=Paper=
{{Paper
|id=None
|storemode=property
|title=Eight Deadly Sins of GRL
|pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-766/paper01.pdf
|volume=Vol-766
|dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/istar/MussbacherAH11
}}
==Eight Deadly Sins of GRL==
<pdf width="1500px">https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-766/paper01.pdf</pdf>
<pre>
     CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




                           $"#.
 '3 $)-
*! 

              HAG8E
$HFF546;8E 
4A<8?
@LBG  4A7 '4GE<6>
8L@4AF

         8CG 
B9
*LFG8@F
4A7
B@CHG8E
A:<A88E<A:
4E?8GBA
,A<I8EF<GL
4A474
                                
 

    *6;BB?
B9
?86GE<64?
A:<A88E<A:
4A7
B@CHG8E
*6<8A68
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
&GG4J4
4A474
                                


                 
                   ')8 *
)8F84E6;
8AGE8
,A<I8EF<GL
B9
%4@HE
8?:<H@
                                  






         -.,. B4?
 @B78?<A:
 ?4A:H4:8F
 4E8 ABJ 4A
 <AG8:E4?
 C4EG
 B9
 E8DH<E8@8AGF
       8A:<A88E<A: 
+;8L
4??BJ
9BE G;8
FLFG8@4G<6
64CGHE8
B9
E4G<BA4?8F
9BE
FG4>8;B?78E
       A887F
 4A7
 8A45?8
 G;8
 E84FBA<A:
 45BHG
 CBG8AG<4? FLFG8@ FB?HG<BAF +;8
 :B4?
       BE<8AG87
 )8DH<E8@8AG
 #4A:H4:8
 )# <F
 5BG;
 4
 GLC<64? :B4?
 @B78?<A:
 ?4A
       :H4:8 4A7
 4A
 <AG8EA4G<BA4?
 FG4A74E7 L8G
 <G FH998EF 9EB@ @4AL F;BEG6B@<A:F
       4><A
 GB
 7847?L
 F<AF G;4G
 E8?4G8
 GB <GF 6BA6E8G8
 FLAG4K
 F8@4AG<6F
 4CCEB46;
 GB
       @B7H?4E<GL
4A4?LF<F
4A7
8KG8AF<5<?<GL 4F87
BA
 
 L84EF
B9
8KC8E<8A68
HF<A:
       )#
J8 7<F6HFF F8I8E4? F;BEG6B@<A:F 4A7
CB<AG
GB
E8?8I4AG
9HGHE8
JBE>
4E84F

        31*,- B4?
$B78?<A:
)# *LAG4K
*8@4AG<6F $B7H?4E<GL
A4?LF<F


      ).,*/.$*)

B4? @B78?<A: 9BE@F 4A
 <@CBEG4AG
 C4EG
 B9
 E8DH<E8@8AGF
 8A:<A88E<A: 
 &I8E
 G;8 ?4FG
786478
 G;EBH:;
 8KC8E<8A68 78I8?BC<A:
 FG4A74E7<M<A:
 4A7 HF<A: G;8
 B4?BE<8AG87
)8DH<E8@8AG
#4A:H4:8
)# 23
J8
;4I8
B5F8EI87
F8I8E4? <@CBEG4AG <FFH8F G;4G J8
6BAF<78E
GB
58 4><A
GB T7847?L
F<AFU .8
4?FB
FHFC86G
G;4G
@4AL
B9
G;8F8
F<AF 6BH?7 58
:8A8E4?<M87
GB
 BG;8E
 :B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F
FH6;
4F
< "&*
4A7
+EBCBF
 ;8A68
G;8<E
 :8A8E4?
 <AG8E8FG
 GB
 G;8
 :B4?
 @B78?<A:
 6B@@HA<GL A
 G;8
 9B??BJ<A:
 F86G<BA
 J8
5E<89?L
 F8G
 BHG
 BHE
 E8F84E6;
 B5=86G<I8F
 4A7
 <A
 *86G<BA 
 J8
 7<F6HFF
 G;8
 <78AG<9<87
<FFH8F 
*86G<BA  CEBI<78F
BHE
6BA6?HF<BA
4A7 E8CBEGF <A
4
98J
JBE7F BA
9HGHE8
JBE>


       - ,# % .$0 -

.8
4<@
GB
<@CEBI8
G;8
FG4G8
B9
G;8
4EG
B9
:B4?
@B78?<A:
5L
9<EFG
<78AG<9L<A:
F;BEG6B@
<A:F
<A BA8 B9
G;8
@4<AFGE84@ :B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F )#
G;8A
4A4?LM<A:
G;8F8
F;BEG6B@<A:F
FLFG8@4G<64??L
<AI8FG<:4G<A: <784F
BA
;BJ
GB
477E8FF
G;8@ 4A7
9<A4??L
CEBI<7<A: FB?HG<BAF
 9BE
 G;8F8 F;BEG6B@<A:F G;4G
 64A
 58
 <A6BECBE4G87
 <AGB G;8
 )#
FG4A74E7 4A7
C8E;4CF
<AGB
BG;8E
:B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F 8E8
J8 E8CBEG BA G;8 6HE
E8AG?L <78AG<9<87 8<:;G @4=BE F;BEG6B@<A:F
4A4?B:BHF
GB
7847?L
F<AF
G;8
F8I8A
6B@
@BA
BA8F
C?HF 8FC4<E B9 )# ?4A:H4:8
78F<:A8EF 4A7
GBB?
5H<?78EF <A6?H7<A:
HF




                                                  2
      CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




      $ ).$!$
 *).,$/.$*)-

+;8
?<FG
B9 8<:;G F<AF
B9
:B4?
@B78?<A: ?4A:H4:8F
<A
G;<F
F86G<BA
FG4EGF J<G;
<FFH8F
E8
?4G87 GB
 G;8
 FLAG4K
 B9
 :B4?
 @B78?<A:
 ?4A:H4:8F *86G<BA  
 G;8A
 6BAG<AH8F
 J<G;
F8@4AG<6
 <FFH8F *86G<BA  
 4A7
 6BA6?H78F J<G; <FFH8F E8:4E7<A: @B7H?4E<GL *86
G<BAF    
4A7   4A4?LF<F *86G<BAF   4A7  
4A7
8KG8AF<5<?<GL
*86G<BA  
.;8A8I8E 4CC?<645?8 78C8A78A6<8F
58GJ88A
<FFH8F
4E8
FG4G87


    ,$         &
*!
/++*,.
!*, /'.$+'                                                                                                                                                                          *), . 
3).2 -
B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F
4E8 HFH4??L I8EL
CEBH7
B9
G;8<E
I<FH4?
E8CE8F8AG4G<BAF B4?
@B78?F
;BJ8I8E G8A7
GB
58
6B@C?8K
J<G;
@4AL
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
4@BA: @4AL
<AG8AG<BA
4?
 8?8@8AGF 4A7
 46GBEF A
 477<G<BA <G
 <F
 7<99<6H?G
 9BE
 BA8
 F<A:?8
 6BA6E8G8
 FLAG4K
 GB
FHCCBEG
G;8
@4AL
GLC8F
B9
:B4?
?4A:H4:8
HF8EF
<A
G;8<E
I4E<BHF
@B78?<A:
4A7
4A4?LF<F
G4F>F 
 BE
8K4@C?8
J;<?8
)#SF :E4C;<64? FLAG4K ;8?CF J<G; G;8 HA78EFG4A7<A:
4A7
4A4?LF<F
B9
:B4?
@B78?F 4F
4A
BHGCHG
E8CE8F8AG4G<BA <G
<F
B9G8A <A899<6<8AG
4F
4A
<ACHG
E8CE8F8AG4G<BA 4F
 <G G8A7F GB
 F?BJ
 7BJA
 G;8
 6E84G<BA
 4A7
 @4<AG8A4A68
 B9
 6B@C?8K
@B78?F 8<A:
?4E:8?L
54F87
BA
<
)#SF ABG4G<BA 4?FB
?<>8?L
FH998EF
9EB@ @4AL
B9
G;8
789<6<8A6<8F
<78AG<9<87
9BE
<
<A
G8E@F
B9
6B:A<G<I8
89986G<I8A8FF
2 3 +;8
6HEE8AG
FLAG4K
 6BH?7
 58
 E8I<F87
 GB 9<K
 G;8F8
 789<6<8A6<8F
 4A7
 A8J
 :E4C;<64?
 FLAG4K8F
 6BH?7
8I8A
58
47787 9BE
FC86<9<6
GLC8F
B9
HF8EF $BE8BI8E 4 @BE8
CE46G<64? G8KGH4?
6BA6E8G8
FLAG4K ?<>8
 4
 CEB:E4@@<A:
 ?4A:H4:8
 J<G;
 4
 FH<G45?8 AG8:E4G87
 8I8?BC@8AG
 AI<
EBA@8AG
6BH?7 
 58
@478
4I4<?45?8
G;<F
G<@8
@4<A?L
4F
4A
4?G8EA4G<I8
<ACHG
E8CE8
F8AG4G<BA 
 
 CEBCBF4?
 J4F
 @478 5L
 #<H
 4A7
 0H <A
 G;8<E BE<:<A4?
 )#
 CEBCBF4? 2 3
5HG
J4F
 A8I8E
9B??BJ87HC
4A7 <G A8I8E
 @478
<G
GB
G;8
FG4A74E7 *<@<?4E?L
9BE
 HF8EF
HA94@<?<4E
 J<G;
 :B4?
 @B78?<A: 4 G45H?4E54F87
 E8CE8F8AG4G<BA N
 ?4
 BHF8
 B9
 (H4?<
GL 23 @4L
58
HF87 <: 
 F;BJF
4A
8K4@C?8
B9
J;4G <: 6BH?7
?BB>
?<>8
<A
4
G45H
?4E
 9BE@
 8 : 
 <AG8AG<BA4?
 8?8@8AGF
 4E8
 F;BJA
 J<G;
 G;8<E
 GLC8F
 ?<A>F
 9EB@
 EBJF
 GB
6B?H@AF
4A7
5<A7<A:F
GB
46GBEF
F;BJA 4F <@CBEG4A68
?8I8?F
58GJ88A
 
4A7
                
        
                               

 
 
                                                                      

 
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         
&!

##
"
""""#
                                                                                                                                                     !!
$
 !"
"$!%




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
 $
!
$!#'

#
                                                $
"#
#"

$




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              !%
!$!
! !#"
#

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          
#!%
""""#




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ##
#!
#!
 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      


"$!%

                                                                                                                                                                                           "#
!
 "#
'




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    $

'#
                                                                                    ""
"$!%



                                                                                                                            #!
"$!%




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      
 $ #
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   "$!
 !%'
                                                                                                           #!
#!




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         
#




        $
"#
#"

$                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

                                                                               
        ""
"$!%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        

        #!
#!                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              

        #!
"$!%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

        !!
$
 !"
"$!%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                     

        "#
!
 "#
'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 

         
#!%
""""#                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             
                

         
&!

##
"
""""#                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        
                

        !%
!$!
! !#"
#
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             
                                                                                
          
 $
!
$!#'

#                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          
                                                            
        


"$!%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
                           
         "$!
 !%'                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
              


                $"  K4@C?8 B9
'BG8AG<4?
+45H?4E )8CE8F8AG4G<BA B9
4
B4?
$B78?




                                                                                                                                                    3
      CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




                                                     & ,            ,
*'!+$
                                                                   +*
'
& ,
                                                     /*+%                     
          ++                                                                                                           '%
                                                                                 
         +')                                                                                      +')              ,(&+
         '&+)'$                                                                                   *,)-!$$&
         !!$       (
(,$!
                    !&')%
,)+$/              !**                                            
                         &
+!%$/                *,)-!$$&                                                                     &*,)
                                                                      +')                                                        ()!-/
                                                                      '&+)'$
                                             )'-!
) ,$)
                                             )(')+*
+'
++                         )')%
& ,          *+
')
                                              +')
'&+)'$                              ()%!*            (*+!!
                                               !!$
        
                     *,)-!$$&          !/       



                !$
                  &+                                                        !$
                           '

 ''                                       &+)!-&             '%
'.&)

                         *,)-!$$&
"'                                 ****%&+                +&&+
*$
                                                                                                    ****%&+




                                            $"  K4@C?8
9BE
$B7H?4E<GL
 FFH8F

+;8
I4E<BHF
/$#
9BE@4GF
CEBCBF87
BI8E
G;8
L84EF
23 4E8
:BB7
4F
<AG8E6;4A:8
9BE
@4GF
 5HG
 ABG
 9BE
 ;H@4A
 <ACHG 
 +;<F
 6BA6E8G8
 FLAG4K
 <FFH8
 <F
 BEG;B:BA4?
 GB
 4??
 BG;8E
<FFH8F
78F6E<587
<A
*86G<BA 


     )03 &
*!
*, 
*,('  ().$-
B4?
 ?4A:H4:8F
 4E8
 B9G8A
 8AI<BHF
 B9
 G;8
 @4GHE<GL
 B9
 BG;8E
 @B78?<A:
 ?4A:H4:8F
 <A
G8E@F
B9
FG4A74E7<M87
F8@4AG<6F )#
CBFF8FF8F
4
9BE@4?
45FGE46G
FLAG4K
<A
G;8
9BE@
B9
4
FG4A74E7
@8G4@B78? BJ8I8E G;8 @84A<A:
B9
4 )# @B78?
<F
?4E:8?L
789<A87
5L
G;8
8I4?H4G<BA
@86;4A<F@
6;BF8A
9BE G;4G @B78? 8 : 
I4E<BHF
64G8:BE<8F
B9
@86;
4A<F@F
4E8
CE8F8AG87
<A
23
J<G;
BG;8E
4A4?LF<F
G86;A<DH8F
<A 23 +;8
9BE@4?
HA78E
C<AA<A:
9BE
8I4?H4G<BA 4A4?LF<F @86;4A<F@F
<F
E4G;8E
47 ;B6 BAF8DH8AG?L
<G
<F
7<99<
6H?G
GB
HA78EFG4A7
J;L
BA8
@86;4A<F@
F;BH?7
58
6;BF8A
BI8E
4ABG;8E &A8
BCG<BA
GB
<@CEBI8
9BE@4?<GL <F
G;8 789<A<G<BA 4A7
I4?<74G<BA B9
4 E898E8A68 9BE@4? F8@4AG<6F
9BE
)# EBBG87
 <A
 @4G;8@4G<6F <AFG847
 B9
 GLC<64?
 BC8E4G<BA4?
 F8@4AG<6F <A
 G;8
 9BE@
 B9
4?:BE<G;@F
 9BE
 <AFG4A68 5L
 9B??BJ<A:
 G;8
 :H<78?<A8F
 CEBCBF87 <A 23 
 +;<F
 6BH?7
 58
9B??BJ87
 5L
 G;8
 78I8?BC@8AG
 B9
 6B@C?<4AG <AG8ECE8G4G<BAF <A
 G;8
 9BE@
 B9 6BAFGE4<AG
F4G<F946G<BA
CEB5?8@F 9BE J;<6; CBJ8E9H?
4A4?LF<F
G86;A<DH8F
4A7
GBB?F 4?E847L 8K<FG


     /-. &
*!
/++*,.
!*,
). ,! 
 !$)$.$*)-
.;<?8
 <G
 <F
 FB@8J;4G
 CBFF<5?8
 GB
 6BAF<78E
 4A
 46GBE
 4F
 4A
 8A64CFH?4G87
 HA<G
 G;<F
 <F
DH<G8
7<99<6H?G
9BE
4
G4F>
BE
4AL
BG;8E
<AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AG
G;4G
<F
58<A:
786B@CBF87
<AGB
?BJ8E
?8I8?
8?8@8AGF 
I8A
J<G;
46GBEF
4
6?84E
<AG8E9468
789<A<G<BA
<F
45F8AG
?847
<A:
 GB
 ?HFG9H?
 F<GH4G<BAF
 58GJ88A
 @B78?<A:
 8?8@8AGF 
 8C8A78A6<8F
 ;8?C
 GB
 4
 68EG4<A
8KG8AG
 GB
 F8C4E4G8
 :B4?
 GE88F
 B9 I4E<BHF
 46GBEF
 5HG E8?4G<BAF;<CF 4@BA:
 8?8@8AGF
 B9
7<998E8AG
46GBEF
 @4L
 B66HE
4G 4AL
 ?8I8?
 B9
45FGE46G<BA
F88
 ;BJ
G;8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
58
GJ88A
G;8
9BHE
46GBEF
<A <: @4A<98FG
G;8@F8?I8F
4G
7<998E8AG
786B@CBF<G<BA ?8I8?F


     '*.# & *!
/++*,.
!*,  '.$*)-#$+ -.,.$*)-
 A
)#
G;8E8
<F
AB
FHCCBEG
5BG;
9EB@
4
?4A:H4:8
78F<:A
CB<AG
B9
I<8J
4A7
9EB@
4
GBB?
FHCCBEG
CB<AG
B9
I<8J
9BE 78F6E<5<A: G;8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
B9
4A
<AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AG




                                                                                4
      CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




54F87
BA
G;8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
B9
<GF
6BAFG<GH8AG
8?8@8AGF 
F
4A
8K4@C?8
6BAF<78E
J;4G
G;8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
B9
G;8
;<:;?<:;G87 G4F> <A <: F;BH?7
58 &A?L
BA8 6BAGE<5HG<BA
<F
F;BJA 9BE
G;<F
G4F>
5HG
F8I8E4?
BG;8EF
8K<FG
J;8A <GF ?BJ8E?8I8?
8?8@8AGF
4E8
G4>8A
<AGB
466BHAG 
&9
6BHEF8 ABG
8I8ELG;<A:
A887F
GB
58
F;BJA
<A 4
C4EG<4?
I<8J
FH6;
4F 4
:B4?
:E4C;
5HG
G;8E8
F;BH?7
58
FB@8
J4L
GB
I<8J 
 E8?4G<BAF;<CF
B9
4AL
:<I8A 46GBE
BE <AG8AG<BA4?
 8?8@8AG +BB? 5H<?78EF
 4E8 F?BG;9H? <A
 G;8<E FHCCBEG
 9BE
 7LA4@<64??L
78E<I<A: 9EB@
G;8
6B@C?8G8
:B4?
@B78? 4
I<8J
9BE
4
C4EG<6H?4E
8?8@8AG G;4G G4>8F G;8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
B9
<GF
6;<?7E8A
<AGB
466BHAG 
HEG;8E@BE8
<G
F;BH?7
58
CBFF<5?8
GB
8KC?BE8
4 :B4?
 @B78?
J<G; <AG8E46G<I8
DH8E<8F FH6;
4F
TF;BJ
 @8
4?? <AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AGF
9BE
G;<F
46GBEU
4A7
T8KC4A7
G;<F
<AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AGSF E8?4G<BAF;<CF 5L GJB ?8I8?FU E4G;8E
G;4A
=HFG
;4I<A:
FG4G<6
I<8JF DH8E<8F
4E8 4
6B@@BA
984GHE8
B9
,$#
@B78?<A:
GBB?F
   .;<?8 7LA4@<6
 I<8JF
 4E8 @BFG?L
 4
 GBB?
 FHCCBEG
 CEB5?8@
 9BE
 4A
 4?E847L
 9<A4?<M87
:B4?
@B78? 4A 4E:H45?L 8I8A
JBEF8 F<GH4G<BA B66HEF
J;8A
G;8
:B4?
@B78?
<F
5H<?G
<A
G;8
 9<EFG
 C?468 #8G
 HF
 4FFH@8
 G;4G
 4 6BAGE<5HG<BA ;4F
 588A
 789<A87
 9BE
 4
 ;<:;?8I8?
<AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AG
GB <A7<64G8
G;<F <@CBEG4AG E8?4G<BAF;<C 4G
G;<F ?8I8?
B9
45FGE46G<BA
.;8A
786B@CBF<A:
G;8 8?8@8AG
<AGB
?BJ8E?8I8?
8?8@8AGF
BA8
@4L
J4AG
GB
4?FB
E8
9<A8
G;8 6BAGE<5HG<BA F;BJA 9BE G;8
8?8@8AG 
+;<F
;BJ8I8E
<F
GLC<64??L
ABG
CBFF<5?8
J<G;BHG
 ;4I<A:
 GB
 E8@BI8
 G;8
 ;<:;8E?8I8? 6BAGE<5HG<BA 4A7
 6BAF8DH8AG?L
 ?BF<A:
 G;8
;<:;?8I8?
 BI8EI<8J 
 %BG8
 G;4G
 G;<F
 <FFH8
 78C8A7F
 F<:A<9<64AG?L
 BA
 G;8 AIL .E4G;
4A7 #HFG F<AF 9BE@4?
 F8@4AG<6F
 J<G;
 CEBC8E FHCCBEG
 9BE
 45FGE46G<BAF
 JBH?7
 4??BJ
<AG8E9468F
GB
58
789<A87
@BE8
84F<?L
4G
I4E<BHF
?8I8?F
B9
45FGE46G<BA 4A7
I<68
I8EF4


    '/..*)3 &
*!
/++*,.
!*,
 +,.$*)
*!
 *) ,)-
)# FH998EF 9EB@
 :?HGGBAL
 <A
 G;4G
 4??
 6BA68EAF
 B9G8A
 A887
 GB
 58
 6BAFH@87
 4G
 BA68
.<G;
4FC86GBE<8AG87
@B78?<A:
586B@<A:
@BE8
4A7
@BE8
C4EG
B9
@4<AFGE84@
@B78?
<A:
 G86;A<DH8F
 :B4?
 @B78?F
 F;BH?7
 FHCCBEG
 G;8
 <78AG<9<64G<BA
 4A7
 8A64CFH?4G<BA
 B9
6BA68EAF
E8:4E7?8FF
B9
J;8G;8E
G;8L
4E8
6EBFF6HGG<A:
BE
ABG 
+;<F
@4L
<AIB?I8
F<@C?8
FHCCBEG
9BE
G4::<A:
4A
8?8@8AG
4F
58<A:
C4EG
B9
4
6BA68EA
GB
9H??9?87:87
FHCCBEG
9BE
4FC86GBE<8AG87
 @4G6;<A:
 4A7
 6B@CBF<G<BA 2 3 $B78?
 GE4AF9BE@4G<BAF 2 3 4A7
 FH:
:8FG<BAF
 @478
 9BE
 < 23 @4L
 4?FB
 ;8?C
 477E8FF
 G;<F
 @B7H?4E<GL
 <FFH8 
 ?HGGBAL <F
?4E:8?L
4A
BEG;B:BA4?
<FFH8
GB
4??
BG;8E
<FFH8F
<A
*86G<BA 


    ,.#      )'3-$- )*('$ -
+;8E8
<F
4 9EHFGE4G<A:
4A7
8I8A <A9HE<4G<A: <AG8E46G<BA
58GJ88A
G;8
78F<E8
GB
I<8J
E8?4
G<BAF;<CF
 4G
 7<998E8AG
 ?8I8?F
 B9
 45FGE46G<BA
 4A7
 G;8
 78C?BL87
 8I4?H4G<BA
 @86;4A<F@F
G
G;8
;84EG
B9
G;<F
<FFH8
<F
G;4G 4
E8?4G<BAF;<C
F;BJA
4G
@BE8
G;4A
BA8
?8I8?
B9
45FGE46
G<BA
@HFG
58
G4>8A
<AGB
466BHAG BA?L
BA68
7HE<A:
4A4?LF<F .;<?8
G;8 ?89G
4A7 @<77?8
)# :E4C;F <A <:  4E8
8DH<I4?8AG
G;8 E<:;G :B4? :E4C; ?847F
GB
4
7<998E8AG
8I4?H4
G<BA
E8FH?G 5864HF8
E8?4G<BAF;<CF
J<G;
G;8
FB9G:B4?
4E8
F;BJA @4AL
G<@8F 4G
7<998E8AG
?8I8?F
B9
45FGE46G<BA 
HEG;8E@BE8
G;8 6BAGE<5HG<BA
I4?H8
9BE
G;8
;<:;8E?8I8?
G4F> <A
G;8 @<77?8 :B4?
 :E4C; A887F
 GB
 58 F8G GB  GB
 E89?86G
 G;4G G;8
 6BAGE<5HG<BAF
 B9 5BG;
FH5G4F>F <A
G;8 ?89G :B4?
:E4C; 4E8
6B??4CF87
<AGB
BA8
;<:;8E?8I8?
6BAGE<5HG<BA




                                              5
     CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




                                                                           
                                                                                
        '+ '$        *#
          '+ '$        *#
          '+ '$         *#

                                                                                  
                                                                         
                                                                           

        *#
          *#
         *#
          *#
         *#
           *#
 


                                $"  K4@C?8
9BE
A4?LF<F AB@4?L

.;<?8
)#
4??BJF
946GBEF
GB
58
789<A87
9BE
<AG8AG<BA4?
8?8@8AGF
GB
7<998E8AG<4G8
G;8<E
<@CBEG4A68
 GB
 4
 FG4>8;B?78E
 G;8
 <@CBEG4A68
 B9
 FG4>8;B?78EF
 G;8@F8?I8F
 <F
 GLC<64??L
ABG
 64CGHE87
 8I8A
 G;BH:; 4??
 FG4>8;B?78EF 7B
 ABG ;4I8
 G;8
 F4@8
 <A9?H8A68
 BI8E
 G;8
FLFG8@ HA78E
 6BAFGEH6G<BA 
 *<@<?4E?L
 FB@8
 <AG8AG<BA4?
 8?8@8AG @4L
 58
 ABA
A8:BG<45?8
9EB@
G;8
CB<AG
B9
I<8J
B9
BA8 FG4>8;B?78E 5HG
ABG
9EB@
G;8
CB<AG
B9
I<8J
B9
4ABG;8E FG4>8;B?78E
5HG
G;<F
<F
4?FB
ABG
64CGHE87


      -+$,  )$)"' --
/( ,-
,*' (
$B78?8EF
DH<6>?L
?BF8
;BC8
<A
8KC?B<G<A:
:B4?
@B78?F <A
4
HF89H?
J4L J;8A
G;8 @B7
8?F 7B
 ABG
 CEBC8E?L
 E89?86G
 E84?<GL &A8
 B9
 G;8 @4<A 7<99<6H?G<8F J;8A
 6E84G<A:
 :B4?
@B78?F <F GB FC86<9L 4CCEBCE<4G8
6BAGE<5HG<BA
?8I8?F BA
6BAGE<5HG<BA
?<A>F )# F;BH?7
8A45?8
@B78?8EF
GB CEBI<78 6BAGE<5HG<BA E4A:8F
GB
8A45?8
F8AF<G<I<GL 4A4?LF<F
BE
4?
G8EA4G<I8
?8I8?F
4F
C4EG
B9
G;8
:B4?
@B78? 

E8?4G87
<FFH8
<F
G;4G
<G
<F
B9G8A
ABG
CBFF<5?8
GB
9<A7
4
6BEE8FCBA78A68
58GJ88A
G;8
E8FH?G
B9 4A 8I4?H4G<BA 4A7
E84?
?<98
4F
<G
<F
7<99<
6H?G
 GB GE4AF?4G8
 E84?
 ?<98
 <AGB
 G;8F8 F88@<A:?L
 4E5<GE4EL DH4AG<G4G<I8 AH@58EF 4A7
DH4?<G4G<I8
 FL@5B?F 4A7
 I<68
 I8EF4 E84G8E
 E8?<4A68
 BA
 >8L
 C8E9BE@4A68
 <A7<64GBEF
"' F
78E<I87
9EB@
@84FHE8@8AGF
B9
G;8
E84? JBE?7 @4L
477E8FF
G;8
?4GG8E
<FFH8 4F
FH::8FG87
<A
2 3 +;8F8 <FFH8F
4E8
6BAA86G87
GB .E4G; 4F
G;8
45<?<GL
GB
789<A8
F8AF<
5?8
6BAGE<5HG<BA
?8I8?F
<F
4
CE8E8DH<F<G8
9BE
4
HF89H? 4A7
FBHA7 8I4?H4G<BA
B9
@B78?F


     ,  &
*! 2. )-$$'$.3
&9G8A
:B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F
7B
ABG 4??BJ
?4A:H4:8
8?8@8AGF
GB
58
8KG8A787 <A
4
FLFG8@4G<6
J4L 
+;<F
?847F
GB 7<998E8AG HF8E
6B@@HA<G<8F
G;4G 4CC?L 4
C4EG<6H?4E :B4?
@B78?<A:
 ?4A:H4:8 <A
 I8EL :E887L J4LF 4A7
 HA9BEGHA4G8?L J<G;
 <A6B@C4G<5?8
 7<4
?86GF A
4CCEB46;
GB
477E8FF
G;<F
<FFH8
<F
GB
CEBI<78
G;8
45<?<GL
GB
4
789<A8
G4:F
FG8
E8BGLC8F
 BE
 @8G474G4
 9BE
 @B78?<A:
 8?8@8AGF
 5
 8FG45?<F;
 ?<A>F
 58GJ88A
 4E5<GE4EL
@B78?<A:
 8?8@8AGF
 6
 :EBHC
 @B78?<A:
 8?8@8AGF
 4A7
 7
 789<A8 FG4G<6 6BAFGE4<AGF BA
G;8
:B4?
@B78? 8 :  J<G; &# +;<F
<F
C4EG<4??L
FHCCBEG87
<A
)#
2 3
5HG
G;8E8
<F
@H6;
EBB@
9BE <@CEBI<A:
G;8
C46>4:<A:
4A7
@B7H?4E<M4G<BA
B9
FH6;
8KG8AF<BAF +;<F
<FFH8
;4F
4
78C8A78A6L
J<G; AIL 4F
G;8
45<?<GL
GB
789<A8
?4A:H4:8
8KG8AF<BAF
9BE@4?
?L
 <@CEBI8F
 G;8
 F8@4AG<6
 6B@C4G<5<?<GL
 58GJ88A
 I4E<4AGF
 B9
 G;8
 @B78?<A:
 ?4A:H4:8
8GG8E
 8KG8AF<5<?<GL
 6BH?7
 4?FB
 ;8?C
 G46>?8
 G;8 ?46>
 B9
 6B:A<G<I8
 9<GA8FF 7<F6HFF87
 <A
AIL
5HG
G;<F
@4L
ABG
4?J4LF
58
G;8
58FG
J4L
B9
CEB7H6<A:
4
FH<G45?8
7<4?86G




                                                  6
      CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




          *)'/-$*)- )
/./, 
*,&

.8
;4I8
CE8F8AG87
4
?<FG
B9
F;BEG6B@<A:F
B9 )# J<G;
4A4?B:<8F
GB
7847?L
F<AF +;8
@BFG
F8E<BHF
<FFH8F
E8?4G8
GB
I4:H8
789<A<G<BAF
B9
:B4?
@B78?
F8@4AG<6F J;<6;
8FF8A
G<4??L
49986GF
@BFG
F<AF
G;8
?46>
B9
CEBC8E
@B7H?4E<M4G<BA
4A7
G;8 E8?4G87 7<99<6H?G<8F
J;8A 4A4?LM<A: :B4?
 @B78?F
 4G
7<998E8AG
?8I8?F
 B9
45FGE46G<BA +;8
?46>
 B9 @B7H?4E
<M87 8KG8AF<5<?<GL
 @86;4A<F@F
<F
4?FB
4
6BA68EA .8
FHFC86G
G;4G
 BG;8E
CBCH?4E
 :B4?
@B78?<A:
?4A:H4:8F ;4I8
6B@@<GG87 @4AL
B9
G;8F8
F<AF 4F
J8??
GB
I4E<BHF
8KG8AGF
     A BHE 9HGHE8
JBE> BA
)#
J8
C?4A
GB 9<A7
45FB?HG<BA
5L 4 FB?<7<9L<A: G;8 9BE@4?
F8@4AG<6F
J<G;
G;8
;8?C
B9 @4G;8@4G<64?
4A7 6BAFGE4<AG54F87 G86;A<DH8F 5 <AI8FG<
:4G<A: @B7H?8F
 9BE
 FG4>8;B?78EF 4A7 <AG8AG<BA4?
 8?8@8AGF
 G;4G
 CEBI<78
 CE86<F8
 <AG8E
9468
789<A<G<BAF 6 CEBI<7<A: G8KGH4?
4A7
G45H?4E
FLAG4K8F
9BE
:B4?
@B78?F
GB
<@CEBI8
@B78?
 6E84G<BA
 89986G<I8A8FF
 7 CEBI<7<A: FHCCBEG
 9BE 78F6E<5<A: E8?4G<BAF;<CF
 B9
FG4>8;B?78EF
 4A7
 <AG8AG<BA4?
 8?8@8AGF 54F87 BA G;8<E ?BJ8E?8I8?
 8?8@8AGF
 4A7
 8
CEBI<7<A: 7LA4@<6
@B78?
8KC?BE4G<BA
946<?<G<8F
8 : 
DH8E<8F
<A =,$%4I
2 3


 ! , ) -
     ?8A64E
 
#H68A4
$ 
*<?I4
 
*4AGBF
  4FGEB
!  @CEBI<A:
G;8
$B7H?4E<GL
B9
<
     $B78?F G;
 AG8EA4G<BA4?
<
.BE>F;BC
,) IB? 

                
     @LBG
  
 BE>B99
 ! 
 EBFF
  
 $HFF546;8E
    #<:;GJ8<:;G
 )#
 'EB9<?8
 9BE
 <
     $B78?<A: ) <$           
)
.BE>F;BCF *CE<A:8E #%* IB? 
                   
    @LBG
  
 ;4A4I4G<
 * 
 BE>B99 ! 
 $HFF546;8E
  
 '8LGBA
 # 
 0H
   I4?H4G<A:
     B4?
$B78?F
J<G;<A
G;8
B4?BE<8AG87
)8DH<E8@8AG
#4A:H4:8 
 AG8EA4G<BA4?
!BHEA4?
B9
 A
     G8??<:8AG
*LFG8@F
 ! * IB? 
   H:HFG
            
    4E8F
  
 E4A6;
 / 
 '8E<A<
  
 *HF<
  
 +BJ4E7F
 <AG8EBC8E45<?<GL
 B9
 <
 @B78?F
 HF<A:
     <*G4E$# 
B@CHG 
*G4A7 
 AG8E9468F
 
!4AH4EL
              
    E4A6;
/  A6BECBE4G<A:
$B7H?8F
<AGB
G;8
<
E4@8JBE> 7I4A687
 A9BE@4G<BA
*LFG8@F
     A:<A88E<A:
 A7 AG BA9 
<*
                
*CE<A:8E
#%* IB? 
               
    4E8?
  
 )H@C8
   $84A<A:9H?
 @B78?<A:
 J;4GF
 G;8
 F8@4AG<6F
 B9
 F8@4AG<6F 
     B@CHG8E
  
          
    4HF8E
! )  ?4HF<A:
  +;8
;BHF8
B9
DH4?<GL 
4EI4E7
HF<A8FF
)8I<8J
$4L!HA8

       
    BE>B99
 !  0H
   A4?LM<A:
 :B4?
 @B78?F
 7<998E8AG
 4CCEB46;8F
 4A7
 ;BJ
 GB
 6;BBF8
     4@BA:
G;8@ 
        
$
*L@C BA
CC?<87
B@CHG<A:
*
  
$
                           
     +,+
,F8E
)8DH<E8@8AGF
%BG4G<BA
,)% R #4A:H4:8
789<A<G<BA
 +,+
)86B@@8A74
     G<BA
1  
       
8A8I4
*J<GM8E?4A7
            ;GGC JJJ <GH <AG E86 +)1  8A
     =,$%4I
  
;GGC FB9GJ4E88A:<A88E<A: 64 =H6@A4I
     #<H
# 
4A7
0H
  )#  B4?BE<8AG87
)8DH<E8@8AG
#4A:H4:8                  
     ;GGC JJJ 6F GBEBAGB 87H >@ )#
     $BB7L
 
8L@4AF
' 
$4GH?8I<P<HF
) 
-<FH4?
FLAG4K 7B8F @4GG8E
<@CEBI<A:
G;8
6B:
     A<G<I8
89986G<I8A8FF
B9
G;8
<
I<FH4?
ABG4G<BA 
)8DH<E8@8AGF A: !     
                 
    $HFF546;8E   FC86GBE<8AG87
,F8E
)8DH<E8@8AGF
%BG4G<BA ';  
G;8F<F
* +
,A<I8E
     F<GL
B9
&GG4J4
4A474 %BI8@58E
             
    'BHEF;4;<7
 
;8A
' 
@LBG
 
BEFG8E
 ! 
;4A4I4G<
* 
'8LGBA
# 
.8<FF
$ 
     HF<A8FF
 'EB68FF
 $4A4:8@8AG
 J<G;
 G;8
 ,F8E
 )8DH<E8@8AGF
 %BG4G<BA 
 ?86GEBA<6
 B@
     @8E68
)8F84E6;
   868@58E
               




                                                    7

</pre>