CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




              
 

%  
$!
 #

    0=84;
<H>C 
D=C4A
!DBB10274A  &4?8347
70=0E0C8 
0=3
0B>=
40;4H

    &27>>;
>5
;42CA820;
=68=44A8=6
0=3
><?DC4A
&284=24
(=8E4AB8CH
>5
#CC0F0
0=030
             
  
      4?C
>5
&HBC4<B
0=3
><?DC4A
=68=44A8=6
0A;4C>=
(=8E4AB8CH
#CC0F0
0=030
                                 
                           0E0;0BC
&>5CF0A4
=2
0C8=40D
0=030
                                      



        !! '74
 >0;>A84=C43
 %4@D8A4<4=C
 0=6D064
 % 
 ?0AC
 >5
 C74
 (B4A
       %4@D8A4<4=CB
 ">C0C8>=
 (%"
 BC0=30A3
 8B
 DB43
 C>
 <>34;
 0=3
 0=0;HI4
 BC0:4
       7>;34A
 6>0;B
 0=3
 A4@D8A4<4=CB
 9(!"0E
 8B
 0
 5A44
 2;8?B410B43
 <>34;8=6
       0=0;HB8B
0=3
CA0=B5>A<0C8>=
C>>;
5>A (%"
C70C
F0B
58ABC
A4;40B43
8=
       '78B
       ?0?4A
A4E84FB
C74
BC0CDB >5
C78B
C>>;
E4AB8>=
  
C74 C7 >558280;
A4;40B4
7867
       ;867CB
8CB
<08=
540CDA4B
0=3 1A845;H 38B2DBB4B
5DCDA4
34E4;>?<4=C
?;0=B

         %$  =0;HB8B 2;8?B4 >0; !>34;8=6 >0;>A84=C43
%4@D8A4<4=C
 0=
       6D064
9(!"0E (B4A
%4@D8A4<4=CB
">C0C8>=


       !"!

'74
 (B4A
 %4@D8A4<4=CB
 ">C0C8>=
 (%"
 8B
 0
 6A0?7820;
 A4@D8A4<4=CB
 <>34;8=6
 ;0=
6D064
C70C
2><18=4B
CF>
2><?;4<4=C0AH
E84FB
C74
>0;>A84=C43
%4@D8A4<4=C
 0=
6D064
 % 
 5>A
 BC0:47>;34A
 >1942C8E4B
 0=3
 3428B8>=
 A0C8>=0;4B
 0=3
 C74
 (B4
 0B4
!0?
(!
=>C0C8>=
5>A
B24=0A8>B
0=3
1DB8=4BB
?A>24BB4B
2><18=43
F8C7
0A278C42CDA
0;
2><?>=4=CB . /
=
">E4<14A
            
(%"
F0B
>558280;;H
BC0=30A38I43
1H
C74
=C4A
=0C8>=0;
'4;42><<D=820C8>=B
(=8>= 0B
%42><<4=30C8>=
-  
'74
34B86=
>5
(%"
8CB4;5
BC0AC43
<>A4
C70=
0
342034
06>
0=3
C78B
=>C0C8>=
8B
=>F
DB43
5>A
A4@D8A4<4=CB
4=68=44A8=6
02C8E8C84B
8=
0
<D;C8CD34
>5
38554A4=C
2>=C4GCB
0;;
0A>D=3
C74
F>A;3 . /
   =
      
 BCD34=CB
 0C
 C74
 (=8E4AB8CH
 >5
 #CC0F0
 BC0AC43
 34E4;>?8=6    0=
2;8?B410B43
C>>; 5>A
(! <>34;8=6
%>H
4GC4=343
8C
C>
BD??>AC
% 
<>34;8=6
0=3
0=0;HB8B ./
0=3
40;4H
;0C4A
03343
(!
0=0;HB8B
./
'78B
5A44
>?4=
B>DA24
?A>942C
70B
 B8=24
 14=458C43
 5A><
 <0=H
 2>=CA81DC8>=B
 ">F
 0C
 8CB
 C7 >558280;
 A4;40B4
9(!"0E
E4AB8>=
   ./ 70B
142><4
C74
<>BC
2><?A474=B8E4
(%" C>>; 0E08;01;4


       #            

%  
!" 
 

9(!"0E
 BD??>ACB
 C74
 BC0=30A3
 % 
 =>C0C8>=
 F8C7
 B4E4A0;
 4GC4=B8>=B '74
 <08=
438C>A
E84F
?A>E834B
C74
;8BC
>5
% (!
3806A0<B
8=
C74
<>34;
C>64C74A
F8C7
?0;
4CC4B
0=3
2>=C4GCB4=B8C8E4
?>?D?
<4=DB '78B
438C>A 70B
C74
?0AC82D;0A8CH
>5
?A4E4=C




                                              160
     CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




8=6
C74
2>=BCAD2C8>=
>5
BH=C02C820;;H
8=2>AA42C
% 
<>34;B
;B>
38554A4=C
3806A0<B
8=
 0
 (%"
 <>34;
 20=
 A454A4=24
 C74
 B0<4
 4;4<4=C
 3458=8C8>=B
 02C>A
 8=C4=C8>=0;
 4;4
<4=C
;8=:
4C2
74=24
8<?A>E8=6
2>=B8BC4=2H
0=3
0;;>F8=6
5>A
2><?;4G
<>34;B
C>
14
B?;8C
 8=C>
 <D;C8?;4
 3806A0<B 9(!"0E
 8=2;D34B BC0=30A3
 E84FB
 BD27
 0B
 0
 =0E860C>A
5>A
 ?A>942CB
 0=3
 <>34;
 58;4B
 E0A8>DB
 >DC;8=4B
 4;4<4=C
 ?A>?4AC84B
 F8C7
 C01B 0=3
?A>1;4<B
'H?820;
2;8?B4
540CDA4B
BD27
0B
I>><8=6 0A4
BD??>AC43
8=
0338C8>=
C>
D=
;8<8C43
 D=3>A43>
 0=3
 2>?H?0BC8=6
 >5
 <>34;
 4;4<4=CB
 8=
 C74
 B0<4
 <>34;
 02A>BB
<>34;B
>A
C>
C74
2;8?1>0A3
46
C>
?0BC4
0
3806A0<
8=C>
0
F>A3
?A>24BB>A
3>2D<4=C




=C4A4BC8=6
4GC4=B8>=B C>
(%" 8=2;D34 8 
  
   $B
8=
% 
C>
<>=8C>A 4GC4A=0;
B>DA24B
>5
30C0
0=3 2>=E4AC
C74< C>
C74
2>=E4=C8>=0;
% 
. 
    /
4E0;D0C8>=
B20;4 ./
0=3 88
0B?42C>A84=C43
4GC4=B8>=B
F8C7
0=
0B?42C
2><?>B8
C8>=
<4270=8B<
2DAA4=C;H
>=;H
BD??>AC43
5>A
(!B ./
   >A 0=0;HB8B
9(!"0E
BD??>ACB
%   84
8=8C80;
B0C8B502C8>=
E0;D4B
5>A
B4E4A0;
8=C4=C8>=0;
4;4<4=CB
0=3
B8G
4E0;D0C8>=
0;6>A8C7<B . /
@D0=C8C0C8E4
@D0;8C0
C8E4
 CF>
 7H1A83
 >=4B
 @D0=C8C0C8E4
 F8C7 $ 5D=2C8>=B066A460C8>=
 0=3
 2>=BCA08=C
>A84=C43 *78;4
C74
58ABC
58E4
BD??>AC
1>CC><D?
?A>?060C8>= >=;H C74
;0BC
>=4
DB4B
0
2>=BCA08=C
B>;E4A
0=3
8B
74=24
<>A4
64=4A82
C70=
1>CC><D?
0=3
C>?3>F=
?A>?060C8>=
0;6>A8C7<B
0C
C74
2>BC
>5
0
;>F4A
?4A5>A<0=24 '74B4
0;6>A8C7<B
0A4
8=34?4=34=C
1DC
@D0;8C0C8E4
 >=4B 0A4
 >5C4=
 DB43
 F74=
 ;8CC;4 :=>F;4364 01>DC
 C74
 6>0;B 8B 0E08;01;4
F74A40B
@D0=C8C0C8E4
>=4B
142><4
DB45D;
0B
344?4A
:=>F;4364
8B
0E08;01;4 '74
&24
=0A8>B
0=3
&CA0C46H
E84F
4=01;4B
<>34;4AB
C>
2A40C4 <0=064
0=3
4G42DC4
BCA0C4684B
>;>A
 5443102:
 8B
 ?A>E8343
 8=
 A40;C8<4
 3DA8=6
 4E0;D0C8>=B
 5A><  8=
 A43
 C>
  8=
 6A44= !>A4>E4A (!
 B24=0A8>B
 20=
 14
 3458=43
 0=3
 B8<D;0C43 =
9(!"0E % 
B0C8B502C8>=
E0;D4B 20= 14
DB43 0B
E0A801;4B 8=
2>=38C8>=B
0CC02743
C>
(!
4;4<4=CB
46
8= 5>A:B >A
C8<4AB
0=3 14 D?30C43
8=
(!
A4B?>=B818;8C84B '74
(!% E84FB >5 0 (%" <>34; 20=
74=24 8=5;D4=24 4027 >C74A 3DA8=6
0=0;HB8B




                                            161
     CEUR Proceedings of the 5th International i* Workshop (iStar 2011)




   (%"
 BD??>ACB
 <>34;
 4;4<4=C
 6A>D?8=6
    CA024018;8CH  
  0=3
0==>C0C8=6BC4A4>CH?8=6    =
0338C8>=
# 
AD;4B 0??;843
C>
C74
(%"
<4C
0<>34; 20=
14
3458=43B4;42C43
1H
DB4AB
C>
0BB4BB
0338C8>=0;
BC0C82
B4<0=C82
>A
BCH;8B
C82 2>=BCA08=CB
E8>;0C8>=B
0A4
A4?>AC43
C>
C74
$A>1;4<B
E84F
*74= 2><18=43
C74B4
<4270=8B<B
 20= BD??>AC
 ;867CF4867C
 ?A>58;4B 1>C7 1H
 4GC4=38=6
 0=3
 A4BCA82C8=6
 C74
DB064
>5
(%"
4;4<4=CB
F78;4
A4<08=8=6
2><?;80=C
F8C7
C74
-  
BC0=30A3
'74
C>>;
2><4B
F8C7
?A43458=43
DB4AB4;42C01;4
2>=BCA08=CB
8=2;D38=6 AD;4B BD??>AC8=6 0
%
?A>58;4
5>A
8 . /
# 
8B
0;B>
DB43
C>
2><?DC4 DB4A3458=43
<4CA82B
>= <>34;B
   9(!"0E
 BD??>ACB
 <0=H
 <>34;
 CA0=B5>A<0C8>=B
 C7A>D67
 8<?>AC8=6
 -  
 +!
5>A<0C
% 
20C0;>6D4B
0=3
4G?>AC8=6
-  
+! 
5>A<0C
% 
20C0;>6D4B
 !4B
B064
&4@D4=24
70ACB
0=3
>A4
&24=0A8>
!>34;
5A><
(!
0=3
&)
5>A
% 
BCA0C
46H
 4E0;D0C8>=B
 <4270=8B<B
 %4?>ACB
 20=
 0;B>
 14
 64=4A0C43
 8=
 $
 %' 0=3
'! 
0=3 3806A0<B
20=
14
4G?>AC43
8=
E0A8>DB
18C<0?
5>A<0CB
=
8=C46A0C8>=
F8C7
!'4;4;>682
##%&
5>A
5D;;
A4@D8A4<4=CB
<0=064<4=C
8B
0;B>
0E08;01;4


      "  
 "!" 

&8=24
     9(!"0E
 70B
 144=
 DB43
 BD224BB5D;;H
 8=
 B>5CF0A4A4@D8A4<4=CB
 2>DAB4B
8= <>A4
C70=
0
3>I4=
D=8E4AB8C84B
0=3
8C
8B
DB43
8=
3>I4=B
>5
;01B
0=3
2><?0=84B
5>A
A4B40A27
0=3
8=3DBCA80;
?A>942CB
'74
C>>;
0=3
8CB DB4A34E4;>?4A 3>2D<4=C0C8>=
74;?
<4C0<>34;
 4G0<?;4B
 CDC>A80;B 4C2
 0A4
 5A44;H
 0E08;01;4
 >=;8=4 0C
 ./ DCDA4
 ?;0=B
8=2;D34
DB018;8CH
8<?A>E4<4=CB
0
C4GCD0;
BH=C0G
5>A
% 
0=3
(!
8<?A>E43
(%"
;8=:
<0=064<4=C 8=C4A>?4A018;8CH
F8C7  0=3
C74
BD??>AC
>5
0B?42C>A84=C43
% 



   <H>C
 
 >A:>55
 
 A>BB
 
 !DBB10274A
  
 867CF4867C
 % 
 $A>58;4
 5>A
 8
    !>34;8=6
 A3
=C
*>A:B7>?
>=
%4@D8A4<4=CB
=C4=C8>=B
0=3
>0;B
8=
>=24?CD0;
!>3
    4;8=6
%8!
     
%
*>A:B7>?B &?A8=64A "& E>;
                    
   <H>C
 
 70=0E0C8
 &
 >A:>55 
 !DBB10274A
 
 $4HC>=
 
 ,D
  E0;D0C8=6
    >0;
!>34;B
F8C78=
C74
>0;>A84=C43
%4@D8A4<4=C
 0=6D064
=C4A=0C8>=0;
>DA=0;
>5
=
    C4;;864=C
&HBC4<B
&
)>;
 
BBD4

  D6DBC
        
   <H>C
 !DBB10274A
 (B4A
%4@D8A4<4=CB
">C0C8>=
'74
8ABC
'4=
,40AB '74
"4GC
    '4=
,40AB
=E8C43
?0?4A
>DA=0;
>5
&>5CF0A4
&*
)>;

">
  
!0H
          
   '('
(B4A
%4@D8A4<4=CB
">C0C8>=
(%" J 0=6D064
3458=8C8>=
'('
%42><<4=30
    C8>=
-  
  
4=4E0
&F8CI4A;0=3
         7CC?FFF8CD8=CA42'%-  4=
  9(!"0E
   
          7CC?B>5CF0A44=68=44A8=6209D2<=0E
  40;4H
 <H>C

=70=243
(B4
0B4
!0?
'A0E4AB0;
&4<0=C82B & 
                4B86=
    5>A 4?4=301;4 &HBC4<B &?A8=64A
 "& E>;                    
  !DBB10274A
  B?42C>A84=C43
 (B4A
 %4@D8A4<4=CB
 ">C0C8>=
 $7
 C74B8B
 &27>>;
 >5
 =
    5>A<0C8>=
'427=>;>6H
0=3
=68=44A8=6
(=8E4AB8CH
>5
#CC0F0
0=030             
  $>DAB70783

74=
$
<H>C 
>ABC4A

70=0E0C8
&
$4HC>=
 
*48BB
!
    DB8=4BB
 $A>24BB
 !0=064<4=C
 F8C7
 C74
 (B4A
 %4@D8A4<4=CB
 ">C0C8>=
 ;42CA>=82
 ><
    <4A24
%4B40A27
 
&?A8=64A
   424<14A
 
  %>H

40;4H

<H>C

'>F0A3B
=C46A0C43
'>>;
&D??>AC
5>A
C74
(B4A
%4@D8A4
    <4=CB
">C0C8>= &!
        
 0=6D064
$A>58;4B
&?A8=64A "&
                  




                                              162