AI4EVIR 2025
AI for Evidential Reasoning 2025

Table of Contents

• Preface
  Summary: There were 9 papers submitted for peer-review to this workshop. Out of these, 6 papers were accepted for this volume, 4 as regular papers and 2 as short papers.

• On Reporting Likelihood Ratio's of Exhaustive and Non-Exhaustive Hypotheses about Rare Events in Criminal Cases 1-7
  Anne Ruth Mackor , Henry Prakken
• A Qualitative Logic for Uncertain Evidence and Belief Comparison 8-22
  Aybüke Özgün , Daira Pinto Prieto
• A Bayesian Justification for the Scenario Approach to Legal Proof 23-33
  Mario Günther , Conrad Friedrich
• The Quality Assessment of LLM in Digital Forensics 34-39
  Federico Costantini , Fausto Galvan , Pier Luca Montessoro , Francesco Crisci , Luca Baron
• Investigating the value of qualitative Bayesian networks of complete cases as "double-check" tools on traditional judicial reasoning: An exploratory study 40-71
  Leya Hampson , Ludi van Leeuwen
• Towards Trustworthy AI Results using Evidence Structures: From Certificates to Argumentation Frameworks 72-87
  Shawn Bowers , Bertram Ludäscher