=Paper=
{{Paper
|id=Vol-3679/paper19
|storemode=property
|title=Leveraging cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment for developing soft skills in future primary school teachers
|pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3679/paper19.pdf
|volume=Vol-3679
|authors=Olha Vasko,Oksana Bilier,Svitlana Kondratiuk,Nataliia Pavlushchenko
|dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/cte/VaskoBKP23
}}
==Leveraging cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment for developing soft skills in future primary school teachers==
https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-3679/paper19.pdf
Leveraging cloud technologies to create an effective
educational environment for developing soft skills in
future primary school teachers
Olha Vasko1 , Oksana Bilier1 , Svitlana Kondratiuk1 and Nataliia Pavlushchenko1
1
Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko, 87 Romenska Str., Sumy, 40002, Ukraine
Abstract
The article considers the possibilities of using cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment is
aimed at the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills. The experience of using cloud technologies
is demonstrated, the advantages, challenges and possible limitations of their use are revealed. Prospects for further
development of the topic are determined. The main aspects of the article include: clarification of the essence of
the concept of “educational environment” and signs of a quality educational environment; review of the potential
of cloud technologies for the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills; characteristics of the
SAMR model, which describes the levels of technology integration in the educational process; systematized data
on types of activities, their impact on the development of certain soft skills of future primary school teachers and
applied cloud technologies with practical implementation examples. The obtained research results are emphasized
the potential of cloud technologies in creating an effective educational environment is aimed at the development
of soft skills of future primary school teachers. The conclusions of the article can be served as a basis for further
research and the development of programs and strategies aimed at the effective use of cloud technologies in the
educational process.
Keywords
soft skills, educational environment, cloud technologies, future primary school teachers, SAMR model
1. Introduction
The need to develop soft skills of future primary school teachers is determined by the growing importance
of soft skills in modern society [1, 2]. In particular, the World Economic Forum’s 2023 Future of Jobs
Report 2023 emphasizes the need for the development of soft skills in connection with changes in the
field of work and rapid technological development. According to the report by the World Economic
Forum, 44% of workers’ skills will be lost in the next five years. Therefore, six out of 10 workers will
need training by 2027 [3]. Therefore, the criteria for quality training of future primary school teachers
will include matching the skills of a graduate of a higher education institution to the requirements of
the labour field and the need to undergo on-the-job training after graduating from a higher education
institution.
Taking into account the above, the training of future primary school teachers requires the creation of
an effective educational environment [4, 5] that will contribute to the development of education seekers’
soft skills, in particular, the Top-10 Skills published by the World Economic Forum in 2023. Among
which are cognitive skills such as creative and analytical thinking; three self-efficacy skills – curiosity
and lifelong learning, motivation and self-awareness, resilience, flexibility, and agility; technological
literacy; reliability and attention to detail; two skills for working with others – empathy and active
listening, leadership and social influence; quality control [3].
The importance of the development of soft skills in the future primary school teachers is evidenced
by the results of an electronic search from the outlined direction in the Google Scholar search system
CTE 2023: 11th Workshop on Cloud Technologies in Education, December 22, 2023, Kryvyi Rih, Ukraine
" Vasko.Olga@gmail.com (O. Vasko); oksana.biler88@gmail.com (O. Bilier); kondratiuks.m@gmail.com (S. Kondratiuk);
Pavluschenko.Natalya@gmail.com (N. Pavlushchenko)
0000-0001-5241-0958 (O. Vasko); 0000-0001-9969-3289 (O. Bilier); 0000-0002-3850-6731 (S. Kondratiuk);
0000-0002-7010-816X (N. Pavlushchenko)
© 2024 Copyright for this paper by its authors.
Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).
CEUR
ceur-ws.org
Workshop ISSN 1613-0073
Proceedings
127
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
and the ERIC database over the past five years. A combination of such words as: “the development of
soft skills” and “future primary school teachers” was chosen as keywords for research selection.
In Google Scholar, the search was carried out for words in Ukrainian and English, in the ERIC
database – in English. In Google Scholar, the total number of search results in both languages in which
one of the keywords occurs is 17,965 (in Ukrainian – 965, in English – 17,000). Both keywords – 294 (in
Ukrainian – 65, in English – 229); in the ERIC database – 8761 search results for publications in which
one of the keywords occurs, both keywords occur in 110 publications. The relevancy of all queries was
determined, and a subset representing 10% of the results in Google Scholar and ERIC was selected. By
reading the titles and abstracts, the selection of publications for detailed analysis was continued.
In a number of studies, the importance of the development of “soft skills” of future primary school
teachers is emphasized, which is substantiated by education reforms [6, 7]. The following are identified
as necessary soft skills for successful professional activity: communication skills, critical thinking,
creativity, emotional intelligence, flexibility of mind [6]; basic, communicative, social, thinking skills, self-
control, self-assessment [7]; communicative, social, positive self-concept, mental activity, self-control
[8]; teamwork, communication skills, critical thinking, ability to solve problems [9]; accountability,
communication, innovation, problem-solving, teamwork, professional working, and networking skills
[10]; lifelong learning skills, verbal and non-verbal communication skills [11].
Kasim et al. [10] proposed to form the soft skills of undergraduate students using the learning by
teaching technique, considering it as an alternative learning technique, in which the development of
soft skills becomes the goal of learning.
The focus of this research is to examine the ways in which new technologies can be integrated into
reflective English for Specific Purposes (ESP) teaching methods [12] to stimulate student motivation
and encourage the development of the aforementioned skills which are not only professional, but also
metacognitive in nature, within the context of first year non-specialist English language students in
Communication Studies [11].
The effectiveness of the integration of traditional and innovative teaching methods for the devel-
opment of “soft skills” of future primary school teachers is revealed in the study [6]. In particular,
attention is focused on encouraging students to reflectively evaluate their emotions, speech technique,
behaviour in the course of gaining practical experience and self-study [6].
Technologies for the development of “soft skills” in future teachers include, along with traditional
pedagogical technologies, the following: project activities, problem-based learning, and the creation of
a subject-development environment [13].
The study by Haran et al. [8] is also mentioned the integration of traditional and innovative technolo-
gies during distance learning, which contribute to the development of “soft skills” of student youth. It
is noted that the use of information technologies in distance learning allows the teacher to use a variety
of innovative technologies, which contributes to the development of “soft skills” of student youth [8].
The feasibility of using cloud technologies in the educational process of higher education institutions
is recognized today at various levels, including international organizations and normative documents
that set standards in the field of education [14].
UNESCO identifies the use of information and communication technologies as one of the main
strategies for the development of modern education, including the use of cloud technologies to improve
access to education, collaboration, and knowledge sharing [15].
Strategic documents of the European Commission, such as “Digital Education Action Plan (2021-2027)”
[16] and “European Commission digital strategy” [17] are emphasized the feasibility and importance
of integrating cloud technologies into the educational process to improve accessibility, efficiency, and
innovation. These documents are provided guidance and strategic support for the development and
implementation of digital solutions in the field of education using cloud technologies.
The European Union supports initiatives aimed at the use of cloud technologies in the field of
education. The “Horizon Europe” program [18] defines the development of digital infrastructures and
platforms, in particular cloud services, as one of the priority areas of funding.
Ukraine has declared the use of cloud technologies as one of the priorities for the development of
education in the context of the digital transformation of education. The project of the Concept of
128
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Digital Transformation of Education and Science for the period until 2026 is envisaged the use of cloud
technologies in education to create an infrastructure of cloud services in order to ensure access to
educational materials and create a digital educational environment [19].
These normative provisions are indicated that the use of cloud technologies in the training of future
specialists has strategic importance and is considered as an effective means of improving the quality of
education, promoting collaboration and providing access to various educational resources.
Interest in the problem of using cloud technologies in education is also followed by scientific events
devoted to this problem, in particular within the framework of the peer-reviewed annual international
computer science conference ICTERI [20] and annual CTE seminar on cloud technologies in education
[21].
The problem of using cloud technologies for the development of individual soft skills of students of
higher education is not new in modern educational practice. In particular, such aspects as:
• development of creative abilities of students as a component of the process of forming soft skills
with the help of remote technologies [22, 23]. It is determined that for the formation of the
creative abilities during distant learning it is advisable to use systems of education’s management,
to use cloud-technologies, systems of videoconferences’ organization, messengers [24, 25, 26];
• develop cloud resources to support chemistry education and the formation of soft skills in the
field of group work skills [27, 28, 29];
• using of cloud technologies for the formation and development of critical thinking in future
lawyers [30];
• research on the effectiveness of the use of cloud technologies by teachers in education using the
CTES tool [31], etc.
Therefore, the uniqueness of our scientific work is in the application of cloud technologies not as a
means for the formation of individual or complex soft skills of higher education seekers, but as a means
that allows creating an effective educational environment for the development of soft skills of future
primary school teachers.
The purpose of the article is to investigate the possibilities of cloud technologies for creating an
effective educational environment aimed at the development of soft skills of future primary school
teachers; consider practical examples of the implementation of cloud technologies in the educational
process of higher education applicants; identify the benefits, challenges and possible limitations of their
use.
To conduct this research, aimed at solving the problem of creating an effective educational environ-
ment for the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills by means of cloud technologies,
the method of exploratory research was chosen. This approach was made it possible to carry out
the systematic analysis and generalization of the available scientific literature and, on this basis, to
determine the relevance of scientific research, to reveal the definitions and essence of its main concepts
and the theoretical basis of the research, which became the basis for the development of didactic
materials for the creation of an educational environment aimed at the development of soft skills of
future teachers primary classes using cloud technologies. The special emphasis in the work was made
on the description of the experience of using cloud technologies in the preparation of future primary
school teachers to create an effective educational environment aimed at the development of their soft
skills. The analysis of which made it possible to highlight the advantages and disadvantages of their
application, and, as a result, to define a prospective research plan.
2. Application of cloud technologies to create an effective educational
environment for the development of soft skills of future primary
school teachers
The development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills is considered as an end-to-end process,
which is carried out when studying various educational components of educational and professional
129
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
training programs for future primary school teachers at both the first (bachelor’s) and second (master’s)
levels.
2.1. Definition and essence of “educational environment” concept
The definition and essence of the concept of “educational environment” is widely researched in scientific
and pedagogical literature [32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]. Petrenko [44] analyses and
compares different definitions of the term “educational environment”. She defines that the concept of
“educational environment” means the natural or artificially created environment of the participants of the
educational process in the space of education, which includes the content and means of education aimed
at ensuring the productive creative activity of the individual, his educational development, pedagogical
conditions, situations, the system of relations between people united by common pedagogical and
educational activities. In addition, the work revealed that the educational environment has qualitative
characteristics, its own environmental factors, and a multi-level structure with vertical interrelationships
between levels [44].
Loboda [45] examines the concepts of substantiation of the “educational environment” phenomenon
by modern scientists, focusing on approaches to the interpretation of the educational environment, such
as ecological-personal approach, communicatively oriented approach, anthropological-psychological
approach, eco-psychological approach. The author notes that a wide range of approaches to defining the
essence of the concept of “educational environment” has been formed in modern pedagogical science,
this is due to the complexity and multifaceted nature of this phenomenon. Loboda [45] makes similar
generalizations as the previous researcher, notes that the educational environment is understood as
both the natural and artificially created sociocultural environment of a person, which contains content,
various learning and education’ means, which ensure the process of personality development through
the creation of favourable for this condition.
So, in the context of our research, we define the concept of “educational environment” as a complex
set of conditions, resources, tools, and practices that contribute to the learning and development of
students of higher education.
2.2. Signs of the effective educational environment
The direction of our scientific search is determined by the creation of an effective educational environ-
ment for the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills. Therefore, the next steps are
related to the definition of the signs of an effective educational environment.
Studying the problem of the quality of the educational environment, we turned to the research
of Kosenko [46], which is presented recommendations on approaches to assessing the quality of the
educational space:
1. To clearly distinguish approaches to the assessment of the quality of the educational space in the
system of internal and external quality assurance of the institution’s educational activities.
2. Self-assessment of the quality of the educational space. In the institution, firstly, attention should
be paid to the factors that ensure safe and harmless conditions of stay of students and teachers.
3. Functional suitability of premises and site.
4. Availability of the necessary amount of furniture and equipment, compliance of the arrangement
of premises and areas of the territory according to the purpose and anthropometric features of
the users. This recommendation is directly related to the previous one.
5. Consideration of psychological and pedagogical factors. D. Kosenko notes that there are few clear
criteria in this field, therefore the task of the internal quality assurance system is to accumulate
and discuss, evaluate, systematize and generalize experience, on the basis of which conclusions
are drawn and to look for opportunities to implement the necessary changes.
6. Aesthetic aspect.
130
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
In the considered work [46], attention is focused on the educational space. Obviously, educational
environment and educational space are closely related concepts that describe the conditions, context,
and resources used to implement the educational process. However, they have some differences in
their perception and coverage. Educational environment is a broader concept which is covered all
aspects that affect the learning and development of students. Educational environment is included: the
physical environment (educational premises, furniture, equipment), social environment (interaction
with teachers, classmates, and other higher education students), organizational aspects (educational
and training programs, methods and approaches), as well as access to resources and technologies. As
mentioned above, the educational environment is created in order to promote learning, skill development,
stimulation of creativity and independence of education seekers.
Analysing the concept of “educational space”, we see that it, to a greater extent, is focused on the
physical and virtual space where learning takes place. Examples of educational space are educational
institutions, classrooms, libraries, laboratories, virtual platforms and other places where students of
higher education interact with teachers, classmates, other students of education. The educational
space includes physical and digital infrastructure that supports the educational process and facilitates
accessibility and interaction.
Thus, the educational environment is a broader concept that is encompassed all aspects that affect
the learning and development of learners, including the educational space. An educational space is a
specific physical or virtual environment where learning, interaction and communication take place.
The connection between the educational environment and the educational space is that the creation
of an effective educational environment is involved taking into account and organizing the physical and
virtual space, which is contributed to the learning and development of students of higher education.
The educational environment is defined the general principles, values, approaches to learning, while
the educational space is concretized these principles and turns them into concrete physical and virtual
means.
To determine the signs of the effectiveness of the educational environment for the development of
future primary school teachers’ soft skills, we focus on general principles, approaches to the education
of future primary school teachers, as well as the Top-10 Skills published by the World Economic Forum
in 2023. In view of the above, the effectiveness of the educational environment will be determined by
several features.
The first feature is characterized the focus of the educational environment on stimulating learning and
development of higher education seekers. This means that it should be promoted the active involvement
of students in the educational process, created comfortable conditions for acquiring knowledge and
developing skills.
The second feature is that the effective educational environment should be been conducive to
cooperation and interaction. It should support opportunities for collective and group work, exchange
of ideas and experiences between students and teachers. Such opportunities can be provided with the
help of joint work areas, project tasks, group discussions, use of common digital platforms and other
collaboration tools.
Another sign of the effective educational environment is the provision of an individual approach to
students of higher education. It should be contributed to understanding and, taking into account the
needs and interests of each student, stimulate their self-development and independence. This can be
provided through individual assignments, personalized learning programs, and a variety of materials
and resources.
An effective educational environment has to be technologically oriented. The use of cloud technologies
is one means of achieving this. They provide opportunities to access learning resources from any device
and from any location, collaborate and share knowledge in real time. This increases the accessibility of
learning, expands opportunities for collaboration and promotes innovation in education.
Therefore, an effective educational environment is characterized by such features as:
• stimulation of conditions for training and development of higher education seekers;
131
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
• favourable conditions for cooperation and interaction, both between students of higher education
and with teachers;
• individual approach to students of higher education;
• using modern technologies, including cloud technologies.
2.3. Possibilities of cloud technologies for the development of soft skills of future
primary school teachers
In our practical activities for the training of future primary school teachers, we have identified a
number of possibilities of cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment aimed at
the development of their soft skills.
Firstly, it is access to advanced educational content. With the help of cloud technologies, students of
higher education are given the opportunity to access a variety of educational materials, including video
lessons, interactive exercises, e-textbooks, and more. This is allowed to enrich the educational process
and make it more exciting and accessible.
Secondly, it is joint work and exchange of knowledge. Cloud technologies allow learners and teachers
to collaborate, exchange ideas and knowledge in real time and remotely. They can work on joint projects,
comment on and improve each other’s work, and discuss and analyse learning material.
Thirdly, it is online communication and collaboration. Cloud technologies provide the opportunity to
interact in real time through video conferencing, chats and forums. This promotes active communication
between students and teachers, joint solving of tasks, discussion of problems and communication outside
the classroom.
Fourthly, is personalized training. Cloud technologies are allowed to customize the educational
process according to the needs of each student. With the help of individual progress tracking systems,
teachers are able to provide a personalized approach to learning. Cloud technologies are made it possible
to adapt materials, tasks, and resources according to the individual needs and level of knowledge of each
student. Using analytics and collected data helps educators understand the needs of higher education
students and provide them with appropriate support and assistance.
Fifthly, it is independent learning and development. Students of higher education are given the
opportunity to access various educational resources, electronic libraries, online courses and tools for
independent acquisition of new skills and deepening of knowledge. They are able to set their own pace
of learning, explore issues that interest them, and develop their soft skills such as self-organization,
self-discipline, and self-management etc.
Sixthly, it is mobility and flexibility. With the help of cloud technologies, the educational environment
is become mobile and flexible. Students can access learning content and resources from any device,
anytime, anywhere. This allows them to learn at their own pace, conveniently organize their time and
adapt to personal needs and circumstances.
2.4. The SAMR model
The SAMR model (Substitution, Augmentation, Modification, Redefinition) is the conceptual model that
describes the levels of technology integration in the educational process. This model was developed by
Puentedura [47] in 2010 and provides educators with tools to evaluate and understand how effectively
they are using technology in teaching.
The SAMR model includes four levels:
1. Substitution. Technology is acted as a direct tool substitute, with no functionality [47]. The
substitution strategy is saved time and space, and reduced time-consuming tasks with pen and
paper [48]. The example of a substitution could be: using an electronic text instead of a paper one,
or uploading a sheet in PDF format for student access, as opposed to photocopying; encourage
students to print their work instead of writing by hand; using online tests and programs instead
of pen and paper; using a digital interactive whiteboard as opposed to a traditional whiteboard
132
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
and saving the results as a document [48]. Replacement is created favourable conditions for a soft
transition to the development of technological skills, compared to modification and transformation.
It is provided an opportunity for higher education students to familiarize themselves with new
technologies before they are begun to transform students learning [48].
2. Augmentation. Technology is acted as a direct tool substitute, with functional improvement [47].
In the augmentation phase, technology is added something to the learning process beyond conve-
nience, which can make a complex topic clearer or more exciting than traditional methods [48].
Examples of addition: using a translator to translate words from a foreign language; conducting
more informative and interesting oral presentations, which are supported by accompanying
multimedia presentation, created using, for example, PowerPoint, Prezi, etc.; using the Internet
for independent research on the topic; the instructions are supplemented with videos that explain
a particularly difficult concept to understand [48]. Supplementation is allowed for independent
and student-centered learning, and the use of technology as a source of information encourages
active learning that does not require constant teacher guidance [48].
3. Modification. Technology is allowed for significant task redesign [? ]. At this level, technology is
allowed changing tasks and provides new opportunities that were previously unavailable without
the use of technology. At the modification stage, technology is used to develop interactive
and dynamic tasks that are gone beyond the traditional classroom. For example, students can
collaborate on joint documents or work in large groups, which ensures seamless collaboration and
sharing of knowledge and experience. This interaction is based on the principle of “equal-equal”,
contributes to the formation of the ability to cooperate and the dynamic culture of the group.
Technologically modified assignments allow learners to create inspired and innovative work that
is not limited to paper [48]. Examples of modification: creation of a collective web project where
students can collaborate and interact; creating a podcast that is a summary of the topic that can
be accessed by other higher education students as a resource for review in the future; creating an
informative video presentation instead of a standard oral presentation; use of technological tools
that are allowed visualizing an abstract concept [48].
4. Redefinition. Technology is allowed for the creation of new tasks, previously inconceivable [47].
It changes the very essence of learning and contributes to the expansion of opportunities.
In the transformation stage, technology is used to create completely new opportunities for learning.
Transformation is had the potential to connect learning to the real world and produce real results. It
equips learners with strong technological skills such as digital collaboration, communication, technolog-
ical literacy and the ability to adapt to new systems and processes. Most importantly, using technology
to reimagine learning in the classroom leads to the emergence of active and interested education seekers
who embrace a growth mindset [48].
Examples of transformation: publishing one’s work online, for viewing by peers and the wider
community; recording of speeches with a presentation or practising of physical or other skills of
education seekers for further analysis and their discussion; experiment with tasks that use large
multimodal elements (e.g., creating short videos, a web page, printing documents with creative layouts,
etc.) [48].
The SAMR model is promoted the transition from simple replacement of technologies to their modifi-
cation and transformation in the educational process. It is created opportunities for the development
of creative and analytical thinking of students of higher education, promoted involvement in active
cooperation and co-creation, and also developed problem-solving skills.
The use of the SAMR model is allowed teachers to effectively introduce technology into the ed-
ucational process, stimulating the development of students of higher education. It is promoted the
active participation of students in education, involvement in various research tasks and projects that
contribute to the development of their creative and analytical thinking.
However, the SAMR model is not a strict line of progress. It is reflected in a graduation from simple
to complex use of technology, but successful learning also depends on the design of tasks that are
performed using technology, as well as on the appropriate guidance and support of the teacher.
133
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
The SAMR model is a useful tool for teachers, which is helped to rethink the use of technology in the
educational process and can be become an assistant in creating an effective educational environment
for the development of soft skills of future primary school teachers by means of cloud technologies.
2.5. The experience of using cloud technologies in the training of future primary
school teachers to create the effective educational environment for the
development of their soft skills
We consider practical examples of the application of cloud technologies to create an effective educational
environment for the development of soft skills of future primary school teachers in distance learning
conditions. In this case, the educational space was formed by the Moodle educational platform and
the Zoom video conference platform. The planning and creation of an educational environment for
future primary school teachers, which would be contributed to the development of their soft skills, was
carried out with a focus on the identified signs of the effectiveness of the educational environment and
the abilities of cloud technologies.
The focus on distance learning is due to the fact that in 2022-2023 in connection with the Russian
armed aggression against Ukraine the educational process at Sumy State Pedagogical University named
after A. S. Makarenko was taken place exclusively in a distance format. Note that the vast majority of
classes in the previous 2021-2022 school year were also held in distance due to the COVID-19 pandemic
[49]. However, the proposed options for using cloud technologies can be applied regardless of the
form of education, in particular, offline education. Because they are relied on BYOD technology, the
large number of the offered cloud technologies can be implemented using the mobile devices of higher
education students directly in the classroom.
The primary task was to find techniques, methods, means, and technologies that would allow creating
an effective educational environment for the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills.
To solve this problem, they relied on the SAMR model [47, 48] and The Padagogy Wheel by Carrington
[50].
Alan Carrington’s Pedagogical Wheel is a model developed by educator Alan Carrington for designing
and developing effective instructional design using technology. This model provides a framework for
integrating learning objectives, methods, technology, and assessment to achieve the best learning
outcomes.
The work carried out on the selection of cloud technologies for the creation of an effective educational
environment aimed at the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills was made it possible
to systematize data on the types of activities, their impact on the development of certain soft skills of
future primary school teachers and applied cloud technologies. The results are presented in Table 1,
where a plus sign “+” indicates a purposeful active influence on the development of the relevant skill, a
minus sign “–” – the absence of a purposeful influence on the development of the relevant skill.
According to table 1, we consider several examples of the use of cloud technologies in the aspect of
the research problem.
Example 1. Determining the emotional state, setting up for effective work
Determining the emotional state and setting up for effective work are important steps in creating a
supportive and enabling educational environment. This is allowed the participants of the educational
process to feel comfortable, feel supported and motivated, which contributes to their active learning
and development of soft skills. Cloud technologies can be used to collect and analyse data on the
emotional state of participants in the educational process. For example, with the help of Mentimeter,
Padlet, Jamboard applications, it is possible to quickly collect data on the emotional state of students at
the beginning of the lesson. This is enabled the teacher to respond in time to the emotional needs of
students of higher education and set them up for effective work.
Using the Mentimeter application, we offer such variations of this activity as: “Mood thermometer” –
we used the “Multiple Choice” template (see figure 1 (1)); “My mood” – the template “Multiple Choice”
134
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Table 1
Types of activities with corresponding cloud technologies for the development of soft skills of future primary
school teachers.
Types of soft skills*
Activities Cloud technologies
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Determining the emotional state, – + – – – + + + + – Mentimetr, Padlet, Jamboard, WodlWall, Inter-
setting up for effective work acty
Reflection – + + – – + + + – + Mentimetr, Jamboard, Padlet, WodlWall
Joint creative work in groups + + + + + + + + + + Padlet, Jamboard, Google Docs, Google Slides,
Canva
Collaborative projects + + + + + + + + + + Padlet, Jamboard, Google Docs, Google Slides,
Canva
Brainstorming, circle of ideas + + + + + + + + + + Padlet, Jamboard, Google Docs, Google Slides,
Canva
Data visualization + + + – – + + – – + Canva, Genially, Visme, Venngage, Mindomo
Visualization of ideas + + + – – + + + – + Canva, Genially, Visme, Venngage, Mindomo
Using online services for data + + + – – + + – – + Google, Google Scholar, Facebook, LinkedIn,
searching eLibrary, eLABa, YouTube
Creation of interactive educa- + + + – – + + – – + Canva, Genially, WodlWall, LerningApps, Ka-
tional materials hoot, Quizlet,LiveWorksheets, Wizer.Me, Wor-
dArt
Content creation + + + – – + + – – + Canva, Genially, Visme, Screenity
*Conditional marks: 1 – creative thinking; 2 – analytical thinking; 3 – curiosity and lifelong learning; 4 – stability;
5 – flexibility and dexterity; 6 – technological literacy; 7 – reliability and attention to details; 8 – empathy and
active listening; 9 – leadership and social influence; 10 – quality control.
was used (figure 1 (2)); “I feel myself” used the “Pin on Image” template (figure 1 (3)) and “I am at the
beginning of the lesson”— used the “Scales” template (figure 1 (4)).
In the Mentimeter application, we create a questionnaire using one of the above templates. For higher
education applicants, we provide a link and a QR code to access the questionnaire. In the first two cases
(“Mood thermometer” and “My mood”), we invite students to look at the presented options of emotions
and choose one of them that corresponds to their state here and now. When using the questionnaire
“How I feel myself”, we invite higher education’s students to look at the pictures and put a mark on the
one of them that best corresponds to their condition. After all higher education applicants have made
their choice, we analyse the results. Be sure to focus on the fact that you should not be ashamed to
express your emotions. Each person can feel both good and bad, that our condition is not something
permanent and not changeable. Be sure to discuss with students’ what resources they use to improve
their mood. We gradually form in them an understanding that if training takes place in a friendly and
joyful atmosphere, it will be effective, and we also focus attention on the fact that training itself should
also be joyful.
The questionnaire “I’m at the beginning of the class” is based on the Scales template, consists of two
scales – my mood and readiness for the class, each participant has to put a mark on them: where 1
is very bad, and 5 is very good. The group’s summarized results are displayed on a slide for further
analysis and discussion.
The tasks developed in the Mentimeter application to determine the emotional state of higher
education students according to the SAMR model are an example of modification, since they cannot be
carried out without using the application.
Another tool used to determine the emotional state of students was the online board Padlet. The
Mood Screen task variants created belong to the Substitution level, as they are substitutes for the Mood
Screen material variants.
Access to the board was provided through a link and a QR code. Two versions of the task were used:
1) they were suggested looking at the emoticons and choosing the one that most closely matches the
135
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Figure 1: Examples of questionnaires for determining the emotional state of higher education applicants
developed in the Mentimeter application.
student’s mood at that moment and marking it as a favourite (figure 2 (1)) they were recommended to
look at the emoticons and writing their last name under the emoticon that best matches the mood of
136
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
the student at that moment (figure 2 (2)).
Figure 2: Some variations of the “Mood Screen” created in the Padlet application.
The Jamboard online board was used by analogy with the Padlet online board to create a “Mood
Screen”. It also was served as a substitute for the physical version of the mood screen. Access to the
board was provided through a link and a QR code. Students of higher education were offered to look at
the presented variants of cactus emotions and choose the one that best matches the mood of the student
at that moment and move it up (figure 3). At the end, the results must be analyzed and discussed.
The experience of using the Mentimeter, Padlet, and Jamboard applications to determine the emotional
state of higher education applicants is showed that they are quickly allowed to cope with the specified
task. The Mentimeter app is allowed to get the fastest result and taken the least time to complete the
task, but Padlet and Jamboard are allowed to see not only the overall result, but also the results of
individual participants.
Example 2. Reflection
Reflection is important in the process of developing soft skills of future primary school teachers. It
is a process of introspection in which students of higher education examine in detail their thoughts,
137
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Figure 3: “Mood screens” which is created in relation to Jamboard.
emotions, actions, and interactions with others. In the context of soft skills development, reflection is
allowed future elementary school teachers to consciously evaluate their skills and understand how they
affect their professional development and interaction with other participants in the educational process.
The capabilities of the Mentimeter application made it possible to develop a task for conducting a
quick reflection. Based on the “Traffic Lights” question template, the “Microphone” task was created
(figure 4 (1)). The “Multiple Choice” template (figure 4 (2)) was used to construct a task in which one
should choose one of the statements regarding the overall assessment of the lesson and the level of
understanding of the material. The “Scales” template (figure 4(3)) made it possible to reflect on several
parameters: assessment of one’s activity, assessment of the teacher’s activity, assessment of content,
assessment of forms and methods of interaction. Each parameter was evaluated by students of higher
education on a scale from 0 to 5: where 0 – did not like it, and 5 – liked everything. The generalized
results of the group were displayed on a slide, which made it possible to analyse and discuss them.
If we analyse the tasks from the perspective of the SAMR model, then the first two reflection tasks
are examples of Augmentation, since such reflection options can be carried out using traditional means,
but the use of the Mentimeter application makes them more exciting. But the third option belongs to
the level of Modification, since it is not possible to carry out such a task using traditional means.
The experience of reflection using cloud technologies is showed such positive changes as:
1. Development of self-awareness of future primary school teachers. Reflection is allowed each
student of higher education to realize their strengths and weaknesses, which stimulates them to
actively work on their professional growth.
2. Personality development. Reflection is contributed to the personal development of students of
higher education, helped to expand their horizons, understood other points of view, developed
empathy and tolerance.
3. Improvement of skills. Reflective activity is allowed future primary school teachers to analyse
their work, identify strengths and weaknesses, and find ways to improve. This contributes to the
continuous improvement of professional skills of higher education students.
4. Supporting professional growth, as reflection, is a key element in the professional growth of
future primary school teachers. It is helped to identify areas in which can be improved soft skills
and inspired to: improve learning approaches, find new methods and use innovations in the
138
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Figure 4: Some examples of reflection tasks created using the Mentimeter application.
educational process.
Example 3. Collaborative projects
Collaborative projects are a form of joint work where participants combine their knowledge, skills,
and resources to achieve a common goal. In such projects, students of higher education work together,
collaborate, exchange ideas, interact and contribute to the process of creative work.
One of the variants of the collaborative project was work on creating a road map of the lesson.
At the beginning, students of higher education were united in teams of 3 people. Each of the teams
received the task:
1. Work out fragments of textbook pages and “enliven the page”, that is, develop a fragment of a
lesson based on this textbook, using an activity approach.
2. Record the developed fragment of the lesson with the help of a road map. Each team has 30
minutes to create a road map.
3. Place the created road map on the Padlet board (see figure 5).
4. To reflect using a framework for analysing the process of interaction between an adult and a
child.
In this case, the Padlet board (figure 5) was played several functions: as a board on which tasks were
placed, as well as electronic fragments of textbook pages; as a board for presenting work results; as a
139
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
Figure 5: The fragment of the Padlet online board while working on a joint project to create a lesson roadmap.
means of passing reflection. From the point of view of the SAMR model, this option of using the Padlet
is corresponded to the Modification level of the SAMR model.
Each team used the Jamboard online board to create a roadmap, justifying their choice by the
convenience of collaborative work.
The experience of involving students of higher education in collaborative projects proves that their
use contributes to the development of soft skills of future primary school teachers at several levels:
1. Communication. Collaborative projects are stimulated communication between participants,
which contributes to the development of listening skills, expressing one’s thoughts, interaction,
and cooperation. Participants learn to clearly and clearly express their ideas and opinions, take
into account the opinions of others, and find a common solution.
2. Work in a team. Collaborative projects are required joint work and interaction of participants. Par-
ticipants learn to cooperate effectively, delegate tasks, follow a work schedule and resolve conflict
situations. It is promoted the development of teamwork skills, leadership, and an understanding
of the roles and contributions of each member.
3. Analytical and creative thinking. Collaborative projects are often involved in solving complex
tasks or problems. Participants learn to analyse the situation, generate ideas, search for solutions
and evaluate their effectiveness. This contributes to the development of analytical and creative
thinking, a creative approach to solving issues and the ability to work with uncertainty.
4. Planning and organization. Collaborative projects are required in goal definition, resource
allocation, action planning, and task control. Participants learn to plan their time, manage tasks
and achieve their goals.
Example 4. Visualization of ideas
Visualization of ideas is the process of transforming abstract concepts, thoughts, ideas, or data into
visual forms that is allowed better understanding, representation and communication of these ideas. To
140
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
visualize ideas, it can be used the variety of tools such as charts, graphs, diagrams, maps, illustrations,
and other visual aids to convey information in a clear and accessible way.
Visualization of ideas helps to represent complex concepts, relationships, interactions, and information
in the form of graphic images, making it easier to understand and remember. Visualization is also
helped improve communication and collaboration because it allows you to visually share ideas and
interact with other people.
An interesting option for the visualization of ideas is to work on the task of creating a “Flower-card” –
five spheres of child development.
The students of higher education were offered, after familiarizing themselves with the content of the
question about the areas of child development, tasks of the following nature:
• Create a “flower-card” with five petals, on which to record keywords that ordain reveal the
meaning of each area of the child’s development.
• In the centre of the “flower”, write down a phrase that unites all these areas and is directly related
to the purpose of primary education.
• Take a photo/take a screenshot of the “flower-card” and add it to the Padlet board.
To create “Flowers-cards” (figure 6), students of higher education used such applications as Genially
(figure 6 (1)), Canva (figure 6 (2)), Visme (figure 6 (3)). In this case, the technologies are corresponded to
the Modification level of the SAMR model.
Figure 6: Some examples of performance of the task “Flowers-cards” by students of higher education.
In the context of soft skills development, visualization of ideas is helped to develop skills such as
creative thinking, communication, collaboration and analytical thinking. It stimulates the creative
process, helps enrich ideas, develop strategies and find innovative solutions. Visualization of ideas can
be used in educational, work and creative processes to improve communication, solving of problem,
project development and ensure effective collaboration.
2.6. Advantages, challenges and possible limitations of using cloud technologies
The experience of using cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment aimed at
the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills allows us to highlight the following
141
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
advantages of their use:
1. Availability. Cloud technologies are provided access to tools and resources from any device with
an Internet connection, allowing higher education students to use them anywhere, anytime.
2. Cooperation and communication. Cloud technologies are provided tools for collaboration and
communication that promote communication skills, collaboration, and effective teamwork.
3. Flexibility and adaptability. The use of cloud technologies is allowed future primary school
teachers to adapt to changing needs and situations, use a variety of tools and resources to develop
various soft skills.
4. Data storage. Cloud technologies are provided convenient storage and backup of data, which is
allowed to save important information and progress in the development of soft skills without the
risk of loss.
However, their use has a number of challenges and limitations:
Firstly, it is the computer literacy of all participants in the educational process, since the use of cloud
technologies requires users to have basic computer literacy and skills in working with digital tools.
Therefore, maybe, someone needs training and education to use these technologies effectively.
Secondly, it is the dependence on the Internet. It is obvious that the use of cloud technologies is
required constant access to the Internet, the lack of connection can be created obstacles to work and
collaboration, especially in conditions of limited Internet coverage or low-quality connection.
Thirdly, it is privacy and security. Storing data in cloud services can be raised questions about the
confidentiality and security of information. Be careful and use reliable services with proper security
measures to protect your data.
Fourthly – technical problems, such as system failures, unavailability of services, etc. This can be
affected in the continuity of the work and change the attitude of the interaction participants towards
the activity.
Fifthly, it is cost. Although many cloud services have free plans, full functionality and additional
features may require paid subscriptions or advanced plans. Financial aspects and budget must be taken
into account when using cloud technologies.
3. Conclusions
The study of the possibilities of cloud technologies for creating the effective educational environment
aimed at the development of future primary school teachers’ soft skills, the consideration of practical
examples of the introduction of these technologies into the educational process of higher education
applicants, as well as the identification of advantages, challenges and possible limitations is showed the
potential of cloud technologies in the field of development soft skills of future primary school teachers.
On the basis of the conducted research, we see further development of the topic from the following
perspective plans:
1. Expanding the analysis of modern publications on the research problem, for a more thorough
study of it.
2. Selection of tools for evaluating the validity of made didactic materials for creating an effective
educational environment aimed at developing soft skills of future primary school teachers.
3. Conducting the experimental study to assess the impact of the use of cloud technologies on the
creation of an effective educational environment was aimed at the development of soft skills of
future primary school teachers. This is allowed obtaining concrete data and conclusions about
the effectiveness of these technologies in the context of education.
4. Development of instructions and educational materials that ordain contribute to the successful
implementation of cloud technologies to create an effective educational environment is taken
for the development of soft skills of future primary school teachers. Convenient and accessible
instructions and educational materials help students of higher education master these technologies
and use them effectively in their practice.
142
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
5. The development of specialized platforms and resources that ordain combine materials, tools, and
examples of the use of cloud technologies for the development of future primary school teachers’
soft skills, help ensure the availability and ease of use of these resources.
6. Cooperation with other educational institutions and experts in the field of education to create a
platform for the exchange of ideas, transfer of best practices and joint development of innovative
approaches to the use of cloud technologies for the development of future primary school teachers’
soft skills.
Acknowledgments
We express our sincere gratitude to Sumy State Pedagogical University named after A. S. Makarenko
for a significant contribution to the training of future primary school teachers and promoting the
development of educational processes. We are extremely grateful for the access to resources and support
of our initiatives. Thank you for creating the proper conditions for the high-quality organization of
distance education, which made it possible to conduct our research.
We express our sincere gratitude to the Armed Forces of Ukraine for their constant service and
sacrifice in ensuring the sovereignty of our state, for the opportunity to work and carry out scientific
research.
References
[1] T. A. Vakaliuk, V. V. Kontsedailo, I. S. Mintii, Professional soft competencies of future software
engineers: key concepts, Educational Dimension 2 (2020) 101–110. doi:10.31812/educdim.
v54i2.3859.
[2] N. V. Bondar, T. V. Konovalenko, Developing soft skills in future foreign language teachers through
ICT, CTE Workshop Proceedings 11 (2024) 52–66. doi:10.55056/cte.692.
[3] The Future of Jobs Report 2023, Technical Report, World Economic Forum, 2023. URL: https:
//www.weforum.org/reports/the-future-of-jobs-report-2023/.
[4] I. Khyzhniak, K. Vlasenko, I. Viktorenko, V. Velychko, Training of future primary school teacher
for use digital educational resources in their professional activities, Educational Technology
Quarterly 2021 (2021) 103–117. doi:10.55056/etq.23.
[5] N. V. Bakhmat, Theoretical principles of cloud-based pedagogical environment design for primary
school teachers’ training, CTE Workshop Proceedings 3 (2015) 29–40. doi:10.55056/cte.242.
[6] L. Okhrimenko, Development of “Soft Skills” as a Component of Professional Training for Future
Primary School Teachers, The Youth and the Market 3 (2023) 162–165. doi:10.24919/2308-4634.
2023.277522.
[7] H. Pirozhok, Formation of Key Soft Skills in Students of Pedagogical College, Pedagogical sciences
98 (2022) 48–53. doi:10.32999/ksu2413-1865/2022-98-7.
[8] N. Haran, V. Zamorotska, K. Kolesnyk, Development of “Soft Skills” of Student Youth in the
Institution of Higher Education under the Conditions of Distance Learning, Humanization of the
Educational Process 1 (2023) 23–32. doi:10.31865/2077-1827.1(103)2023.284520.
[9] K. Karras, The Importance of Acquiring Soft Skills by Future Primary Teachers: A Comparative
Study, in: Towards the Next Epoch of Education, volume 20 of BCES Conference Books, Bulgarian
Comparative Education Society, Sofia, 2022, pp. 41–48. URL: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/
ED622699.pdf.
[10] U. Kasim, A. Muslem, F. Mustafa, The Effect of Learning by Teaching on Soft-Skill Improvement
among Undergraduate Students, European Journal of Educational Research 11 (2022) 1337–1348.
URL: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1353367.pdf.
[11] D. Di Pardo Léon-Henri, Going beyond words and actions: teaching metacognitive and soft skills
to ESP communication students at the dawn of the fourth industrial revolution, in: S. Papadima-
Sophocleous, E. K. Constantinou, C. N. Giannikas (Eds.), ESP teaching and teacher education:
143
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
current theories and practices, Research-publishing.net, 2019, pp. 147–161. doi:10.14705/rpnet.
2019.33.931.
[12] V. Lemeshchenko-Lagoda, I. Kryvonos, Interactive means of motivating students to learn English
for specific purposes at agrarian and technical universities, Educational Dimension 3 (2020)
233–250. doi:10.31812/educdim.v55i0.3950.
[13] L. Maliar, B. Popadych, I. Kuzma, Technologies for the Development of Soft Skills in Future
Teachers, Pedagogic Innovations in Professional Education 1 (2022) 38–43. URL: https://dspace.
uzhnu.edu.ua/jspui/handle/lib/45654.
[14] O. G. Glazunova, V. I. Korolchuk, O. V. Parhomenko, T. V. Voloshyna, N. V. Morze, E. M. Smyrnova-
Trybulska, A methodology for flipped learning in a cloud-oriented environment: enhancing future
IT specialists’ training, Educational Technology Quarterly 2023 (2023) 233–255. doi:10.55056/
etq.629.
[15] Lifelong learning opportunities for all: medium-term strategy 2022–2029, 2022. URL: https://
unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000380778.
[16] Digital Education Action Plan (2021-2027), 2024. URL: https://education.ec.europa.eu/focus-topics/
digital-education/action-plan.
[17] European Commission digital strategy, 2022. URL: https://commission.europa.eu/publications/
european-commission-digital-strategy_en.
[18] Horizon Europe, 2022. URL: https://commission.europa.eu/funding-tenders/find-funding/
eu-funding-programmes/horizon-europe_en.
[19] Concept of digital transformation of education and science: Mes invites public discussion, 2021.
URL: https://tinyurl.com/ye2326mm.
[20] 18th International Conference on ICT in Education, Research, and Industrial Applications, 2023.
URL: https://icteri.org/icteri-2023/.
[21] CITEd 2022, ACNS Conference on Cloud and Immersive Technologies in Education, 2022. URL:
https://cited.easyscience.education/2022/.
[22] V. B. Demianenko, Trends in the use of cloud computing technologies to create personalized
learning trajectories for students of the Minor Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, CTE Workshop
Proceedings 1 (2013) 84–86. doi:10.55056/cte.139.
[23] L. L. Nezhyva, S. P. Palamar, M. V. Marienko, Clouds of words as a didactic tool in literary education
of primary school children, CTE Workshop Proceedings 9 (2022) 381–393. doi:10.55056/cte.
127.
[24] A. I. Smirnova, Ways to improve the effectiveness of teacher, CTE Workshop Proceedings 2 (2014)
85–95. doi:10.55056/cte.192.
[25] H. Alieksieieva, N. Kravchenko, L. Horbatiuk, V. Zhyhir, O. Chernieha, et al., The Creative Abilities’
Development as the Component of the Process of Formation Soft Skills with the Help of Distant
Technologies, Creative Education 11 (2020) 2499. doi:10.4236/ce.2020.1112183.
[26] N. A. Khmil, Experience of preparing future teachers to use the cloud services to create presenta-
tions in the educational process, CTE Workshop Proceedings 3 (2015) 101–105. doi:10.55056/
cte.251.
[27] D. G. Naryshkin, Possibilities of cloud educational technologies in the study of physical chemistry,
CTE Workshop Proceedings 1 (2013) 154–155. doi:10.55056/cte.181.
[28] D. Semenkova, Cloud services as a tool for forming collaboration skills in chemical education, in:
The Youth of the 21st Century: Education, Science, Innovations : Proceedings of VIII International
Conference for Students, Postgraduates and Young Scientists, Vitebsk, 2021, pp. 169–171. URL:
https://rep.vsu.by/bitstream/123456789/30702/1/169-171.pdf.
[29] P. P. Nechypurenko, S. O. Semerikov, O. Y. Pokhliestova, Cloud technologies of augmented reality
as a means of supporting educational and research activities in chemistry for 11th grade students,
Educational Technology Quarterly 2023 (2023) 69–91. doi:10.55056/etq.44.
[30] Y. S. Shemshuchenko, E. M. Gerasymova, Z. S. Vykhovanets, I. L. Mosenkis, O. M. Strokal, Use of
Cloud Technologies in the Process of Professional and Linguistic Training of Law Students for
the Development of Academic Performance, International Journal of Higher Education 9 (2020)
144
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
310–320. URL: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1277484.pdf.
[31] A. T. Korucu, A. Karakoca, Development and Validation of the Cloud Technologies Usage in
Education Scale, Bartın University Journal of Faculty of Education 9 (2020) 69–82. doi:10.14686/
buefad.623459.
[32] M. P. Shyshkina, Modern trends in the formation and development of the scientific and educational
environment of a higher educational institution, CTE Workshop Proceedings 1 (2013) 7–8. doi:10.
55056/cte.59.
[33] T. V. Volkova, O. D. Humennyi, Forming the informational and educational environment of the
vocational school by means of blogs, CTE Workshop Proceedings 1 (2013) 79–80. doi:10.55056/
cte.110.
[34] V. S. Mkrtchian, N. I. Shyjan, About the educational environment of a cloud platform for managing
and modeling a variable structure in sliding mode, CTE Workshop Proceedings 1 (2013) 14–15.
doi:10.55056/cte.63.
[35] V. I. Bobrytska, S. M. Protska, The computer-oriented educational environment of higher educa-
tional establishment as an instrument of forming the professional competences for future teachers,
CTE Workshop Proceedings 2 (2014) 67–76. doi:10.55056/cte.190.
[36] Y. V. Gritsuk, O. V. Gritsuk, Online surveys as an element feedback in building cloud educational
environment, CTE Workshop Proceedings 2 (2014) 50–53. doi:10.55056/cte.186.
[37] S. H. Lytvynova, All-Ukrainian project “Cloud services in education” as a factor of development
of cloud-oriented educational environments in general educational institutions, CTE Workshop
Proceedings 3 (2015) 16–23. doi:10.55056/cte.223.
[38] N. P. Franchuk, Modern educational environment, CTE Workshop Proceedings 4 (2017) 7–11.
doi:10.55056/cte.317.
[39] V. B. Shapovalov, Y. B. Shapovalov, Z. I. Bilyk, A. I. Atamas, R. A. Tarasenko, V. V. Tron, Centralized
information web-oriented educational environment of Ukraine, CTE Workshop Proceedings 6
(2019) 246–255. doi:10.55056/cte.383.
[40] A. D. Uchitel, I. V. Batsurovska, N. A. Dotsenko, O. A. Gorbenko, N. I. Kim, Implementation of future
agricultural engineers’ training technology in the informational and educational environment,
CTE Workshop Proceedings 8 (2021) 233–246. doi:10.55056/cte.235.
[41] N. V. Morze, V. O. Kucherovska, Ways to design a digital educational environment for K-12
education, CTE Workshop Proceedings 8 (2021) 200–211. doi:10.55056/cte.232.
[42] Y. Kuchyn, O. Naumenko, O. Vlasenko, S. Lytvynova, O. Burov, I. Kucherenko, P. Mykytenko, The
experience of designing a single information and educational environment of the university “NMU
Digital”, Educational Technology Quarterly 2022 (2022) 73–87. doi:10.55056/etq.10.
[43] N. R. Balyk, G. P. Shmyger, Y. P. Vasylenko, V. P. Oleksiuk, Exploring modern trends in developing
a digital educational environment for university: A case study of Ternopil Volodymyr Hnatiuk
National Pedagogical University, CTE Workshop Proceedings 10 (2023) 45–63. doi:10.55056/
cte.545.
[44] O. Petrenko, Definition and essential content of the concept of “educational environment” in
the context of the modern educational paradigm, Innovation in Education 7 (2018) 6–16. URL:
http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/inuv_2018_7(2)__3.
[45] O. Loboda, The phenomenon of educational environment from the standpoint of modern ap-
proaches to it understanding, Pedagogy of creative personality formation in higher and secondary
schools 77 (2021) 19–22. URL: http://pedagogy-journal.kpu.zp.ua/archive/2021/77/part_2/5.pdf.
[46] D. Kosenko, Quality of educational space: approaches, criteria, as-
sessment tools, 2019. URL: http://www.education-ua.org/ru/articles/
1339-yakist-osvitnogo-prostoru-pidkhodi-kriteriji-instrumenti-otsinyuvannya.
[47] R. R. Puentedura, SAMR and the Learning Design Process, 2018. URL: http://hippasus.com/blog/
archives/425.
[48] J. Best, The SAMR Model Explained (With 15 Practical Examples), 2020. URL: https://www.
3plearning.com/blog/connectingsamrmodel/.
[49] L. A. Kartashova, A. M. Gurzhii, V. O. Zaichuk, T. M. Sorochan, Digital twin technology for blended
145
Olha Vasko et al. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 127–146
learning in educational institutions during COVID-19 pandemic, CTE Workshop Proceedings 11
(2024) 411–426. doi:10.55056/cte.666.
[50] A. Carrington, The Padagogy wheel–it’s not about the apps, it’s about the pedagogy, Teachthought
(2016). URL: https://www.teachthought.com/%20technology/the-padagogy-wheel/.
146