The success of wikis for collaborative knowledge construction is triggering the development of a number of tools for collaborative conceptual modeling based on them. In this paper we present a completely revised version of MoKi, a tool for modelling ontologies and business process models in an integrated way.
1.1
Being a tool supporting the description of ontological and procedural knowledge according to OWL and BPMN, the basic element for MoKi are concepts, properties, and individuals in the ontology, and processes in the process model. Each instance of these elements is therefore associated to a MoKi page, composed of an unstructured part and a structured part.
The unstructured part This part contains text written following the standard MediaWiki markup format: in particular, it can contain plain text, possibly enriched by formatting information, links The work described in this paper has been partially funded by the European Commission under the contract number FP7-248594 1See http://moki.fbk.eu. 2See http://www.mediawiki.org.
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee.
Copyright 20XX ACM X-XXXXX-XX-X/XX/XX ...$10.00. to other MoKi pages or to external resources, uploaded images, and so on. The format of this part of the page is the same for all the different elements of the models.
The structured part This part, which is delimited by specific tags to separate it from the unstructured text, contains knowledge stored according to the modelling language adopted. In the current implementation, the structured part of a page describing an ontology element contains a RDF/XML serialisation of a set of OWL statements formalising the element, while, similarly, the structured part of a page describing a BPMN process contains an XML serialisation of the process diagram. 1.2
Users can access the ontological and procedural knowledge contained in MoKi using three different access modes: one mode, the unstructured access mode, to access the unstructured part of a MoKi page, and two different modes, the fully-structured access mode and the lightly-structured access mode, to access the structured part.
The unstructured access mode This access mode allows the user to edit/view the content of the unstructured part of the MoKi page of a model element. The editing/viewing of this part occurs in the standard MediaWiki way (e.g. see Figure 13).
The fully-structured access mode This access mode allows the user to edit/view the content of the structured part of a MoKi page using the full expressivity of the modelling language adopted. For ontological knowledge the fully-structured access mode allows the user to view/edit formal statements (axioms) describing the element associated to the page. Axioms are written according to the latex2owl syntax4 , an intuitive latex-style format for writing ontologies using a text-editor, format which can be automatically translated into (an RDF/XML serialisation of) OWL. The user can easily edit the list of axioms in a form based interface, as the one shown 3The content of the page in Figure 1 is an excerpt taken from Wikipedia. 4see dkm.fbk.eu/index.php/Latex2owl in Figure 2.
For procedural knowledge we have implemented an access mode that, by tightly integrating in MoKi the Oryx editor5, a full-fledged business process editor, allows the user to edit the BPMN process diagram described in the page.
The lightly-structured access mode The purpose of this access mode is to allow users with limited knowledge engineering skills, to edit/view the content of the structured part of the MoKi page in a simplified and less formal way. For ontological knowledge the lightly-structured access mode is provided through a form made of two components, as depicted in Figure 3. In the top half part the user can view and edit simple statements which can be easily converted to/from OWL statements. If the OWL version of any of these statements is already contained in the structured part of the page, then the corresponding fields are pre-filled with the appropriate content. Similarly, when any of these simple statements is modified in the lightly-structured access mode, the changes are propagated to the content of the structural part of the page. The bottom half of the form provides a description of those OWL statements which cannot be intuitively translated/edited as simple statements as the ones in the top half of the page. In the current implementation, this part contains the translation of those statements in Attempto Controlled English, provided by the OWL 2 Verbalizer6.
For procedural knowledge we have implemented an access mode based on a light-weight graphical process editor which uses a restricted subset of process building blocks. 1.3
Model Overview pages are MoKi special pages dynamically created from the (structured) content of the pages describing model elements. For ontological knowledge, the model overview pages 5See http://bpt.hpi.uni-potsdam.de/Oryx/ 6See http://attempto.ifi.uzh.ch. allow to explore the generalisation and part/subparts decomposition hierarchies of ontology concepts, as well as the classification of the ontology individuals. In particular, MoKi provides two kinds of model overview pages. In the tabular-based one, the user can access a table listing every concept (resp. individual) of the ontology together with the concepts of which it is a specialisation and the concepts in which it decomposes according to the part of relation (resp. the concepts to which the individual belongs to). In the graphical-based one, a tree-like view shows the hierarchy of concepts according to either the subclass or the part-of relation, or the membership of individuals to concepts. Drag and drop editing facilities are also provided to rearrange the tree. For procedural knowledge, the model overview page provides an overview of the process/sub-process decomposition mechanism by means of a table listing every process defined in MoKi together with the processes in which it decomposes. 1.4
The different versions of MoKi have been applied in several scenarios. Focusing on the usages with real domain experts, MoKi has been successfully applied by four application partners within the FP6 EU-project APOSDLE7 to develop enterprise models (composed of a domain ontology and a process model) in six different domains, and it is currently used by a team of knowledge engineers and domain experts to collaboratively build an Organic Agriculture and Agroecology Ontology within the FP7 EU-project Organic.Edunet8.
Although the version of the tool here presented is tailored to the
development of ontologies and business processes, the tool can be
customized to support modelling other kinds of knowledge. For
example, a preliminary version of the tool which support modelling
of clinical protocols according the ASBRU language is described
in [
In this paper we have presented a completely revised version of
MoKi, a tool for modelling ontologies and business process
models in an integrated way. The main novelties of the tool w.r.t. the
previous version presented ([
In our future work, we aim at improving the support for process modeling, in particular in providing an extensive automatic support for aligning the fully-structured access mode and lightly-structured access mode in case of procedural knowledge. We also aim at evaluating our tool further, on larger case studies. 7See http://www.aposdle.org/ 8See http://www.organic-edunet.eu/