, according to a specific ith
security seal (for example, taking into account
[
i=1 j=1
{{nsM1.1, nsM1.2 , nsM1.3 , nsM1.4},{nsM 2.1},{nsM 3.1},{nsM 4.1},...{nsM 7.1}},
where nsM i. j is the set number of MCCIs that
are registered and kept as of the end of the
reporting period [
For example, if = 1 for k2 = 2 (i = 1,2) ,
k4 = 7 ( j = 1,7) , k4.1 = 4 , k4.2 k4.7 = 1 then (18),
taking into account the composition of the set
nsM i.1 , will be as [
i=1 j=1 e=1 = {{nsM1.1.1, nsM1.1.2 , nsM1.1.3, nsM1.1.4},{nsM1.2.1},{nsM1.3.1},{nsM1.4.1},...{nsM1.7.1}, {nsM 2.1.1, nsM 2.1.2 , nsM 2.1.3 , nsM 2.1.4},{nsM 2.2.1},{nsM 2.3.1},{nsM 2.4.1},...{nsM 2.7.1}} = = {{nsM1.1.1, nsM1.1.2 , nsM1.1.3, nsM1.1.4},{nsM1.2.1},{nsM1.3.1},{nsM1.4.1},{nsM1.5.1},{nsM1.6.1},{nsM1.7.1}}, {{nsM 2.1.1, nsM 2.1.2 , nsM 2.1.3, nsM 2.1.4},{nsM 2.2.1},{nsM 2.3.1},{nsM 2.4.1},{nsM 2.5.1},{nsM 2.6.1},{nsM 2.7.1}} = = {{“20”, “15”, “15”, “5”}, {“30”}, {“25”}, {“40”}, {“50”}, {“10”}, {“5”}},
{{“10”, “5”, “5”, “5”}, {“5”}, {“10”}, {“10”}, “10”}, {“10”}, {“5”}}, i.e., in NAU, the number of MCCI, which are registered and stored as of the end of the reporting period, with secrecy vultures: 1) “secret” (or S): the number of MCCI related to cryptographic protection of information: the number of means of cryptographic protection of information—20; the number of books of technical (operational) and regulatory documentation—15; number of key documents—15; number of MCCI of the state recognition system—5; regulatory and administrative acts—30; technical and operational documentation—25; secret products—40; other MCCI (volumes of cases, copies of publications, photo documents, notebooks, etc.)—50; the number of computer media (FMD, HMDD, CDs, flash drives, microfilms)—10; including with the mark “Letter “M”—5; 2) “top secret” (or TS): number of MCCI related to cryptographic protection of information: number of means of cryptographic protection of information—10; the number of books of technical (operational) and regulatory documentation—5; number of key documents—5; number of MCCI of the state recognition system—5; regulatory and administrative acts—5; technical and operational documentation—10; secret products—10; other MCCI (case volumes,
k2 k5 IS 4.5 = nrM = {{nrM i. j }} = {{nrM1.1,...},...,{...,nrM i. j ,...},...,{...,nrM k2.k5 }}, i=1 j=1 copies of publications, photo documents, notebooks, etc.)—10; the number of computer media (FMD, HMDD, CDs, flash drives, microfilms)—10; including with the mark “Letter “M”—5.
(19)
where nrM i. j nrM (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k5 ) is jth
identifier of other MNSI (volumes of cases,
copies of publications, photo documents,
notebooks, etc.), and k5 is their number for
each k2 , that is, according to a specific ith
classification of secrecy (for example, taking
[
2 4 1 = {⋃ ⋃ =1 =1 where nMr i. j nMr (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k6 ) is jth identifier of the number of MCCI, the security vultures of which have been reviewed, and k6 is their number for each k2 , that is, according
2 3 1 = {⋃ ⋃ . } =
=1 =1
{{ 1.1, 1.2, 1.3}, { 2.1, 2.2,
= {{“4”, “7”, “2”}, {“3”, “2”, “0”}},
to the specific ith security vulture (for example,
taking into account [
k2 k7 IS 4.7 = nMt = {{ nMt i. j }} = {{nMt1.1}, ...,{nMt i. j },...,{nMt k2.k7 }}, i=1 j=1 stamp)—2; 2) “top secret” (or TS): brought into line with the current CISS (secrecy seal changed)—3, transferred to the category with the access restriction seal “For official use”—2, declassified (access restriction seal removed)— 0).
(21) where nMt i. j nMt (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k7 ) is jth identifier of the number of MNSI, which was transferred to foreign states and international organizations in the reporting period, and k7 is their number for each k2 , i.e. according to the specific ith secrecy vulture (let’s imagine that if = 1 , for k2 = 2 (i = 1,2) , k7 = 1 ( j = 1) , then (21) will be as:
2 1 1 = {⋃ ⋃
=1 =1 = {{ 1.1}, { = {{“6”}, {“1”}}, i.e., in the NAU, the number of MCCI, which were transferred to foreign states and international organizations in the reporting period with the vultures of secrecy “secret” (or
S)—6, and “top secret” (or TS)—1.
where nMf i. j nMf (i = 1, k2 , j = 1, k8.i ) is jth
identifier of the number of MNI with
restrictions on the access of foreign states and
international organizations (placed in columns
taking into account the comparison with the
secrecy of Ukraine following international
treaties), and k8.i is their number for each k2 ,
hat is, according to the specific ith security of
secrecy (for example, taking into account [
2 k8.i nMf = {{ nMfi.j }} =
i=1 j=1
= {{nMfi.1.1, nMfi.1.2}, nMfi.2},
where nMfi.j is set “The number of MCCI with
international organizations (put in columns
taking into account the comparison with the
secrecy of Ukraine following international
treaties)” includes [
which arrived in the reporting period”); nMfi.2 is set “The number of MCCI, which were produced in the reporting period on the order of foreign states or international organizations.”
For example, if = 1 for k2 = 2 (i = 1,2) ,
k8 = 2 ( j = 1,2) , k8.1 = 2 , k8.2 = 1 then (22),
taking into account the composition of the set
nMfi.1 , will be as [
2 2 k8.i nMf = {{{ nMfi.j.u}} = {{nMfi.1.1, nMfi.1.2}, nMfi.2} =
i=1 j=1 u=1 = {{nMf1.1.1, nMf1.1.2 ,},{nMf1.2}},{{nMf 2.1.1, nMf 2.1.2},{nsM 2.2}} =
= {{“20”, “15”}, {“30”}}, {{“10”, “5”}, {“5”}}, i.e., in NAU, the number of MCCIs with restrictions on the access of foreign states and international organizations (put in columns taking into account the comparison with Ukrainian secrecy vultures following international treaties) is as follows: 1) “secret” (or S): the total number of MCCIs as of the end of the reporting period: total—20, incl. which arrived in the reporting period—15; the number
k9 IS 4.9 = sU = { sU i } = {sU 1, sU 2 , ..., sU k9 }, i=1 of MCCI, which were produced in the reporting period on the order of foreign states or international organizations—30; 2) “completely secret” (or CS): the total number of MCCI as of the end of the reporting period: a total of 10, including which arrived in the reporting period—5; the number of MCCI, which were produced in the reporting period on the order of foreign states or international organizations—5.
(23)
where sU i sU (i = 1, k9 ) is ith identifier of the
access restriction vultures of the former USSR,
and k9 is their number. According to [
3 sU = { sU i} = {sU 1, sU 2 , sU 3} = i=1
= {“С”, “СС”, “ОВ”}.
k9 k10
IS 4.10 = nMu = {{ nMu i. j}} = {{nMu1.1},...,{nMu i. j},...,{nMu k9.k10 }},
i=1 j=1
(24)
where nMu i. j nM (i = 1, k9 , j = 1, k10 ) is jth
identifier of the number of MCCI with access
restriction vultures of the former USSR, and k10
is their number for each k9 , i.e. for a specific ith
vulture of access restriction of the former USSR
(for example, taking into account [
2 2 1 = {⋃ ⋃ =1 =1 = {{ 1.1, 1.2}, { 2.1, 2.2}} =
= {{“14”, “17”}, {“8”, “3”}}, i.e., in NAU, the number of MCCI with access restriction stamps of the former USSR is as follows: 1) “secret” (or S): the total number of MCCI as of the end of the reporting period (without taking into account interstate standards of limited distribution of the former USSR) is 14, the total number of copies of interstate standards of restricted distribution of the former USSR—17; 2) “top secret” (or TS): the total number of MCCI as of the end of the reporting period (not including interstate standards of limited distribution of the former USSR) is 8, the total number of copies of interstate standards of limited distribution of the former USSR is 3.
The developed model's general hierarchical structure (considering the given examples) is presented in Fig. 1 IS
IS 1 IS 2
A tuple model was developed, which, due to the set-theoretic representation of sets of tuple models of the integrated representation of the internal parameters of the state of provision of PSS, which reflect the values of the reporting period as a set characterizing the MCCI and the number of employees with access and admission to the PSS, etc., allows determining the required number of initial values to form a database, keep statistics and improve the formalization of the process of assessing damage (damages) from the loss of SS to the national security of Ukraine, both at the level of the state and the level of its regions, territorial communities following the legislation of Ukraine.
In the future, to implement the evaluation process, it is necessary to continue the development of a tuple model for the formation of a database of secondary parameters to improve the Method following domestic regulatory requirements, and in the future, taking into account the legislation of NATO member countries and the European Union. cherez-rozgholoshennya-derzhavnoitaiemnytsi/ [17] O. Korchenko, Y. Dreis, L. Derkach, A Theoretical-Multiple Approach to Assessing Damage to the National Security of Ukraine in the Event of a Leak of Information Constituting a State Secret, Guidelines (2021). [18] O. Korchenko, Y. Dreis, Tuple Model for Forming a Database of Primary Parameters for Assessing the State Secret Protection Status, Ukrainian Sci. J. Inf. Secur. 28(1) (2022) 35–42. doi: 10.18372/2225-5036.28.16911. [19] YouControl is a Counterparty Verification Service, a Catalogue of Court Decisions. URL: https://youcontrol.com. ua/catalog/court-document/10172467 6/ [20] National Aviation University (NAU).
URL: https://nau.edu.ua.https://nau. edu.ua/download/buhgalteriya/2021/S htatnij2021.pdf