IRVO: an Architectural Model for Collaborative Interaction in Mixed Reality Environments !" # $ ! %& ! ' (# $ ! % ABSTRACT )) ( " (( "( , ) " ) "( )* * ( )( ( +( ( , * 4- 9 4 $ ) > ,( ( ( , ) -. / ( % )" (+ % , ) " * +(" -( .01 )2! (), ( "( 0 3 % , + * ) -. () ( , +"(" (,) " * )( ) ) 0( )"( ( (, () ( ), ,* )! ( + ) 0 + )) 01 ) % 0 ( ,( * ) , % ,( ( )) , 0 ) ( ) ) ,! %() * + * ) )" (+ % -. , !4 ( , " ( * * ) ) % -. , ) " * 0 3 % )( 0 ( " )( ! , ! " ) * ( ) -. , () ( ), ,* )! " "( * + * * ) RELATED MODELS FOR MIXED REALITY , %,( ( ) ) ,)0 ) -. , ! 8 4 9 /8 ( +) 4 ) 9(( 2 ) 4 ( , " ( * * ) ) % -. ) (0 ( ( % ), , )" 0 * ) " )4 - " )( ! /4 $-(+$ 29 /9 ) ( $ 0) ( $ 2 6 ?7 4 /4 ( $ )2 Keywords 6 @7! % " ) , ) )( % (( ,* 4( ( , ( ) ( ( , ( % ) " % )" +" ( ** " , 0 ( + 3 (( " ! , ,( (! INTRODUCTION + * ( %9 $ , ), ( " 5 ,, ( " , ( / , ( )* * ) 0 ' 0 ( )6@7A " < *( = % " " % " 4( ( 2( ) (,* ) " 9 $ , ), +"(" ()( ( " <* ) ( % ( ( ) ) , )( )! " (, ( ) + ,* )= " < +$ ( ( ,* )= () ) ) ) 01 ) )* ( ) 0 " + *( ( ) 0 ") " % ", ) ) 0 +(" )* (%( * 0((() * ( 0 " ( * ( < * =! B)* ) )" $ ,* ) ) , +(" ) )) " ( ) () ) ) % " <0 "( , " ( ),=* ( ) * % * ))( 0 6 7! " <) %+ *( = % " ", ! ** " 4 ( ( + )( ( " " %( % (0 ( % )C , )"( (* * ) ( , 0 + ( ( (!8 +(" , 0) 4- 4 * A4 9 4( , , +" " () ( 4( 4 /)( 4 - 2 -(+ ( ))*( ( ( 6 :7! "( )() ) %( 0 ' 0 () !6 7+(" <*" )( * ) ( )= / *$*2 % " *" )( 0 ()( ( 0 + , ( / 2 ,0 ( , ) % (0 ( % ) < (( , ( ( / -2! * ) ( )= / *$ 2% " ,* ( , ( "() + + ( -. , ,* )+(" ,0 ( *" )( % , 6 D7! / ( +(" -( .01 )2" *% " & ($ % * * ) ( ( , % 9 )$ )( *" ) % ,( ( ) ) ,! (,) 8 49 ( % ) " " < ) , ( = "( (; " ( % 0 + ) 01 ) 6?7!.01 % " )3 ' , ( 01 ) / ( 2 " ,* ) ) ,! () " % , ( * +(" ,* (% ) ( ( < "( , = (% " ) * % -. ( ), () , )! " ) ( ( () , ) + $+ ) )0 + " ) " , ( 01 )A ) ) " () , +"(" )% ,) " ) B) ( ) ( ,, )! C) ) "( ( ) " " " ( ) % " () , ) , (* 01 )! " () , ) ) * ( % 0 3 ) " ,, () ( 01 )! "() , () (, ,* ( % )( 0 ( ) )( ( *(( C ) .4 E /+"(" () , ( + ) ,( ( " , , ! ( 2! " (0 ( ) % ") , ) ,( " EC /% , .9$ $E2, ()* * ) 0 ( " 0 ) ( 0 & , 6 7! ' 0( ) !6 @7!.01 ) % " )3 / )32 ) " , , + , ( )( 6 ?7 +(" " / 2 * ) 0 " )( ( " + ! 0 ( + ) " )( % " ) /C2 " ,* ) ) , /E2 (* * )/ (2 ,* (; **( ( ) +"("* ( ) ( * * )/ 2 ) * ) ! " ! "( ), () ) * " , ( ;( * ) 01 ) " (; 0 A % 0 ( )3) ((() +"(" () % *( , • " ", ) ) ( (* (( % ,) " ( ,* % 01 ( )! ,* ) Collaborative Activity • " ( +" " ) ") % ) 3 ( " 0 ( )( + " ) " * ( )3) ((() • " 0(( % * 01 )" " 0 ) ( " 4 6D7 " , ) )) ,, ( ( ( ( * ( ((()! "( ) ( ") ) 0 , 0( 8 + ( ( % ( ((() )* ( % ( , ) " , < EC FF=6 7 ,, ( ( ( ( 0 ) % * ( ( ) ( " , ) * , +(" * () ((() +"(" 0 * ) ( , " ( ( "( )%( , )" ) +("(! " **( ( ! % 0 ( + 3 " ), , ( (%% () " EC % ) ) " * / " ), )( )* 2 + " ) * 01 ) " % () ( ,( , )* (%( + 3 * ( , (()A " ) ( !8 (" -. + + 0 " % ( % )" ( ) + 3 ( ,( ( + +(" " ,0(( 0 " 01 ! %( ) 0 ( + 3 " + 3 , ( , -( ( )* )! , (() 0 % ) " 0 ( %% % " ( ( ) !" **( 4 $& ) ) ( "( )" ( " * 1 "()" ** " ) ) ,)6 7! * ( ) ) % (%% 0((() * ( )/ ( 01 ) )2! , ) " G(, ) % ) ) ,A IRVO MODEL • C) , Model basis -. ( , () +("( (( * ) • )3, " ( )0 + / ) 2 ) ) /C2 " • ' , (, 01 /.2 % " (( / ( 2!& ) " (( " , * () ) J, , 6( ( • 9 ) ( , I7 + ) ( " ) ( () " " / 2! • '( , " , )+ + " ,* $) ** • **( ( * % ,, (( " ( , % " **( ( /4 2 ( ) *(( )" + 0 ) ( ( ) * (( * ( ( " CONCEPTUAL BACKGROUND ( ( ! "(), 0 )( ,* ,* . , ( + 3()% " (( " * ( " ( % , ( % " (( 0 - )3 H! )( *( 0 **( ( ! % ( 6I7! U " (( " *) )" ( ( ) (3 " ( , ! "()) ) ( ) *" )( U ) ( )( " ( ,) ) /( * ( " Tr Or )H )* *( 2 (( " ( * ( % ( !" T O ( () )( ) )* ) " ( ,) ) (!! Tv Ov " (0 ) ) ( , ) ( )! " ()"(" (% ( " (( 0 ) ** ( 0 M ) ** , ( " , * (()! ,( ( (a) (b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ollaborative Work Modelling " 0 ( + 3 () ( " " ) , * 0 + )3)2 () %* (, (,* * *) " ( ( ( , ) )! () ! " ) % 0 ( + 3 " ) , * ) ) ) + 3( +( " ,( ( ) ) , IRVO NOTATION )" ( " ) , ) " ) , 01 ) 0 "() ( ) ,, (; ) ( *"( ( , ( * ) +( " -. 0 ( ? ! ( ) 0 + ) ) 01 ) ) " ,* ) ) ,! U1 U2 U3 U2 Entities T2 O2 () * ) , ( 0 " ) +"( " " ) ) T O O1 T3 ( ( K+ )( A U1 M U3 • " () " /-2A , ( ) ( * / )( " 2 M T1 O3 ) * /( ( % )( " ) 0 $ 3( (a) (b) ( )2! ,* ) %, ) % 0 ( + 3A A " ) , * K0A () ! • " ( " / 2A ) ( * /" ( 2 ) * / ( A 3( )( ( !!!2! " ) % () 0 ( /( ?02 " ) ) )( " ( + ) 01 ) " ( , /4 2 • " 3( ) " ( " *( " /O52A ) * 3( %" " % " (%% 01 *( )! /" ( )*( ) !!!2 ) ( * /) ) % "() %( ( 0 * ))(0 " 01 ) " ) . "2! () " + " ) /.? . 2 ( ! " " ." ) ) ) ) " ) ) /2 ) ) %), /E2 ) ) C? C ) " ) ) %" ( ) %C ) 0 )( (% )) )( " +( " " ( )! * ) ( ! ." L( , ( L ) ) 0 )( A % User U ,* +( " )" 01 ) ( ( ( ) ! KH A V ( ! * *) " ( ) % 0 ( C) * ) ( ! % 0 ( ) ) ,) / 4 2( 6 7A ! * ) ( ) ( ( " ! • , 0 ( ( , ( () ( ( 0 + ) 01 ) () " 0 < =/ .2* " ** ( " % " ! " ) • , 0 ( ( , (( ) ) ) ) " " 01 () ( /. • 0 ( ( , ( ! . 2! Link with task tree E 3) / ( 02 ) )" + ( % 01 ) -. * () %( ) " (0 + " ) % " ) , 3( ) ( /( 2 )" + " 01 ) " ) ) ) , (* ! "() ) ) " ) , 01 ) ) 0$* ) % " )! ( () , ( ) ( * ) ( ! " B) 0 ( ) ( 3 Tool T +( " " )3 , +"( " ) (0 ) " )3) " ) Object O * % , +( " " ) ) , " ,* ( )"(* ... O O Nested 0 + " ) )3)! Object Object Object (a) (b) (c) & ) " )3) )( " ) , (% ) " -. , ( , " 01 0 " .01 * ) ( ! " ) " ) , , , A + +( ) ( " " ? 3( ) % /( @2A ,* % " 4 "$M , " ( + ) • & + ( + /( @ 2 * ) ( ) ( " ( + 0 * ) ) " (; )" ( +"( " 0 L )) L+( " ( * % ( 01 ! " " * % ) ) /) 0 +2! " , * () * * ( ) % " ( ) %" • & + (%% * )( " + /( @02 ) * % "() * * 0 % " ( )( ! * ) ) ( * ( ( )" + " < * ( = " , , % " ( ) ( " + " % "() 0 ! + (% + * ) " * * ( ) "(0( ( EC , 6 7 0 $ ) ( " * * ,, ( 0 ( +( " ) ( -. +( " (%%( ! " , "() () * ) )( ( @ ! ( Geometrical constraints between entities + * ) " %$)( ,( ) ) ( ( @ (( ), " , ( ) ( )! * ) " /* ( +* 0 * B ( +* 2! % " ( B, ( " )3 P×B) ,0 8 )( " () *" )( 0 ( " ( + () * " + ( " /( D 2! % " ( )) ) + 3( " ( )* < 0(G ( )= B , /(! ! ( " )3) % " ( , 0 E* ! **( ( 2 P⊗B " )( () ) / ( D02! % " ) )( ) place 1 place 2 place 3 place 4 * 0 " , % " ( " " ) ( () 0) 0 ( "() ( A % A↔ V→ Real ,* ( ( D 54 ' /5 4 ()* 2() (b) (c) (d) world + ( 0 " ) " , ( +( " "(,! (a) Pen T R HMD E screen E V (a) U× (b) ⊗ (c) U↔ Virtual ( , ( ) ( ) * ) ( ! world " ** )( (% ( , " P↔B)( () ) ! # 0 ( ) * ) ( ! 9 %( ( 0 ( , , ) " " *" )( ,, ( 0 + ( + ) ) ( ) 0 + " + ( ( )A "() 1) ) ,, ( % , ( %, + " ) 0 )% , ( " % "() ) ( )" 0 )* (%( ( ( +"( " () (; 0 /( 2K " )( " ) " , ! ,* ( ( D " 9 /2 ) * ( () 0 ( )+ ! () ( 3 " C) /C20 ) ( () " 0 "(,! $$! /( 02! ) +" + " , "() ( % , ( () , ! & ( " ) % ! 0 +( " *" )( ) )! ) 01 ) " 0 % ( 3 /P×B2 " ,0 ( 01 ! R Sensor S Effector E V EXAMPLES (a) (b) First example: ACCORéA project % ) ) * ) ( ! " . Q * 1 (,) ) " (0 ( % , 4( ( ( " % )( ( " &' & /4 2 0 * ) ( (( ) 0 " ( " ( ( ( 0 ( /(% )) 2 ) 0 (3 ) 01 ) +( " P4 B ! (, )( )! . ** " () " (; 0 " ( Relations % ( ,0 + ( ( ( ) % (0 ) " /* ) 0 +)2 * ) " * ))(0 0 " % " 01 ) % " )3 % " ) " %( % , ( 0 + ( ( )! 0 +"( " * " 01 )! ( / + ,( % , ) C2 * *( %" %( ) ) + ( )( " )( +(( ( , / + ( ) 2! " ) " ( ( ( ) %) ( (%( * * )! * (,( + 3( (%( /O5 -2 +" " + ) ) ) ( ) " " )3) " ) " ) " )* ( ( ) %" ( % , ( ! & + ) 01 ) " * ( ) " , 6 7! +) * ) " ( % ) 01 )! . %( ) * * () " )(,( " '( ( ' )3 ( * ) ) )" ( , ) "() ( 6 I7 ( 6 7 &C '$ 6I7! 8 ) ( ( () ) 0 () (,* ( " )3 /% +"( 0 ) ) 0 +"( " , ) ,* " " *( % 0 3 % " , ) () (,* 0 * ! "( +"( " () + () * 0 " % , ( ( % ( " * + 0 ) " % 0 3() ) ) , +"( " ()* 0 3 ( %, ( " , ( * ( 0 ) ( " *( " ) 2! , +( " * 1 ! ) ) )) 0 ( ) )" + " ( I + * ) , % $ (( )3) " 3( %( % , ( / + ( + 20 ( ( ) )! 8 ( ( + )( " " , ( " % " ) ) ) ( ,( ( ) ) , ) (0 0 K8 ( ? * ( (* ( " ( ( *! ,* " ?' ( + ? , * )( ))( ,* , , ) %" * " * ) ) ( +( " , ) ! Writer1 U1 Reviewer1 U3 Writer2 U2 Reviewer2 U4 ↔ ↔ ↔ ↔ KH A V KH A V KH A V KH A V hand Document O1 Pen T1 + (view1) U↔ ... Or hand Pages × R Interact. S Data E Mouse S Screen E V table ⊗ projector ⊗ U↔ ⊗ Pointer T2 Document (view2) O2 ... O+v Page U↔ ... modifications Pages Or × × Computational model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xample 2: DoubleDigitalDesk (Wellner) ) " ,* % User1 U1 User2 U2 0 ( ,( ( , + , (; ↔ ↔ +( " -. " ' 0 $ KH A V KH A V '( ( ' )3 * * ) 0 8 6 I7 ( ( ! T1 Pen T2 Pen " ) () ( ( U1 ↔ U2 ↔ Shared + O +( " ( )" % + paper * * +( " ) * ! O1 Paper O2 "( +"( " ) " B) Paper × × +( () * 0 , ()* " )" %* * %C) ? R m s cam S Data E cam S Data E m s ,( +( " "() " + V ⊗ projector ⊗ ⊗ projector ⊗ +( ! "() , * *( () )" + 0 " PFB ) ,0 % " -. ( ! " ) , * ' 0 '( ( ' )3/8 2! * () Player1 U1 Player2 U2 Player3 U3 ↔ ↔ ↔ KH A V KH A V KH A V right (c) hand (c) (c) (a) (a) Stylus Tr left (a) + + hand + U↔ Shared Board O(c) Personal + O(a) (b) Interaction Game (a) (b) Panel Or(c) Table (c) Panel Or(a) ⊗ U↔ R Tracker HMD1 HMD2 HMD3 V ⊗ U1 × U2 × U3 × ... Ov(c) Tile Group O(b) Or(c) ↔ Tile Group ... Ov(a) U1 ↔ Tile group Or(a) ↔ + 4 "$M , /E; ( ! I2! . " + ( " * A )) ( )3 ! 0 3 C) ! 0 " + ) )" " ( )( TAXONOMY + " ) , )" %* * ! ) * ( ( 6 I7 " 8 " ) " ( -. 0 " ) 01 ) )( ,( % , " , " ) 0 * )) " ( 0 ! % + " " (,( " ( %( ( * %% ! "( ( " , ) % +( ) )A +( " "() )* " ) < " ( * 0 ,)= ( • " 01 %" )3() % ( " + /. R . 2 " ) * % -. 0 " *"( ( " * )( ) " ) * 0 ,)! • " 01 () % ( " ( + /. R . 2 . ( + ) ) " , (; ( % ( • " 01 () ( " + , 0 ( ,, ( ( " 0 + " ) ) +( " " " * % <"( )=/ ( A . R. F 2 + ,( *" ) + )* 3 ) /P,)B) ) )$ %% )2! • " 01 () ( " ( + , 0 ) % + ) ,, ( +) 0 + ) ) 0 $ <"( )=/ ( A . R . F 2! + () ) ( ( %" , ! " ) , () ( ( 0 % " ) +( " " Example 3: Mah-Jongg game (Szalavari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eal object Augmented real object Augmented virtual object Virtual obejct (Or) (Or+v) (Ov+r) (Ov) Real Real world (see text) AR AV tool Media Blocks [18] Karma [cited in 10, 11] (Tr) DoubleDigitalDesk [19] Video Tangible Wearable Accoréa Ariel [10] & Auged Mosaic [10] interfaces Computing Real Digital Desk [19] Tool ] CASPER [5,6] [12 (Tr+v) orm p latf Auged G IC virtual MA Mah-Jongg [15] tool (Tv+r) BUILD-IT [9] WIMP Virtual interfaces Reality Virtual (see text) Interior Design tool Toolglass [4] [cited in 6] (Tv) . , % 4( ( ) ) ,) +( " ) , ,* )! )( <( ( 01 )= (! 01 ) % , OTHER APPLICATIONS ) * ( " " ( ( , (3 ( ! " & 4 -. ( 0 ) * ) $ ) " + % ,( ) ( ( ) ( ( ) " ) 0($, ( ( 01 / . 2! () " ))( ) %< ( ( )) )! ) ,* + * ) ( ( ? " , "( = ( () ) (% "() , % ( ( +( " )) 3 % , 6 7! ) () < = ! U User 6 7 " " ) )( <,( ( ( )= ) ( " ↔ ( ( +( " ( ( 01 ( " *" )( + KH A V ( ( +( " *" )( 01 ( " ( ( + ! 8 right left "( 3 " ) ) ) * ) ( , ( +" " hand hand " 01 ( " ) , + / . . " ( , ( ) ) ) +" ) R mouse S trackball S screen E 01 ) , 2" % " + $ % ) ) V U↔ U↔ ⊗ " ** $ ( " ) ) 0 <,( ( ( )= ) %( 0 ! Petri Net Toolglass T1 Collaborative activities T Pointer T2 Trans. or O ' 0 '( ( ' )3 /? ,* 0 2 01 U↔ Tn place () ( " + /" % + ( . ) % tool n , 20 " 01 % " )3/ *" )( )" % * * 2() , " ( ( ( %" , U↔ 01 * 1 (! +( ) + &($, ( ( +( " ))! " + ) A . R . F N "() () )" + 0 " 0 ( )" ( +"( " * ) ) " )" ** ( ( ! " ) () , ( " )) +( " " % " 0 )( " ) " 01 () , 0 <( ( 30 **( ) " 0 ( 3( " , ) 01 =! /, +( " " ( " " 2 " )( ( * %" 9 ( ) " + ) , (%! "() ,* + ) " "() 3( % , ( () 0 3( " ( % " -. ( % "(0( ( " 0($ 0 0 " *" )( 0 0 + ? , , ( ( " +"( " () , %+ * ) * ) +"( " () + ) * " * % /)" + ) )" ( 2A " , ) * ( " % * ) ! " ))! "( ) ) " ( ) < , ( = B) 0 ( ) " "() , ( () ( ,* (0 +( " 1) ,0( ( % )! " - , ( + ) (, ( $( ) RELATIONS BETWEEN ARCH, AMF-C AND IRVO , ( (3 . F F ! 4 0 " ) , * ( -. )) 0% (), ( " ( % 0 + 0 **( % )/ F F F 20 + B )) " )) , 3( ( " ) %( ,* ( " ) ) ) )> 01 )/(" ( 2, (* 0 ) )! % + )( " " , 6( ( ?7 -. () ,2 9 8 ?! D/ ! ?2 % 4 ( " < *( = % "() * , ?:: E??@ E*( $- ! % " ( " + /( 2! " P4B ( % @! ' 0 () ! 60( 10 # (1 # $%#3 ( &* )# %&/0 $% -. () ,* ))( " , ( * % " ) %+ (1 # $%#7 ! #+$0 ! #$ %&/ 0*&$0 ! # $ %#* *( 0 ) ( B) ( " (, % -. , (; ( 0 / , $0/0 *&$#( ! "U) ' C ( )( Q M ) *" ) () ( , ) ) " ) 4 $ 6 @7! " ( $ 0 1( ?:: /?D@* )2! -. 01 0 )) ( 4 $ ! , 01 ) + " ! ' 0 () ! 9! ( ! ) FFA ' )( ))( <* ) ( % =+"( " () ( 3 " ( ( % 4 0( 4 ( E ) ,)! ! !5 !80 / # * % " 01 /. 2 + < % = +"( " () 22 E* ( $- **! ? $ ! ( 3 " * /. 2! "() % () ( + 0 " D! () !8 ( M! * , % *+ ! ) 0 () 1) + 0 + " 4 $ 0) ! 9,:; 4 9 )) **!D $II! , " -. ( % , ! I! 1 4 ! " O!&( ") 4 !- " ) !O AMF-C scope 5! 0 4 !9" )( -( )A ( ( " ** ( " ' )( % *+ ! $0<0$- na l Dialogue Pr Abst 6#! - & ) $6# & $0# !5 4#*0 1 3 ! +($# n ctio & I esen ract Fo Core r nte tati (++! $#) !!+# &$0<# 9! = O + ,( to rac on ap tion 9 0()" ) ?::? **! @ $ I:! ad Inte M Co . & Pr l co iona !4 3 8 !! , ( A ( 3( r ncr es IRVO re t Tv Ov nc ete . scope ( + ) $ + * ( , % ( ( +( " Fo S E ,* )! ! ,:> 4 9 ))! :!4 ( , 9! O()"( ! , %,( ( Tr Or () ()* )! & *& $0 ! *! 5 ! &$0! User -*$# * - DD$' V ? ! ( )0 + " / )" ( )2 !( ! E ,0( 9! 4 " ! ( 9! 4 $ -. , )! 9 )G ( ! 4 0( 0 ( , ( A E ( &) ' )( ** "! CONCLUSION ! ##)01* !5 !80/# 22 E* ( $- **! "() * * + * ) "( (; ( ? $?@@! , % 0 ( ( ( * ,( ( ( , )! ( +( " " ( ( " + ?!9 W !/?:::24 $& ) ' )( ( ( (%( ( ( ) +"( " * ( (* ( " % ( ** ( ( )!E* ( $- ! ( ( A ) 01 % " )3 " ! ( 9! ( ! /?::?2 4 0( 0 ( ,* ** ( ( , ! " ) % " ,( , ( A " , E ! ( ) ) + ) 01 ) 0 ( ! ##)01* !5 ,2 4 ?:: E " ) " * ( ( ( ) % "() 0( + + "(0( ! ??@ E* ( $- **! @$ ! 4 " ( )* 3( -. 0 ) " ) !E; ( X! 3) ( ! ; 4! 0 ( ( ( ( % ( ,* ,( ( , ( ! ! ##)01* !5 (%% ) ( )> ,* , + ,:> (* ( (+ 4 **! @$?: ! 0 % , (; " ( +( " 4 $ , 5 )( * ))! @! *( $& ! ' ( &! ! 9 (, 9! , + 3) * ) % ) " ) *+ A 4 $ REFERENCES ** "! ! ?:> O + ,( !& , 4 ! !"#$ ! %&' $()# )#* &++! $* ),( 9 0()" ) **!??@$? ! *-*$. # )# %&/ 0$% &(1 # $%# &( + ! #**(* )# ! #+$0! !4 Q, ( ' C ( )( Q 4 ( ?:: ! ! () '! - 3 M! 4 G &!4 $& ) ** " , ( E ) ,)! ! !5 ?! & ( $ % 4! ) , ( A $# &$0! &/ @( # 22A3 #$#3 ## # A ( 4 % ' )( ( 9 ) $8 4 9 $ + 0 , )) ( ) ?:: ! **! ?D $ % )! ! , 222 4 9 )) **! $ @ ! ?DD! !& ( $ % 4 ! )) 5! 4! " "( D!C , &! )"(( 5! , ( , + 3) % (0 ,* , ( % 9 ?::: 9 ) $8 4 9 ) ( % )! -*$# * @!( &/ ! V *"( ** ( ( ! ! 2223 & 40 #1! Y ?::: **! @$ ! ,0 ?::: 4 9 )) **! I $ :! I!8 9! ( +( " 9 * " '( ( $' )3! ! ' 0 () ! ( ! ; M! )() ( ! ( 0&$0 ! * !5$6# ! VD ** , ( E ) ,)! ! ##)01* !5 I$ !