=Paper=
{{Paper
|id=None
|storemode=property
|title=Producing and Consuming Linked Open Data on Art with a Local Community
|pdfUrl=https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-905/MatsumuraEtAl_COLD2012.pdf
|volume=Vol-905
|dblpUrl=https://dblp.org/rec/conf/semweb/MatsumuraKKKOT12
}}
==Producing and Consuming Linked Open Data on Art with a Local Community==
https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-905/MatsumuraEtAl_COLD2012.pdf
Producing and Consuming Linked Open Data
on Art with a Local Community
Fuyuko Matsumura1 , Iwao Kobayashi2 , Fumihiro Kato3 , Tetsuro Kamura4,5 ,
Ikki Ohmukai1,4 , and Hideaki Takeda1,4
1
National Institute of Informatics,
fuyuko@nii.ac.jp, i2k@nii.ac.jp, takeda@nii.ac.jp
2
Open Community Data Initiative
iwao@scholex.com
3
Research Organization of Information and Systems
fumi@nii.ac.jp
4
The Graduate University for Advanced Studies
5
Tokyo University of the Arts
kamura.tetsuro@noc.geidai.ac.jp
Abstract. The importance of Linked Open Data (LOD) has not yet
been recognized by ordinary people. As the effort to involve them into
LOD activity, we have developed Yokohama Art Spot, a mash-up ap-
plication on local museum information to demonstrate the value of in-
formation sharing and reuse where data from different communities are
used together. Thanks to the flexibility of LOD, it provides useful views
for local museum information and uses three different data sources, i.e.,
LODAC Museum which is a museum collection dataset, Yokohama Art
LOD which is an event dataset maintained by a local community, and
PinQA which is a Q&A dataset maintained by a company. In particular,
Yokohama Art LOD was the result of communication among researchers,
local volunteers, and people of the local government. Yokohama Art Spot
works as a good example of how such efforts by local people can be re-
warded by flexible use of the provided data.
1 Introduction
Open government is a move to publish government information to enhance gov-
ernment transparency and encourage citizens to participate in politics. Several
western countries and cities such as the United States1 , the United Kingdom2 ,
Paris3 , and Berlin4 have websites to provide data to citizens and some of them
have already started to publish data in the Linked Data[1] format. Publishing
Linked Data accelerates the move toward open data and enables data sharing,
not only within the same field, but also with other fields. Indeed, in the United
Kingdom, citizens and companies can develop and provide web application or
smartphone applications using Linked Data provided by the government.
1
http://data.gov/
2
http://data.gov.uk/
3
http://opendata.paris.fr/
4
http://daten.berlin.de/
In Japan, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications and the Min-
istry of Economy, Trade and Industry lead in the effort toward open government
and publish their data in various formats. However, most of these are published
in PDF or Excel file formats, and it is difficult for computers to automatically
recognize and extract a required data from such files in unstructured formats.
Under these circumstances, dissemination of the idea of Linked Open Data
(LOD) is important to the future of the Internet but it has not yet been rec-
ognized by ordinary people. The Linked Open Data for ACademia (LODAC)
project5 has started to publish LOD of museum, biodiversity, and geographic
information aiming to advance sharing and reuse of academic data in Japan. In
particular, the integrated museum collection data is called LODAC Museum[2].
Such actions for open data are becoming increasingly common in local com-
munities that publish local information with social tools. In the city of Yoko-
hama, which is the most populous city in Japan, there are many portal sites
that distribute information about that area, however, a lot of overlaps occurs
between data used in each site, e.g., profiles of the same concert hall or the
same restaurant. Several citizens and organizations in Yokohama realized the
importance of open data for the efficient use of data on local information about
Yokohama. They established Yokohama LOD project6 for individual persons or
groups to accelerate information publishing by the sharing and reuse of local
information in the LOD format. As a first step, the project has started to pub-
lish LOD of information on art events as Yokohama Art LOD and generated
typed links to LODAC Museum based on the discussion between researchers in
LODAC projects, local volunteer developers, and people of the local government.
In order to demonstrate the value of information sharing and reuse in the
LOD format, Yokohama Art Spot7 , a web application that provides information
on art in Yokohama, was developed. It uses PinQA, which is a local Q&A dataset
in addition to LODAC Museum and Yokohama Art LOD. This paper thus in-
troduces the best practice of collaboration with a local community toward the
acceleration of information distribution in the LOD format.
2 Linked Open Data (LOD)
Linked Open Data (LOD) represents datasets that give a Uniform Resource
Identifier (URI) to each thing as a global ID on the web and express relations
between those as links. LOD datasets connect to each other and construct a
global data space on the web called web of data[3], according to the following
principles: 1) Use URIs to identify things, 2) Use HTTP URIs so that these things
can be referred to and looked up (dereferenced) by people and user agents, 3)
Provide useful information about the thing when its URI is dereferenced, using
standard formats such as RDF/XML, and 4) Include links to other, related URIs
in the exposed data to improve discovery of other related information on the web.
5
http://lod.ac/
6
http://ocdi.jp/
7
http://lod.ac/apps/yas
The advantages of LOD can be divided into the following three points: 1)
encourage open data, 2) realize data sharing within the same field, and 3) realize
data sharing with other fields. On the web, open data is published in various data
formats, such as HTML, PDF, and Excel. People can easily read data expressed
in these formats; however, it is difficult for programs to automatically recognize
and extract a required data from such files, whereas, each thing is given a URI to
be identified as a resource in LOD. Compared to data such as HTML documents,
this makes it easier to access and reuse open data when the data is published
as LOD. Moreover, it is also effective for data sharing within the same field or
with other fields to identify unique items with URIs when several sites have data
indicating the same thing in common.
3 LODAC Museum: Integrating Museum Collection Data
in Japan
3.1 Overview of LODAC Museum
LODAC Museum is an LOD of museum information constructed by the LODAC
project at the Transdisciplinary Research Integration Center in the Research
Organization of Information and Systems. In Japan, museums publish their col-
lection information on their own websites, except for some web services that
integrate collection information, such as Cultural Heritage Online8 . This means
that currently it is impossible, for example, to extract a list of museums that
own the art works of Taikan Yokoyama, a famous Japanese-style painter.
The LODAC project is thus attempting to build an LOD of museum col-
lection information utilizing the advantages of LOD that advance data sharing
within the same field, as mentioned in section 2. Essentially, it is desired that
each museum publish their collection data in the LOD format and coordinate
them with semantic links. However, currently, the LODAC project obtains col-
lection data from various websites and publishes such obtained data as a single
LOD.
LODAC Museum consists of over 40 million triples extracted from 114 mu-
seums and research institutes in Japan. This information is integrated according
to the Database of Japan Arts Thesaurus which is a reliable thesaurus of art
in Japan[4]. The database of government-designated cultural property9 , Cultural
Heritage Online, DBpedia Japanese Lite and DBpedia Japanese10 are also uti-
lized to populate LODAC Museum.
3.2 Expression and implementation of data
Fig. 1 shows an RDF triple of a part of LODAC Museum. The main resource
types of LODAC Museum are works, creators, and institutions. Each resource
includes links to other resources, and all the data are described as graphs consist-
ing of resources and links. For instance, the fact “The artist who painted Spring
8
http://bunka.nii.ac.jp/
9
http://kunishitei.bunka.go.jp/bsys/
10
http://ja.dbpedia.org
Sea is Taikan Yokoyama” is described as a triple like
as shown in Fig. 1.
To integrate information of a certain thing distributed to several data sources,
a resource representing the thing is given a URI as an ID resource and includes
links to reference resources consisting of information about the thing included
in each data source. For example, if information on Taikan Yokoyama can be
obtained from museums A and B, an ID resource would be created to express
the identity of Taikan, and two reference resources are generated to describe
information obtained from museums A and B, respectively.
Furthermore, LODAC Museum uses the OWLIM-SE11 as our RDF store and
provides a SPARQL endpoint and a browsing interface with keyword search.
4 Yokohama Art LOD: Providing Information on Art
Events in Yokohama
4.1 The circumstances on publication of local information in
Yokohama
Nowadays, there are more and more events in local communities actively planned
and managed by citizens. At the same time, online tools such as Twitter, Face-
book, and blogs that enable ordinary people to publish their news or opinions
have become popular. In the city of Yokohama, there are many people or groups
who provide local information on Yokohama using such online tools. However,
it is difficult to make people reach the information published by each citizen or
each group because of too many information floods. Thus, the local government
and several organizations provide several portal sites to aggregate and deliver
such event information. For instance, the Yokohama Arts Foundation distributes
event information and news on art in Yokohama at their website Yokohama Art
Navi12 . On the other hand, the Yokohama Convention & Visitors Bureau lists
local sightseeing spots, events, and restaurants on the website of the Yokohama
visitor’s guide13 . Hamaspo.com provides local sports information and Otodokebin
delivers event information in each ward of Yokohama.
Fig. 1. A triple that expresses Taikan Yokoyama.
11
http://www.ontotext.com/owlim
12
http://yan.yafjp.org/
13
http://www.welcome.city.yokohama.jp/eng/travel/
4.2 Yokohama LOD Project and information on art events in the
LOD format
Nevertheless, sometimes overlaps of information, i.e., address, genre, and open-
ing hours of institutions, occur between such portal sites because these are com-
mon in the same area, Yokohama. Thus, some local volunteers came up with
an idea that open data realizes efficient utilization of local information. Then,
they have established the Yokohama LOD project to integrate those data in the
LOD format to encourage publishing, sharing, and reusing local information in
Yokohama. It would enable the reuse of data created by others according to the
web standard and the reduction of cost for such data creations.
As a necessary first step, Yokohama Arts Foundation has allowed them to
use data of all art events provided at Yokohama Art Navi website, and they
have started to construct Yokohama Art LOD from those data. Researchers at
LODAC projects have also discussed how to design their data and how to choose
vocabularies with them. The number of triples of Yokohama Art LOD is 627,257
at present.
Currently, Yokohama Arts Foundation aggregates event information from
each museum or each gallery and manually inputs these into the appropriate
format for publication by the staff. The event information is written in text
format; however, if the information of events, institutions, artists, and nearest
station is expressed as resources and the relation between them are written as
semantic links, it becomes possible to complement the missing information of a
certain resource with other accumulated information via links.
In fact, event resources of Yokohama Art LOD have semantic links to the re-
sources of LODAC Museum that describe the institutions which are the venues
for those events, and institutions resources have also links to the resources of
DBpedia Japanese which indicate same venues. Identification of those venues in
two different datasets were processed based on text matching. It would be capa-
ble to obtain more detailed information on art via those links and demonstrate
the value of the information sharing and reuse.
Providing information in the LOD format is suitable for the publication of
local information, which contains groups or communities of various scales, be-
cause sharing and linking resources realize broader information distribution in
local communities without making the effort to collect all the data separately.
In the United States and the United Kingdom, the government and the pub-
lic administration lead the effort on open data[5][6], whereas in Yokohama, their
work should be noted because their LOD activities for open data is being at-
tempted from the grass-root level.
5 Yokohama Art Spot
This section introduces Yokohama Art Spot, a web application developed as a
result of the collaboration between researchers, a local community and a com-
pany to make ordinary people notice the value of sharing and reuse of the data
provided by others. It uses following three different datasets as data sources;
LODAC Museum, Yokohama Art LOD and PinQA.
PinQA is a social geographical Q&A service provided by NTT Resonant, Inc.
that obtains and shares users Q&As corresponding to the specified geographical
regions in a map. They have also started to publish a small LOD dataset con-
sisting of 777 triples generated from aggregated Q&A data, but it has not been
linked to LODAC Museum and Yokohama Art LOD yet. It would help users to
imagine their visit to the event, for instance, they can plan to take a rest at a cof-
fee shop near the venue according to the past question about restaurants around
there made by other users. Thus, typed links only exist between the resources of
institutions in LODAC Museum and the resources of events in Yokohama Art
LOD in this system. Links represented by dotted line are planned to connect in
the near future.
Therefore, Yokohama Art Spot is provided conventional and novel local in-
formation on art in Yokohama based on a museum collection dataset, an art
events dataset, and a local Q&A dataset.
5.1 Overview of the developed system
Fig. 2 shows an overview of this application. First, the people who will use
this system are divided into two types: a user who visits the application on the
web and a staff who manually aggregates and maintains the data. A user uses
this application to obtain desired information and a staff manages updates and
addition of LOD datasets used in this system.
The interface is developed with HTML and JavaScript. If a user takes an
action, such as opening a new page that describes details about an institution,
this is queried to the SPARQL endpoints of each LOD. The application then
presents new information to the user using the data returned from the SPARQL
endpoints.
5.2 Main features of the developed system
Yokohama Art Spot consists of 1) map view, 2) institution view, and 3) ad-
ministration view. Both 1) and 2) provide information on art in Yokohama by
embedding data obtained with SPARQL into templates of web pages.
Map view When a user accesses the application, a map view is presented, as
shown in Fig. 3. This view gives users information on the kind of art they can ex-
perience by displaying institutions. The locations of the current day’s events and
Q&As related to the displayed area are also presented on the map of Yokohama.
In this map view, the name, address, and geographical coordinates of institutions
to be presented are extracted from LODAC Museum with SPARQL using the
latitudes and longitudes of the displayed area. As for the event information, the
application obtains data for the events that would be held at those institutions
included in the displayed area from Yokohama Art LOD using SPARQL.
Institution view The institution view appears when a user clicks on the marker
of the institution on the map view as shown in Fig. 4. This page shows basic
information on the institution, event information and collection information. To
display basic information on the institution, the name, access options, hours of
operation, and the geographical coordinates are extracted from LODAC Museum
with SPARQL according to the URI of the institution. Moreover, events that
have links indicating a venue for the institution are extracted by SPARQL,
and those event data are displayed in a timeline interface as shown in Fig. 4.
Collection data are also acquired from LODAC Museum by tracing art works
linked to the institution with SPARQL.
Administration view Event data of Yokohama Art LOD are frequently up-
dated and added, whereas information on collections and institutions is fairly
stable. Currently, the same data is published in the art calendar on the Yokohama
Art Navi and is manually updated by the staff of Yokohama Arts Foundation.
However, it is difficult for staff who are not familiar with RDF to input data in
the LOD format. This application, however, creates forms to make it easier to
Fig. 2. The system overview of Yokohama Art Spot.
Fig. 3. The map view of Yokohama Art Spot
Fig. 4. The institution view of the Yokohama Museum of Art.
Fig. 5. The input form for institution information generated by Semantic MediaWiki.
input event or artist information based on Semantic MediaWiki14 [7]. The staff
would thus be able to generate RDF of Yokohama Art LOD by inputting re-
quired data into the form as illustrated in Fig. 5. This would enable addition
or correction of data and realize data circulation of LOD consisting of creation,
sharing, aggregation and usage.
6 Discussion
Yokohama Art Spot was developed by using three different LOD datasets aiming
to make ordinary people notice the importance of sharing and reuse of informa-
tion, and involve them into the LOD activities.
First, the effects of interdisciplinary use of three datasets are discussed. The
developed system provides a couple of views such as map view and institution
14
http://semantic-mediawiki.org/
Fig. 6. An example of a scenario that guides users to discover new knowledge.
view even though the link connects only an institution data and an event data
in LODAC Museum and Yokohama Art LOD, respectively. As shown in Fig. 6,
for example, when users access the institution view of a specific institution to
view the events to be held there, they may have a chance to see the collection
data of that institution. If they find their favorite or famous paintings, they can
explore the information through links to LODAC Museum. It is also possible to
reach the same artist’s paintings owned by other institutions. Therefore, more
extensive information distribution would be realized by linking three different
types of LOD datasets such as collection data containing ancient artworks and
the data of current art events.
Second, the benefits of the compliance with the web standard are discussed.
Even if data from other applications were available via an API, some modifica-
tions would be required to use such data because each API is different. Thus,
when an application uses data from several data sources, this costs more com-
pared to using a single data source. In contrast, in LOD, data are described
using RDF, the standard data model, and they can be queried with SPARQL,
the standard query language. Even if the number of LOD used in the applica-
tion increases, any modifications to the application would be small. Because of
this, the event data in the LOD format are easily presented on the institution
view and it also acts as a reference of the institution when it has no webpage by
simply providing accumulated data in the LOD format. In addition, developers
of PinQA have also released their data in the LOD format and the map view
presents word of mouth from PinQA on the displayed area without any major
modification.
Finally, Yokohama Art Spot has been awarded the prize at Linked Open
Data Challenge Japan 2011 for the contribution on the collaborative use of LOD
datasets. In response, Yokohama LOD project has been interviewed as a leading-
edge example of open data in the LOD format by the people from the government
who work for open data. There is no doubt that the developed system acts an
important role to get people to notice the importance of information sharing and
they would lead the open data with other ordinary people in Japan.
7 Related Work
Several related projects have attempted to provide users the chance to access
cultural heritage information.
The Google Art Project15 is an ambitious project that allows viewing of
artworks with a brush stroke-level detail for greater appreciation as well as a
virtual tour of 151 museums across 40 countries. They prepared this application
to provide an environment to enjoy the fine art in famous museums around the
world. The developed application, Yokohama Art Spot, aims to introduce a wide
variety of modern art that are still being created and exhibited in the local area
in addition to the fine art.
The following projects structured their data in the LOD format and enable
a multifaceted search based on the properties of resources. Europeana[8] aggre-
gates collection data from museums in Europe and structure the data based on
the Europeana Data Model[9]. They organized some hackathons to encourage
the use of Europeana via the Europeana API, and some applications have been
developed. Although these applications use Europeana only via API, possible
relations between Europeana and other LOD datasets have not been defined
and utilized yet.
CultureSampo[10] provides Finland’s national cultural heritage content from
various perspectives generated by integrated multiple metadata schemas and
cross-domain content. Yokohama Art Spot is similar to this system because it
affords diverse semantic visualizations based on metadata: map view, timeline
view, and collection view[11][12]. The developed system also utilizes several types
of content, such as collection data and events, just as CultureSampo does. The
MultimediaN E-Culture project[13] also merged partial collection data of the
Rijksmuseum Amsterdam and the Rijksmuseum voor Volkenkunde into a sin-
gle LOD dataset. Yokohama Art Spot is different from these projects because
they manually integrate data aggregated from several data sources into a sin-
gle dataset, whereas the developed system separately uses three independent
datasets.
The CHIP Project[14] and the British Museum16 generate their own LOD
datasets from collection data of the Rijksmuseum Amsterdam and the British
Museum, respectively. The former tries to enrich a user’s experience with a
personalized interactive tour guide using recommendations based on user mod-
els[15][16]. These projects, however, focus only on data and users inside each
museum, in contrast to the developed system.
The novelty of our research activities is the collaborative use of three different
types of LOD: LODAC Museum, Yokohama Art LOD, and PinQA based on the
actual collaboration between researchers, the local volunteers, and the people
from the local government. We also succeeded to involve ordinary people to
open data or the LOD activities by the demonstration of the benefit to share
data and reuse them each other.
15
http://www.googleartproject.com/
16
http://www.britishmuseum.org/
8 Conclusion
In this paper, Yokohama Art Spot, a web application for the art guide in Yoko-
hama, has been developed and it uses three different types of LOD datasets,
i.e., LODAC Museum which is a collection dataset crawled from museum web
sites, Yokohama Art LOD which is an art event dataset maintained by a local
community, and PinQA which is a local Q&A dataset maintained by a company
based on the collaboration between researchers, local volunteers, and the people
of the local government.
LOD datasets such as collection data containing ancient artworks and the
data of current art events or Q&As complement each other, and this is expected
to enable broader information distribution. The addition of a new data source
has become easy by the standard format and technologies such as RDF and
SPARQL. As a result, Yokohama Art Spot works as a good example of how the
efforts by local volunteers can be rewarded by flexible use of the LOD dataset
provided by them.
Currently, it is required to input an institution’s LODAC Museum URI to
link with the event resource of Yokohama Art LOD, and thus the usability of
updates will be improved by suggesting candidates according to the keywords
input for the actual operation. In addition, ATR Creative Co., Ltd. has added
new functionality to display Points Of Interest (POIs) included in LODAC Mu-
seum on the map on an iPhone application. Thus, our project plans to develop
a smartphone application that will allow a user to search the contents close to
the current position and annotate his/her own personal perspective to resources.
Finally, it is desired to advance the use and the creation of museum collection
LOD datasets and local information LOD datasets for future work by develop-
ing a web application package like the developed system to apply to other local
communities in Japan.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Yokokhama Arts Foundation and Hiroyuki Sato from
NTT Resonant, Inc. for providing their datasets on art events and Q&As, re-
spectively. We also gratefully appreciate the contribution of Toru Takahashi and
Hiroshi Ueda from ATR Creative Co., Ltd. for the discussion on the developed
application.
References
1. Bizer, C., Heath, T. and Berners-Lee, T.: Linked Data - The Story So Far, Interna-
tional Journal on Semantic Web and Information Systems (IJSWIS), Vol.5, No.3,
pp.1–22 (2009)
2. Kamura, T., Takeda, H., Ohmukai, I., Kato, F., Takahashi, T., and Ueda, H.: Study
Support and Integration of Cultural Information Resources with Linked Data, in
Proc. of 2nd International Conference on Culture and Computing, pp.177–178
(2011)
3. Berners-Lee, T. and Fischetti, M: Weaving the Web: The original design and ulti-
mate destiny of the World Wide Web by its inventor, HarperOne (1999)
4. Fukuda, H. and Omuka, T.: Constructing Web-based Art Thesaurus, Focusing
Around Data Conversion (in Japanese), The Bulletin of Japan Art Documentation
Society, No.14, pp.56–66 (2007)
5. Coglianese, C.: The Transparency President? The Obama Administration and
Open Government, Governance, Vol.22, No.4, pp.529–544, 2009.
6. Shadbolt, N., O’Hara, K., Berners-lee, T., Gibbins, N., Glaser, H., Hall, W. and
Schraefel, M. C.: Linked Open Government Data: Lessons from Data.gov.uk, In-
telligent Systems, IEEE, Vol.27, No.3, pp.16–24, 2012.
7. Krötzsch, M., Vrandečić, D. and Völkel, M.: Semantic MediaWiki, Lecture Notes
in Computer Science, 4273/2006, pp.935–942 (2006)
8. Haslhofer, B. and Isaac, A.: data.europeana.eu - The Europeana Linked Open Data
Pilot, Proceedings of the International Conference on Dublin Core and Metadata
Applications(DC2011), pp.21–23 (2011)
9. Hennicke, S., Olensky, M., de Boer, V., Isaac, A. and Wielemaker, J.: A data model
for cross-domain data representation: The Europeana Data Model in the case of
archival and museum data, In Proceedings of the 12th International Symposium
on Information Science (ISI 2011) (2011)
10. Hyvönen, E., Mäkelä, E., Kauppinen, T., Alm, O., Kurki, J., Ruotsalo, T.,
Seppälä, K., Takala, J., Puputti, K., and Kuittinen, H., et al.: CultureSampo:A
National Publication System of Cultural Heritage on the Semantic Web 2 .
0 1 A Basis for Cultural Heritage on the Semantic Web, THE SEMANTIC
WEB: RESEARCH AND APPLICATIONS, Lecture Notes in Computer Science,
Vol.5554/2009, pp.851–856 (2009)
11. Kauppinen, T., Paakkarinen, P., Mäkelä, E., Kuittinen, H., Väätäinen, J.,
Hyvönen, E., Lytras, A. M., et al.: Geospatio-temporal Semantic Web for Cul-
tural Heritage. Digital Culture and E-Tourism: Technologies, Applications and
Management Approaches, Vol. 2010, pp.48–64 (2010)
12. Hyvönen, E., Lindquist, T., Tr̈nroos, J., and Mäkelä, E.: History on the Semantic
Web as Linked Data - An Event Gazetteer and Timeline for the World War I,
CIDOC2012 (2012)
13. Schreiber, G., Amin, A., van Assem, M., de Boer, Viktor et al: MultimediaN E-
Culture Demonstrator, In Proceedings of the 5th International Semantic Web Con-
ference (ISWC2006), pp.951–958 (2006)
14. Roes, I., Stash, N., Wang, Y. and Aroyo, L.: A Personalized Walk through the Mu-
seum : The CHIP Interactive Tour Guide, In Proceedings of the 27th international
conference extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems (CHI EA
2009), pp.3317–3322 (2009)
15. Wang, Y., Aroyo, L., Stash, N. and Rutledge, L.: Interactive User Modeling for
Personalized Access to Museum Collections : The Rijksmuseum Case Study, In
Proceedings of the 11th international conference on User Modeling (UM 2007),
LNAI 4511, pp.385–389 (2007)
16. Wang, Y., Wang, S., Stash, N., Aroyo, L. and Schreiber, G.: Enhancing Content-
Based Recommendation with the Task Model of Classification, In Proceedings of
the 17th international conference on Knowledge engineering and management by
the masses (EKAW 2010), LNAI 6317, pp.431–440 (2010)